HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kar5pt

239 karma · joined February 9, 2021

submissionscomments
kar5pt··on For long-term health and happiness, marriage still matters
Nobody is anti-marriage. You're just pulling a straw-man out of your ass.
kar5pt··on Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on the future of Airbnb?
Whenever I travel, AirBNBs are still much cheaper than comparable hotels.
kar5pt··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
1. I was referring to walking as recreation, not walking in general (not sure how people missed this) 2. Body parts don't have a "purpose" unless you believe in a creator-god.
kar5pt··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
I was referring to a book I read by a Brit who lived in Africa for 30 years. He wrote about an interaction where he moved to an African village and "went for a walk" through the village. The locals thought he was strange to walk for no reason and assumed he was looking for workers.
kar5pt··on Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee Mobility (2022)
Did you even read the article? CBT and the cognitive model are not the same thing. CBT (the therapy) works, but that doesn't mean the underlying theory is correct.

"Not only is there contrary evidence showing problems with reasoning are widespread as well as potentially associated with mental health rather than mental disorder. But the evidence in favour of CBT’s take on mental illness is tainted because the tests used in these studies do not even track problems with reasoning. CBT provides a compelling story about mental illness – mental illness is associated with “faulty” reasoning, and in resolving this, negative behaviour and emotions are addressed. Unfortunately, research doesn’t quite back up this story."

kar5pt··on Men Without Full-Time Jobs Are 33% More Likely to Divorce
If he was an investment banker he wouldn't have been playing video games 14 hours a day.
kar5pt··on Depression, Anxiety, and Stress Spread Through Employee Mobility (2022)
This is not true. The cognitive model of depression has been debunked: https://theconversation.com/cbt-is-wrong-in-how-it-understan...
kar5pt··on Honestly, It's Probably the Phones
Yeah. Virtually none of the suggestions OP is making are "natural" in any meaningful way. Even going for walks usually implies walking in a park, which is an invention of the past 100 years or so. It's also very Euro-centric. In many other cultures its considered strange to just walk around for no reason.
kar5pt··on Workers’ Pay Globally Hasn’t Kept Up with Inflation
I wish this were true, but is it? One of the most stable societies in human history was ancient Egypt which was ruled by a god-king and remained relatively unchanged for thousands of years. Democracies, on the other hand, tend to be much more volatile. I think equal societies may be more unstable than unequal ones.
kar5pt··on Workers’ Pay Globally Hasn’t Kept Up with Inflation
How do you put on pants in the morning?
kar5pt··on The Presocratic Philosophers [pdf]
Also Plato is the earliest (Western) philosopher for whom we have full dialogues. For most of the presocratics we only have fragments of their works.
kar5pt··on Individuals who share an ideology have more similar neural representations
It seems reasonable that the kind of ideology might affect how it correlates with brain activity, wouldn't it?
kar5pt··on New Yorkers Never Came ‘Flooding Back.’ Why Did Rents Go Up So Much?
I find it hard to believe that refusing to rent out 3 units would raise the fourth one from $1000 to $4000. I also don't think businesses normally refuse to sell large portions of already produced merchandise to maintain artificial scarcity. Maybe that happens in limited scenarios for short periods of time, but I don't think it's usually a cause of severe, chronic undersupply like what we're seeing in the NYC housing market.

Of course, like I said to the other comment. I'm open to hearing contrary evidence (if it comes from actual economists and not journalists).

kar5pt··on New Yorkers Never Came ‘Flooding Back.’ Why Did Rents Go Up So Much?
I was hoping for peer-reviewed research, not articles written by journalists. I'm not denying the vacancies are real (not sure how you thought that?). I'm questioning whether the cause of the vacancies are landlords intentionally refusing to rent out units for which qualified renters exist (in the absence of market-distortions like rent-control).

I'm open to evidence that this happening, I'm just pointing out that I've seen dozens of people online make this claim and no one ever provides evidence to back it up. I don't have time to thoroughly read through all 6 of those articles, but I've skimmed through them and don't see evidence for the claim there either. The Jacobin and City articles just assert that it's true without citing any evidence. The Business Insider doesn't even try to make that claim, it immediately blames rent-control in the 4-6 paragraphs. The Fox5 article just says units are empty without trying to provide an explanation.

If there is a piece of the articles I missed, please point it out.

kar5pt··on Critique of the mind/body problem
Yes. Something can be difficult to define exactly, yet also have clearly recognizable features. You haven't thought about it very hard if this "amuses you".
kar5pt··on Critique of the mind/body problem
The cake analogy works for the brain, not the mind. The brain is the abstract unification of all your neurons and electrical impulses into a single entity. The mind is...well...it's difficult to define exactly what the mind is, but it's related your experiences and is clearly a completely different kind of thing than the physical hunk of meat between your ears.

Your cake analogy side-steps the mind-body problem by conflating the mind with the brain.

kar5pt··on New Yorkers Never Came ‘Flooding Back.’ Why Did Rents Go Up So Much?
People keep telling this story but not providing any evidence. What evidence is there that landlords not wanting to rent their units is the cause of high rents in nyc? On its surface it makes no sense. Why wouldn't they want to collect rents if they can do it?
kar5pt··on What’s the Matter with Men?
What a useless platitude.
kar5pt··on Neuropsychiatric researchers rethink what depression might be
I could flip this around and say that focusing on internal causes of depression is a way for those in power to avoid the social responsibility of having to change it. We can kick the responsibility ball back and forth all day.

Why is it so hard for people to get adequate sleep, exercise, a good diet and social interaction? Even most non-depressed people I know don't do these things well (except maybe the last one), so this isn't something unique to depression.

kar5pt··on Drug-resistant cases of gonorrhea detected in the US
This would be a great comment if you cited sources.
kar5pt··on Remote work turns out to be a much better deal for men than for women
Important context: the studies were done in China and Korea.

The article references two previous studies that were presumably done in America, but they were both done in 2020 during the height of the pandemic. Seems like a big limitation of the research.

The article then says 9 out of 10 women prefer remote work and that remote work has been found to increase diversity.

kar5pt··on Antidepressants are over-prescribed, but genuinely help some patients
What DNA test did you take?
kar5pt··on I hacked Gumroad’s API and broke a bunch of tools
Based on their app, this isn't surprising
kar5pt··on Five mildly anti-Buddhist essays
"Accept it and move on" sounds like a pretty unhelpful response to someone seeking therapy for childhood trauma.
kar5pt··on Five mildly anti-Buddhist essays
The Taoist influence on Zen is overstated in my opinion. Most of the non-dual stuff Westerns would consider "Taoism" is right there in the Diamond Sutra (straight out of India). Westerners also typically underestimate how much Taoism has borrowed from Chan Buddhism. A lot of the similarities are because Taoism copied Zen, not the other way around.
kar5pt··on Five mildly anti-Buddhist essays
> Do what works for you. The only truth is what you can directly experience in the laboratory of your life. All the other teachings are just suggestions.

This is just your own opinion at this point. It's not buddhism. Buddhism has specific teachings that it posits as being true, regardless of whether you've personally experienced them.

kar5pt··on Five mildly anti-Buddhist essays
I practiced zen for a while and had the exact same experience. I had real-life problems that were causing me psychological distress and was using buddhism to avoid having to address those issues. I figured none of it mattered anyway since life is dukkha and trying to improve my life wouldn't remove the craving that is the fundamental cause of dukkha. So I might as well just meditate as much as I could and hope for enlightenment. I wouldn't blame buddhism entirely for my personal failings, but buddhism certainly didn't help.

I've come to the conclusion after a lot of reading, practice, and contemplation that there is NO form of buddhism that makes any sense to engage with unless you believe in rebirth. The point of buddhism is to escape rebirth, not achieve some psychological state like happiness or well-being. If you're expecting the later out of buddhism, you're probably better off putting your energy into more "worldly" endeavors. I've been much happier since I stopped meditating and started using that time to focus on friends, hobbies, career and dating.

Traditional buddhists would probably facepalm at this and say something like "no duh, rebirth is buddhism 101". But a lot of American buddhist traditions present rebirth as an optional belief which is nonessential to buddhist practice. I even watched an American zen teacher call rebirth "bullshit" publicly in a talk once.

What's sad to me is that therapists have started recommending meditation as some universal good, despite the research on it still being pretty young. It seems they've been influenced by the American buddhist/mindfulness movement and are being rather uncritical. I'm sure small amounts of meditation can help some people with stress and anxiety, but it shouldn't be viewed as something to automatically recommend to every patient like sleep and exercise.

kar5pt··on Ask HN: Are ICs at tech companies usually so concerned about job performance?
I'm also at Meta and worked at two non-FAANG fortune 500s before this (5 YOE total). The performance anxiety at the two previous companies was nowhere close. Performance reviews were done mostly by managers and the stakes were much lower. Best case scenario, you get maybe a 10% raise. PIP was unlikely unless you're just grossly incompetent or not trying.
kar5pt··on Too big to live, too loved to die: Big Tech's billion dollar curse of the free
Does anyone have recommendations to get off of Gmail? I've tried in the past, but I get so much junk mail that not having gmail's auto-categorizing makes my email unusable.
kar5pt··on Groundbreaking marks start of work on Penn Station Access
Grand Central is not "less than minutes away from Penn Station". It's at least a 15 minute commute. Potentially more depending on which part of the station your walking to/from and if there's delays.
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →