HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotu

989 karma · joined November 15, 2007

submissionscomments
lotu··on Google Sued Under Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act
Would the photographer be allowed to identify using your face? This is pretty commonly done in newspapers.
lotu··on College-educated workers are taking over the American factory floor
Yes, they do. Exposure doesn’t mean the student internalizes the ideas but yes collages absolutely expose people to a variety of view point.
lotu··on Many elementary teachers don’t understand math, and it makes them anxious
Generally a lot of the formalism of Algebra requires specific brain development milestones dealing with abstraction to be reached. That’s why it is taught at the end of middle school. Now could some concepts be introduced earlier? Yes a common exercise in elementary school is to solve questions in the form of 7 + _ = 15. In this case x is replaced with a _ because variables are hard to grasp.
lotu··on Google Chrome experiment crashes browser tabs, impacts companies worldwide
What if Firefox has a problem?
lotu··on A.I. Systems Echo Biases They’re Fed, Putting Scientists on Guard
Are we suggesting that humans don’t do the same thing?
lotu··on Comparison of California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and GDPR [pdf]
Correct google keeps two separate cookies one for ads and one for everything else. This was part of the agreement with the FTC when they bought Double Click. They are prohibited from joining those two cookies by that agreement.
lotu··on Omniviolence Is Coming and the World Isn’t Ready
The scale is so different that it’s not really the same thing. It’s like comparing a mortar to an orbital bombardment with rail-guns. Yes both involve sending a projectile at a target at high speed but they aren’t remotely similar.
lotu··on Omniviolence Is Coming and the World Isn’t Ready
Or maybe something like developing, manufacturing, and prompting a new pain pill, that gets millions of people addicted to opioids, thus ultimately resulting of millions of overdose death over a decade.
lotu··on Web Scraping and Crawling Are Perfectly Legal, Right? (2017)
Except the court is empowered to make you follow it.
lotu··on YouTube isn’t for kids, but kids videos are among its most popular
Or... maybe we should use the built in webcam to determine the age of the user watching the video and use that to target ads. This could be a very effective solution. /sarcasm

We simultaneously what internet companies to do exactly the right thing but don't want to allow them to collect the data needed to do that right thing. It is an ironic behavior I notice in the tech community.

lotu··on YouTube isn’t for kids, but kids videos are among its most popular
This approach has a two fold problem. One, what if you are say Canadian or European, does this mean that America now gets to decide what your kids do and don't watch? Secondly, this type of action can lead to retaliation and segmentation of the internet into regional entities where you have an American internet, a Russian Internet, a European Internet etc. We have been trying very hard (not fully succufully, see China) to avoid this.
lotu··on Google’s 4k-Word Privacy Policy Is a History of the Internet
GDPR fines are up to 4% of global revenue. Do you honestly believe that Google is willing to risk literally Billions of dollars to hold on to your data? It just plain is not worth it so few people ever ask for data to be deleted it costs more to implement the data deletion code than is lost via less good ad targeting.
lotu··on Google’s 4k-Word Privacy Policy Is a History of the Internet
cookies are needed to “frequency cap” ads (avoid showing the same ad over and over and over again) and for enforcing user’s ban on specific ads, (yes google’s ad choices this so, if an ad is annoying you can ban it even if you are not being targeted by that ad). While the former is more for the benefit of the advertiser, the publisher also sometimes tries to avoid annoying the user.
lotu··on Absolute truths I unlearned as junior developer
It's more blurry but Games are still DONE in a way that an ongoing project where new features are constantly being added aren't. There are some exceptions like Minecraft but on average most games can not economically justify multiple full time engineers working on them for over a decade.

There is also the side issue of game engines which many teams reuse from game to game so maybe that doesn't really apply.

lotu··on Open Source Game Clones
> If your lawyer thinks you have a strong case, they will work for you for free, in exchange for a share of the bounty.

Unfortunately if you are being sued winning just means you don't own anyone money. It is a separate thing to collect lawyers fees from the other party.

I truly wish there was some sort of legal money parity rule, so the burden of paying for the case in terms of lawyers and court costs was shared by both sides in proportion to their available assets.

lotu··on Breast MRI in cancer survivors results in more unneeded biopsies
From the article it sounds like most of the harm of false positives from the MRI is the extra stress of the biopsy and/or waiting for biopsy results. As such it feels rational to try to treat the stress/anxiety with well know methods like talk therapy. Prescheduling an appointment for after the MRI/Biopsy might greatly reduce the stress of patients. Of course this runs into the cost "problem".

The rest is pure speculation based on how it appears these procedures are portrayed.

Patients think of the MRI as yes/no for cancer and when comes back as yes they get understandably upset. If instead the MRI biopsy are presented as a single procedure (ideally done together, but money) the MRI is just getting targeting information needed for the biopsy not providing a yes/no decision. If it turns out there is nothing to biopsy the patient gets a happy surprise no-one is ever upset about this. (Again problem of money)

lotu··on Breast MRI in cancer survivors results in more unneeded biopsies
I don't think comparing it to prostate biopsy helps most people. I assume they anesthetize you so you don't actually feel pain just really weird, possibly upsetting tugging right? Afterwards you take some regular pain killers for a few days. This doesn't feel like a big deal to me but I'm likely wrong. Maybe it is only a big deal for some people like how how people who are claustrophobic freak out in the MRI.
lotu··on When Grown-Ups Get Caught in Teens’ AirDrop Crossfire
The lack of a manual feels like a red herring only a small fraction of user actually reads the manual. And among those that do they read it to find a specific thing (like wifi) not to understand the product as a whole.
lotu··on The Euthanasia That Wasn’t
You would think that techies who constantly complain about crap documentation would realize quality writing is not free. (Best of luck BTW)
lotu··on “Apps intended for kids may not include third-party advertising or analytics”
I realize you are not the original poster but it sounds like your view would be the same even if we lived in a world without children. In this case it’s not really about helping children it is about advancing your desired outcome and that annoys me a bit.

The bigger issue is do you really think things will be better this way. Services like Google Search, Maps, newspapers would all become pay-walled. I honestly would personally like this outcome, as I have enough income to pay an extra $20-30 / month for these features. However for those in poverty 15-20% in the US and much more world wide this would be a major hardship. I really don’t think we want all of these currently ad supported things to be pay only in future, which is the inevitable outcome of banning advertising.

lotu··on Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year?
I like the random color/giant emoji idea. The major downside I see is space on the tag and all the current printers are black and white so they all need to be replaced for this to be effective.
lotu··on Why do airlines still mislay 25M bags a year?
I'm pretty sure they mean misrouted not lost. Lost makes a better headline.
lotu··on “Apps intended for kids may not include third-party advertising or analytics”
Well given that Google own the AdSense/DoubleClick platform which is used for serving ads on YouTube as well as all of it's own custom analytic tools none of these would be third party. The part about not linking out of the app would still apply though.
lotu··on “Apps intended for kids may not include third-party advertising or analytics”
I'm interpreting this as third party targeting, not that you can't use a third party handle the process of targeting, serving, and billing ads.

If they are saying that the game company has to have their own ad platform that basically means only Google and Facebook will be able to release ad supported child targeted games on iOS in the future, which doesn't really make any sense to me.

lotu··on “Apps intended for kids may not include third-party advertising or analytics”
Obviously, but where do you want to go with that? Are you suggesting that because kids can use any app on a phone that all tracking and ads should be banned?
lotu··on Firefox Monitor
This is a fair point and it has to be weighed against the value of the data to the individual. I generally feel they have struck the correct balance but if you think different approach is warranted you should explain it and why it better balances these different needs.
lotu··on Firefox Monitor
Pwned is not a standard english word. The vast majority of non-tech non-gamer non-under 40s are unfamiliar with this word but are familiar with firefox.
lotu··on When it comes to privacy, default settings matter
WARNING advertising SWE insider

I don't like how the opening line of article exploits the fact the average person does not know cost of average online ad to make it appear like tracking has basically no value.

>... data about you was transmitted to dozens or even hundreds of companies, all so that the website could earn an additional $0.00008 per ad.

For the reader to be able to accurately understand how much money this is they need to know the percentages.

Very roughly (this varies widely based on the country and websitem) the average online ad only costs ~$0.0005, so that insignificant $0.00008 is around 10-20%. If the article had presented the exact same information but instead framed it in the form of revenue available to pay employees at an online company dependent on advertising, this would sound very different while really conveying the same concept.

Edit: I read the linked study and the data they used had an average cost per add of $0.001 putting the difference around 4%. This is smaller than I would have predicted. I would still rather they have lead with this number.

lotu··on Maine passes bill to prevent ISPs from selling browsing data without consent
Really we need to stop relying on third parties to use our data "correctly" no-one has the time and expertise to carfully read and understand what these third parties say they intend to do with the data and then actually verify that they did what they said.

It is much easier to just assume these third parties will do whatever they want and either not share the data or accept that it will be used in ways you can't control.

lotu··on Betrayed by an app she had never heard of
BS but I imagine this is how they verify you own the number and prevent a rival app from executing a denial of services attack on them by unlisting everyone’s number.
← PreviousPage 4 of 17Next →