It's not that stupid (and the EU even did the same thing first ... it's just that most of the British media reporting on how much more effective their windfall taxes were downplayed or omitted the fat that most of the money was coming from renewable generation). If the UK ever builds the kind of renewable capacity needed for our climate goals those windfall profits will go pop because they only exist due to electricity prices being based on the most expensive generation needed to meet demand, which is currently natural gas. Once renewables are pushing gas out of the generation mix most of the time that price drops to nearly zero except when the renewables aren't performing well. Basically, the only way for these profits to encourage investment is if renewable companies think they can sandbag the energy transition.
(The renewable generation that the Conservative government is pushing for isn't really affected by this because some time ago, they changed how the subsidies were structured into contracts for difference where the companies get a fixed price with the government paying back or receiving the difference from the market price. Profits from generation covered by those CfDs are not subject to any windfall tax.)
Yeah, it's just that people are unlikely to realise this because the British press has spent the last year or so lying about this for both partisan reasons (most of them hate the party currently in power) and environmentalist ones (there's been a huge campaign to block new fossil fuel production in order to fight global warming which relies on convincing people that the only reason governments haven't done so is because it'd hurt fossil fuel company profits - admitting that it'd actually increase their profits and make ordinary people worse off would get in the way of that).
It's even stranger if you think about another common anti-Brexit argument: that many of the "EU laws" which caused people to vote for Brexit were actually created by the UK and Brexit supporters were tricked into blaming the EU for them, where the "UK" in question was actually the same tiny group of UK leaders that we're meant to fear Brexit will hand over control to, behind closed doors, with no real functioning democratic oversight.
That article seemed to me like a microcosm of what's wrong with UK journalism since Brexit. Every one of those issues is shared with Europe as a whole (or in the case of "the ability to defend its skies against the level of missile and drone strikes that Ukraine is enduring", basically every country on the planet as I understand it), but the article makes the UK look uniquely bad by using a completely different framing when talking about the UK's military vs other countries like France and Germany. For the UK they talk only about the current problems, whereas for other countries they focus only on the fact that those countries have annouced plans to improve their militaries whilst ignoring the current state of their militaries and the question of whether those plans are realistically going to work or actually happen. Germany's military in particular is in an awful state and they've kept on putting off the supposed funding increase it's meant to be getting.
Like, the UK is arguably the main military power in Europe at this point and a major contributor to Ukraine not being outright annexed by Russia, but you wouldn't get that impression at all from the article.
"Looks like" is very much the right way of describing it - it's largely a matter of appearances. Especially since Brexit, a lot of the British media pushes only the downsides of any option the government chooses and only the upsides of the alternatives, whilst at the same time spinning everything other countries do as a success. For example, Germany's rail infrastructure has been having real problems actually running trains as a result of massive underinvestment (about a third of what the UK spends if I remember ightly) but our media makes it sounds like they're the ones with a better rail system due to actually investing.
Or take Covid - our press pushed this tale about South Korea having such effective contact tracing they could lift restrictions and reopen society, whereas our incompetent government failed to do so, but in reality they were actually less successful at doing so and even had their own equivalent of Eat Out to Help Out planned that they completely failed to launch in 2020 because they couldn't keep restrictions lifted for long enough. It's just that the British press only reported on them attempting to lift restrictions as proof they succeeded and ignored the part where it kept on failingg and they were almost immediately reimposed, whilst their UK coverage only focused on failures and not on the country being largely out of lockdown for most of summer 2020.
Also, the only zero-fraud option for something like furlough or business support is to deny everyone - every real-world set of anti-fraud checks inevitably blocks some genuine people and permits some fraudsters, I'm sure HN must be familiar with this concept by now, and of course the media attacked the government as incompetent for both. (For example, complaining that businesses couldn't just add people to payroll and immediately claim furlough for them - which would enable massive, trivial fraud - and also that they had no way of detecting if employers were making people come into work whilst claming they were furloughed.) Most of the publications pushing that story even spin normal benefit fraud as something that's not a big deal and right-wing Tory attempts to crack down on it as damaging and counterproductive using essentially this argument. On the other hand, Germany's financial regulator actually opened a criminal investigation into the journalists who investigated the Wirecard fraud, and Germany's own press and politicians failed so hard at investigating that it fell to journalists from outside the country working for the Financial Times to finally prove it. Those are, qualititively, very different kinds of fraud problems and not in a way that makes Germany look good.
i don't think this argument actually makes sense. The rate at which money arrives in people's pockets via income such as wages and becomes available for them to spend - what you call the half life of money - is effectively what people think of as money. What money means to most people is the amount available for them to buy stuff with, and while the money may recirculate when they buy something for personal consumption the actual goods and services do not. This means that money recirculating back around faster through wages has the same effect on inflation as just printing and handing out more money: both result in more money chasing the same limited supply of goods and services. When looking at the economy as a whole, it's the rate of flow that matters.
This is especially true if you follow MMT. Remember, the whole underlying premise of MMT is that the government's ability to pay for goods and services is not in any way limited by a need to collect money first, that they cannot ever be forced to default on debt denominated in their own currency, that the only actual limiting factor is the actual real resources like labour, raw materials, and so on, and that the purpose of taxation is to keep inflation under control by reducing private demand for those things. From that point of view, money sittting in offshore accounts is a red herring because it doesn't represent consumption of real resources, and wages and money being brought into the country to buy things with are exactly what does need to be taxed because they do represent actual demand which will cause consumption of those resources.
Absolutely. For example, take this quote from the article: "The opposition Labour Party estimated in November that at least £576 million had been lost nationally in levelling up funds due to inflation. A frustration to those on the front-line of projects is that the Conservative government isn’t providing extra funding to cover these costs." That inflation is just the big, publicly-visible aspect of the whole world becoming poorer in real terms; inadequate energy supplies, shutting down large parts of the world's economies over the last three years, and worker shortages throughout the developed world have all sapped away at the UK and other countries' actual capacity to carry out big projects like the ones talked about in the article. This can't just be fixed by the government giving out more funding, there ultimately have to be cuts somewhere - and the decisions in the UK specificially that lead here had bipartisan support with the opposition generally calling for the government to go even further.
The whole "wealth gap" framing is a bit dubious. A big chunk of the UK's wealth is high house prices, and this has substantial downsides - obviously people don't get much direct benefit from the fact that their own home is worth more on paper, and it makes it harder for people to buy homes and increases people's cost of living. This article (arguably correctly) frames the fact that the housing affordability advantage of Sheffield is narrowing as them falling behind, but of course by the janky logic of the British mainstream media less affordable housing is actually an increase in wealth.
If anything it's the other way around - the 1% are going to be OK pretty much no matter what, it's everyone else that this matters for. Right now the US and most of the developed world does not have workers to spare for weird and potentially pointless speculative work of questionable value to society as a whole - they're struggling to find the workforce needed to supply the things ordinary people need and want, including stuff like healthcare. Just pointing at "supply and demand" and calling for pay rises, as I've seen so many do, does not solve this issue unless it causes a shift in workers from doing useless work to more useful work.
There is no fiducary duty to maximise shareholder profit. It doesn't exist, it's basically made up. (There is a duty not to intentionally screw over shareholders, but that's far narrower.) In particular, most US corporations are incorporated in Delaware which has something called the business judgement rule, where so long as executives have reasonable belief that their actions are in the best interests of the business they're protected.
That would still ultimately be spun as greed and proof they were getting pay increases when everyone else was suffering - at least, that's what happened in the UK when a bunch of CEOs didn't get their normal bonuses during Covid. This substantially decreased the total pay of the average FTSE 100 CEO that year, and once it returned to normal every news outlet ran articles about how their pay had increased by a massive amount in the last year alone whilst ordinary workers' pay had decreased over the last decade. Of course, it was really only their pay returning to normal after dropping substantially over the last year or two in a way that normal workers' pay had not, and the actual numbers in the report this way all based on put their pay at lower than it was a decade ago.
Still, the press managed to turn them taking a temporary cut in pay that ordinary workers didn't suffer from into them getting an increase in pay that ordinary workers didn't get.
This is definitely overstating its case. The problem I've seen isn't so much that there isn't research taking into account problems like this, it's that research which ignores the hard parts of the problem and comes to the conclusion that switching to green energy would be easy if only governments stopped dragging their feet gets picked up by the media and pushed into the public's perception of what science and the experts say is possible, making it seem like the only reason that governments aren't swiching faster is because they're in the pockets of big fossil fuel.
In particular, there's been a lot of work done here in the UK on switching these voltage and frequency control services over from fossil fuels to other, renewable sources that's public but not widely known about. Meanwhile, the voting public think that the government has literally done nothing and isn't even trying because all that gets media coverage is overly-optimistic claims based on ignoring the hard parts of the problem and attempts to spin anything they're not doing (like onshore wind and large-scale solar) as the solution and anything they are doing (offshore wind, hydrogen, etc) as stupid.
I don't think they're just missing the point; rather, their entire worldview and politics center on insisting that it does not exist. There's this idea that's been fairly widespread for a while that whatever views are held by extremely online left-wingers today are simply the correct, non-bigoted ones, and that the only reason that anyone would want to even give a label to them, let alone debate or challenge them, is to defend bigotry. (Not only that, if tomorrow or in a week or month or year those people change their view of the world, then those are simply the correct views and always have been.) The idea that this in itself is a form of bias, or that it gives power to a particular group of people who could be wrong, just is not within the accceptable range of thought.
A lot of people who think along these lines, especially younger people, don't think of wealth as something that can be created or destroyed at all. They just believe that there's some fixed amount out there, and that if ordinary people don't have enough that must be because the super-rich have stolen their fair share and need to be brought down a peg. The very idea of wealth that can be created is seen as a lie spread by the super rich to conceal their theft. (I do wonder if part of this is that a lot of people are too young to have seen their societies become substantially better of as a whole, unlike previous generations.)
If by "off the charts" you mean about the same as the EU then sure. (Germany is particularly badly affected - which is interesting because the British press has been pointing to their higher levels of healthcare funding and larger number of hospital beds as proof our healthcare system has been catastrophically underfunded. Eurostat doesn't have the December figures, but Germany had a 23% excess mortality rate in October, the most recent month, when England was still at 10%. If it was the other way around the headlines here would be yelling about a catastrophic failure... It looks like other EU members experienced similar spikes earlier in 2022 too.)
Talking about personal carbon footprints gets in the way of the narrative that fossil fuel companies were the main beneficaries of the fossil fuel era and they were the ones who'd lose out if fossil fuels weren't available, that much is true. The trouble is, the "personal carbon footprint" narrative is much closer to the truth than the "fossil fuel companies benefit" narrative. I actually had a look at some of the leaked internal documents and even internally they couldn't figure out a way to meet consumer energy demand without fossil fuels on the timescales needed if global warming was as bad as forecast - renewables would take about as long to be in widespread use as they ended up taking in the real world, and the only feasible alternative was nuclear which ran headlong into a bunch of difficulties in reality. (I also read the press release by the showboating US prosecutor characterising this as proof they secretly knew the world needed to switch to renewables much sooner in order to prevent global warming.)
OPEC is an alliance of state-owned oil producers in the Middle East, and their influence on global oil prices were seriously curtailed when the US started producing more oil - if attempts by global warming activists to limit oil production in the democratic developed world were more successful that'd really help give them back power. Also, there's not really an OPEC analog for natural gas but the ESG movement seems to have had similar effects in practice.
I reckon the comment you're replying to is exactly right - people have been mislead about their interests and the effects of specific policies on them. Specifically, the media has pushed for fossil fuel production to be cut back without first tackling the need for it and told people that the reason governments won't do this is because it'll hurt big oil's profits, and then when this had the opposite effect that it was the result of corporate profiteering, and that any claims to the contrary were just big oil propaganda. People bought this because it fit into their existing view of the world and all their friends did. Of course, this couldn't possibly work as advertised because it'd require consumers and the industries supplying them to burn fossil fuel that's not actually available. The whole reason prices go up and consumers can afford less is because the fossil fuel demand at previous levels of consumption can no longer be supplied.
The thing is that some of those options (especially building more storage) might actually be more expensive and less practical than just building even more wind and letting a lot of the power from it be "wasted".
No, we didn't. I looked up the specs when the topic came up and I think the data part was something like 2Mbps shared by everyone. The big "broadband" content that BT were hoping would fund the whole thing was analog pay TV, basically leveraging their telephone monopoly into a cable TV monopoly as well. Without that extra shared pay TV money it wasn't feasible to install an individual optical network terminal in everyone's house with the tech back then, and that's the big monopoly Thatcher's government balked at. In the end they did end up using another version of the same tech in some areas which used shared optical terminals between multiple houses that was telephony only - and I mean literally telephony only. A bunch of people found out about their high tech fibre optic lines when they couldn't get anything faster than dialup internet whilst all the people with normal copper lines had ADSL.
Absolute molecular weight is important. Can't remember why off-hand but if I recall correctly there's a pretty substantial efficiency hit from using heavier gas molecules and conventional Stirling engines have a similar issue.
The calibration for quartz crystal variance in these watches is done much, much later in the manufacturing process using solder bridges on the PCB - people have reverse engineered it. I think there are watch oscillator chips out there with one-time programmable calibration (particularly for analog watches) though.
This feels like it assigns too much competence and control to the CIA and not enough to the unnammed "NATO ally" country or countries with the means and motification to make a whole bunch of Russian military infrastructure go kaboom. A lot of the US reporting on the war between Russia and Ukraine is very US-centric, and there's a few European countrise which really want to wreck the Russian military, have the historic ties and connections that they could probably carry out a good sabotage campaign, and that now have a justificaton to make it happen.
Almost certainly not in an FTTP configuration. BT experimented with that but the problem was that the ONTs were too expensive at the time to install one in each house. The way that they originally hoped to pay for some of the costs was by running television over the fibre (not internet access - the proposals did have some space for data but it was tiny by modern standards), effectively leveraging their telephone monopoly to become a cable TV provider as well. That's where all the talk about competition and US cable companies comes in. Having found and read some of the reports Dr. Cochrane seems to be rewriting history a bit to fit modern partisan politics.
In practice, BT did use something called TPON to run phone lines over fibre to some areas, but this was termiated in the street to analog-only narrowband over copper using hardware shared between multiple houses. This meant that people unfortunate enough to be in areas served by fibre often found they couldn't get anything faster than dialup well into the 21st century. In some cases BT actually ended up replacing this with plain copper runs back to the exchange so that customers could at least get ADSL.
There are plenty of instances which forbid you from talking about specific topics, and no shortage of ones which block any kind of interaction with other instances which refuse to forbid specific topics - meaning that if you use that instance, you cannot follow users on instances which do not restrict discussion in the correct way and they cannot follow you. Some of those topics have included information that other Mastodon users would have really wanted to know about for reasons of personal safety, such as the latest alias and position of online power of someone trailed by a decade or two of rape allegations across multiple communities.
It's not a weird description at all. Imagine that one day you had what you thought was a valid cause to sue some dodgy corporation over some dispute you had with them, only to discover that your ability to sue had been taken away because that corporation had already taken the judges and legal clerks in your state to court and won a lawsuit against them which neither you nor anyone else with actual reason to sue ever had a say in. Because the Texas law was structured as a purely civil remedy just like if you were to sue someone else or some business over a dispute, allowing this kind of lawsuit against judges would open a direct route to this happening. It would create a way to entirely bypass the part where cases and controversies actually went to trial with the parties involved able to present their case. There's probably more sensible ways that the Supreme Court could've defanged that law, if they wanted to and the issue hadn't been rendered moot anyway.
I don't think the Supreme Court actually ever ended up ruling on whether the Texas law's attempts to do an end-run around constitutional protections were allowed; Roe v. Wade was overturned entirely before that ever had a chance to come up. They did rule against some of the attempts to do an end run around that end run so to speak by allowing aborrtion providers to pre-emptively sue the judges and clerks that would've been tasked with enforcing the law but given how fundamental not allowing that is to the functioning of the legal system that's no surprise.
That probably has very little to do with it. The immediate cause of all the problems was that Lloyds TSB was forcibly split up in order to try and increase competition and the Lloyds half kept the IT department, and when the TSB half tried to move over to the existing IT platform of their new parent company everything broke.
The article is part of the problem. UK politics and the media narratives around it have beeen utterly wrecked by the fight over Brexit and the attempts to give its creators the boot. For example, take this claim: "Investment is down and inflation higher than it would have been inside the European Union." The UK's inflation in the year to November 2022 was 10.7%, compared to 10.1% in the Eurozone. It just doesn't seem at all plausible that the UK would somehow have substantially lower inflation if it were in the EU, based on what countries actually in the EU have experienced, yet it's treated as so obviously true that only lying Brexiters would reject it.
This belief is boosted by the fact the British press only ever compares our inflation with France, which has the lowest inflation in Europe due to substantial nuclear generating capacity and energy subsidies funded through borrowing. Our government was attacked for attempting even a fraction of those energy subsidies to the point they did a U-turn because ultimately the public pays for it, but that downside is ignored when talking about France. They also also have substantially more national debt for obvious reasons... but luckily the UK national debt is usually only compared with Germany's.
Not really. As I understand it, the floating LNG terminal is much more expensive to operate and has much less capacity than the fixed LNG terminals which Germany still needs. It's basically a pricy partial stopgap.