HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Apple to Pay £3.8m Tax on £1.2bn UK Sales
> We pay all that we owe according to tax laws and local customs wherever we operate

The problem is that Apple and other big corporations have lobbied all around the world to minimise the amount of taxes they pay.

That they follow the law becomes kind of irrelevant when they have helped to design the law.

Meanwhile, 130,000 people died in the UK because governments are cutting on healthcare. (https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jun/01/perfect-sto...)

To be legal is not the same that to be moral or even sustainable in the long term. Someone has to pay for education and health care. If the middle class have to support everyone else, who will buy the next iPhone? Long term and capitalism are at odds. We need some more thinking into it.

kartan··on Wikipedia community reacts to an editor being temporarily banned
It's about the absolute right to free speech. It has been a far right tactic to attack people that condemns their speeches: https://lithub.com/when-fascists-weaponize-free-speech-absol...

USA has started the political campaign and with it there is an increase in manipulation. What should be a matter of politeness - don't insult people - becomes an opportunity to push against moderated discussion. :(

Please HN review this thread carefully as this is what comes for the next year.

kartan··on Wikipedia community reacts to an editor being temporarily banned
He wrote 'Fuck Arbcon' in the entry for the arbitration committee. He had other warnings. He got banned for a year.

Makes sense. I do not know from were the 'freedom' argument comes from our relates to this.

kartan··on Some of America’s Top Chicken Purveyors Are Under Investigation for Price Fixing
> the price of broiler chickens jumped by 50 percent between 2008 to 2016, despite the fact that cost of feeding the chickens went down during this period.

If costs to down and price go up and there is no increase in demand there is a problem.

> Three of these companies — Sanderson, Tyson, and Pilgrim’s Pride — control nearly half the American chicken market

This sums up XXI century capitalism. Olygopolies control everything leaving consumers or even business with just a couple of options. It's easier to fix prices that way as it's easier to increase profit thru cooperation that to risk a competition war.

kartan··on China strip mines political prisoners for organs
> The US wastes like $100k a year on its prisoners

I think that the USA wastes $100k on private companies taking care of prisoners. To spend that money in rehabilitation will be an investment.

kartan··on Consumers Are Becoming Wise to Your Nudge
> Are physical ads like the ones you describe really so burdensome?

Yes. They are everywhere. I cannot look at a building, a road, or go to the subway without seeing a hundred advertisements. My brain will try to read automatically any text in my field of vision. It is exhausting. My job is complex enough to overload my brain with things I do not need or care about.

It's a war on human attention. And we need de-escalation.

I guess that it is different for each individual. And, your experience is not like mine. But for the ones like me it needs to stop.

kartan··on FedEx sues U.S. government over 'impossible' task of policing exports to China
> it wants to be compensated for complying.

This will not scale. Next, industries will want to be compensated to add filters to not pollute rivers. Car makers will want to be compensated for doing safe cars. Supermarkets will want to be compensated for having to check customers age before selling alcohol or tobacco. Etc.

To follow the law is part of doing business. If the law is unreasonable or it is a problem with the law or it is a problem with the business model.

kartan··on FedEx sues U.S. government over 'impossible' task of policing exports to China
The problem that I see with this approach is that we are privatising profits while socializing costs.

Customs should be dealing with it is akin to say that taxpayers should deal with the cost of FedEx businesses whenever they use it or not.

I see the point of sharing health care or education expenses thru society. But, your new iPhone cost should be on you.

Customs should still do random checks and things like that to assure that all companies follow the law, thou.

But, it is not a strong opinion. I see the value of having customs doing it. I just get inclined for FedEx taking in the cost.

kartan··on RBA not fazed by Australian $50 note typo
Yes. I have to pay the taxes. The 100 is a fine for doing it wrong and I guess pay for the extra time that they need to spend.
kartan··on Facebook moderators break NDAs to expose working conditions
> I bet this can be done with ML and IA instead human power.

IA and ML work in bulk. But they misclassify things that a human easily can discern.

Think Tesla VS Google. Google wants a self-driving car, and that is not working yet. Tesla wants a car that helps you to drive and that is good enough.

It's order of magnitude easier to be almost always correct that to be correct all the time. And you only need one kiddie porn video in your Facebook feed to start to worry about Facebook.

kartan··on RBA not fazed by Australian $50 note typo
> But "nobody died" isn't a valid excuse for mistakes on filing for taxes or legal contracts.

I have had a lot of mistakes filing my taxes (Spain) when I was working as a contractor. You pay a small fine (100€ for a yearly report) and move on.

You will be prosecuted if you lied in your taxes. But, mistakes happen all the time and its not big deal.

kartan··on Boeing employee: I would not put my family on a Max plane
I see people complaining about the fact that it is just employee opinion.

I agree that just one employee opinion it's not important or so relevant by itself.

But, for most people, a human face for a problem makes the problem easier to understand and to sympathize with the situation. So, it seems that the journalist decided to give voice to Stuart as an stylistic choice. HN readers may like or not this choice. But, it does not invalidate the content of the article.

An example does not invalidate the rule. It would be interesting to discuss the content more than the style, even that it's also a valid discussion.

My take out of the article is that lack of trust on upper management is part of the problem.

> “I want to think that I work for one of the best companies in the world. I want to think that when I come home from a 10-12 hour shift that I’ve done something good. But I don’t know because I see the lies. They’re going back on everything that they’ve told us. So it’s really difficult for me to feel good about any of it.”

Most people see themselves as good persons. Most people wants to do a good job. When your company leadership fails you there is a conflict between that believe and reality. That is why company leadership is so important and it should not only respond to share holders but to all stakeholders in the company including customers and employees.

kartan··on REST and GraphQL framework to build API-driven projects
JavaScript is still super quirky and inconsistent though. You can't fix that without breaking backward compatibility.
kartan··on OpenMandriva, the first Clang-built Linux distribution
Why not use static code analyzers? You run them in compilation time and warn you of uninitialized variables.

Initializing values just because seems wasteful. That's why global and static variables are already initialized in this way.

For me it would yet make sense that Gcc allows it even if it's not a very good practice it may have its uses.

kartan··on Living in Switzerland ruined me for America and its lousy work culture (2016)
> It depends if you're in the north or the south

As most work is located in the big cities (Madrid, Barcelona, etc.) that is what most people will experience. But, the South or even the countryside is quite different. I agree with you.

kartan··on Living in Switzerland ruined me for America and its lousy work culture (2016)
> These countries are laid back

Have you worked in Italy or Spain? I'm Spanish and laid back at work is not a thing. The main reason I moved to Sweden is for is better work life balance.

Never go to live where you go for vacations, you will be very disappointed.

kartan··on Living in Switzerland ruined me for America and its lousy work culture (2016)
> Work is always going to be frustrating

I had a direct report with this problem. We talked about it and I helped him to realize that his previous situation was unhealthy.

He was used to crunch, he was used to feel a hero for delivering at the cost of his own health and without time for his girlfriend.

After the long talk he recognized that he was missing the adrenaline, he was so used to the stress that he was missing it. With time it got better.

Feeling needed, the adrenaline rush, that feeling of accomplishment can be addictive. But, like tobacco, it does not mean that it is good for you.

kartan··on Boston Dynamics prepares to launch its first commercial robot
It takes time for tech to develop. We have in our homes small simple robot toys and Roomba-like robots clean our apartments. Each step seems very little compared with our expectations. But, technology will get with time cheaper, and easier to use.

Funny thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dKjCWfuvYxQ

kartan··on YouTube’s Algorithm Incentivizes the Wrong Behavior
> They cannot use anything except an algorithm to recommend videos.

I agree that with the current business model it is not possible for YouTube to sort it manually.

When I was a kid, a long long time ago, it would have been impossible to conceive that a TV channel showed that kind of content regularly and continue open. If their answer would have been that they cannot fix it because it costs money there would have been an outraged response.

If YouTube cannot keep things legal, cannot respect people rights, cannot be a good responsible part of society because it is not cost effective for me the way to go is clear. And that is true for YouTube, Facebook or any other business digital or not.

kartan··on Swiss women strike for more money, time and respect
I see just two comments right now and I see a lot of cynism.

Things are better today than in the past thanks to people fighting for their and others rights. And the job is not finished.

Democracy is not something that happens once each four years. It's important to vote, but as important is to express your dissatisfaction with the wrongdoings of the system.

> Ms Born, who joined a newsroom staffed entirely by men in 1986, is quietly optimistic. "We've achieved some good things since 1991," she points out. "We have maternity leave now."

Parental leave seams such a natural right to have that it's strange that there exists any opposition to it. Mothers and fathers benefit from it. Fighting for women's rights is also figthing for a more just and balance society for everyone.

kartan··on How Cars Transformed Policing
> How could a democratic society founded on self-governance depend on police governance and still be free?

This is something that I see radically different between the USA and Europe. Europe had more authoritative states and police enforcement moved from repression force to citizens service. In the USA the path seems the opposite. From self-policing and freedom towards repression.

> U.S. courts did more to encourage and sustain, rather than to check, the growing authority of the police.

I guess that there was a need for more law enforcement. But, the trend never stopped even when it made no sense anymore.

> The upshot, as time would tell, was not the protection of individuals’ privacy in their cars but the empowerment of highway patrollers and traffic cops who could take advantage of the thicket of procedures to exercise their power in discretionary, even discriminatory, ways.

This is the pattern that I have seen. The problem with much of the cases that I see on the news is that there is no accountability. Police forces are going to make mistakes, and that mistakes can be lethal. But, I do not see self-reflection or improvement.

When you make the same mistake a hundred times. It is not a mistake anymore but part of the system.

kartan··on Hong Kong Police Fire Tear Gas, Rubber Bullets at Protesters
> have no sympathy for those in Hong Kong who have more rights and a better standard of living than they do.

I always find this paradox as interesting as sad.

This Lose/Win mentality evolved as a solution to small community of humans with limited resources. In that situation, how to split the insufficient resources is the main problem. The more others get, the less is left for me.

In current modern society, the more education and resources has the people around me the more they produce and I can benefit from it.

Or brain did not evolve to our modern world, I guess. Helping people to think Win/Win would be a great paradigm shift moving into the future of our society.

kartan··on WordPress VIP sites have been hit by outages
Diversity in nature or technology is important. And it's worrisome that both are disappearing.

"The resulting homogeneity and uniformity can offer substantial advantages in both the quantity and quality of crop harvested, but this same genetic homogeneity can also reflect greater susceptibility or pathogens. Thus it appears the more that agricultural selection disturbs the natural balance in favor of variety uniformity over large areas, the more vulnerable such varieties are to losses from epidemics." https://www.nap.edu/read/2116/chapter/5

- https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/06/01/aws_outage/

- https://www.theverge.com/2019/6/2/18649635/youtube-snapchat-...

- https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/06/11/wordpress_vip_go_ou...

And if we take the word of Steve Jobs on this one we are for a hard ride: "It turns out the same thing can happen in technology companies that get monopolies, like IBM or Xerox. If you were a product person at IBM or Xerox, so you make a better copier or computer. So what? When you have monopoly market share, the company's not any more successful.

So the people that can make the company more successful are sales and marketing people, and they end up running the companies. And the product people get driven out of the decision making forums, and the companies forget what it means to make great products. The product sensibility and the product genius that brought them to that monopolistic position gets rotted out by people running these companies that have no conception of a good product versus a bad product.

They have no conception of the craftsmanship that's required to take a good idea and turn it into a good product. And they really have no feeling in their hearts, usually, about wanting to really help the customers." https://www.businessinsider.com/steve-jobs-on-why-innovation...

With our economy and daily lives so dependent in a few companies, any drop in quality will impact all corners of society.

kartan··on Living on the wrong side of a time zone can be hazardous to your health
> Niš Serbia; 43.3209° N, 21.8958° E: Rise 04:52, Set 20:12 A Coruña Spain; 43.3623° N, 8.4115° W: Rise 06:53, Set 22:14.

People get surprised that in Spain the lunch hour is around 13:30 instead of 12:00. But when you take into account the sunrise/sunset times it corrects part of the difference.

Maybe a fix: reduce working hours (school time, etc.). That will save lives and facilitate a more healthy population.

We have the data. We know the causes of why people are dying. News makes us more worried about terrorist attacks, that kill really very few people and have no impact beyond the publicity that news provides than the real risks to our health.

- https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/climate-cha... - https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jun/01/perfect-sto... - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/may/15/diesel-e... - https://www.drugabuse.gov/drugs-abuse/opioids/opioid-overdos...

We don't need to do everything perfectly. We do not need to panic. But, we can improve a lot how we deal with risks to our health.

kartan··on Android now forces apps to include proprietary code for push notifications
> Problem: The Firebase Android client library is proprietary, meaning FOSS apps can not use it. Apps that do not comply are reported to the user as "using too much battery".

This is a standard on the industry. From 1999: https://www.theregister.co.uk/1999/11/05/how_ms_played_the_i...

It doesn't matter how much money Google is going to have to pay in the future as a fine for this practice. The amount of money that they will get for kicking out the competition is going to be way higher. That is a learned lesson from Microsoft (and probably others before them).

kartan··on An examination of Uber’s economics
> They also believe that adults shouldn’t be able to get themselves into money losing business deal

When one person gets into a bad deal it is a bad decision. When tens or hundreds of thousands get into the same bad deal with the same company then it's systemic and creates a systemic risk.

> Regulation that subsidies late night taxis for low wage night shift workers economically distorts just like uber drivers that are receiving food stamps. Why is the former okay but the later is not?

It is not the same that the government subsidizes a night service to improve people's lives and the economy that a company like Uber bases its business model in not paying enough its employees and letting the taxpayers get the bill.

Uber is gaining a competitive advantage (over taxis and other forms of public transportation) at the cost of taxpayers. Late night taxis will probably cease to circulate if it were not for a subsidy. And then someone at the government thinks that to be able to take a taxi at night to go home is something desirable.

kartan··on Cameras Came to the Newsroom
UK: " https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/surveillance-the-legal-iss...

- If an employer wishes to use CCTV in the workplace, the ICO must be notified as to why they intend to use it. This is part of the registration process for a data controller under the DPA. An employer cannot then use the information collected for any other reason. For example, if the organisation is using CCTV to monitor crime, it cannot then use it to monitor staff. Employers should, before using surveillance cameras, carry out an impact assessment, decide if alternatives are possible and only go ahead if the use of cameras meets a legitimate aim.

- Staff must be informed that they may be recorded and where cameras are located. To make this undisputable the employer should use clear and visible signs.

- Levels of CCTV surveillance in work must be proportionate to the reasonable expectation of privacy. In certain areas with a higher level of expected privacy, such as near toilets, changing rooms, kitchen and break areas, it is unlikely to be acceptable to have cameras.

Maintaining integrity in these areas is essential. Employers need to be aware that staff can request to see the recordings kept of them by making a subject access request, and the data must be provided no longer than 40 days after a request is received. "

It seems that the UK law is reasonable. (At least for a country that has a high level of surveillance)

kartan··on Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 percent since 1996: study
> I suspect that a large part of that has to do with student loans

I think that this is not just a USA issue but it is also happening in all Occident. Student loans are just one of the reasons. But, it is bigger than that.

e.g. UK: https://www.ft.com/content/81343d9e-187b-11e8-9e9c-25c814761...

kartan··on California is cracking down on the gig economy
> Disregarding any problems we might have with specific companies, I think ridesharing companies are a benefit to consumers.

I am all for ridesharing. But Uber and Lyft, as an example, has nothing to do with that concept. It is not like your Uber driver was coincidentally going to the exact place that you were going.

Ridesharing, as understood before the gig economy, was someone in the company realizing that there were more employees in her neighbourhood and providing a ride for them for a price (some times just sharing gas expenses).

That is a really good approach. Uber/Lyft and others hide their business model calling themselves ridesharing when they are not, calling their employees contractors, when they are not, etc.

kartan··on Ask HN: Why is the US the center of the tech industry?
> World War II. In WWII, the only country that had the means to meaningfully fund longer-term military research projects was the US

This is true not only for tech but also for everything else. Being poor in the USA was better than to be middle class anywhere else. Also, European scientists left to the USA.

> The development of a strong education and research system.

Yes. Education is the base for the knowledge economy.

> Market size.

Sweden is a good example of a country in a similar situation to the one in the USA. But, it is very small. Sweden has been very successful in IT but its impact is very small.

I completely agree with you.

← PreviousPage 3 of 25Next →