989 karma · joined November 15, 2007
We simultaneously what internet companies to do exactly the right thing but don't want to allow them to collect the data needed to do that right thing. It is an ironic behavior I notice in the tech community.
There is also the side issue of game engines which many teams reuse from game to game so maybe that doesn't really apply.
Unfortunately if you are being sued winning just means you don't own anyone money. It is a separate thing to collect lawyers fees from the other party.
I truly wish there was some sort of legal money parity rule, so the burden of paying for the case in terms of lawyers and court costs was shared by both sides in proportion to their available assets.
The rest is pure speculation based on how it appears these procedures are portrayed.
Patients think of the MRI as yes/no for cancer and when comes back as yes they get understandably upset. If instead the MRI biopsy are presented as a single procedure (ideally done together, but money) the MRI is just getting targeting information needed for the biopsy not providing a yes/no decision. If it turns out there is nothing to biopsy the patient gets a happy surprise no-one is ever upset about this. (Again problem of money)
The bigger issue is do you really think things will be better this way. Services like Google Search, Maps, newspapers would all become pay-walled. I honestly would personally like this outcome, as I have enough income to pay an extra $20-30 / month for these features. However for those in poverty 15-20% in the US and much more world wide this would be a major hardship. I really don’t think we want all of these currently ad supported things to be pay only in future, which is the inevitable outcome of banning advertising.
If they are saying that the game company has to have their own ad platform that basically means only Google and Facebook will be able to release ad supported child targeted games on iOS in the future, which doesn't really make any sense to me.
I don't like how the opening line of article exploits the fact the average person does not know cost of average online ad to make it appear like tracking has basically no value.
>... data about you was transmitted to dozens or even hundreds of companies, all so that the website could earn an additional $0.00008 per ad.
For the reader to be able to accurately understand how much money this is they need to know the percentages.
Very roughly (this varies widely based on the country and websitem) the average online ad only costs ~$0.0005, so that insignificant $0.00008 is around 10-20%. If the article had presented the exact same information but instead framed it in the form of revenue available to pay employees at an online company dependent on advertising, this would sound very different while really conveying the same concept.
Edit: I read the linked study and the data they used had an average cost per add of $0.001 putting the difference around 4%. This is smaller than I would have predicted. I would still rather they have lead with this number.
It is much easier to just assume these third parties will do whatever they want and either not share the data or accept that it will be used in ways you can't control.