HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jforman

1,398 karma · joined February 18, 2010

Director of Product Management at Wayfair. Previously: Faculty MIT Sloan; Founder, Inkling (backed by Sequoia). Erstwhile quantitative biologist.
submissionscomments
jforman··on Princeton bans academics from handing copyright to journal publishers
Government employees' work by law is in the public domain:

"Copyright protection under this title is not available for any work of the United States Government, but the United States Government is not precluded from receiving and holding copyrights transferred to it by assignment, bequest, or otherwise." (17 U.S.C. § 105)

"A 'work of the United States Government' is a work prepared by an officer or employee of the United States Government as part of that person’s official duties." (17 U.S.C. § 101)

...although I disagree that the pressure to give away copyright is weak. At least in the life sciences, the prestige you get from a publication in, say, Nature or Science is far more valuable than the work alone.

jforman··on Princeton bans academics from handing copyright to journal publishers
A little known fact: the vast majority of grants (by volume of cash) are technically awarded to the professor's university rather than to the professor him/herself, giving the university broad control over the product of the professor's research. At least, this is the case in the life sciences.

From time to time, this yields something good. Props to the grad school I dropped out of :)

jforman··on What You Eat Affects Your Genes
If a miRNA alters the expression of transcription factors, chromatin remodeling agents, or other epigenome modifiers, the effect could last long after a person stops eating the miRNA-containing food.
jforman··on Urban Airship: Postgres to NoSQL and back
How many startup man-hours were spent tracking that Ubuntu bug down on Cassandra instances? I've heard several nightmarish stories.
jforman··on New leukemia treatment "exceeded our wildest expectations"
I haven't studied the details of the vector they used, but as a general comment HIV is a very well-understood virus, so removing its potential to infect a human should be easy to do in theory. Practice is another matter, since molecular biology is quite messy.
jforman··on Are you a Facebook employee?
9391, back from ye olde "The Facebook" days
jforman··on Official KISSmetrics Response to Data Collection Practices
Your cynicism is not well borne out on this message board.
jforman··on Official KISSmetrics Response to Data Collection Practices
Comparing the relatively thoughtful discussion on this topic among the web development community to the reddit mob is not particularly fair or accurate.
jforman··on Official KISSmetrics Response to Data Collection Practices
I understand technology, and I'm pretty skeezed out by their use of Etags...

Also, if they truly think they're innocent, why wouldn't they just educate their userbase? Seems odd to make such drastic architectural changes just because of a perceptual problem.

jforman··on Official KISSmetrics Response to Data Collection Practices
If the report "significantly distorts our technology and business practices," why are they making such significant changes to their technology and business practices as a result?
jforman··on Randi Zuckerberg Runs in the Wrong Direction on Pseudonymity Online
As somebody who worked on a social networking website for high schoolers back in the day, I can say with authority that trolling never stops in that age range. We quickly gave up the profanity filter arms race as we saw more and more obscure uses of unicode.
jforman··on Google’s YouTube Uses FFmpeg
On the other hand, many companies avoid using AGPL code altogether. Code that isn't used can't be improved.
jforman··on The Financial Times Tries An Apple End-Run
This is not permitted.
jforman··on Collapsing Revenue Metrics - Skyrocketing Costs = Groupon's Disaster
They aren't waiting — watch the demo of Google Wallet / Google Offers from D9 last week:

http://allthingsd.com/video/?video_id=49011B68-9F7F-44C0-BC2...

jforman··on Tiny Variation in One Gene May Have Led to Crucial Changes in Human Brain
I am curious why they call the variation "tiny." The mutation they describe is "the deletion of two genetic letters" — since genes are read in groups of three, a deletion of two letters results in a completely different protein after the site of the mutation (called a "frameshift" mutation because of this property). It seems as if they're trying to cast the result as somehow surprising, when it isn't (this aspect of it, at least).
jforman··on Startup Visa D.O.A., and Startup America Just a Giant Press Release?
No, individual states cannot issue visas. The border is controlled by the federal government (specifically, the Department of Homeland Security).

One thing you can do is sign up for votizen and send a message to your representatives here, however:

https://www.votizen.com/issues/startupvisa/

jforman··on Groupon President and COO Rob Solomon Steps Down
No reason other than, oh, on the order of $100MM in unvested shares?
jforman··on What Apple’s new subscription policy means for news
The true total market value of a company is certainly a proper metric for comparing size.
jforman··on Root molecular cause of declining health in the old found by scientists
This paper is significant because it finds a precise molecular mechanism whereby reduced telomere function affects organ health. From the article,

"We demonstrate that telomere dysfunction activates p53 which in turn binds and represses PGC-1α and PGC-1β promoters, thereby forging a direct link between telomere and mitochondrial biology. We propose that this telomere–p53–PGC axis contributes to organ and metabolic failure and to diminishing organismal fitness in the setting of telomere dysfunction."

Physorg isn't the most reputable science journalism around (heh), but Nature is arguably the most prestigious journal for life science in the world, and everybody involved in the process of publishing this paper, and writing the News & Views article about it, is aware of Elizabeth Blackburn and telomere research.

The more we know about the pathways involved, the more avenues we have for drug development.

jforman··on HIV is powered by RNA
rNTPs are the monomers of RNA
jforman··on Prion disease can spread through air
> Anthropomorphizing such things is a silly because it confuses people

The rest of my post gave a very high-level explanation of how a virus infects a human cell. To explain it in full would take many hours verbally (it took me months in my program to even get up to speed on molecular biology, having come from a CS background).

I'll give some more detail, though: when I say "specifically tuned to human physiology" I mean "tuned" to an extreme level. A human cell is a bag of water, protein, and nucleic acids enveloped by a lipid bilayer. This lipid bilayer physically prevents anything larger than...I think a subset of very small molecules from entering the cell? I am very weak in biochem, so I don't know the exact parameters around this, but I do know for certain that a virus is many orders of magnitude too large to just "get in" to a cell.

In order to gain entry to the cell, the virus has to have a protein that is extremely specifically targeted to a human protein that sits on the surface of a human cell. Like, antibody-to-antigen level specific - this is the product of many many generations of evolution. After attaching to that protein, the virus performs a very biochemically specific action to inject its payload into the cell.

> Their folding state _is_ the infection mechanism

Er, not really. It's the infection mechanism once the prion is in the cell (since the proteins to which the infection spreads are in a cell). How does the protein get in the cell in the first place?

...that's what nobody knows. It can't just float in, again because of the lipid bilayer. It needs to be actively pulled into the cell. Why would that happen?

jforman··on Prion disease can spread through air
A 15-minute search yields: we don't know how prions infect a cell.

"the underlying mechanism of infection remains unresolved" http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjo...

"the exact physiological function of PrPC and the mechanism of neurotoxicity are still unknown" http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/cp/2010/00000007/0...

...I did run across this interesting paper suggesting that prions could be a widely-used regulatory mechanism rather than an aberration, however:

http://www.nature.com/nrm/journal/v11/n12/abs/nrm3007.html

jforman··on Prion disease can spread through air
That's...a very good question. So much for my vaunted Ph.D. I'm going to Google Scholar to figure out how the hell a consumed protein can get into a nerve cell...
jforman··on Prion disease can spread through air
It's definitely not a duh (I got three years into a computational biology PhD before coming out to silicon valley).

Prions are fundamentally different from other diseases in that they're very dumb. Both viruses and bacteria have enormously complicated systems for infection that are specifically tuned to human physiology. A virus is many orders of magnitude too large to diffuse into a cell, so it has surface proteins that attach to human cell surface proteins in order to gain entry.

A protein doesn't have this (one can easily assume), but it's also too large to diffuse into a cell. So, yeah...I wonder what the molecular mechanism of this is? I have no idea.

jforman··on Google already knows its search sucks (and is working to fix it)
Ex-Microsoft here. It's been a while since I worked there, but my recollection is the same: blind, automated testing stripped of UI elements showed that Microsoft's search results were at parity to Google's in terms of relevance.

People sometimes forget that all of these large companies have teams of very smart engineers and researchers. Google may be a talent sink, but they're not a talent monopoly.

jforman··on The NoSQL Hype Curve is Bending
This is a terrible article. His three main points:

1. "You find yourself writing lots of code to reinvent the wheels that SQL gives you for free, and before long you’ve unwittingly reinvented the relational database."

NoSQL came about because people were sharding their data and managing relationships outside of the data layer in custom code anyway, and they were well-served by putting some of that complexity back into the data layer. This wasn't a trend because people don't understand the mathematical beauty of normal forms. This was a trend because altering the schema of a heavily accessed MySQL table will bring your website down.

2. Digg

A Digg engineer on Quora recently said, "The whole 'Cassandra to blame' thing is 100% a result of folks clinging on to the NoSQL vs SQL thing. It's a red herring." (http://www.quora.com/Is-Cassandra-to-blame-for-Digg-v4s-tech...). Yup.

3. The MongoDB is Web Scale video

...really?

jforman··on New Statistical Law Discovered
Just in time to vie for "most overhyped scientific headline of 2010."

The paper, "Bimodal gene expression in noncooperative regulatory systems" (available at http://www.pnas.org/content/107/51/22096.full), addresses the question of how bacterial populations achieve bimodal phenotypic distributions (basically, 1 blue cell goes in, 5 blue cells and 5 pink cells come out in a stable ratio, wtf).

This phenomenon has previously been explained by a) cooperativity or b) feedback loops. Cooperativity is a phenomenon in molecular biology where the binding of one protein to, say, DNA will increase the rate of binding of a partner in crime (which can, say, turn a gene on) -- this is a relatively simple regulatory scheme that allows proteins that respond in linear fashion to their environment to produce a non-linear output. Feedback loops are pretty self-explanatory (one thing worth mentioning is that if the feedback loop involves the transcription of a gene, then it is much slower-acting than cooperativity).

Cooperativity can explain the bimodal distribution problem because cooperative systems can act as "regulatory switches" where very small fluctuations in environment can result in very different behavior (see http://bioweb.wku.edu/courses/biol566/Images/MCB3-29hemoglob... for a simplistic example of hemoglobin response to oxygen). Thus, one blue cell goes in, 10 cells come out with very slight environmental differences that are on this response-boundary - voila, 5 blue cells, 5 pink cells.

Anyway, this paper shows that a cell population can have a bimodal phenotypic distribution without cooperativity, simply by having single proteins that respond in non-linear fashion to their environment. That's...a new statistical law?

I don't have the time to fully deconstruct this paper, but after a skim I'm left with the question, "so how does a single protein achieve non-linear response?" This paper seems to provide a mathematical model without giving a good explanation for how it would be achieved in nature. The only answer I can come up with is cooperativity within the protein itself - say, cooperative allosteric regulation. Which would make the theoretical contribution of this paper a lot less exciting.

jforman··on The disposable academic: Why doing a PhD is often a waste of time
The problem is that the people who are doing it to become a professor are playing a game that is stacked against them. And if/when you lose that game you're well behind your peers in opportunity cost (see my other post).

I know several brilliant scientists (postdocs and PhD students) from my time at Princeton who had / are having a very hard time finding an academic job. At some point even the purest motivations will succumb to feeling used in these circumstances.

jforman··on The disposable academic: Why doing a PhD is often a waste of time
The answer to "why not?" is pretty simple: opportunity cost.

I spent three years in a computational biology PhD program before getting an e-mail from a college friend looking for people to join a new startup (where I am now a co-founder). I enjoyed the research I was doing, but I asked myself: should I really spend three more years here toiling away at very cool but very obscure science just to purchase a lottery ticket? Where if I lose the lottery (which is the most likely result by far) I will have languished in postdoc roles until I burnt out past my prime?

You have a lot of energy between age 25 and 35. I decided to apply that energy to something where the expected value of total reward (both intellectually and monetarily) is much higher.

jforman··on Top 3 Code Editors For the iPad
I wouldn't call enforcing consistency in a primary interaction mode "silly." There would be a considerable increase in cognitive load if a user had to parse what they're seeing every time a keyboard appears. You'd benefit the tail (e.g., people who want to code on an iPad) but reduce utility for the majority of users. Like most things, it's a trade-off, and Apple usually (almost always?) lands on the side of simplicity in that trade-off.
← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →