HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hwbehrens

1,437 karma · joined October 10, 2019

https://behrens.dev

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/hwbehrens; my proof: https://keybase.io/hwbehrens/sigs/dLHJ81Px5e89QVjFDYNRo6_ogUJozHWtgGR9MK3AYQQ ]

submissionscomments
hwbehrens··on Irish police to be given powers over passwords
> [...] we see this here in the US as well.

This is only true when the revealed information is a "foregone conclusion", specifically when it "adds little or nothing to the sum total of the Government’s information."

Here is a good treatment on the subject: https://harvardlawreview.org/2021/04/state-v-andrews/

hwbehrens··on Apple asks staff to return to office 3 days a week starting in early September
I'm obviously an outlier, but I live an 8 minute (peaceful) bike ride from work. I hate commuting, so I optimized for that for this job, and working from home last year was absolutely a net negative for me. Distracting kids, poor work-life balance, more expensive (AC, food, water, etc).

I think the lesson here is, some companies can be remote-first, some companies can be in-person, and different employees will prefer different environments based on what's going on in their lives and the choices they make.

It should not be the case that one "tribe" should try to impose their preference on the other, which was the case pre-COVID (e.g. almost everyone was forced to be in-person), and I suspect fear of a return to that status quo is what is driving a lot of these discussions.

hwbehrens··on Swiss Covid Certificate – Technical documentation of the swiss Covid certificate
This is true in the U.S. as well [0]. Some states allow for religious, philosophical, or medical exemptions; these exceptions are similar to the systems implemented in the Netherlands (religious [1]), Australia (philosophical [2]) or Germany (medical [1]).

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccination_policy_in_the_Unit...

[1]: https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1057/s41271-019-001...

[2]: https://www.sabin.org/sites/sabin.org/files/restricted/Salmo...

hwbehrens··on U.S. moves to double Canadian lumber tariffs
It varies between regions, but in general, building with wood is significantly faster and less expensive than using concrete. They are also easier to remodel, extend, and ultimately demolish, but these are secondary reasons.

Some areas, such as regions of Florida or Arizona for example, have substantial historical housing stock made from concrete. However, the majority of new construction is wood for the reasons stated above.

There are not (to my knowledge) any building codes that prohibit concrete construction for residential.

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: Where would you incorporate in 2021?
The parent may be referring to the Nonhabitual Resident Status exemption, which provides reduced (potentially to 0%) tax rates for different types of income. However, it appears that this may be changing [0]. "Portugal Golden Visa" is a good search to start.

[0]: https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2020/04/flash-alert-20...

hwbehrens··on E-Prime – English without the verb “to be”
My experience with E-Prime began with a challenge predicated on the idea that the copula stands in for far too many verbs, and that by limiting the use of one verb, the heterogeneity of the remainder increases. Viewed in that context, I think E-Prime provides some benefit.

It does sometimes lead to belabored wording, and demands more careful consideration during composition. However, when regarded as a tool for encourage more thoughtful word choice, and in contrast to the explicitly stated goals of "Newspeak", the use of E-Prime increases the 'area of choice' and broadens the spectrum of vocabulary used in practice, if not in theory.

hwbehrens··on What if remote work didn’t mean working from home?
A trick I've used before in a pinch is to set your monitor connection (via USB-C/HDMI/DisplayPort) as the Zoom audio output. I never use it as an output, so it's permanently muted in the on-screen menus. Since Zoom makes it fairly easy to customize audio, it can act as a simple mute effect.
hwbehrens··on Complexities of e-mail validation logic
My email address ends with the .cc TLD, and the number of websites which say "Did you mean to type .ca?" and then refuse to let me continue without changing it drives me similarly batty.
hwbehrens··on Ask HN: What kind of chair are you using for WFH?
I've been using a Steelcase Leap that I bought way back in 2008, and it's basically as good as new. Considering how much time we spend in our chairs and how (relatively) durable they are, I think making the investment in a nice one is probably not one you'll regret.

You might want to visit a local ergonomics store to test-drive, if it's practical for you -- for example, I personally don't prefer Aerons because the mesh bothers me. Those kinds of personal preferences are better to discover prior to spending $$$ on something.

Also, don't discount the rest of your equipment -- equally important to my ergonomics are wrist support and proper monitor placement. A good-quality VESA arm will also last decades and be able to follow you around. Your monitor should be about arms-length from you, with the center of the screen falling about a hand-span below your eye line.

hwbehrens··on One man’s fight for the right to repair broken MacBooks
> If a third party is paying a reasonably agreed upon market price to a factory to buy extra factory run of stock (example: DRAM ICs, or touchscreens), that's not theft.

In the case this is a misunderstanding of the US perspective, and not a deliberate misinterpretation, the context taken here by Apple is based on US intellectual property law.

In that context, this would be a criminal offense and would very likely be pursued in court by Apple, leading to punitive damages, loss of contract, or both (e.g., the GEEP lawsuit). Third-shift manufacturing [0] is seen as a serious issue by many large corporations who have their production based in China for this reason.

If the schematics or other intellectual property were transferred to a third party (e.g. another factory) for production, then this would be IP theft, if the use of the word `theft` specifically is the crux of your objection.

I'm not saying the current situation is "right" or "correct", just clarifying the terminology so everyone is on the same page semantically.

[0]: https://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1825...

hwbehrens··on 2022 Ford F-150 Lightning
> I do notice (and sometimes make fun) if [...]

I think this is the key point in the whole thread. I have no idea how many people who live on my street have pickups -- I've never noticed.

The only pickups I notice are the ones which are "coal rolling", have multiple flagpoles flying political slogans in the bed, or are lifted so far I have clear sightlines beneath them.

I have never seen a "coal rolling" Honda Accord, in contrast.

hwbehrens··on How the UK's online safety bill threatens Matrix
While I agree with their position overall, particularly with the ambiguity of "harmfulness", I think this is not the right tack to take here:

> fails to acknowledge how actually harmful it would be for certain groups of the population to have their real life identity associated with their online identity

No nanny-state-style government is going to buy this argument for a moment, because it requires a certain level of distrust of authority that certainly won't be present in the authorities themselves. Even among the population at large, there are undeniable trends in many countries towards authoritarianism on both the left and the right that are ignored or embraced by a majority (or a large minority) of their respective bases of support.

Combined with prevailing trends against web-based anonymity and concerns over "fake news" and other amplification mechanisms for information warfare, I suspect we will see a further bifurcation into regulated, KYC-style services and unregulated, anonymous communities. Even here on HN, posters and commenters are regularly chastised for failing to adequately disclose their identities when they have a vested interest in the topic under discussion.

Rather, the privacy angle which has been so conveniently mooted by Apple lately is (in my opinion) more palatable to the general public. By giving more responsibility to the service providers, the government is also implicitly giving them more power as well (as censors, if nothing else). But in practice, most people have personally observed that when more power/information is provided to private companies, it leads to a slippery slope of monetization, advertising, and lock-in.

An appeal to this sense of unfairness and power imbalance with companies seems more "sellable" to me than convincing people their governments have nefarious/censorious motives. As a supporting argument, consider the general global consensus on gun control -- if people were willing to believe that their governments were ready to turn on them (in terms of physical oppression) at any moment, there would be more global concern about the physical power disparity between police/military and the civilian populace.

Currently (with some exceptions, e.g. the U.S.), the global consensus is that people are much more willing to trust their police/military with weaponry than their fellow citizens, based on the implicit notion that the likelihood of experiencing harm from the latter is disproportionately more likely than the former.

In contrast, as partially evidenced by the relative growth of Signal as a response to the changes in WhatsApp and the public support for app-tracking changes in iOS, people are demonstrably concerned about privacy in the commercial space.

Thus, I theorize that an appeal to privacy would be more effective: "Under the proposed changes, we would have the ability to do ____, which would exploit your personal, private information for profit. If we can do it, that means ____, ____, and ____ can do it too. Do you want your government giving even more power to private companies to profit off you?"

hwbehrens··on China increases spending 500% to influence America
The parent is referring to this [0] (satirical) conspiracy theory.

[0]: https://birdsarentreal.com/pages/the-history

hwbehrens··on I mailed an AirTag and tracked its progress
The "Participate in 'Find My Network' is the option you're referring to, but it's opt-out, not opt-in.
hwbehrens··on Amazon Sidewalk
I do research on mesh networking, and the response to Sidewalk in the tech community has been pretty discouraging. People have rightly brought up Apple's Find My network as a similar application; companies are leveraging existing, ubiquitous devices to create additional network transport layers. See also, the proliferation and adoption of the Thread protocol.

This doesn't mean we have to use these networks! But this is one of the first, easiest steps to make progress towards ubiquitous, decentralized connectivity. I understand that not everyone trusts Amazon with their private data, but do you trust Verizon or Comcast more? I don't!

If there are multiple, competing standards that offer heterogeneous connectivity options, we'll be (relatively) much closer to resilient, censorship-resistant communication infrastructure than we are now. Like TCP/UDP, there are methods to guard the contents of a message on mesh networks as well.

Finally, for those who think that it would be better to maintain centralized, monopolistic infrastructure and legislate privacy through legal means instead, I would argue that the arc of government is long, and bends toward control & surveillance. If a government is the only barrier between users and total control of information flow, then if that government wavers in their commitment, regaining the previous level of freedom is very difficult without the ability to communicate freely.

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: Are you still using Keybase?
I still use it for its identity features, but I switched chat over to a Matrix instance. To be honest, the timing of the acquisition wasn't good -- it came at the height of the Zoom/China FUD, and given that Keybase attracts security-minded users, it was a recipe for diaspora.
hwbehrens··on What is Chia cryptocurrency and why is it bad news for hard drives?
> what Bitcoin has done to GPUs

I understand your argument, but Bitcoin hasn't been mined on GPUs since 2011/2012. Broaden your argument from Bitcoin to "proof of work schemes" more generally, and from GPUs to "profligate (mis)use of resources", and it will land more effectively.

If you are against cryptocurrencies more broadly, inclusive of proof of stake and other more recent approaches that aim to address the resource consumption issue, then that position didn't come across clearly.

hwbehrens··on Hedonometer: Average Happiness of Twitter over Time
It seems counterintuitive that as the volume of tweets increases, the variance increases. What could be the explanation for this?
hwbehrens··on Dominance of Apple and Google’s app stores impacting competition and consumers
In technical terms, this situation is referred to as a monopsony [0]; the customer can, at any time, go out and purchase apps from other sources. However, app developers cannot choose to "sell" their apps to other retailers, since there are basically only 2.

It's a distinction without a difference in terms of the power they exert, but legally speaking, the distinction is relevant because the types of behaviors that are proscribed (in the U.S., at least) are relatively narrowly defined. This is not the first time these laws would have to be modified to account for shifts in market exploitation practices, nor will it be last.

For a recent discussion of the topic, see [1].

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopsony [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/24/opinion/joan-robinson-eco...

hwbehrens··on CDC panel recommends resuming use of Johnson and Johnson vaccine
While I mostly agree, there have been a few rare cases of reinfection; here [0] is a metastudy that looks at several claims of reinfection, ultimately concluding that 6 cases were credible reinfections. So while the relative risk is very low, I think one could make a plausible argument that since the risk of harmful side effects is also low, getting vaccinated may be beneficial.

There is also preliminary evidence [1] to indicate that post-infection vaccination can help to resolve lingering symptoms such as fatigue, breathlessness, and insomnia.

[0]: https://www.journalofinfection.com/article/S0163-4453(20)305...

[1]: https://europepmc.org/article/ppr/ppr296506

hwbehrens··on Ubuntu 21.04
My guess is that it was downvoted because it violates two of the comment guidelines:

> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

The parent comment is neither thoughtful nor substantive, merely agreeing with the grandparent -- a verbose equivalent of a "This!" comment. A better comment might include the commenter's reasoning, their experiences with other platforms and their pros and cons, or how they have used Ubuntu personally or professionally, for example.

> Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents.

The parent's implicit dismissal of Windows or Mac desktop platforms as un-enjoyable could be interpreted as flamebait, since choice of operating system can be a common point of contention.

Hopefully this explanation helps. Since the comment was low-quality but not flagrantly bad, I assume it will pick up one or two downvotes but not a flag, and will sink naturally down the discussion as higher-quality posts supersede it.

hwbehrens··on Trust in blockchain-based systems
> citizens should trust a protocol (and an implementation, and a machine) that only people having a doctorate in the field can assess

People commonly do rely upon encryption schemes in precisely this way to protect their finances, healthcare, privacy, and so on (and in spite of constant implementation failures!). I would revise the premise to something like, "it will several decades for users to build trust such a system".

> In my opinion, e-voting is a solution to a problem that never existed.

I believe using it to re-implement existing voting schemes is misguided; it would be like using the internet to replace in-person banking with video calls to a bank teller. New paradigms are more exciting to me than recreations of existing paradigms, even if some features are sacrificed (e.g. cash deposits, in the banking example).

The geographically-hierarchical systems we rely on currently evolved based on their useful properties of being communication- and computation-efficient. That is, holding elections which satisfy the Smith criterion [0] or offer Byzantine tolerance [1] would be difficult to achieve if all you have is paper, pencil, and Pony Express. It also supports why elections are held relatively infrequently -- sending politicians overland to gather together to perform some kind of in-person consensus mechanism (e.g. quorum establishment) isn't something you want to do all the time.

We have back-justified this system with the rationalization that local leaders best reflect the concerns of their community, but this is an enormous simplification -- essentially, it takes the preference space of the electorate (all the issues they care about), embeds it down to one dimension (the list of candidates), and then re-projects it back to the higher space (the candidate's stances). Preserving the feature space by holding more frequent elections [2], or allowing users to choose which features they care about through issue-based vote delegation [3], would be more interesting to me.

To go back to the previous point, as complexity increases, trust becomes more difficult to grow, and existing mechanisms also have thousands of years as a head-start. It will take time, but I hope that people will be open-minded enough to try it at some point in the future. Maybe it will be as low-stakes as how to stock the office fridge, or which equipment to purchase for the local park. But these are the kinds of baby steps that will eventually enable better governance systems.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_criterion

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_fault

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semi-direct_democracy

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy

hwbehrens··on Amazon workers vote against unionizing in Alabama
> the employer is incentivized to hold back raises, benefits, and concessions until it's time for negotiations

The employer is incentivized to hold these back in any case, absent some countervailing pressure (e.g. retention against competing offers, if they exist, etc.). This is why the largest raises (in tech, at least) typically come when jumping companies.

hwbehrens··on Amazon workers vote against unionizing in Alabama
Wouldn't that be a false negative?

A false positive would be when a high-performer is perceived as being a low-performer, and terminated for that reason despite their superior productivity.

I can certainly imagine this occurring, especially to employees who are socially deficient, but then you start to get into the quagmire of politically- and socially-motivated terminations, which I think is outside the scope of this discussion.

hwbehrens··on ISO-8601 date format reference not publicly available
It's not an analogy -- ISO/IEC 18033-3 [0] is literally an encryption standard that you have to buy to inspect.

[0]: https://www.iso.org/standard/37972.html

hwbehrens··on In the U.S., more immigrants with children are still in their first marriage
What makes it more surprising to me (as a participant in the counter-contrarian dynamic that dang highlighted) is that among the many factors that correlate with reductions in divorce rate, they must surely be over-represented in the HN demographics: higher educations, greater incomes, later marriages, and more technical professions, for example.

HN commenters (or the stereotype thereof) who are married would actually be more likely to be in stable marriages, and thus able to weigh first-hand the relative likelihood of a stable/happy correlation.

hwbehrens··on Why are fewer young adults having casual sex?
One of the cited works [0] did look at the relationship between mental health and sexual activity, if you're interested.

They found that higher sexual activity correlated with greater levels of depression, especially in men. Sexually active women also correlated with decreases in mental health, but the authors' interpretation was that that decline primarily stems from higher rates of victimization among that population, which would obviously lead to negative mental outcomes.

[0]: https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10508-019-014...

hwbehrens··on Jacquard by Google
And the relevant HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9625641
hwbehrens··on Join a browser fingerprinting study
It seems the intention of the study is precisely to determine the impacts that these plugins have on prevention (or facilitation) of fingerprinting.

I think it should eventually complete, since mine did and I use a similar constellation of privacy plugins -- I think there is a timeout that eventually occurs once the various fingerprinting methods fail.

hwbehrens··on An Engineering Argument for Basic Income
> you don't want to increase the UBI amount because it'll cost you more than it gets you

I think this is an oversimplification, because in practice, there will be a gradient of people around the inflection point who would be willing to take less in order to stop working, and that gradient will vary by the individual and by the job.

Additionally, I can also imagine politicians promising increases to the UBI without concomitant tax increases, funded by bonds or other kind of financial mechanisms for monetary injection whose long-term negative externalities would be easy to obfuscate from voters.

> Imagine a world with widespread automation and general or close-to-general AI without a UBI.

This is the key point. UBI is (in my current opinion) a necessary tool for smoothing an economic transition to a highly-automated level. However, I am concerned that it might induce other economic instabilities such as in tax rates, voluntary or involuntary unemployment, underemployment, inflation, borrowing, minimum wage, and so on -- these instabilities could then spread to social or political disruption that would undermine progress towards the transition that UBI was originally meant to support.

Since the size of the UBI would roughly correlate with the size of its influence economically/socially/politically, then as the UBI increases, the variance of these potential instabilities would also increase. As such, increases to the UBI should be carefully controlled, for example by gating them to developmental milestones. Of course, that opens a whole can of worms on who sets the milestones and so on, so I suppose it's really just shrugging and hand-wringing all the way down.

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →