HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

exo-pla-net

1,260 karma · joined November 30, 2018

submissionscomments
exo-pla-net··on DeepMind says reinforcement learning is ‘enough’ to reach general AI
One needs to actually read the paper to understand what it's postulating; the paper's title is not enough.

There is a temptation to view our capabilities as a complex set of interacting modules. Under that view, each module would need to be separately developed in order to artificially recreate our abilities. The paper makes the case that we need only a single carrot.

Per the paper:

"For example, the ability of social intelligence has often been framed as the Nash equilibrium of a multi-agent system; the ability of language by a combination of goals such as parsing, part-of-speech tagging, lexical analysis, and sentiment analysis; and the ability of perception by object segmentation and recognition.

In this paper, we consider an alternative hypothesis: that the generic objective of maximising reward is enough to drive behaviour that exhibits most if not all abilities that are studied in natural and artificial intelligence."

exo-pla-net··on Angband 4.2.2: A free, single-player roguelike dungeon exploration game
I've played most of these, but my favorite remains Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup. It's actively developed with a dedicated community, and you can even play online, where a peanut gallery will often appear if you make it deep into the dungeon.
exo-pla-net··on The Big Alien Theory
I feel like a lot of people here are pontificating about something they don't understand. It smells like few people here are mathematicians, and yet they're speaking with reddit levels of hubris, attributing simpletons' logical fallacies to a published astrophysicist. Usually Hacker News is better than this.

I'm myself not a mathematician, but I believe I understand his argument, and I see no fallacies. Everything he's written falls out of assuming power laws govern the pertinent quantities. In the absence of additional information, this seems not just valid but the correct starting assumption.

I hope we all understand the linked website is a casual release for the public. With the reception he's getting here -- the absolute lack of respect for a professor's passion project -- it's no wonder few scientists bother to engage with the public. He's written a formal paper on this: https://academic.oup.com/mnrasl/article/456/1/L59/2589573 A dollar says that his ideas have survived close scrutiny by his colleagues, both mathematicians and astrophysicists. One of them might step in to teach us something, if we were a bit more respectful.

exo-pla-net··on I’m Not Scared to Reenter Society. I’m Just Not Sure I Want To
I think we're on exactly the same page. The fact that the writer is hurting wasn't beautiful. Many of his ideas, however, were. If they're not your cup of tea, so be it.

I think that you think that "It's okay to be depressed" is a platitude celebrating complacency. It's actually about shame. Many people, especially men, would sooner suffer than admit to needing help. Behind the platitude is the desire to say, "You don't need to be ashamed about being depressed. It's a thing that strikes the best of us, and you can hold your head high as we help you back to your feet."

But yeah, a lot of therapists are terrible. It's indeed important to find one that wants to get you back on your feet as soon as possible; sympathy isn't a substitute for recovery.

I like your veterans' tips for climbing out of depression:

* Develop a hobby

* Regularly exercise outside

* Take on a big project, and put something into it every day

* Spend in-person time with people who get it

I sometimes do mental health volunteer work, and I'll incorporate your tips. Nothing beats a strategy that has met empirical success.

exo-pla-net··on I’m Not Scared to Reenter Society. I’m Just Not Sure I Want To
There is indeed compassion to be found around us. There is also coldness and callousness and contempt, and if these human sympathies have been expunged from your world, a lot of us would pay handsomely for interstellar travel to join you.

I agree that we all need to be pushing our oars as hard as we can, even if we're bruised and bloodied and can't push very hard. Freeloaders aren't acceptable; we all need to be trying our best.

Is the article writer trying his best? I don't know, but I found his piece beautiful. His battle right now is with meaning and metamorphosis, and I think those are respectable things to wrestle with.

I'm fond of the mental health innovation for veterans that I'm familiar with: VR exposure therapy for PTSD. I'm genuinely curious -- what else does the veteran community do for people who are struggling?

exo-pla-net··on I’m Not Scared to Reenter Society. I’m Just Not Sure I Want To
This scathing contempt for poor mental health is precisely the kind of attitude that drives people to commit suicide instead of seeking help.

Poor mental health isn't "whining"; it's the number one cause of death for ages 15-24 in the US. It's rampant, and many people reading your comment will themselves be struggling.

If anyone reading this is in a bad way, please know that most of us don't look down on you. Many downright heroic people who have changed the world have had their (very) bad patches. Newton, Tesla, Lincoln.

Programmers aren't known for their empathy, so don't pay attention to any tone deaf drum beating you hear here. Outside of Hacker News, you're surrounded by people who do indeed care about and respect you, as well as professionals who will put the best of their minds into helping you through the storm.

exo-pla-net··on How to Speak Cicada
Fun article, but to prevent disappointment, we've only learned four cicada phrases:

I want to mate.

No, you can't mate with me.

Sure, mate with me.

Stop touching me.

exo-pla-net··on After years of conflict and instability, Iraq is opening up to tourism
It's almost like countries comprise human beings with varying attitudes, and the fanatics don't speak for everybody, much less the kids currently being born.
exo-pla-net··on Our digital pasts weren’t supposed to be weaponized like this
Caution is still advised. ML identity-matching using your writing patterns/idiosyncracies will likely be a thing in the near future.
exo-pla-net··on Two airlines will postpone sales of alcohol amid surge of in-flight violence
Exceeding the posted speed limit is also illegal, and few care. What's important is the consequence for getting caught. Provided you haven't angered the flight attendant, he'll politely ask you to stop.

Source: I found zero reports of someone getting in trouble for this. Just requests to cease.

exo-pla-net··on Users post more falsehoods after others correct them: study
I'm glad you've decided to let me arbitrate this matter. Here is my official misinformation heuristic, three questions to ask oneself before acting:

1) Is this misinformation likely to convince and harm a great number of people?

2) Could belief in this misinformation result in severe health or emotional damage, for a single person or more who believe it?

3) If yes to either, are you an expert on the issue, relative to the person or group making the claim?

If you're indeed an expert, try to save the person or people from their downfall.

If you're not an expert, read up on the issue before meddling. God forbid it's you who is wrong.

And, of course, if no significant harm is likely, ignore it.

exo-pla-net··on Users post more falsehoods after others correct them: study
You will win more friends with a "never correct others" policy. However, what if belief in the misinformation has deadly consequences? Steve Jobs died due to him seeking "alternative" cancer treatment. Had someone convincing spoken up when acupuncture was being discussed around him, someone who changed his mind into recognizing that acupuncture is a sham, Jobs might still be alive.
exo-pla-net··on Hydras suggest that sleep evolved before brains
I mean, that's a fun and trippy idea. But we're vessels for propagating genes. Can't do that while you're sleeping, so one would have to construct an exceedingly strange model of the universe to make sleeping central to our existence.
exo-pla-net··on How India went from a ray of hope to world record for most Covid cases in a day
Edit: succumbed to the perils of unnecessary abbreviations
exo-pla-net··on Word usage guidance and alternative terms
This reads like a hypothesis / creation fable. It's conceivable that some in power have intentionally leveraged identity politics to fracture an opposing voting bloc, but citation needed.
exo-pla-net··on Let us now praise tiny ants
An example from the article:

> Winnow ants disperse so many herbaceous seeds in North America, Dr. Rice notes, that “removing them causes wildflower abundance to drop by 50 percent.”

exo-pla-net··on A Bayesian Approach to the Simulation Argument
The simulation might not be faithful to what it's simulating. SimCity versus actual cities. One can imagine scenarios wherein you, as a mind being simulated, could discover the nature of the simulation. And that would be interesting, to say the least.
exo-pla-net··on Social media addiction linked to cyberbullying
You're being downvoted, but studies suggest your intuition is correct.

People engage with social media at least in part out of social urges. However, consumption of social media leads to increased feelings of loneliness: https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/is-a-steady-diet-of-soci...

So, social media is indeed a diet that just makes one hungrier.

But does loneliness lead to more aggressive / "bullying" behavior? This hasn't been well studied, but evidence suggests this is the case: http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/comm/malamuth/pdf/85jspr2.pdf

exo-pla-net··on Text to Image Generation
Yes, but you can engage in your phallic pursuits, for free, using Google Colab.
exo-pla-net··on Text to Image Generation
For anyone who isn't familiar, DALL-E is the state of the art for text-to-image generation. It's closed source, but it's astonishing: https://openai.com/blog/dall-e/
exo-pla-net··on How can you tell if someone is lying?
He was using the equivalent of a Facebook infographic to "prove" that epidemiologists are wrong.

His type believes that scientists are part of a cabal that is lying to the public for nefarious reasons.

I won't say that he himself is deranged, but his thought pattern on this issue is.

Anyhow, for those who believe in science: https://www.pnas.org/content/118/4/e2014564118

exo-pla-net··on How can you tell if someone is lying?
It was a joke, a reference to a Quentin Tarrantino movie where a character says there are 17 pantomimes that give a male liar away, but the character doesn't list them.
exo-pla-net··on Gödel's Loophole
I think that the majority of people chuckled and moved on. The people who were, for whatever odd reason, perturbed or galvanized by the amusing little article compose the group that self-selected to comment.

I think this is a peril of reading the comment section before checking out links. If it's not worth talking about, you'll only find unhinged or pedantic conversations about it.

exo-pla-net··on Result from LHCb experiment challenges the Standard Model
I think "subjunctive" is used loosely. I think that I'm right in terms of descriptive diction; anything irrealis and non-imperative is often (typically?) called subjunctive in English, since we only use distinct verbs for indicative, imperative, and subjunctive moods.

I think, however, that I prefer your rigorous distinctions. Moods seem to be important to human language, even if they're atrophied in English. So keeping the gate on the subjunctive vs conditional distinction points people toward a deeper understanding of how language works.

exo-pla-net··on Result from LHCb experiment challenges the Standard Model
Subjunctives aren't rare. They arise whenever we speculate or wish for something.

"I don't think he'd appreciate you stealing his spotlight on grammatical minutia."

"I wouldn't bet on it."

exo-pla-net··on A SpaceX engineer's dark web insider trading sparks an SEC first
Entrapment is a subtle concept. Most people misunderstand it; police are legally permitted to do much more than most expect.

This guide enumerates the misunderstandings about entrapment, and (if you're not already a lawyer) it will likely teach you something that could prove valuable: https://thecriminallawyer.tumblr.com/post/19810672629/12-i-w...

exo-pla-net··on Are you hosting a memetic parasite?
They aren't scientists. And their conclusion is not just false; it's the opposite.

If you have a college education, you're proportionally much more likely to have a "very unfavorable" view of QAnon. (26% with no college degrees, versus ~42% with college or higher).

How did the journalists get it wrong?

1) They fixated on a poorly worded polling question: "How accurate or inaccurate are the claims made by QAnon?" (I myself believe that QAnon's claims are "somewhat accurate", in a similar way that I notice that broken clocks are correct twice per day.)

2) They failed to notice that non-college-educated people overwhelmingly account for people who are "unaware" of QAnon. It could be inferred that education correlates with worldly awareness, and hence the ability to have opinions on obscure topics.

In conclusion, don't trust popular press. Journalists lack the analytical skill and incentives to accurately report on science, much less on raw data. https://xkcd.com/882/

exo-pla-net··on Are you hosting a memetic parasite?
What's your source that more educated people are more prone to buying into Qanon?
exo-pla-net··on Are you hosting a memetic parasite?
The word "meme" was invented by evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins. He's public facing, but his origins are academic. The word caught on because it's a good word that conveyed a novel idea. One could say that it memed its way into our hearts.
exo-pla-net··on Noise Planets
In his code after "and now we apply flow fields and try to move these points", the code is errant. It will produce errors if you try to run it.

The variable "m" in draw() should be changed to "points".

The variable "h" in draw() should be changed to "t".

← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →