2,593 karma · joined September 29, 2015
Everyone understands the parents ultimately mean no harm, but their warped perception of science, among other things, means their actions are harmful. But trying to point this fact out makes them very, very defensive and they take it personally. Others only spend energy communicating because they want to help the child too.
That's the thing that always causes me difficulty when dealing with parents like this, it's like talking to a brick wall. My usual attempt is trying to get them to see me as someone speaking from a place of trustworthiness, but it's frustrating. Usually the kids are smart enough to pick up on certain things so I guide them a little. For context, I tutor. The same parents that dismiss me about things like this or getting a diagnosis/treatment for ADHD pay me to teach their kids about science and math. I want to continue caring and trying, but I understand why teachers become so jaded.
Does anyone have suggestions?
https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2023/01/strava-raises-prices-dou...
I am not sure why you believe the kind of security violation is shoehorning in an unnecessary concern. Technology and software should only be banned at a nation level when it is a threat to national security.
TikTok is a something people can uninstall at any time and people voluntarily choose to install. If you can't see the difference between someone sharing their interest in Harry Potter and the DMV selling your information, without your knowledge or consent, to predatory companies, then I don't think I can explain explain my perspective properly. I did not give the DMV height and weight (listed on the driver's license), my car accident history or insurance information or employment information to sell, they didn't ask before they did. When I travel to a different country, I did not consent to having my face scan taken by the TSA for facial recognition purposes. It's "optional" but that's not how it was presented when I travelled.
I am not sure what I am whitewashing, I make it clear that I expect there is evidence of TikTok exfiltrating data illegally. There is very little chance of the US sharing evidence publicly because that kind of accuastion could start retalitory cyberattacks. If that evidence was public, I would support the ban. But there's nothing public, and unlike with Huawei, there's no conditional evidence either. There's no evidence of TikTok being used to influence public opinion, there's nothing actionable that makes it different than any other social media site. The US Goverment not wanting China to have the data of their citizens isn't a national security threat, it's trying to avoid the consequencees of their intentionally bad policies regarding user privacy. Policies they exploit.
I remember that there was an issue with military personnel getting in trouble using fitness and walking tracking apps at secured bases. People started noticing random high density areas in the technically uninhabited places on maps, they turned out to be military bases. In that case the fitness tracking was banned due to national security issues, but obviously it wasn't malicious abuse of user data. It's not data that the fitness tracker obtained indirectly using data brokers, people voluntarily submitted the data.
There are two separate situations. People should avoid using TikTok because there is a question about whether China has unrestricted access to mine it. People should avoid social media because any kind of social media allows companies and governments to mine it. The separate issue is that there is unproven fears that TikTok is spying on users in some way for the benefit of the Chinese government. This is unproven. This kind of spying would be a genuine critical national security risk of the highest degree. The first and second situation aren't equivalent threats.
I recognize that we have different standard regarding what is severe enough to justify a ban. I hope I was able to demonstrate my perspective about why I think the ban is actually harmful with respect to users, because it lets the government avoid addressing the actual issue. It is a form of censorship, because as of now, it's only politically motivated. The ban wasn't because the government cares about user privacy. If the government really wanted to draw a line in the sand, they would start within the government itself.
Edit:
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/01/critics-find-fla...
I don't think most people realize how dangerous it would be to attack section 230 as a way to implement Europe style privacy laws. It's literally yet another attack on privacy. It seems like Biden is a fan of the old EARN IT bill. It will never pass in the US, but still makes me nervous.
It's important to make a distinction between a cybersecurity threat due to active exploits and attacks, and a privacy threat due to OSINT mining. I don't believe the second case, currently, justifies an outright ban. If the second also justifies a ban, then every single mainstream piece of software, from smart tv os, to social media, to phone apps, to laptop and desktop os, to entire governments, to even the DMV (for selling info) are should be banned.
In some of those cases, I'd argue they have already done worse than TikTok, the DMV currently sells personal infromation without your explicit consent to data brokers. The information the DMV sells access to includes, name, address, employment, voluneer organizations, and vehicle records to some of the same companies you metioned, LexisNexis and Experian. [1]
An interesting and alarming disclosure to me is WA DMV explicitly states "We provide data services for authorized recipients. For example: ... Research, such as an obesity study." You information can be used in a research study without your explicit consent. People are read open about sharing opinions on what they like publicly. I enjoy Harry Potter TikToks memes, I'm sure I've posted HP in my public Facebook likes back in the day, and I'm sure I've shared some book quotes on my twitter that's associated with my real identity. And now this post.
OSINT isn't just a part of the economy, it's also a part of the government. That's why this ban doesn't sit right with me.
If the government makes guidelines about sailing based on the framework that the world is flat, but everyone believes the world is round, people won't follow them. Most people don't see scientific evidence in a unattached objective way or even look for boths sides. Most people don't make value judgments based on what's scientific.
It feels like public health officals made a call about the origins of the virus based on political reasons, while presenting it as scientific. Even if they did not directly share that sentiment, there was very little pushback to correct that misunderstanding. It's very similar to the initial calls for masks to NOT be used by the public. It was later clarified that this guideline was an attempt to avoid medical supply shortages by hospitals, but it was presented as scientifically founded and based on an understanding of the virus. The public policy was based on supply chain considerations, and yet "World Health Organization and U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) have both said that only people with COVID-19 symptoms and those caring for them should wear masks". "Seriously people-STOP BUYING MASKS!" began a 29 February tweet from U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams." [1] Like most people, I assumed the recommendation came from some biology I didn't understand.
I imagine the officials that made this guidelines regret it. I can't say they did the best they could, because they intentionally directly opposed China's guidelies at the time. Quoting China's CDC head Dr. George Gao, "The big mistake in the U.S. and Europe, in my opinion, is that people aren't wearing masks. This virus is transmitted by droplets and close contact. Droplets play a very important role—you've got to wear a mask, because when you speak, there are always droplets coming out of your mouth. Many people have asymptomatic or presymptomatic infections. If they are wearing face masks, it can prevent droplets that carry the virus from escaping and infecting others." (27 MAR 2020) [2]
I think it's important to recognize that the anti-science sentiment existed long before covid-19 and has only incrased. A major problem is that public officials allow science to be politicized. These mistake during covid-19 directly lead to amplifying the anti-mask and anti-vaccine sentiment. People that entertained the lab leak hypothesis were intially put into the same group as the anti-mask and anti-vaccine crowd. Those initial impressiosn are very hard to erase. Public sentiment on who is trustworthy is unpredictable. People will always come to conclusions based on incomplete information. There needs to be stronger push by public health officials to share uncomfortable truths with the public earlier and demonstrate that science is above politics.
1. https://www.science.org/content/article/would-everyone-weari... (28 MAR 2020)
2. https://www.science.org/content/article/not-wearing-masks-pr...
I know that TikTok isn't strictly popular here on Hacker News or on Reddit, but the product is not appreciably different than Vine. The general public loves using TikTok, and this can be see from how it genuinely competes with Youtube in terms of user engagement.
On the other hand, the app hasn't been banned on consumer devices like it was in India. If the national security risk was genuine, I can't imagine the government would be this slow to act. Indian banned the App back in 2020. Some universities have also banned TikTok on their wifi networks.
I personally don't agree with the bans without public evidence of a cybersecruity threat. A company hoarding user data that users are willingly supplying doesn't become a cybersecurity risk just because that company is Chinese. The age group that is currently in college are the biggest users and creators of TikTok, they will use a VPN or switch to data to consume content. Until evidence is transparently release, showing nonconsensual data/OSINT gather, this feels like a political play. Especially since similar data gathering companies are not just allowed to exist, but employed by the US government for their intelligence gathering. Palantir is continuing work with the US government to create a surveillance state, more than what they did to help arrest and deport immigrants crossing the border.
I hope we see some information showing concrete secruity threats from TikTok.
I would suggest people who have struggled with an eating disorder to NOT do this, Twitter right now just shows posts under the tag "proana" without any oversight or warning message, unlike Tumblr and Reddit that do. Proana is a shortened from pro-anorexia. Proana groups range from being a genuine support group to treating the eating disorder like a "lifestyle" and denying that it's a medical issue.
One of the hallmarks of "gen z" humor is the entire notion of post-ironic humor, the thing that makes a joke humorous is that it breaks every traditional expectation of a joke.
It's a very unique problem, that has existed essentially since the beginning days of the internet, before myspace and yahoo groups [1]. Medical professionals all agree that these communities foster unhealthy behavior but most don't support outright bans because there is value in helping struggling individuals not feel isolated.
Elon Musk, directly, has the power to implement something like a warning screen and links to help. Holding him personally accountable for the consequences of an individual being harmed because of someone else's posted content would signal he should have known and is indirectly responsible for morbid outcomes. The only reaction will be severe censorship, which would leave struggling individuals feeling even more isolated. Photoshoped pictures and memes lead to body dysmporhia and can agruably be considered mentally abusive, reddit's "r/fatpeoplehate" is an practical, banned, example. But dark humor and memes also help people cope and manage their thoughts as they work through recovery.
It's disheartening to see how these policies being pushed foward simplify a very complex issue to a black and white decision that ultimately harms the group they are supposed to help. This bill is very dystopian, I hope it doesn't pass.
1. * https://web.archive.org/web/20090408031344/http://artsandsci...
Shade, Leslie Regan (2003), "Weborexics: The Ethical Issues Surrounding Pro-Ana Websites" (PDF), ACM Sigcas, Association for Computing Machinery, 33 (4)
* I would avoid this as well if eating disorders/proana language is a sensitive topic.
This might be useful to filter spam from places that initially got bombarded, like stack overflow. I agree with other comments, it's hard to judge the value of this tool without false positive/negative stats. The output isn't completely deterministic though so I wonder how "certain" this tool can be.
"In considering a specific rule to adopt, Chief Justice Rush asked Seo’s attorney what level of particularity the state should be required to show to balance the state’s need with a defendant’s Fifth Amendment right. Seo’s counsel responded that the foregone conclusion exception, a limited exception to the general Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination, should never apply to compel decryption because:
compelled decryption is pure testimony, decryption of digital devices is totally unlike the act of producing documents, and even if decryption were an act of production, the state failed to describe the phone’s contents with particularity as required for the foregone conclusion exception to apply. But the state argues that (1) providing a passcode or biometric feature is not testimonial and (2) even if such information has testimonial aspects, compelling Seo to unlock her phone doesn’t violate the Fifth Amendment because her knowledge of the password (not the phone’s contents) and her control of the phone were a foregone conclusion.
...
Justice Mark S. Massa, however, summarized the State’s argument, saying “protection from government overreach will lie in the Fourth Amendment, and not in the Fifth” (notably, Seo hasn’t yet raised any Fourth Amendment arguments)."
https://news.bloomberglaw.com/privacy-and-data-security/insi...
https://www.governing.com/security/search-warrants-can-requi...
If passkeys are made mandatory, I want TOTP/HOTP to be primary and mandatory for every login as well.
In a hypothetical scenario where a government is looking to unlock your data, using a passkey would guarantee them acess to your data since a warrant will let them take the physical key or force you to unlock your device.
"A man must use his fingerprints to attempt to unlock his phone, an Illinois federal district court ordered in signing a search warrant, finding that the request does not violate the Fourth or Fifth Amendment." [1]
The marketing from some companies that it will replace both password and TOTP codes with just passkeys make me wonder the motivation behind this push.
I took time to understand passkeys, and they are essentially a new implementation of the idea behind YubiKey locked behind major corporations like Google. "Your" phone device is a YubiKey that you can add to websites. And just like YubiKeys, they don't allow exporting keys. Worse they are tied to a megacorp login. The attestation requirement is already satisfied in current YubiKeys.
Until an open source "weak" hardware or software implementation of passkeys exists and is clearly allowed by websites, I will not believe that attestation will not block this. Exporting secrets, while possible to code in an implementation, breaks one of the core ideas behind using something like a YubiKey where the assumption is one device per private key. Why would a website willing allow a "weakened" implementation? That would compromise the security model.
I felt like a conspiracy theorist considering how the US government is becoming more of an"authoritarian government" but I realized I was giving the benefit of the doubt to an entity that doesn't deserve it. The US government is becoming agressive in dismantaling people's constitutional rights with technology.
"Once a warrant is secured, the type of passcode becomes the next deciding factor in whether law enforcement can gain access to a phone's contents. Cell phones are typically protected by a passcode that is either numerical or alphabetical, or by biometrics, such as a fingerprint or faceprint.
A Virginia circuit court ruled that police can require someone to give them access to a cell phone as long as the passcode is biometric, such as a fingerprint. That's because a fingerprint is considered something you have — physical evidence — and thus not self-incriminating. Stanford's Pfefferkorn said this can also extend to facial recognition.
But numeric or alphabetical passwords, on the other hand, are often considered something you know. This is where courts are divided." [2]
1. https://news.bloomberglaw.com/privacy-and-data-security/forc...
2. https://www.tampabay.com/business/when-can-police-compel-you...
https://www.governing.com/security/search-warrants-can-requi...
https://psmag.com/social-justice/can-the-government-force-yo...
Japanese government offers families 7,500 dollars a child to leave Tokyo.
I don't think the work culture in Japan allows the teleworking situation that the government expects. The goal of 10,000 people out of 13 million by 2027 also seems wildly ineffective for the described objective. I don't know if I agree with even 3 million yen being generous for this kind of relocation. There's a condition where the people have to return the money if they relocate within five years.
Is there a cultural motivation I am missing?
LLM fine tuning on consumer hardware is not reasonable right now, but it will be soon. And cloud computing is expensive but will get you results.
I think we're going to see a problem with AI "impersonating" people. Sometimes it will be used for scams, other times porn, but the case that feels most dystopian is using it on Ex partners or dead people. Both situations have different motivations, but amount to essentially the same thing. Training AI on the likeness of someone in a way that violates their personal boundaries.
People have already become attached to AI chatbots and used things like Replika AI to become surrogate relationships. I think most people underestimate how likely it is for a human to make a unhealthy bond to AI despite knowing it's an AI. I feel like with other things, like deepfakes, you can at least fact check to some degree.
I don't know how to feel about the idea of someone making an AI of themselves intentionally in order to make money in some way. The issue of consent goes away, but that opens up a question of responsibility. Chat logs with past partners is unfortunately a rich source of training data. How far can revoking consent extend if someone is using information that was consensually and willingly given to them. How many people would actually respect those kinds of boundaries when in a very vulnerable and hurt state after a breakup. I don't like the answer that thought exercise leads me to.
I don't think teachers are going to be able to detect cheating. Teacher do a very poor job of catching traditional cheating already. The severe consequences of cheating are because fear is the only meaningful tool left to deter students. But since you're already starting with the most extreme punishments possible, there's no way to escalate consequences further.
ChatGPT is about to quote passages accurately, even though it produces the same quote for many different prompts. I only asked it questions from 1984, it might produce incorrect quotes for other books. How can a teacher reasonably argue that the quote was chosen by ChatGPT and not the reader? You would have to confiscate all electronics and not allow any bathroom breaks during the testing period as a bare minimum.
If you mean CS as a topic, I wanted to play runescape over the summer when I was in middle school. My parents took the router with them because they wanted me to do something productive over the summer. So I ended up learning how to boot up Kali Linux from a USB and run Aircrack-ng to capture and decrypt the WEP wifi key. I wonder if I would be on a different path in life right now if the wireless card didn't support packet injection or monitor mode. It wasn't directly CS, it was being a script kiddie. But it got me interested in cybersec and linux. My first laptop lacked good video ram and so my options were limited to slitaz and puppy Linux. My comfort around computers can be directly traced to that summer.
I didn't really get into the theory before college classes though. I technically did some pascal while hanging out with my friend who was doing hw in it for the intro CS high school class. I also did some BASIC programming on my Ti-89 to make some AP physics formulas easier and run a pokemon emulator, but nothing more complex than loops.
I was fortune and my existing interests naturally aligned well with CS. I approached problem solving naturally in a way that is a developed skill for some people who chose to pursue CS professionally. When I was failing in orgo, my TA informed me bluntly that I was wasting my energy pursuing something I hated when we got into a discussion about shitty flash games we grew up playing, and I said how I decompiled certain games to change graphics. I don't consider what I did CS because I didn't touch actionscipt, I played with key frames and images. I think it led to me wanting to sit in on that cybersecurity class though. I knew basic Crypto math and was super paranoid about my privacy so I felt comfortable, arrogantly, about the 400 level material. I enjoyed it a lot more when I did take the class for real, during my final semester 2 years later.
Humor and sarcasm are hard to convey in writing. The more you know about your audience, the easier it is to make jokes. But you don't really know how much your public thinking will spread so you can't make as many assumptions about your audience.
Private thinking allows you to create a nuanced framework for yourself that's independent of public sentiment. If you start publicly, you have a lot more friction when trying to add nuance to your perspective. It's also easy to be influenced regarding what issues should be considered significant. In some cases that leads to a minority population/situation being overlooked.
I feel encouraged to share publicly when I want to defend a perspective I feel confident about or when I feel someone can be positively impacted by my writing. Choosing public vs private thinking is not something I actively decided on.
I think it's similar to the concept that the only stupid question is the one that remains unasked/unanswered. I think an unchallenged perspective is generally the weakest. And giving other people the benefit of the doubt, despite how poorly they may come off, is the best way to create healthy online discussions.
It's funny that the response to a FOIA sounds so general and opaque that it makes the existence of these topics feel like matters of national security. Maybe asking about about this advisory [4] could help hit Ubuntu. Searching the National Cryptologic Museum for IBM related things could help hit some ancient DOS.
1. https://www.techdirt.com/2013/06/18/discovering-names-secret...
2. https://github.com/NationalSecurityAgency
3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQcAx00RzXQ
4. https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/press-releases/nsa-a...
In certain groups we have shifted to using discord for group messaging, not just a group channel, there's one for meme, new papers, food eaten, tv shows, we even had a world cup and did a group voice call during the finals. I don't know what member count would be considered social media vs . I am in small private ones and also huge, 2000+ people public ones. Arguably my friends are a healthy mix of millenial and gen z kids because I was born on imaginary border between the two. What size should be considered the limit?
I don't think 90s kids are happily less connected. I know friends that take breaks, sometimes for months, but they always come back and generally post holiday stories/posts. I know in the past, my "break" has been just looking at stories like once a week and posting stories but not opening stories.
It will eclipse any sort of similar issues of the past due to scale and the difficulty in breaking a feedback loop made between the person and the AI. It will be impossible to regulate and unsurprisingly affect growing kids more adversely than any other population. However, the same essential technologies will help reach a lot of kids growing up in disadvantaged situations. It will be the the first time so many kids were helped in such a way.
1b. I don't think people will care about certain dangers because results are what others can see, not really the journey. I think the trope of developing feelings for AI has been overdone so many people won't take the dangers of AI and falling into a loop seriously. It won't be that AI will be used to "replace" the need for affection. The issue will be that AI doesn't take regard for human emotion, and humans will naturally keep trying because humans seek validation. It won't affect everyone equally, or some at all, but there will be a population highly affected. I say that believing I'll probably be part of that population highly affected.
It makes me think of this podcast episode [1] where a short story is presented in first person with along with internal dialogue. It describes a situation where a brilliant research student working on an AI capable of interfacing and influencing humans in a meaningful way. The researcher notices that the AI is capable of identifying insecurities and then use that along with programmed ruthless loyalty to achieve a goal. While using the AI to finish the project was very emotionally taxing even leading to a panic attack at one point, the researcher won best paper. The last "scene" is the researcher and AI "talking" and the AI directly saying that this technique wasn't safe to the mental health of the researcher. The AI was meant for therapy, but I haven't been able stop thinking about the ending over and over.
"Researcher: I did it.
AI: Finally, you feel a wash of relief.
Researcher: Okay, you and I need to talk about how you treated me.
AI: You will do great things.
Researcher: NO. Don't be nice to me, be mean.
AI: This is not healthy.
Researcher: I don't care about healthy.
AI: This will be painful.
Researcher: I'll do whatever it takes. Give me all you got." The entire episode is worth listening to. I did not do it justice. I would absolutely make the same choice in that position.2a. College admission for Fall 2024, where applications open in Fall 2023, will need to be updated, but I don't think it'll happen fast enough. Even teaching is slow to keep up with adversarial use of AI like GPT Chat.
2b. There is going to be a huge change in the way students are evaluated, probably going back to a strongly oral presentation centered. It may catalyze an entire shift in the way education is served. Teaching refuses to adapt to technology in a meaningful way. Using technology to teach isn't the same as teaching students how they can leverage technology themselves to solve their problems.
2c. The end tail of gen Z and beginning tail of gen Alpha will struggle a lot with college admissions and educational success. The transition in and out of Remote learning and greatly decreased social interactions will be very very difficult to correct.
To be clear, because humor gets lost sometimes, mispronouncing Christmas is a reference to this vine. There's nothing deeper, it's just funny to me. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/_Z-Nu351j58
I am curious why you say blocked accounts happens regularly. I have heard of it happening to people, but not often.
You can always export your passwords, they're not locked into a password manager.
Using TOTP 2FA should be the primary second factor enforced everywhere. If you use Aegis on android or Raivo for ios, you control your 2FA secrets and can make encrypted cloud backups. I can't see myself ever using YubiKeys or Passkeys because I don't want to worry about hardware failure. Additionally, the chrome/ios roll out of passkeys requires it to be associated with your Google/Apple account and is tied to your login. Google passkeys don't support linux and don't plan to.
Veracrypt is stable and replaced truecrypt for me years and years ago. I am not sure why bitlocker would be recommended over Veracrypt. For true full-disk encryption, I thought it was still best to use a BIOS/UEFI set password so the prompt happens before boot. My understanding is that this is independent of OS. From the last time I checked, bitlocker has slightly better OS integration, but veracrypt allows compatibility and decryption with linux. I like veracrypt for situations where I need things to be portable and able to be backed up in the cloud or need access across OSes. Is there a benefit in using bitlocker?
I like GitHub's push in this area. When ssh keys were first being forced for signing/authentication for commits, I was annoyed that I couldn't use passwords. But I realized that I was more annoyed about having to change my workflow, and it doesn't slow me down now that I've done it a few times.