HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ijpoijpoihpiuoh

389 karma · joined September 24, 2018

submissionscomments
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google’s 4k-Word Privacy Policy Is a History of the Internet
If that's what the person I was replying to meant, they should just say that. They shouldn't say, "It's too long to read."

I don't agree at all with your point of view. I still think consenting adults can take some responsibility for making their own decisions about things. Obviously there should be exceptions when there are serious safety concerns, but such is plainly not the case with search engines.

Anyway, the TOU doesn't even address privacy very much. It would be a paragraph shorter if Google collected no user data at all. So I don't really think that is the point the top-level poster in this thread was making. Or if it was the point they were trying to make, they were doing so circuitously indeed.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google’s 4k-Word Privacy Policy Is a History of the Internet
I don't get it. People want comprehensive details about what companies do with their information, but they also want short privacy policies. You can't have both. And if you look at Google's privacy policy, it's not legalese at all. It's mostly explanatory, since its text binds Google, not the user.

The TOU is a different matter, but, again, users and the law have forced companies into the situation where they have to explicitly spell out every detail. Even with that, Google's terms are written in what seems to me to be plain English (https://policies.google.com/terms?gl=us). What would you cut from that to make it more concise? I can see a few things, but I'm also not a lawyer, and I'm not equipped to judge what liabilities each sentence might protect Google from.

Most people never read this stuff because most people just don't care. They'll never have a dispute with Google that would be covered by the terms, and they don't care enough about privacy to find a less convenient but more privacy-sensitive alternative. Even if they do care about privacy, they probably have a pretty good idea of what kinds of information Google collects, so the privacy policy is at most a reference for cases where they are unsure. Attempting to force them to read it would be unproductive, since it contains information that is either irrelevant or else already known to potential users.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on On the Homogenizing Dangers of Easily Translated Literature (2016)
As with most literary criticism, I'm pretty skeptical of this. Thinking in the opposite direction, Snow Crash would be easier to translate than Neuromancer. Neuromancer would be easier to translate than Finnegan's Wake. That doesn't mean that Snow Crash is part of some homogeneous morass or any less worthy than those other two novels. Though I suppose many literary critics would prize the Joyce over the Stephenson, there are no absolutes in art. There is just what people like.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University System Pleads for Lifeline
If you vote for a budget hawk, he wins, and then he does budget hawk things, in my book, that's getting what you asked for. It's true that you don't get to choose the exact shape of what you are getting, but you do get to choose the general direction. The people know or should know that, and vote accordingly.

It would be different if, for example, they voted for a tax and spend Democrat and then, when elected, that official had made deep budget and tax cuts.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Blindsided by a Devastating Veto, Alaska University System Pleads for Lifeline
Perhaps this makes me a terrible person, but I sometimes half hope to see things like this go through. The people of Alaska asked for this, and it will be interesting to see if they like getting what they asked for. The main reason it's only "half-hope" rather than fully hoping is that the damage from this will still affect people who didn't vote in favor of it. Those kids at the university deserve a better education than they'll get presuming the cut is allowed to stand.

Alternately, if I'm wrong about the value of austerity, and these deep cuts do allow the economy of Alaska to grow, that would also be interesting to learn. Previous recent experiments in this approach, particularly Kansas', don't seem to encourage much hope. But I'd be a fool to believe that you can take budgetary changes and trailing economic results in isolation. The system is far more complicated than that.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Temperatures in France cross 45°C threshold for first time since records began
Maybe. If the average winter temperatures go up, the air conditioning will be at least partially offset by lower heating costs. Of course, there are also theories of global climate change where both the high and low extremes will increase, in which case there's a double-whammy effect.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Type inference has usability problems
The supposed advantage. Many perfectly productive languages don't even offer the option to specify the type at all, and not just in the inference case. As far as I'm aware, nobody has ever convincingly demonstrated (with empirical data) that this is worse along any metric that people care about (development speed, bugs, cost, etc.).

A lot of people have preferences on this front. Somehow, these preferences get promoted to best practices if not moral license. Just, which approach is claimed to be better really depends on who you ask, and then mainly on whichever language that person first cut their teeth on. And nobody's going to be able to cite any well-designed study that demonstrates their preference is actually superior, because none exist.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on US Navy's Railgun Now Undergoing Tests in New Mexico
To me, it's not entirely clear why we're bothering. Do we actually envision shore bombardment as a useful combat modality going forward? IIRC the types of ships that can mount this weapon are the same types that are currently vulnerable to hypersonic anti-ship missiles. All our potential equiv-tech adversaries have those, to my understanding. So wouldn't the railgun only be useful against lower tech opponents? And against such opponents, does it fill a substantial gap where we don't already have sufficient other tools?
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on How Bad Are Things? (2015)
The author probably knows this, but I think a lot of these bad things are dependent one one another. Probably all of them. Poverty (food stamps) probably correlates strongly with all of abuse, especially physical, pain, prison, cognitive disability, other disability, schizophrenia, and old age. Dementia is heavily associated with old age as well.

Which is not to say that things are great, but I think the badness is fairly concentrated on a relatively smaller set of people than the script's results indicate.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Can Life Exist in 2 and 1 Dimensions?
I had a similar reaction to you. People seem to have very limited imaginations when thinking about the types of things that could exist. Or maybe the title is incomplete. Maybe the paper is saying something more like, "Could life exist in a plane that otherwise has the same or very similar physics and chemistry as the universe?" In which case I could understand the skepticism about life's existence.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Gmail confidential mode is not secure or private
Modes like this are not intended to provide hard security. They are not designed to deal with malicious recipients. Rather, they're intended to provide a barrier to accidental or unthinking dissemination of confidential content. It is also designed to prevent permanent retention and the ongoing risk that represents. It solves or limits the fallout from the "silly friend" and "new enemy" problems.

There is no way to convey information to a malicious human s.t. that human cannot convey it onwards to unwanted recipients. The best you can do is provide strong disincentives. Some options for doing this: make sure that your recipients generally don't want to hurt you. Make them fear you (even that doesn't always work, see [1]).

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on A Growing Problem in Real Estate: Too Many Too Big Houses
While 700 square meters is indeed absurd for any family, 150 square meters seems a bit limiting. There are reasonable use-cases for houses larger than that. A living room, a kitchen, three bedrooms and an office will be hard to eke out of that much space.

The justification is pretty idiotic: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/11/13/mega-homes-banne...

50% higher than the average? OK, but what if you have above average needs? (Four kids, live in grandparents, etc.) There are plenty of "real people" who derive legitimate benefit from more than 150 square meters.

Ah well. My city has its share of idiot housing policies, but at least this isn't one of them. We are buying a 300 square meter house in a few days, and it feels like it'll be just about right for our needs.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Nines are not enough: meaningful metrics for clouds
The only real SLA is the ability to vote with your feet and go to another provider that satisfies your business needs, or conversely to increase your investment with a particular cloud if you are satisfied with their performance. Providers know this, and they know that even if they wanted to, they can't capture all the possible values that are important to your particular business in numerical metrics. They also know that what is important to your business might not be important to another one, and therefore that it is hopeless to try to capture the entire gamut in a single set of metrics that are universally applicable. Any attempt would be futile, so it's best to stick to simpler metrics and let businesses and customers decide for themselves whether a given cloud meets their particular needs. SLA violation penalties hurt a little, but the real pain comes when you lose business.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on $1B for 20,000 Bay Area homes
Some people don't have the luxury of living in bespoke housing, and legitimately do want a roof over their head for the minimum price possible. Some others are not architecture aficionados, and would prefer to save, even if they could afford "nicer."
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Google won't help
He is a public personality and in that role has been related to Bitcoin. And he also has his phone number and email publicly visible on the internet.

https://gizmodo.com/a-tv-anchor-tries-to-gift-bitcoin-on-air...

It seems like this only happens to people who have poor opsec about their email addresses, phone numbers, and are publicly related to the cryptocurrency movement. I mean, I'm sure it happens to other people, but that's the only case I've ever heard about.

I would personally be wary about publicly listing the email I use with my bank, or my phone number, and I've done what I can to scrub the internet of these values. If you have to be publicly reachable through a medium other than Facebook or Twitter, have a separate email and phone number through which you conduct your serious personal business. But most people do not need this kind of public reachability, or else have it through work. For those types of people, it would behoove them to keep their profile small.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on SIM swap horror story: I've lost decades of data and Google won't help
You should have emergency backup keys as well printed on real paper. I have a set stored with our important files, and another in my nightstand. Having my phone stolen would be a damnable inconvenience, since that is my second factor -- although not via SIM, but via Google's in-app authentication. But it wouldn't be fatal.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Carnival Cruises emits ten times more sulphur oxide than all of Europe’s cars
"All ships shall keep a record of which fuels they have burned. Each time a ship docks in a European port, the log shall be submitted to the customs enforcement unit at that port. The enforcement unit shall tally the amount of dirty fuel burned since the ship last docked in Europe.

"A ship that has burned X dirty fuel shall be charged $Y Euros per liter burned. If a ship is found to have created fraudulent logs, it shall be charged $Y*10, or seized. There is a reward for reporting such fraud leading to seizure equal to 10% of the forfeiture."

Or something like that. As long as the penalty is financially meaningful compared to the income of the ship's engineer, you would quickly start to have trouble getting away with using such fuel.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Carnival Cruises emits ten times more sulphur oxide than all of Europe’s cars
Does it matter how the ship is flagged? I could imagine solutions like, "If you dock in Europe and your ship is out of compliance, you must pay $X in fines." You can tune $X to whatever is needed to cover the calculated negative externalities.
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Dark Web Drug Sellers Dodge Police Crackdowns
> blindly enforcing a law for that law's sake.

I think this take is really uncharitable. I believe many/most people in the US believe that the laws controlling illegal drugs have at least some good purposes. Sure, most people want weed to be legal (not everyone, but most people). But heroin and fentanyl? I'm guessing support for legalizing those is well below the 50% mark. I bet in an unbiased poll, most people would support efforts to disrupt marketplaces that sell these goods.

I agree that if law enforcement believed what, say, many HNers believe about the effectiveness of prohibition laws, this type of enforcement would represent a slavish devotion to the law over justice. But I'm guessing they generally believe the law is a good law and that the country is better off with it enforced.

> This action doesn't appear to actually enforce any law

I already referenced the law that it enforces. I'm not sure what you mean by reasserting that it doesn't enforce any law, while in the previous paragraph you conceded that "[law enforcement were] enforcing a law for that law's sake." Are they or aren't they enforcing a law?

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Dark Web Drug Sellers Dodge Police Crackdowns
Broadly speaking, the law in question is Title 21 Chapter 13 of the US Code. Buying and selling controlled substances without appropriate authorization is illegal. Disruption of illegal activities by law enforcement is generally legal, provided no other laws are broken in the process.

Now, whether buying and selling these substances should be illegal is another question. But it's definitely not obvious that law enforcement is outside its typical role here.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Let's make them pay for using our personal data
> Do you remember when you were looking for good pair of hiking boots on Google and almost imminently you start seeing promoted posts about nice shoes discounts on Facebook and Twitter.

I don't think this happens?

> Basically what happens is that Google without your (explicit) confirmation collects all history of you search requests and sell it to another company.

This definitely does not happen. Google doesn't sell search history to anyone else. It may be the case that Google itself remarkets things to you. But I don't think so, since how would they get paid in that transaction? Through affiliate links? Doubtful.

Instead, I think what actually happens is that people make a search, they click a link, and target of that link (be it Amazon or some other store) associates their profile with interest in a particular product, then remarkets to that profile on Facebook.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on The Climate and Cloudflare
For anyone wondering why RECs are not enough: they don't make you carbon neutral, not even in theory. Even though renewable energy is better than non-renewable, the processes that built the renewable plants might not be carbon neutral. Also, renewable energy credits might just displace the previous user of renewable energy to non-renewable, which means that you won't have impacted the total renewable energy usage ratio of the planet at all.

To be carbon neutral, you'd have to buy carbon offsets like Google [1] do. There's a lot of really complicated accounting that goes into making sure that you aren't just pushing the dirt from one place to another when you think about renewable energy and carbon offsets.

[1]: https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/www.google.com/en...

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on After the Bust, Are Bitcoins More Like Tulip Mania or the Internet?
I thought this was exactly what you can't do, at least not easily, because the tokens are considered securities if used this way?
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google launches an end-to-end AI platform
The person I'm responding to is comparing product shutdowns between AWS (a cloud services divsion of Amazon) to Google (a company that contains both a cloud services division and a vastly larger consumper products division). This is an apples to oranges comparison. That's how it's relevant.

Before you say, "Amazon never shuts anything down, even outside of cloud." A) They do [1]. B) They have a tiny range of products compared to Google, so of course the absolute frequency of shutdowns will also be lower.

And before you say, "Well, better to have nothing than to have something and have it shut down." A) Some people [2] would disagree. B) Just don't use products in the category (consumer services) that Google tends to shut things down in.

But, please, whatever you do, don't spam every single thread where Google launches a cloud product (a category where they have a decent track record) with your gripes about Google Reader or whatever. It's not helpful and it's not relevant.

[1]: https://www.theverge.com/2015/10/25/9605840/amazon-shuts-dow... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred,_Lord_Tennyson

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google launches an end-to-end AI platform
> Compare to AWS

AWS is not a consumer-facing organization. The standards there are entirely different. Google Cloud has a much more stable offering than Google writ large. Very few of the products on gcemetery.co are cloud-related.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Google launches an end-to-end AI platform
I wish that people would stop with this unproductive line of commentary. Google shuts down consumer products sometimes. Pruning back the set of unprofitable things you're working on is good business. Expect to see Google and literally every other successful company continue to take this approach to unprofitable lines of business.

Also, how would putting ads on a developer platform be profitable? It's far more likely that they would charge money for it.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on The IRS Tried to Take on the Ultrawealthy – It Didn’t Go Well
> A flat tax is regressive [because what matters is utility of money].

It's fine to think that, but normally when people are talking about tax progressiveness, they are thinking about the fractional tax on dollars, not "utils". Otherwise, you'd also call our existing, progressive taxation scheme "regressive," since it still probably taxes poor people's utils at a higher rate than rich people. And there would probably not anywhere in the world be a tax scheme that can properly be called progressive.

One good rule of thumb, IMO, is that when you want to change the meaning of a classifier such that all extant instances of the classified type fall into a single bucket, that's probably not a useful change. YMMV.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on The IRS Tried to Take on the Ultrawealthy – It Didn’t Go Well
"As it affects everyone at the same rate." That's a flat tax. A regressive tax is one that affects the poor more.

However, you are right that it is probably regressive, since the rich normally place more of their wealth percentage-wise in non-cash assets than poor people do.

ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on The IRS Tried to Take on the Ultrawealthy – It Didn’t Go Well
You are worried about the wasted brains in tech companies reading this article? I didn't worry about wasted brains at all, because I value people's agency. But now that you bring it up, it seems like if you're going to worry about brains being wasted, surely it should be those of the tax lawyers helping the rich hide this income?
ijpoijpoihpiuoh··on Facebook to ban white nationalist content
> Its because its not allowed, we either have a list of protected groups - or a general rule that forbids banning anyone because of their 'group'.

It's the former. There is no law, at least in the US, that forbids banning people from private property for group membership in general.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →