HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jballanc

9,437 karma · joined November 23, 2008

I'm just a guy with some ideas...programming lets me do something with them.

Get in touch! jballanc@gmail.com https://github.com/jballanc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jballanc; my proof: https://keybase.io/jballanc/sigs/pxb6FPsVF9hoQMyb2ap0euWoNG3YxwN2g4VY94RRxX8 ]

submissionscomments
jballanc··on SpaceX sticks 11th rocket landing after launching first used Dragon capsule
Designed correctly, there is potentially a whole spectrum between "complete success, desired orbit" and "fire-y ball of death". As other commenters here have pointed out, one of the Space Shuttle's fatal flaws is that it severely narrowed that spectrum (even one of the supposed "abort modes" probably wouldn't have been survivable).

So far, everything SpaceX has done is working to greatly expand the window of "survivable failure". Remember on one of the early Falcon 9 flights when one of the 9 first stage engines literally disintegrated and the rocket kept flying? How many other rockets flying today can do that?

So, no, I don't expect we'll see people die in a SpaceX capsule. When was the last time someone died in a Soyuz?

jballanc··on Coal plants emit more radioactive waste than nuclear plants (2007)
My understanding is that more than direct exposure to radioactive materials in fly ash, the real risk is Radon. As Thorium and Uranium decay they will produce Radon, which can accumulate especially in low-lying areas with poor ventilation (e.g. basements, which tend to rely on concrete as a key building material). Since Radon can be inhaled, it has the potential to cause far more harm than anything "baked into" the concrete itself.
jballanc··on A 16th-century engineer whose work almost defeated the Ottomans
Definitely adding that to my reading list. My understanding is that the Ottoman strategy for controlling the Mediterranean was to go the "long way 'round" and control as much of the surrounding ports, as opposed to the Knights Hospitaler, the Genoese, and the Venetians who took the approach of building unmatched naval strength.

As an example, during the siege of Constantinople, the Genoese and Venetian navies were ultimately defeated when the Ottomans literally carried their ships over land to get behind the other's defensive line.

jballanc··on A 16th-century engineer whose work almost defeated the Ottomans
Suleyman was not only a great military mind, but an extremely astute politician as well. One thing the article fails to mention is that Suleyman didn't just let the people of Rhodes "go free" after their defeat, the Knights Hospitaler had to hand over their fortresses in Kos and Bodrum as part of the deal. This was a smart move as the castle in Bodrum was much better fortified, and Suleyman got it without, in essence, firing a shot. For this reason, the castle in Bodrum is extremely well preserved and a must see if you want to get a sense of crusader architecture.
jballanc··on In southeastern Colorado, robots carefully disarm WWII-era chemical weapons
Well, there's the other interpretation: Such a government jobs program!

I mean, in many cases most of that "huge expense" is going to be salary for the people that manufacture and then dispose of these arms. Of course, that puts the automation of such disposal in an interesting light: the robots are taking our jobs! Admittedly, as in most cases of "robots taking our jobs", these aren't really the sorts of jobs that most people would want to do anyway, but it does change the economic calculus of the whole military-industrial complex.

jballanc··on Where have all the insects gone?
I think the jury's still out on whether or not this is actually different from the past extinctions. Yes, there was an asteroid impact around the time the dinosaurs went extinct, but every year there's some new paper or some new bit of evidence that points to the possibility that the asteroid wasn't the only factor in the K-Pg extinction. It's quite possible that dinosaurs had some role in their own extinction as well.

What is different, in this case, is that in all past cases if the dominant species played a role in bringing about a mass extinction it was almost certainly an accident. We have the (possibly small) chance of potentially averting our own replacement as dominant species, if we're smart...

jballanc··on Where have all the insects gone?
The planet isn't dying. The planet is just a ball of rock running loops around the gravity well of the closest star.

We are, however, in the midst of the sixth great extinction: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction . The evidence for this is pretty dang convincing, even independent of things like global climate change, and it has been going on for quite a while now, starting with the disappearance of mega-fauna from the American continent.

If you do find anyone attempting to "minimize" this fact, you might try pointing something out: each prior great extinction was accompanied by a replacement of the "dominant" species on the Earth. As the current reigning "dominant" species, this seems like something that might be very concerning to humans...

jballanc··on Net neutrality is in jeopardy again
How many ISPs do you have to choose from? Personally, I have two: Comcast and AT&T. Comcast has been a nightmare recently, with almost weekly outages and frequent periods of severely degraded bandwidth. AT&T (even their supposed "Fiber" offering) requires a working copper twisted-pair RJ11 outlet where the gateway is to be installed, which I don't have and which would require an electrician and multiple holes in my walls to supply.

So I'm on Comcast. Reluctantly. Now what if Comcast decided to charge more for access to HN?

Where's your free market god now?

jballanc··on Apple has damaged the perceived value of software
They can now, but couldn't for a loooong time. The damage is done, and everyone now just expects lower prices for iOS apps without realizing that they are (subconsciously, perhaps) pricing in the "it might suck" insurance when they no longer really need to.
jballanc··on Apple has damaged the perceived value of software
I'd argue it's not just the lack of paid upgrades, but also the inability to do trials and/or (easy) refunds. I think the absolute glut of "free with almost all functionality as in-app purchases" style apps speaks to the demand for trials.

The lack of an ability to trial iOS software with no financial risk means that the risk of purchasing crappy software is priced in to the amount people are willing to pay. Think of it as a weird sort of reverse insurance. Every iOS software developer is "paying" (via lower prices) customers for insurance against crappy software and, unfortunately, there is a lot of crappy software, so the premiums are sky-high.

jballanc··on Remove United from your flight results
JetBlue from San Jose is often just as convenient, and the only cost is an extra hour or so on the train.
jballanc··on Remove United from your flight results
I can't begin to explain why, but almost every American airline has been a worse experience for me than almost every non-American airline. I fly regularly on Turkish, for example, and their service is amazing! If ever I have to fly international, they are my first preference, but even Lufthansa, Swiss, AirBerlin, KLM, have all been a nicer experience than any of the major American carriers.

Of course, this doesn't address the issue of dropping United if most of your flying is domestic. In that case, I'd suggest looking into flying out of smaller airports with one of the discount carriers. SouthWest has actually been reasonably good to me. Sure, it's nowhere near the level of service on Turkish, but for the price it's pretty much in line with what I'd expect.

jballanc··on Ask HN: What are pros and cons of PostgreSQL and MySQL?
Pros and Cons depend largely on what you're hoping to use your DB for and how you intend to deploy/administer it. Feature-wise, Postgres has a break-neck speed of new feature adoption compared to MySQL. That could be a Pro or a Con depending on your perspective. If you're dying to try out deep indexing of JSON columns in your SQL DB, then you definitely want Postgres. If you need something stable and reliable, then MySQL might be a better choice.

Not to be trite, but I think the biggest high-level Pro/Con comes down to this: Postgres has the more active OSS community, MySQL has Percona. Seriously, if you're in a situation where you have the option of spending money to solve problems, then having the option of hiring Percona to fix your problems alone makes MySQL a sound decision. If you don't have a large cash reserve, but are willing to spend time combing through message boards and blog posts, pick Postgres.

jballanc··on Fourteen Months with Clojure
There are elements of the Clojure design philosophy that are likely to keep it in the realm of "hosted language" for some time to come. That said, with the advent of self-hosted ClojureScript, there is no reason that you need be tied to the JVM just to use Clojure. In some regards, I see the ClojureScript community growing at an even faster clip than the parent language (though Clojure does have a large head-start).
jballanc··on Ask HN: Do other fields of engineering have an equivalent to whiteboarding?
I've witnessed it in the post-seminar lab visits. It bears little resemblance to the "whiteboard interview" from the developer world, but if you're visiting with a faculty member after you present your work, they may ask you to help them understand some piece of your work by drawing out the mechanism.

I'll disagree with the GP, though, on its applicability to "real-world" work. When I did chemistry, diagraming out a reaction mechanism and pondering it over with colleagues gathered in front of the chalkboard was a daily activity.

jballanc··on Ask HN: Do other fields of engineering have an equivalent to whiteboarding?
It's been almost a decade since I worked in an organic synthesis lab, but when I did we stuck with chalk, instead of the more "modern" whiteboards. There's not much an accidental organic solvent spill will do to slate and sticks of calcium carbonate. Acrylic paint and dry erase markers, on the other hand...
jballanc··on The New ‘Absent Operator’ in Ruby’s Regular Expressions
Same here. I wonder when we stop calling these "regular expressions" and start calling them "parsing expressions"?
jballanc··on Archaea: The 'Dark Matter' of the Microbial World
That is an excellent question!

I should start by saying that we don't know, for sure, that pre-cellular replicons don't still exist. They may, and we may just not have figured out the right place to look for them.

That said, gaining a membrane is a huge advantage for life. The current working hypothesis is that life started as a series of autocatalytic chemical reactions, but for this to work there must have been just the right combination of chemicals in just the right conditions all at the same time. You can imagine that it wouldn't take much of a stray current to wash all that away, and you're back to square one. By surrounding themselves with a membrane, pre-cellular replicons could begin controlling their chemical environment, enriching it with the raw materials needed and regulating the conditions.

Again, though, just because cellular life would be expected to be more robust and, therefore, more successful than acellular replicons, you wouldn't expect those acellular reactions to immediately halt once cellular life arose.

If I had to guess, I'd say that acellular replicons may have persisted for quite some time, but ultimately succumbed to the Great Oxygenation Event (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event). Shortly after cellular life arose (or possibly beginning a bit before cells came on the scene), life cause a massive shift in the Earth's chemistry, freeing vast quantities of oxygen and changing what had been a reducing environment to one that is, on the balance, oxygenating.

Oxygen is, to put it bluntly, nasty stuff. It tends to break down complex molecules very readily, and so any acellular replicons that may have survived up to the Great Oxygenation Event were likely wiped out soon after.

jballanc··on Archaea: The 'Dark Matter' of the Microbial World
Archaea and Eubacteria have different Ribosomes. In the world of biology, if DNA is the source code then ribosomes are the compiler.

In other words, while both families use DNA to store information and RNA to translate it, all the rest of the machinery used by cells in that process is different. This is why there are no intermediates. Likely (and this is a guess, if an educated one) this split happened before cells were even "cells". That is, whatever the pre-cellular replicons were that eventually led to life, there might have been many variations on (what eventually became) the ribosome, but two won out and gave rise to two distinct lineages of cellular life.

The rest, as they say, is history...

jballanc··on Archaea: The 'Dark Matter' of the Microbial World
The terms you want to look up are "allopatric speciation" and "sympatric speciation". In short, events can occur that segment population, and from that point forward you have two species. Given enough time, these two will continue to diverge and split, until you have two completely separate subtrees. It just so happens (or is very likely) that the split between archaea and eubacteria is the earliest of these splits.
jballanc··on Pakistan airline admits taking extra passengers in aisle
For commercial service I agree with you heartily. For AF1...I don't know. I'd be inclined to take a seat myself, but I can understand not, for a number of reasons. For example, even if landing is a tad rough, from the sounds of it there isn't nearly as much "stuff" in the interior (seats, overhead bins, etc.) you could potentially bang into.
jballanc··on A Physicist Who Denies That Dark Matter Exists
I was in the same camp as you until the results from the Bullet Cluster were published (https://arstechnica.com/science/2006/08/5058/). Essentially, for the first time astronomers were able to observe the separation of visible and dark matter. In other words, there was evidence for a gravitational force where no visible matter existed.

That said, I think you're wrong about alternate hypotheses being quickly dismissed. Alternatives are regularly proposed and evaluated. Many are eventually found to be lacking in the face of the evidence collected, but some remain viable candidates (for example: https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/01/new-ideas-on-gravity...).

jballanc··on Pakistan airline admits taking extra passengers in aisle
I'd be inclined to agree with you regarding the "general safety" concern, except for two things:

1. AF1 is a 747. If you've never been on a 747 (or A380), then you might not appreciate how smooth landings are in general. It's a lot of airplane with a lot of momentum (not to mention a lot of electronic assistance for the pilots).

2. You say "The notion that the Airforce One pilots are somehow special with special landing skills strikes me as fanciful." I don't consider that notion fanciful at all! In fact, I'd expect they have special landing skills. The AF1 pilots are not just some random commercial or charter pilots, they are Air Force officers, hand-picked from the best of the best. In addition, not only do they have to take-off and land the president's airplane, they also must be able to take evasive action IN A FREAKIN' 747 in the event of a hostile encounter. So "special landing skills"...I'd buy it.

EDIT: Also, reading the original Quora answer, the particular landing mentioned was on the Shuttle Landing Facility, one of the longest runways in the world! I'd wager the pilot could've practically let AF1 roll out the landing and had room to spare.

jballanc··on SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff
IIRC, the SRBs generated enough thrust to break the hold-down bolts even in the event the frangible nuts don't fire. I'd guess the thinking is that, if both fire you might as well have the main engines running than not (since, as I noted before, the SSMEs couldn't be re-ignited in flight). True, if only one SRB fires, you're pretty much toast no matter what, but NASA loves their contingencies of contingencies of contingencies. For example, I've read that there were serious doubts that a Return-to-Launch-Site (RTLS) abort would actually, you know, be survivable, and yet it remained one of the official abort modes throughout the shuttle program.
jballanc··on SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff
Makes you wonder why anyone ever thought it was a good idea to put solid boosters on a man-rated rocket...and yet NASA is repeating that "mistake" with the SLS.
jballanc··on SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff
This is far from the closest to launch SpaceX has called an abort. Many may not remember 3 years ago when they called the abort at T-1 after main engine ignition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5v0k_0PTLnI

To be honest, though, neither case is really abnormal. There's a whole reason it's "T-minus" and "T-plus". T-zero is the point of no return (on the STS, this was when the solid boosters were fired). An abort at any point before then is still considered normal. Aborts after T-zero are anomalies.

(FWIW, even the STS has aborted take-off post-main-engine ignition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8bkYP3pU76I . The main difference between the SpaceX Falcon and the STS is that the Falcon is capable of re-igniting its engines almost immediately, making a same-day re-attempt of a post-engine-ignition abort possible. The STS main engines require a manual reset, making abort post-engine-ignition more costly.)

jballanc··on Raymond Smullyan has died
"The Lady or the Tiger" is, quite literally, probably the single most influential book from my childhood. In 6th grade, my math teacher had a copy in his classroom. He noticed that I spent so much time before class, after class, (during class) reading it, that at the end of the school year he told me I could take it home so long as I promised to bring it back at the end of the summer. (He was also the 7th and 8th grade math teacher.)

I took that book home and treasured it for the whole summer, pouring over each puzzle, solving each one without peeking at the answers, then comparing my answers to the ones in the back of the book. By the end of the summer I think there were only 1 or 2 I hadn't been able to work out myself. Sure enough, as the first day of 7th grade rolled around, it was in my backpack and promptly returned to the shelf of my math teacher's classroom. Satisfied that I had gotten all I could from "The Lady or the Tiger", I next turned my attention to the Apple IIe he had sitting in the corner and a book entitled "Apple Basic".

The rest, as they say, is history.

One final note...as I continued through school and university, I gradually came to realize that Taoism was the school of philosophy that matched most closely to how I understood the world and is, in some sense, the closest thing I have to a "religion". It wasn't until much later in life (well after I turned 30), that I happened to stumble back across Smullyan and his writings, only to discover that he was also a rather adroit Taoist philosopher. (His "Is God a Taoist?" essay, http://www.mit.edu/people/dpolicar/writing/prose/text/godTao... is highly recommended.)

To this day I wonder if "The Lady or the Tiger" didn't have more of an impact on my early development than simply fostering a love of logic...

jballanc··on The trouble with FreeBSD
That's a straw man. "Audition via github/coding tests/open source contributions" is not equivalent to a "blind audition" for musicians. GitHub/OSS already have lower participation rates from women and minorities than the technology industry as a whole precisely because the OSS "meritocracy" fails to address discriminatory behavior and is not blind: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/12/women-con...

Blind coding tests would come the closest to the equivalent of a blind audition, but coding tests as hiring criteria have their own problems in general.

jballanc··on The trouble with FreeBSD
I don't know that they've ever (publicly) published a post-mortem, but I know GitHub used to emphasize being a "meritocracy" but have since moved away from that after some long-festering issues (that were distinctly anti-idealistic-meritocratic) surfaced.

There's also the fact that the participation of women and minorities in OSS is smaller than their participation in the technology industry as a whole. Granted, not every OSS project touts itself as a meritocracy, but it's probably the area where the concept is championed most vociferously.

jballanc··on [dead]
It's an interesting question to be sure. I can only speak personally... My mother was an immigrant. My grandfather worked in the embroidery industry, and was as close to a "programmer" as you could get in his day (he turned new embroidery designs into punch tape that was then fed to the machines that mass produced the design). He worked in two different countries before finally moving his family with him to the third and settling down.

That said, "digital nomad" definitely doesn't apply for him. The equipment he used for his work was 9 feet tall and occupied a good sized room. "Favorable job market" might be closer to the truth, though, as his skill set was a rather specialized one.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →