HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elefanten

3,113 karma · joined October 7, 2016

submissionscomments
elefanten··on The Economic Consequences of Major Tax Cuts for the Rich [pdf]
My comment followed from the claim about whether meritocracy and inheritance are compatible. I'm addressing the notions in theory rather than in present situational terms in any given country. From that perspective:

1. Disagree. Yes, money can be used to buy power. But it's not power in itself. A strong meritocracy would focus on giving positions of responsibility (auditing/regulating/decision-making type powers) to people who show the merit to perform them well. Money is an advantage, but it is not the power to shape social systems.

2. Rich heirs who put all their wealth into safe investments and sit on it also aren't really getting much out of it. And that money isn't sitting away in a vault, it's a part of the economy. Rich heirs who buy yachts and mansions and hang with celebrities, but lack the merit to contribute anything useful, will burn through (most of) the wealth. It's not just common... it's the default outcome within a few generations.

3. Yes, generations are a long time. But that latency would apply to personal/family wealth rather than decision-making authority.

I'm not a pro-inheritance maximalist. I agree with various forms of taxation on inheritance. But there is value is allowing people to be motivated by their family's future. Inheritance is not inherently at odds with meritocratic assignment of political power.

elefanten··on The Economic Consequences of Major Tax Cuts for the Rich [pdf]
But the motivations of those shaping the structure and systems of civilization should be.
elefanten··on The Economic Consequences of Major Tax Cuts for the Rich [pdf]
You're arguing against the American system as it is. Proponents of meritocracy wouldn't say that America has achieved it.

I agree with the other comments that meritocracy and inheritance are not at odds, especially if the meritocracy component is referring to positions of power & responsibility.

But your point is valid wrt America as it is. Education is a lynchpin of meritocracy. So, America's solution may need to include some reshaping of inheritance as a means to reshape the mechanisms of meritocracy. But the facile leftist take of (more or less) "ban inheritance" would be an overstep and create far more problems than its simplicity solves.

elefanten··on The Economic Consequences of Major Tax Cuts for the Rich [pdf]
Yeah and? In a meritocracy, they wouldn't be given positions of responsibility and power without earning them. So the unearned economic advantage will dwindle within a couple generations unless they can produce something of value.

In no scheme can you regulate away all forms of unearned advantage. The skills, capacities and potential we are born with vary.

People are tremendously motivated by providing for their children. Taking that motivation off the table will drive people to places where they can achieve it.

The long-term, highest-net-value producing system of distributing power / responsibility will be a meritocracy.

elefanten··on Large Ivermectin Study Retracted
I'm curious about what you talk about here, but I haven't heard anything about it. Any reading or further search terms beyond "SMARThealth" and "WHO covax"?
elefanten··on The Imaginarium of a Solarpunk Architect
It all sounds like ineffable cultural projection. Ask 10 self-identified punks for a definition of "punk" and get 10 different answers.
elefanten··on CO₂ Coin: Decentralized Carbon Capture Blockchains (2021)
This is all interesting. Some questions that came up as reading.

1. "as long as the auditor is trustworthy only to the extent that they will not sign lies about dust not being present"

If they get the staked eth bounty, isn't there a pretty direct incentive for auditors to falsely report dust plots?

2. What happens with disputes? How do you challenge a false report about one of your dust plots? What if both sides are convinced they're correct & being honest -- maybe the dust farmer entered the wrong GPS coords, or the auditor visited the wrong coords, or wrote it down wrong in their notebook. What mechanism is there for adjudicating that kind of conflict?

elefanten··on CIA director says he is escalating efforts to solve 'Havana Syndrome'
Russia and China easily have the resources to carry out clandestine ops around the world. Given that this seems to do with signals / electronics, it may not require particularly large teams or equipment.

I think many more countries could do this around the world... I'm not sure about Cuba, but maybe even yes.

elefanten··on CIA director says he is escalating efforts to solve 'Havana Syndrome'
"In a wide-ranging, exclusive interview with NPR's Mary Louise Kelly, Burns also discussed the CIA's future in Afghanistan and the theory that the coronavirus outbreak was caused by a leak from a Chinese state-run laboratory in Wuhan."

This was not a random press conference organized just to loud speak the words "Havana syndrome". It's almost like you didn't even read the linked article.

elefanten··on CIA director says he is escalating efforts to solve 'Havana Syndrome'
You offer no counter-evidence to gp. I've never seen it seriously suggested that Cuba is doing it.

There might've been speculation that Cuba allowed it or supported a foreign operation, but "from Cuba" doesn't mean "by Cuba".

elefanten··on The Tyranny of Spreadsheets
I'd love to learn if I'm doing something wrong, but Sheets has terrible performance compared to Excel in my experience.

Not just sheet sizes, but Sheets feels much slower and has a vastly weaker toolset. Just the fact that the browser takes precedence for keyboard commands from the web app makes the usability suffer massively.

elefanten··on Information Sovereignty
You seem to overestimate the effectiveness of national firewalls. Sure, they'll squash you like a bug if you start saying the wrong things publicly, but China hasn't exactly succeeded with keeping ideas and information out of the country.

These aspiring totalitarian systems are quite porous.

elefanten··on On Leaving California and the Silicon Valley
It's not just housing supply, despite YIMBYs being the loudest voice in the room and housing supply is the most common presumptive scapegoat for all the poverty woes of SF.

There's another side. California is also much friendlier to the homeless and devotes way more resources to even trying to care for them. Meanwhile, the rest of America ships their homeless to a handful of destinations, with California's major population centers being top targets.

elefanten··on U.S. and key allies accuse China of Microsoft Exchange cyberattacks
This is a weird comment. Gp wasn't talking about day to day life or what cities look like or anything like that.

Going to China wouldn't teach you much about its government structure and governance. It's not like you can just walk in and observe party cells interacting with company leadership.

You don't need to go to China to know what the government structure is, what foreign policy it conducts and what kind of economic behavior is clearly not just condoned (small scale hacking, data harvesting) but encouraged (fishing other nations' territorial waters) or even demanded (foreign business ownership requirements, IP transfer requirements) by the party.

You don't need to go to China to hear reports from dissidents experiencing internment, forced labor and cultural genocide. Or to see all the broken international agreements and sovereign promises, eg the early destruction of a free Hong Kong. Or to see the territorial expansionism in salami slicing illegal maritime boundaries.

Or... most importantly, to understand that a despotic cartel that doesn't believe in individual human rights is a terrible form of human organization that has terrible externalities for the whole species and planet.

elefanten··on U.S. and key allies accuse China of Microsoft Exchange cyberattacks
No, there's a pretty stable presumptive meaning of "weapons of mass destruction". It means radiological, biological and chemical.

There are always people trying to expand the definition, but it's usually from more left-leaning critical schools of thought that want to classify landmines, sanctions or guns as WMD.

But in official usage, it's been pretty stable at those three.

elefanten··on U.S. and key allies accuse China of Microsoft Exchange cyberattacks
So, in your view, is security simply not a problem? Is it all a giant lie to fund the security state?

If not, where do you draw the line between real/legitimate security concerns vs. the fake ones?

elefanten··on Word gap: When money’s tight, parents talk less to kids
There are multiple performance and outcome gaps that are unequivocal in research across multiple disciplines. There lots of debate about what causes them. None of them necessarily imply anything permanent/immutable about any group.

Plugging your ears and crying ethical foul impoverishes the discussion and all it’s observers.

You could instead add real arguments to the debate. That enriches the discussion.

elefanten··on 112 Gripes About the French
What a knee-jerk, unserious reply. You performed the perfect example of the point gp was trying to make.
elefanten··on Jet Li rejected The Matrix as he didn’t want his kung fu moves recorded (2018)
And yet he got to see that day anyway
elefanten··on Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard
Yeah I was over the top there. He’s smart and prolific. Public intellectuals are important, it just feels like he’s in that class that cares about spectacle over substance.
elefanten··on Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard
Given how wrapped the letter is in one-sided rhetoric and how full it is of sweeping, dismissive accusations such as "we all knew the mendacious reasons had nothing to do with academic standards"... how exactly do extract an "obvious" takeaway about the underlying events?
elefanten··on Cornel West Releases Resignation Letter from Harvard
He's a celebrity public intellectual. He hasn't pioneered any ideas or theories. He builds departments and plays a ton of politics (both internally at academic institutions and publicly in the American media ecosystem.)

He's a PR intellectual. He gets way too much air time for his contributions to humanity. A boring figure.

elefanten··on The Cultural Implications of Silence Around the World (2020)
I agree that a possessive concept shouldn’t be used as a generic. I’m sure mistakes of that nature are made all the time by non-speakers of various languages.

Neither person in the discussion above claimed bahasa means “our language”. The positions were “bahasa=language(generic)” vs “bahasa=also colloquially used to mean Indonesian”.

It was your assertion/conjecture that it actually means “our language”. The (seemingly) native speaker posting the original comment did not make a similar claim.

elefanten··on The Cultural Implications of Silence Around the World (2020)
This doesn’t make sense. If the word/phrase expresses a relative relationship to it’s user, then that works on a per user basis. Eg- Non-Americans can say “this country” about their own countries. If the word/phrase is a generic term in a given language, it often ends up having fixed context —- eg “la Raza” as used by Latin American communities.

Besides, the original commenter denied it’s used at all. Gp implies otherwise.

Broadly speaking, this whole business of trying to “own” words on an identity basis is poisonous, corrosive and an abuse of the tool of language.

elefanten··on Richard Branson ready for today's 'extraordinary' space flight
If we’re going with maximum cynicism: how are nationalist bureaucrats and bloodthirsty generals any better?
elefanten··on Instacart CEO will be replaced by Facebook executive
News as pedestrian as the PR writing style.
elefanten··on Alcohol, health, and the ruthless logic of the Asian flush
This n=1 personal anecdatum does not fit well in this thread about longitudinal studies.

Alcohol’s potential role in someone’s preferences about how to enjoy life doesn’t have anything to do with the discussion of whether it has a biologically protective effect.

I know a few problem drinkers who are linearly killing themselves and they all grasp for this “scientists have proven alcohol is good for you” misinformation as a part of their excusing narrative.

elefanten··on SafeDollar ‘stablecoin’ drops to $0 following DeFi exploit on Polygon
So it implies the crypto maximalist takes on true trustlessness are not proving workable. At least in practice with lots of real users.
elefanten··on Binance banned from doing business in UK
This perspective is completely alien to me. What misery and violence is the state uniquely causing that wouldn't be recreated by other forces in a non-state society?

That's putting aside all the generations, centuries and millenia of lessons learned that are enshrined in how a government-run state runs. It's hard to guess what alternative you're even imagining, but do you think some anarcho-crypto-decentralized-eco-intentional-autarkic commune where all internal "violence" has been eradicated can live in a bubble detached from the rest of the world?

What is your workable alternative to the state?

elefanten··on YouTube takes down Xinjiang videos, forcing rights group to seek alternative
I’ve seen this kind of crap all over Twitter and other social media. Always these galaxy brain compilation threads that rely on the reader not clicking any links. It’s loosely cobbled together, spurious trash.

Eg- first section, the “investigations” are heavily stage-managed by CCP guides, just like WHO/Wuhan. They usually look at some one specific place, like the World Bank covering it’s ass on a particular vocational school project it funded.

These threads are always full of holes, broken logic and twisted context.

But Zenz hardly matters. There’s far too many sources and data streams from others for this to hinge on Zenz.

← PreviousPage 13 of 28Next →