HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kolektiv

1,625 karma · joined December 25, 2008

London/Horsham (and anywhere else interesting).

Tech Theory + Practice. I care most about changing the world in meaningful ways through technology. I care very little about yet another X.

Contact me at andrew at xyncro dot com.

irc:kolektiv:irc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kolektiv; my proof: https://keybase.io/kolektiv/sigs/0d5gliRyPmqTUqjf5C4XNh5y1sry6und7d3z4LYWCyo ]

submissionscomments
kolektiv··on Master Builders
OP: Thoughts on functional programming, dependent typing, etc. couched as a ham-fisted parable.
kolektiv··on Indie.vc
My first thought on this was "wow, that name couldn't clash any more with the ethos of ind.ie". I would hope they'd think about changing it, as it's really a bit insensitive at the least.
kolektiv··on F# 2014 – A Retrospective and Call to Action
It's always great to hear about people finding it and liking it! Even better is that, in a meaningful way, it's not "a MS language" really now - it's fully open source, probably the best thing to happen to F# this year.

I'm aiming that comment less at you than just generally because the general publicity around that is probably a bit lacking - but if things like that matter to you, F# is still a great place to look :)

Hope you carry on enjoying F# - the community is one of the friendliest, do come and say hello!

kolektiv··on Rust and Go
Yes, some code formatting tools exist (within Visual Studio as part of F# Power Tools, and also I believe standalone in some binary form). However, as a community we're currently a little less dogmatic than Go (for example) about what "correct" formatting is.

Tabs vs. Spaces is decided at the language level (it's spaces or it doesn't work) but other things are often a matter of taste. It doesn't tend to matter too much though because (well written) F# code is expressive almost regardless of minor formatting issues (poorly written code in any language is a comprehensibility mess, regardless of "neatness" or newline consistency!)

kolektiv··on How a new HTML element will make the Web faster
Quite, and it has the enormous advantage that I can extract all data using nothing more than an XML parser, rather than having a two stage [parse XML -> parse embedded DSL] parser for special cases. Even the media aspects of the srcset could probably be better expressed (with more verbosity though) as a standard XML structure.

I really wish it was - though I'm far from a fan of XML for most cases, it does work rather well for this when used as intended...

kolektiv··on The Inner Workings of the Executive Brain
Sometimes I feel like I'm on a different planet to readers of publications like the WSJ:

    "we all "know" that tight deadlines lead to inspiration"
Do we? I've never thought that. It's always seemed straight forward that stress and reduction in avenues of potential exploration lead to less creativity, and the few moments of stress driven "eureka" lead to strong confirmation bias in the wrong direction. If this is apparently not the view of most management/executive types, no wonder business/corporate culture looks the way it currently does!
kolektiv··on Brendan Eich, We’ve Failed You. I’m Sorry.
We haven't failed him. While the old "may not agree with what you say but I'll defend to the death your right to say it" trope gets used here, it doesn't mean you need to protect people from the consequences of their speech.

Brendan Eich can donate to whatever causes he wishes, and rightfully so, but there is rightly no protection from the public opinion based consequences arising from those donations. Equally, justifications such as "meritocracy" imply that being a CEO is a very narrow thing - it isn't, it's a position of authority and leadership, and if you can't (near universally) inspire confidence in the people you're intended to lead, that is a problem with your ability to function as CEO.

kolektiv··on Brendan Eich, We’ve Failed You. I’m Sorry.
I haven't been paying overly close attention, but all of the reaction I have seen has generally been blog/twitter based expressions of sadness/disappointment/betrayal. Has it really escalated far beyond that? (Genuine question).
kolektiv··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (April 2014)
I'm quite happily self-employed at the moment, but good grief - if I wasn't, this is exactly the kind of thing I'd love to read if I was seeking a new challenge. Kudos for your clearly serious commitment to openness, and even more for not filling the "what we want" section with fluff. People who are happy to say "we'd love to be better at this, could you help us in some way?" are the most fun and rewarding to work with (and I'm lucky that I usually do).

Good luck!

kolektiv··on Microsoft Azure: Cutting prices on compute and storage
I'm old enough. I think that's why the parent qualified with "properly functioning"!
kolektiv··on Julie Ann Horvath Describes Sexism and Intimidation Behind Her GitHub Exit
Indeed, it's Muphry's Law.
kolektiv··on Once the full stop meant a sentence was over – now it means you're angry
Seems rather generational and perhaps somewhat geographical as well. Perhaps more prevalent in the US? I'm not sure how this would even reliably work - you're rather relying on automatic wrapping never looking like a line break, etc. Peculiar, for sure.

It would probably be a little interesting to do a study on changes in grammar/punctuational usage based on keystroke requirements. Having to flip to a different onscreen keyboard mode for a character would, I imagine, lessen the attraction of characters that needed that. Same with capitalisation, obviously, which I always assumed to be the driver behind all lower-case SMS messages in general. A full stop doesn't seem like it would be a candidate though, except line break = 1 char, full stop + space = 2...

Edit: Extra thought. If that was actually true, and it's changing people's _style_ of communication, does that essentially act as a kind of Sapir-Whorf hypothesis for group communications when this is in effect?

kolektiv··on What Programming Languages Do You Struggle To Hire For?
Or, to put it another way, why are you so averse to investing in people/your company that you're looking for the finished article on the job market, rather than finding good people and helping them learn the specific skills you need?
kolektiv··on Amazon workers face 'increased risk of mental illness'
There are some rather key differences though don't you think? I imagine as a reasonably valued software engineer you weren't likely to face disciplinary action or loss of employment for not picking fast enough, thus negating a huge cause of stress/anxiety. You also had the knowledge of a definite finite term of employment followed by more relaxing/agreeable work, another rather significant difference.

You also talk about troubleshooting shortages and getting to do things that require problem solving. It sounds from this article (and others like it over the last few years) that this kind of thing, if even still available at all, is not likely to happen to your average seasonal employee.

The fact that other people have it worse in various sweatshops around the world is hardly relevant, or particularly edifying. We are quite capable of seeing problems as a matter of degree I would hope.

Your comment comes across as a little like the CEO who spends a day on the factory floor and proclaims that he had a marvelous time and everyone treated him wonderfully. Unsurprising, but hardly enlightening...

kolektiv··on Europe drafts law to ban mobile roaming charges
If you're drafting legislation around roaming, why not write in reasonable competition provisioning while you're there? It won't be legal if we don't want it to be.
kolektiv··on The bomb in the garden
It's a great talk, and I wish I'd seen it. I found myself nodding quite a lot, despite not being a designer (though I used to play one before I got in to tech/code). And in many ways he's right.

But I did find myself questioning the premise towards the end. Why do we want to save "the web" in the form it was? Apps, etc. are different. Certainly they raise the barriers between the average user and creation in the way that the web traditionally didn't.

But to do well on the web these days - is that really as easy it was anyway? The standards are more complex. If you want to stand out in a real way that's probably going to take something like an App's worth of effort.

So do we want to encourage the web - a small and quite specific (and, perhaps, time-bound) layer? Or do we want to be focusing on the internet? Because that's doing great. I hear it's huge. And all of these apps - well, they use the internet, just maybe not the web.

I don't know what the next 20 years will look like (I do remember what things looked like from about '96 onwards, when I first started dabbling) but I think we should stand a little further back than trying to maintain something because "it was great". Maybe it was, but maybe it's not the right answer for the future.

EDIT: (To reply to some of the comments/downvotes)

I wasn't suggesting a world of Apps. I was suggesting a world of "other" approaches. The internet is also open and standards based. There are many standards which don't sit on top of HTTP. What I meant to point out is that the internet is not the web - and perhaps a new world of standards between connected devices, physical things, etc. will be a much richer place than a document-centric world. It's merely an idea, not a statement against openness.

kolektiv··on What The Heck Happened To Apple's iPad Sales?
In my own case, I'm planning on buying an iPad. I'm not though, because I don't know when the next one is coming out. The "fixed-ish" release cycle can work against you in this way - I don't know how many people are currently holding off purchase, and how much inventory they're sat on, but it wouldn't surprise me if people are now trained in to significantly more spike-based cyclic buying patterns than they've previously been.
kolektiv··on Cameron ‘Porn’ Advisor’s website ‘hacked’ – Threatens/Libels Blogger
Thankfully she's only the PPS to the Secretary of State for Defense. The actual SSD is the far more capable Philip Hammond... (Hmmm.)
kolektiv··on Cameron ‘Porn’ Advisor’s website ‘hacked’ – Threatens/Libels Blogger
I'm not sure this is true. Oh, I don't argue with your point about the historical facts of restriction, but I do think that the internet is still far from regulatable. The story is still really that politicians believe it is - it isn't, but they don't have the expertise to comprehend why that's the case. The internet is a mass publishing medium, not just a mass consumption one.

Legislation has historically successfully targeted only publishers, and you can do this when the number is fairly small, but not when that target is "everyone" because of the work required in monitoring (which is still not amenable to automation, despite what politicians may believe - it's still just too hard for the software technology we have).

kolektiv··on Siri in a Teddy
It seems like some quite strong claims are being made for the AI side of this here. Especially around things like adaptive understanding/learning. Using language like "aware" and "autonomous" is either inaccurate or potentially amazing/terrifying.

That said, it's a fascinating project, and getting mass backing for these kinds of things is going somewhere I'd like to see the world heading.

(Although I share the feelings that toys are really supposed to be about imagination - I've met so many young people lately with poor problem solving/conceptual skills, and I don't think that's disconnected from the increasing prevalence of highly passive young age play activities over the last couple of decades. I've got nothing scientific with which to back that statement though!)

kolektiv··on Victory Lap for Ask Patents
I didn't think from reading it that the two groups at MS were the same - I assumed they were independent parts of the org, in which case it was fairly clear that this was an idea that various people have had without direct communication, and thus throws serious doubt on "non-obvious". I'm pretty sure that you could find plenty of other people who've had the idea.

Companies like Akamai used to (probably still do) have image resizing proxies which took something like a multi-resolution TIFF file as part of their extended CDN features. I can't remember when I first saw that in action, but I'm sure it was pre-2011.

I'm also not sure why using a researchers own publications to kill a patent would be bad in your eyes. If you think something is really, truly patentable you'd keep it under wraps until you did so, as far as possible. If you only decided later, once you'd published research and people were productizing that research - and you then patented and sued them - well, that's exactly the kind of thing that should be stomped on!

kolektiv··on Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree
True, as someone who's done a bit of hiring, if you're meeting someone, you're still considering them as possible - you don't waste your time many times before getting pickier. Two years isn't a hard and fast rule - it never will be - you meet a brilliant candidate with 23 months and you won't hire them? Of course not. It's just a proxy. We want someone with about the skills that you should have acquired in two years.

We've all met people who have those skills with much less experience - and we'd hire them. Yes it's an excuse in a way to say then that this is why you weren't hired. Not a lie as such though - just the "reason".

kolektiv··on Come to London
Hmmm. I'm not one of the people you're really looking for here, but I could take a stab at reasons why I haven't been beating a path to your door...

a) I haven't really heard of you. A few words here and there over the years, but how much do you get out there and tell the geek community you exist? I'm guessing it's specific to a few specific tech areas - which I haven't seen. b) You're in London, you talk about "working hard" and being in your "Clerkenwell office". I've worked round there before, but really? I want a company who's more about working smart - and not in one place all the time. How much do you really need to physically see me? Commuting, plus a little bit of a tiny hint of "macho hard work culture" (probably unfair, but...) is enough for me to take a place off my list. It's a sellers market, generally. c) Also... money. London is expensive. Everyone knows London is expensive (and they're right). You don't say anything about money - no hints, etc. My reaction (being picky) is that it probably isn't enough to make it worth my while (and also that you may try and make me the lowest offer you think you can - I'm assuming you don't have open pay scales). d) Effort. You talk about your tough hiring - multiple rounds, tests, a day working with you (you don't say whether you'll pay me for this...) Why would I do this? If I'm smart, capable, good at what I do, I probably know people who want to work with me already - why jump through these hoops for a possibly good job then?

These may be unfair points - I hope not, but perhaps - but finding good people right now is about attracting them, not throwing up barriers or making them work for it.

kolektiv··on Sign up for the SICP Blitz in London happening in June
I'm not quite sure why this a) is restricted to 15 people or b) requires sponsorship as from the information there it seems to be essentially a book-club type format. Perhaps I'm missing something - are there not already groups/clubs that get together and do things like this?
kolektiv··on Worthless security claims
Well, yes .NET (IIS, specifically) does have a poor default (or rather, the default *.config files created by things like VS have poor defaults). However, hiding the error isn't really enough. Yes, it doesn't expose very many things. But it has exposed, of course, that you're running IIS. And the site is .NET in some form.

Those might not seem a big deal, but you've just provided quite a lot of hints about what the attack surface looks like. Most vulnerability scans will flag up "leakage" of data. IIS also does annoying things by default like "powered by IIS" type HTTP headers (it's not alone in that of course). You'll usually be warned to switch that off because you don't want to make attacks easier than they otherwise would be. Internal error form leakage is just another example.

kolektiv··on Ghost: The Future of Blogging (Node.js)
It looks rather good! But I do wonder if I'm the only person who was more than a little put out once I found it was the "hostage" model of open source - i.e. pay us enough money and we'll release this. Of course, there's nothing to say you can't do this, and I do applaud people finding ways to make OSS pay. But this way leaves a funny taste - it feels somehow counter to the spirit of the thing.

Possibly my ire was raised a bit further by the fact that I found that out in what seemed a slightly bait and switch-y way - "Try this!" click "Maybe later if you pay us!" Hmmmm.

Those gripes aside, it looks pretty.

kolektiv··on Never Say WordPress When Selling a Web Design Project
Well, yes, I guess there'll always be clients like that. I've generally been quite fortunate that I've been able to be fairly selective in life about who I work with/for, and I've rejected as many clients (more in fact) than have rejected me.

Saying that though, in those kinds of situations I do usually try and have a conversation with them about why they want to make those calls - they're paying me (or wishing to) for my professional expertise, and part of that is about educating people around surface choices which seem like a bargain but come with potential hidden costs and disasters. Some can't be helped of course :)

kolektiv··on Never Say WordPress When Selling a Web Design Project
I used to work for a guy who often used to say to me (as the head of tech-y stuff) "customers don't care what it's running on if it works - it can run on wet string and sellotape as long as the customers are happy it's doing what it's supposed to".

I used to laugh, but we both agreed that he was right. If you're selling anything, remember it's what the customer cares about that matters, not what you care about.

kolektiv··on "Put down the crack pipes" doesn't go so well
Well, another depressing comment thread. A huge pile on of comments essentially of the form "I'm male/white/straight and have ALSO suffered some of these things, therefore you probably haven't experienced discrimination and you should just lighten up".

Honestly? This is the best you can do? It would be fantastic if people would take a step back for a moment and try and deeply consider why your initial reaction is not disappointment and anger, but an attempt to deflect or belittle the problem, regardless of whether you made a conscious decision to do so. Of course you're not all sexists/racists/homophobes, but tending towards trusting people would probably benefit us all.

kolektiv··on Ad industry threatens Firefox users with more ads if Mozilla moves on tracking
The part that I particularly like actually is slightly different to that:

> "They'll see untargeted ads, which will look like spam. We have to get this information to them somehow."

Oh really, you have to get this information to me? Seriously? I didn't ask for it, I have no desire for it, no you don't have to. You want to, because someone is paying you to do so. Yet another case of someone thinking they have a right to a business model. No you don't. If it fails it fails. Find something to sell that people want (or at least don't despise enough to actively put you out of business).

← PreviousPage 6 of 11Next →