i.e., while there certainly can be paid/manipulated reviews, the barrier to doing so is higher here than elsewhere (e.g., google reviews, tripadvisor, etc.) and there's enough people who are happy to use other less controlled sites, I haven't witnessed any truly widespread fraudulent reviews like I have elsewhere)
Generally speaking, I'd say Yelp reviews are, generally speaking, comparatively the most reliable
I can't speak to how they sort/present search results - that does seem potentially shady