HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

fbelzile

1,489 karma · joined January 17, 2015

Founder of Cold Turkey: https://getcoldturkey.com
submissionscomments
fbelzile··on Apple’s Anti-Tracking Plans for iPhone
> Their income is from selling physical devices.

Not entirely true anymore:

1) About $8-12 billion paid by Google to have their search engine default. [1]

2) About $20 billion from their 15-30% cut of third party app developers. Where the App Store is protected from competition. [2]

3) Apple services (like Apple TV+), which collects usage data for itself and third parties. [3]

[1] https://www.macrumors.com/2020/10/25/google-apple-search-def...

[2] https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/15/21292203/apple-app-store-...

[3] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208511

fbelzile··on Dear Google: Search Competition should be 1 Click Away so why 15+ on Android?
> Google believes that the browser market is still largely uncompetitive ... This is because Internet Explorer is tied to Microsoft's dominant computer operating system, giving it an unfair advantage over other browsers. Compare this to the mobile market, where Microsoft cannot tie Internet Explorer to a dominant operating system, and its browser therefore has a much lower usage. The value of competition for users (even in the limited form we see today) is clear: tabbed browsing, faster downloads, private browsing features, and more.

Wow, this is enlightening. I'll take back my last statement. Maybe Google should be offering users to pick a default search engine from the start like they wanted Microsoft to do...

fbelzile··on Dear Google: Search Competition should be 1 Click Away so why 15+ on Android?
I never thought I'd have to defend Google, but the steps to change the default search engine for your browser seem perfectly appropriate. This "open letter" comes across as DDG uncovering some Google conspiracy or exposing a dark pattern, but I don't think this is the case.

DDG is a private company seeking profits, just like Google. I'm a happy customer of DDG but empty marketing like this isn't going to move anyone. It feels like one company complaining about it's competitor. You don't see ProtonMail complaining that Gmail comes pre-installed on the OS.

There's plenty of other reasons to criticize Google, changing default settings doesn't seem to be a hill to die on.

fbelzile··on What Comes After Smartphones?
Maybe not replace, but at least displace the phone, watch, camera. I think one of the major hurdles with smart-glasses isn't tech, it's the changing of social norms. Right now, if you walk down the street waving your hands in the air, you'll look like a crazy person.

When people first started using cellphones, from the outside, it didn't look much different than looking down at a book or portable gaming device.

fbelzile··on Sharrows, the bicycle infrastructure that doesn’t work and nobody wants
Low cost by what metric?

Cycling accidents costs money in other ways as well: a) emergency responses to cyclist/car collisions b) insurance costs c) loss of healthcare savings (nationalised healthcare or not) d) well-being through physical exercise

Perceived safety from sharrows vs real safety created through separated bike lanes is exponential. You'd have a lot more commuters/children being allowed to bike to school and much more adoption. The investment in biking infrastructure will pay for itself in other ways.

fbelzile··on Show HN: An anti-book recommendation tool, to help you escape your echo chamber
Seems like a cool idea! Did you think about referral sales (Amazon Associates) as a way to fund the project instead of Patreon?

I have no affiliation or experience with either, just genuinely curious if you chose one over the other. Affiliate sales seems like a good fit for this kind of service.

fbelzile··on I built a picture frame with a greyscale e-paper that runs on battery for years
Very cool. This reminds me of another HN post where someone made an E Ink frame to display the New York Times front page everyday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22831323
fbelzile··on Earnestness
I mean, you're using a site which self-selects for his target demographic. He's the founder of a VC company which created the site your visiting and apparently his blog gets 15 million page views per year. I think it's just a numbers game, not fandom.

I'm not defending what he writes, but this posts are generally fun to read and think about. Sometimes I don't agree with him or find holes in his arguments, but there's usually a nugget of truth you can take away. They're just blog posts, he doesn't need to be infallible.

The occasional self-promotion from the people running the site is a price I'm willing to pay to use the site.

fbelzile··on The Anti-Mac User Interface (1996)
"Might as well check my Thunderbird mail on the way to open Firefox in Mozillatown!" :)
fbelzile··on The Anti-Mac User Interface (1996)
I agree, these new metaphors survived the test of time. Probably because of it's flexibility and ability to change to user requirements.

Flat design is kind of like an extreme version of this. It's easy to build and change when needed.

fbelzile··on Heavy is the Head that wears the AirPods Max
> ... definitely feels like they’re intended for stationary use. Their lack of water resistance aside...

> It’d be nice if [spatial audio] worked with MacBooks... But the device that’s just begging for spatial audio support is Apple TV... It’s crazy that Apple sells a premium movie-watching set-top box and very premium movie-listening wireless headphones and they don’t work together for a premium spatial audio movie-listening experience.

So, AirPods Max are not water resistant and are heavy enough to feel intended for stationary use. Yet the two unique selling propositions of these headphones are: seamless transitions between Apple devices and spacial audio.

Seems to me, if you're not going to be using these on-the-go for comfort reasons, you also won't be benefiting from the only two unique features they offer.

fbelzile··on Ask HN: Successful one-person online businesses?
Thank you! I was thinking of switching it to "Your future self will thank you" because a results from a quick poll I did. Now I'm not sure :)
fbelzile··on Ask HN: Successful one-person online businesses?
You can block time changes under Settings > Blocking in version 4 now :)
fbelzile··on Brave Complies With Apple iOS Guidelines
> My parents, children, and friends who have iPhones have the same benefits.

Your parents are consenting adults. What makes you think your parents don't deserve to be trusted to use an app they want to use?

As for children, just don't give out your Apple ID password. Children under 13 are not allowed to create accounts.

> I have not yet had to help one of them get malware off of their iOS devices.

This is a completely different issue. Apps can still be sand-boxed for security.

> Why did you buy an option that doesn't have the features you want, and now you want to take away a feature many of us like?

You have nothing to lose here. I really don't understand why you're still calling this a feature.

fbelzile··on Ask HN: Successful one-person online businesses?
I run Cold Turkey: https://getcoldturkey.com

It started as a fun side project in university. My friends needed something to block themselves from playing WoW so that they could study.

For three years after graduation, I've continued to work on it in my spare time. In 2015, I decided to see if people would buy the pro version with more features. As it turns out, yes! I was able to quit my job to work on it full time a few years ago.

fbelzile··on Brave Complies With Apple iOS Guidelines
That's fine, use the App Store if you want!

It's the fact that Apple doesn't let you, the owner of your phone and licensed user of iOS, take full advantage of what you purchased.

The inability to side load apps you want to use outside of the App Store (or to use another app store) is an artificial limitation. It's created from greed or fear of competition from a better managed app store.

I think what people are arguing for is a similar model to macOS. Have you ever heard anyone get mad that they were able to download apps outside of the App Store on macOS? No! You can use the App Store if you want, but you're still able to trust a third-party developer to use the device you purchased to it's full potential.

fbelzile··on FTC Sues Facebook for Illegal Monopolization
> Supermarkets might pay for the product, but Kellogg’s, Budweiser, etc pay them for shelf space, eye level, end of aisle placement, etc. there is a dozen ways they make money off the sellers.

I don't see how this invalidates the analogy. Brands paying for eye-level placement is the same as 'sponsored products' on Amazon. Any Amazon Seller has a right to do this and Amazon has the right to sell this access. Just like any brand has the right to meet eye-level requirements.

Yes, supermarkets have a store brand. Yes, they may also place store brand items at eye-level at no cost. But! I think there are two key differences:

1) In most cases, supermarkets buy from the existing product manufacturer at wholesale in order to be able to slap their brand on the product and use other cost saving measures (ie: bland, cheaper packaging, etc) to sell the same product at a lower price. In cases where they don't buy from the manufacturer, the copy of the product is likely not covered by a patent or is different enough as to not infringe on the patent/trademark.

2) Many Amazon Sellers are small independent companies, just look at their success stories page [1] to see the extent to which they market to small business owners. These businesses likely can't afford to patent their products and when Amazon decides to copy their product (based off the data they collected [2]), they can't defend themselves and their product effectively.

Not all Amazon brand products are a problem. The biggest issue is the exploitation of companies in a certain 'sweet spot' on its platform. These small businesses have taken on risk to provide a good product that sells well, but aren't big enough to patent the product or hire lawyers.

Maybe Amazon is just a symptom caused by the imbalance of power in the economy right now. Either way, it's unfair and should be fixed. I think separating Amazon "the marketplace" and Amazon "the competing store brand" would help (as long as Amazon "marketplace" sells store data to Amazon "brand name" at the same price it offers everyone else).

A law requiring store brand items to be made from an existing manufacturer in it's "marketplace" would also help. Supermarkets would be mostly unaffected, Amazon would need to a) buy the product from it's Sellers at wholesale volume (like a supermarket) and b) compete based on other merits like faster shipping, customer service, etc.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/b?node=13496283011 [2] https://www.wsj.com/articles/amazon-scooped-up-data-from-its...

fbelzile··on FTC Sues Facebook for Illegal Monopolization
Thank you. This is the first time I've seen my thoughts on this explained so clearly. This is something I felt was unfair but couldn't quite pare it down in a succinct argument like that.

It just feels so obvious. What leads someone as smart as Bezos to ignore this line of reasoning? Even if it turns out that it's not "illegal," I feel like deep down, people inside the company just know what they're doing is slimy, or at least, unfair.

Wouldn't it be in the best interest of Amazon to call itself a marketplace (or 'bazaar') to avoid future legislative action?

fbelzile··on Show HN: Slices – puzzle game
I agree with this, it matches what I felt too. I stopped playing at level 10 because it started to feel repetitive (also, I could see myself spend too much time on this :P)
fbelzile··on AirPods Max
I agree, the customer support rep was very nice when he told me I had to buy a new Mac mini when my hard drive failed after 5 years. They even offered to recycle the old one if I paid $50! How nice!
fbelzile··on AirPods Max
> They just don't care as much about lock in as you.

I'm sure some Apple customers realize what's happening. As in, they knowingly look at the slowly boiling pot of water and get in because it's not hot enough to burn them yet.

But I think for the most part, Apple is exploiting a common blind spot in human psychology, the ability to predict the future. People look at the Apple devices they have now and make a decision to buy Airpods. They don't see the future implications of being locked-in.

The typical Apple consumer probably starts with an iPhone or mac (because of phone plans, open standards, apps, etc). The real lock-in begins with the AirPods, iWatch, etc. Once they get you to buy one of these 'lock in' devices, they're much more likely to continue making more money off of you the next time you need a new laptop/phone/desktop. That's all well and fine if you know this going in, but I'd wager most don't.

fbelzile··on AirPods Max
> I'm happy to pay $500 for something that works

Sure, if by "works" you mean "only works with other Apple products." The cost isn't just $500, it's also the opportunity cost of going with any other competing (and possibly better) product in the future. Apple's pricing is high, but is even higher if you account for the hidden hand of future buying power you give them. It's a brilliant business strategy as it limits your choice as a consumer for the lifetime of the headphones.

Say Apple decides to slow down your old iPhone again (what? no! [1])... Or maybe you just like the new Google Pixel. Sucks to be you, time to buy a new iPhone again ($$$) if you don't want your headphones to stop "just working."

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-51413724

fbelzile··on Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy-saving platform
> The company is registered in Malta because the Apple co-founder said he had long wanted to invest in the region. "It has been on my mind for decades. Like no other place in the world," he said.

Statements like this make me question the truthiness of the entire venture. If they chose Malta for specific tax reasons or laws, just say so! Most rational people are going to read this and have their bullshit detector go off (for better or for worse).

fbelzile··on Diem – A rebrand of Facebook’s Libra
I agree with you, but there are some people around the world that don't trust their governments. A use-case most people here would agree with is in the yellow economic circle in Hong Kong: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_economic_circle

Using a cryptocurrency is kind of like a technological band-aid to a political problem. Viewed through the lens as a form of peaceful protest against the government, it makes sense. Otherwise, it's completely your call if you want to make transactions where the receiver has no obligation to provide the product or service you paid for.

fbelzile··on Yet another macOS privacy protections bypass
Sorry, I didn't mean to argue for apps to be able to read your browsing history.

The main point I was trying to make was that apps having network access without warning is more of a security/privacy issue than apps being able to read local files without warning. It's probably why Little Snitch became so popular and why I think Apple is in the process of shoving them out of the market by building it into the OS (I'm guessing!).

fbelzile··on Yet another macOS privacy protections bypass
No, not any random app. You knowingly chose to install the app. It either came from the App Store or it was notarized by Apple.

There are just so many reasons why software needs to access your hard drive. My app, for example, needs to write files in ~/Library/Application Support/Chrome in order to add native messaging permissions for my extension. Can you imagine the number of "Karens" that are going to email me because they "caught" me trying to "steal their data" if they add restrictions to this folder?

Apple did the right thing by only adding warnings for more sensitive areas like your Downloads or Documents folder, but any more than that and I think it'll cause more harm than good.

I agree with the blog post. Apple seems to be more focused with "security theatre" right now (or at least half-assed security for the sake of marketing). They do things like add easy-to-implement (via their FileManager class) file access warnings to appease most non-technical users. But at the same time ignore bigger looming threats like apps accessing the Internet. I think the issue isn't the warnings, it's what the warnings are about.

Anyway, my guess is that Apple will be adding network access warnings in the future (since it seems they re-wrote a large chunk of the networking code recently) but let's not deny the two-faced marketing speak going on right now and fact that they do stuff like making it impossible to inspect network traffic from Apple apps. The hand-wavy "trust us" argument shouldn't work for Apple either. Why do I have to trust Apple more than a third party developer?

fbelzile··on FrontPage: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
You're a very good writer. Thank you for this :) If you had a mailing list, I'd sign up!
fbelzile··on PHP 8
I've never thought about it this way before, but it makes sense! I think I've been pushing things from the middle to the edges subconsciously but didn't have a solid understanding as to why. I got something out of this, thank you!
fbelzile··on 1% of farms operate 70% of world's farmland
Increased innovation created through more competition (eg: vertical farming). Also, all the issues associated with mono-cultures.

I don't think comparing agribusiness to other industries is going to help. Yes, factory farming is more efficient, which makes it cheaper. But the price we pay doesn't necessarily reflect the actual costs to our health and the environment.

fbelzile··on 1% of farms operate 70% of world's farmland
Common, yes. There's bound to be some kind of disproportion between the number of land owners vs land area in capitalist societies. Though, the extent of the power law distribution is surprising, at least to me.
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →