HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kelnage

577 karma · joined May 21, 2009

submissionscomments
kelnage··on PKI for busy people
Textbook RSA is not secure, as there’s no element of randomness in the encryption, rendering it susceptible to chosen ciphertext attacks. RSA+OAEP includes randomness and also protects again vulnerability such as certain plaintexts always having the same encryption regardless of key.
kelnage··on Gaming worth more than video and music combined
Active mental participation? Surely you should be getting paid for that!
kelnage··on A fun optimization trick from rsync
My understanding of the code from the article is that if method #4 stopped working, it would just carry on down the list. The static variable just means where to skip to in the case list.
kelnage··on Dear Spotify, please let me unlink my Facebook account
This is a recent change on Facebook's behalf - apps are no longer permitted to post automatically on your behalf [1]. I can understand why they've done it (searching for that reference involved going through 3 pages of "how do I stop app X from posting on Facebook") - but for those who actually wanted that feature, it will be missed.

1. http://uk.businessinsider.com/facebook-no-longer-lets-apps-a...

kelnage··on Dear Spotify, please let me unlink my Facebook account
Nice - this trick also works for Strava (for which I originally signed up using Google)!
kelnage··on Show HN: I made a privacy-first minimalist Google Analytics
But you are assuming the users browse the website in full screen mode/maximised. Whilst true for most mobile devices, this is certainly not given on desktops.
kelnage··on Guidelines for writing readable code
Urgh, I was nodding away until I reached guide 16. Although the idea it expresses is fine, their example of parsing CSV files yourself is a terrible one, especially since they link to a previous article where they anticipate some issues that can be encountered when parsing CSVs, but ignore the legion of others (different separators, quotation characters etc).

If you’re going to parse a CSV file, please, just use a standard library for your language - please don’t just split on commas and call it done. The only case where it might be acceptable to do it yourself is if you have complete control of the input - but that would to me imply a static data that could be added to the code base instead of a CSV file.

kelnage··on I don't trust Signal
You suggest Telegram over Signal? Now we know you're spreading FUD.
kelnage··on Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver DNS feature is dangerous
Perhaps if you only work for small organisations. Medium to large organisations tend to handle these issues relatively smoothly, with company computers and devices usually having their root CA pre-loaded into the trust store - or requiring users to do it themselves in order to connect to the intranet.

Just because you don't see it, doesn't mean its not there!

kelnage··on Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver DNS feature is dangerous
Great! And you can already choose to do so. But it seems pretty likely that Firefox will be making that decision on behalf of all its users (except those with the wherewithal to know how to opt out), without effectively communicating the risks of that decision to them (based upon their communication about this feature so far).
kelnage··on Show HN: I made a tool that made me faster at Git
In my experience of using git integration features in IntelliJ, they are nice for simple tasks like quickly checking the status of a file or committing all the changes, but as soon as I need to do more complex tasks in git, I find the UIs either get in the way and slow me down or just aren’t fully featured enough to do what I need to do and I end up back on the command line. Hence why I always encourage newcomers to git to learn both if possible.

I do agree that git could certainly do with a more consistent command line interface - but I imagine that won’t even be considered until that next major version of git, if it ever arrives.

kelnage··on Loss aversion is not supported by the evidence
I’d say it’s true of most knowledge, regardless of domain. AI seems like a great candidate in computer science, for example.
kelnage··on British Women Killed by Men They Previously Reported to Police
Based on previous recorded homicide rates in the U.K. [1], 49 women over three years equates to about 10% of homicides committed against women. As a proportion, that does not seem such a small number to me.

1. https://www.ons.gov.uk/generator?uri=/peoplepopulationandcom...

kelnage··on How real simultaneous dual band Wi-Fi enables next-gen in-vehicle connectivity
This is kind of true, but only from a certain angle.

For one, autonomous vehicles (the ones most people care about anyway - Waymo et al) are not widely using connectivity between vehicles - who wants an autonomous vehicle that will only stop for other compatible vehicles? Instead they are almost entirely reliant on visual sensors etc.

What has changed between 4G and 5G is the device to device protocol (which is not widely used and is completely incompatible with normal mobile signals) has been improved to support vehicles travelling at high speeds. But the thing is, there was already a protocol to enable that kind of communication and 5G does little if anything to improve on it.

Autonomous vehicles are probably never going to rely on network connectivity to work properly - the risk of losing your connectivity is too great.

kelnage··on European regulators reject latest proposal by ICANN over its Whois data service
Because Governments can make laws but ICANN can’t? (GDPR explicitly exempts personal data that is legally required to be disclosed from protection)

Edit: actually after a bit more thought, it’s more nuanced than my somewhat glib response lets on (since there’s also an exemption for contractual obligations).

The answer is likely that a) the law hasn’t been tested in the courts under GDPR and/or b) the Government requirement has the additional test of providing a service, which may alleviate the privacy cost sufficiently.

kelnage··on A sad update about a scissors maker that went viral
Wrong model choice - they were just a little too heavy for my partner to use effectively.
kelnage··on A sad update about a scissors maker that went viral
That is incredibly sad. I bought several pairs of their shears for my partner, and they are absolutely brilliant. The company was also great to buy from - they were able to give personalised advice about which ones I should get and when one wasn’t quite right, they were really quick to offer a return and replacement.
kelnage··on Blockers to IPv6 Adoption
Isn't the same true of HTTPS (first developed in 1994, but has only seen wide usage recently, outside of specific use-cases), or even programming languages like Python 3? At the end of the day, it seems to me that incumbent internet technologies that are widely used will always see slow incremental change to a new incompatible version, regardless of how small the changes or how many improvements there are, without significant and clear external incentives. Such incentives are very hard to manufacture - so foresight of upcoming issues (such as IPv4 address space depletion) will always seem premature until they actually occur. But it certainly doesn't make forward planning a bad idea.
kelnage··on AI winter is well on its way
But software is starting from the same base. To claim it isn't would be to claim that the computers programmed themselves completely (which is simply not true).
kelnage··on Associations of egg consumption with cardiovascular disease
1 large egg contains approximately 1.6g of saturated fat. Recommended saturated fat intakes vary by who is making the recommendation, but the NHS in the U.K. says it should be at most 30g/20g for men/women, whilst the American Heart Association says it should be around 13g for a 2000 calorie diet. No idea where you got your 70+% figure from.

Edit: You've now corrected this to 10%, but even that is based upon a very cautious RDA for saturated fat.

Also, consuming 9 eggs by themselves would not cause you overdose on selenium either - the RDA for selenium is between 55-135mg (again, depending on source), whilst the overdose threshold for it is believed to be around 400mg. However, an egg contains around 15mg of selenium - so whilst consuming 9 of them would put you over or at your RDA, it is not an overdose, since the RDA is a recommendation, not a limit.

kelnage··on Verizon AS701 blocking Tor consensus server tor26 (86.59.21.38)
Of course it is - unless we’re going by the relevant RFC, in which case we can simply define it as traffic with the evil bit set ;) But net neutrality is, in its essence, a subjective term. At the end of the day, it would be down to the courts as the final arbiters of what is malicious or not, should it come to that.
kelnage··on Verizon AS701 blocking Tor consensus server tor26 (86.59.21.38)
I hope most net neutrality proponents would not say that it implies that all providers must allow all traffic through their network, regardless of whether it is malicious or not. If they do believe that then it turns out I’m against net neutrality.
kelnage··on Bret Victor Redesigns Classic Strogatz Paper (2011)
I love it when people do take the time to do good information visualisation, especially when it helps everyone understand a complex idea.

However, I do think that those who believe that all academic papers should take this form fundamentally misunderstand the purpose of academic papers. Sadly, most of these papers are not about improving universal knowledge - instead they are simply attempting to convey to their peers some insight into a commonly understood problem or question. Because they are aiming at such a small target audience who have a deep understanding of the problem domain, shorthand and skimping on explainatory visualisations is not only an acceptable choice - it can make the difference between a paper being published or not. Few academics have the time, experience or funding to make beautiful visualisations - and those that can afford to spend them on that aspect often do so in exchange for depth of insight - and thus they are often seen as less valuable.

kelnage··on Tesla’s response to getting maps updates over LTE or service center WiFi
Obviously they wouldn’t have to spend that much. Right now the majority of their customers get these updates via WiFi - so it would just be a matter of finding out which vehicles were sufficiently out of date and only sending them the data.
kelnage··on Peer review: the end of an error?
I agree there is definitely a bias towards such results - but I fear that completely free-for-all open access reviewing will make the effect even greater.
kelnage··on Peer review: the end of an error?
The initial examples the author uses really do reflect the magnitude of the third problem. All of them were big breakthrough results in their fields - and hence people cared enough to do proper reviews - especially in the latter two cases. As an academic, I have participated in reviews of papers that I would have never otherwise read, but could still contribute to the process. Without something pushing all academics to participate in the system, then a more open solution risks moving science even closer to “only interesting problems/solutions/results get published”.
kelnage··on Tail recursion in Python
True, but irrelevant. For all values of n > 1, that function will return 1, which is clearly not what the author intended.
kelnage··on Unexpected challenges of making money on the internet
Sorry, I wasn’t trying to say that the only people who use PayPal fall into those categories - in fact, I don’t, but use PayPal semi-regularly for some purchases - just that there are some PayPal users who can’t use common alternatives.
kelnage··on Unexpected challenges of making money on the internet
In my experience, all the PayPal horror stories I have seen have been from merchants rather than users. PayPal tends to do a good job of protecting users, often to the detriment of merchants’ trust.

Also, PayPal services a niche of users who have bank accounts and/or PayPal credit, but no access to a widely accepted debit or credit card (such as Visa or MasterCard). Those users are often unable to use most other payment providers.

kelnage··on Childhood intelligence in relation to major causes of death in 68 year follow-up
I can’t find any evidence of whether they controlled for obesity (which is certainly believed to be a factor is several of the diseases that a correlation was found for). But other than that, I’d say that it is a very interesting study.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →