HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mftrhu

303 karma · joined May 11, 2017

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/mftrhu; my proof: https://keybase.io/mftrhu/sigs/VmVZb3Bi2xjXA9N9Yg55vP7KmmbkF9OSGOZ-ykVkKl4 ]
submissionscomments
mftrhu··on Elon: Let Me Help You Speed Run the Content Moderation Learning Curve
People also seem to forget just how the Nazi got started [1], and who they also targeted for extermination [2].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_book_burnings#The_burning...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pink_triangle

mftrhu··on Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are forbidden: Tribal lands
So, corruption creates corruption?
mftrhu··on The Fediverse is inefficient but that's a good trade-off
Does this principle trump the freedom of association of the person who is actually hosting, and paying for, for each instance?
mftrhu··on The Fediverse is inefficient but that's a good trade-off
> Hell, it would be all to easy for adversarial group to just server hop and get a bunch of sites blocked purely because the mods of those sites are not on 24/7... or just allow for free speech

Nah. De-federating is manual. Such an adversarial group would need to join up, start spamming, and keep on spamming long enough for their instance to be added to a blacklist, and for other admins to pull that blacklist in, without the admin ever acting in the meantime.

It's not like the fediverse is that big, either - people talk to each other.

mftrhu··on The Fediverse is inefficient but that's a good trade-off
An instance set up by Google would be likely de-federated on the next day, and it would be a good thing.
mftrhu··on The Fediverse is inefficient but that's a good trade-off
I don't see anything wrong with the people who manage and pay for the server - usually for themselves and their friends, or because they are passionate about decentralization, and hardly ever because they set out to provide a platform for everyone to be able to say everything to anyone else - to be able to decide who their server will interact with.

In the fediverse, after all, users who don't like that decision can always move to another instance, or set up their own - you can't do that on twitter, HN, Reddit, and the barrier to entry for setting up one's e-mail server is high enough that the capability to do that is only theoretical.

mftrhu··on Pëtr Kropotkin and Mutual Aid
Oh, you probably meant "state capitalist". The definition of that fits to a tee.

> State capitalism is an economic system in which the state undertakes business and commercial (i.e. for-profit) economic activity and where the means of production are nationalized as state-owned enterprises (including the processes of capital accumulation, centralized management and wage labor). [...] Other examples include Singapore under Lee Kuan Yew and Turkey, as well as military dictatorships during the Cold War and fascist regimes such as Nazi Germany.

mftrhu··on East German Doping Victims Die 10 to 12 Years Earlier (2018)
> When it comes to the long term physical and mental outcomes of transgender hormonal therapy, we simply don't know.

Correction: you don't know anything about the long-term physical and mental outcomes for patients on HRT HRT, because you did not do any kind of research into it - you wouldn't need to use adjectives as vague as "unnatural" or "synthetic" otherwise.

mftrhu··on East German Doping Victims Die 10 to 12 Years Earlier (2018)
Like "I can't be arsed to engage, on your terms, with culture war bullshit".
mftrhu··on East German Doping Victims Die 10 to 12 Years Earlier (2018)
> the levels of testosterone esters that were administered to the female athletes (typically 25mg/week)

Comparing generic "testosterone esters" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Androgen_ester - from the fifties to "testosterone esters" from today, without knowing exactly which kind of medication was involved or how it was administered, doesn't seem like a good way to reach any kind of conclusion.

mftrhu··on East German Doping Victims Die 10 to 12 Years Earlier (2018)
If you are just "questioning" it for the sake of questioning, throwing shower thoughts out without doing a iota of research into procedures which are a century old? Yes. It's unreasonable for people to ask others to do their homework.
mftrhu··on East German Doping Victims Die 10 to 12 Years Earlier (2018)
It should be ignored until sampling bias is found to be unlikely. Vague suspicions based on anecdotal experience with chronic illness forums are worthless.
mftrhu··on I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or my idea
If you really feel the need to engage in culture war bullshit, could you kindly do so in a less boring manner?
mftrhu··on I was forced to be a child star. It was never my dream or my idea
It's from old research by the PIDOOMA Institute - "${minority} is trying to convert our children".
mftrhu··on Meal of a lifetime: what to eat at every age
> “Asian people seem to be physiologically intolerant to milk, is it possible that Asian people are more tolerant to soy than western people in the same way that the inverse is true?”

> You:

> “MILK BAD SOY GOOD WHERE PROOF”

While I'm sure that your skill at logical leaps must be impressive, and bring you a lot of joy, I would caution against relying on it overmuch: you just took a series of logical tumble-off-a-cliff.

The very premise - "beware of soy, for it might be to blame for low T in the west!" - is nonsensical, like using old papers loaded with "might" and "we don't understand things yet" to assert the existence of a strong and obvious link between the two.

"Western people have only been drinking soy for 50 years" is also an incredibly weak argument, and jumping from that to "maybe Asian people just tolerate soy more" is - absent even minimal research that would at least suggest the possible existence of such a phenomena - just a way to castle up, and to refuse admitting that the argument(s) that led to this were flawed.

mftrhu··on Meal of a lifetime: what to eat at every age
What strong link? "[...] might decrease [...] might increase [...] may impact [...] it's not yet understood [...] there may be slight changes" does not suggest any sort of strong nor obvious link.

> That an Asian persons body has had the time to adapt to Soy does not mean it's safe for westerners immediately, it could be, but it equally could not be.

I'm sorry, what?

I do not keep up with the research, so I must have missed the papers which proved that Asian people's bodies process phytoestrogens - which, I might add, usually act as estrogen antagonists if they even do anything - in a radically different way than westerners.

mftrhu··on UK.gov to make adults give credit card details for access to Facebook or TikTok
> On the other hand, it has the potential for readers to mistake their drivel for substantive discourse.

The thing is, not engaging with them - in non-moderated communities - also has the potential for readers to mistake their drivel for substantive discourse, both by way of familiarizing them with it - mere exposure effect - and by making it appear like their assertions are not being challenged because they cannot be challenged.

That's why the engagement really needs to happen on two fronts: both on their own level - assertions met with demands for proof, unrelated or misunderstood papers pointed out as such, counter-assertions backed with proof - and on a meta level. If you only do the former you will run afoul of Brandolini's bullshit asymmetry principle, while letting them choose the field of engagement: there is a literally infinite number of bullshit claims they are able to make - be that "trans people are just incels, really" or "transsexualism [sic] is a sexual addiction, which is why epileptics never transition" - and attempting to disprove them will perforce require much more effort than it takes them to shit them out.

Helping them can be very satisfying, also. I still fondly remember that time when I decided to engage with a Nazi who was denying the existence of the gas chambers, asking them for proof, only to receive a link to a report, hosted on Nikzor, which went about debunking their own claim.

mftrhu··on UK.gov to make adults give credit card details for access to Facebook or TikTok
"Revealed"? I'm sorry?

The only person who can display "genuine curiosity" over the nth dimwit making the same set of already thoroughly debunked claims for the hundredth time - claims that get repeated, only infinitesimally changed, over timeframes measured in years to decades - is someone who suffers from heavy memory problems.

Engaging with them is frankly pointless: even if they are willing and able to learn - which is a big if - there's always another person around the corner ready to take their place, and argue the inarguable. Oh, sure, there are probably a lot of people, at any point of time, who are willing to engage with them in good faith, but bullshit is fundamentally asymmetric: they do get tired of it.

At that point, the only real solution is to either stop engaging - and let them appear unopposed, while other people burn themselves out in an effort to bring them the light - try to shut them down, or - in loosely moderated places - deploy mockery and use them as a teaching tool: people who think themselves rational do not, as a rule, want to be associated - even in their own minds - with people who are absolutely foaming at the mouth to spew easily-debunked bullshit, and who get ridiculed as a result. Most of these bad actors do not possess a lot of self-control, and are easily riled up, or otherwise convinced to go mask off in a way that makes them unpalatable to the general population - say, by simply asking them to discuss their beliefs further - which makes this method very effective in limiting the spread of their memes.

TL;DR: "revealed"? I'm sorry?

mftrhu··on UK.gov to make adults give credit card details for access to Facebook or TikTok
> Increasing acceptance hasn't done anything positive for their depression rates, drug use rates, suicide rates, either.

Bold assertion. What are you basing it on, the PIDOOMA institute report?

> Trans culture, at least in part and mostly why it's slanted so far MtF is because autism affects men more than women and they internalized the porn differently in that they'd just tther be the women seen in the porn.

> Trans and Incel culture are two sides of the same coin Imho.

No, you just have no bloody idea what you are talking about, and are blindly parroting talking points that you decided sounded right: you started out with a falsehood, followed by a bunch of not even wrong assertions, throwing in a couple of articles - very loosely related to at most one of your assertions - to give them the appearance of respectability.

> Why do you think trans people call people bigots for not wanting to sleep with them.?

If you simply cannot control your need to engage in culture war bullshit - targeting an already extremely victimized minority to do so - could you kindly do so in a less boring manner?

mftrhu··on Is Nim a Transpiler?
It's meant to be used in print, and print has bleed. It's too thin, by far, when it is used on screen (or even modern laser printers): see https://www.levien.com/type/cmr/gain.html
mftrhu··on How did American “wokeness” jump from elite schools to everyday life?
It's funny, because when it came to women's suffrage and the later waves of feminism, people would write the exact same thing you did when referring to the patriarchy - willfully misunderstanding, or not even bothering to understand what was being talked about, to ridicule it as "too nebulous" to deal with, or some sort of conspiracy that people were deliberately participating to, in an attempt to dismiss it out of hand as an "attack" - and someone commented as much in this same thread.
mftrhu··on Study That Impregnated Male Rats Stirs Controversy
> That is just fucked up and things like GR are still pretty bonkers if you even understanding. Like a guy getting a hole that he has to dilate in order to keep open, and most descriptions of this kind of surgery they are disturbing even for the people that believe they want them...

Do you put lemon juice on your face often, or is it reserved for special occasions? We are not sitting around a campfire, so your spooky stories about minorities - which are totes real, guys, not inaccurate in the least! - seem a tad unnecessary.

On a completely unrelated note, I'd like to mention the - irrelevant! - fact that SRS - with all its complications, such as the initial maintenance necessary to train the muscles and avoid scarring - was first created, and is very much still used, for cis people.

mftrhu··on Lesser Known Terminal Editors
> troff - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troff

... why is troff on a list of terminal editors? It can format text for the terminal, sure - and it's quite versatile, as I discovered playing around with it - but it's as much of an editor as LaTeX or markdown.

That said, if I used to find new editors fascinating - http://www.texteditors.org/cgi-bin/wiki.pl - these days I just can't imagine leaving Emacs and my own customizations behind.

mftrhu··on The world needs nuclear power and we shouldn’t be afraid of it
> People say this, but I'll note that humans have lived through "crippling poverty" for most of our 2 million year existence. It is only crippling poverty by today's distortion lens (also a shifting baseline).

Humans have died through crippling poverty for most of our existence, and that baseline, however shifted, is still not enough to ensure that everyone - in both developing and developed countries - can have good health, good food, and shelter.

Sure, this is mostly due to inequal resource distribution, but I don't believe that the crisis caused by climate change will rectify that, at least by itself.

mftrhu··on Ask HN: How does WhatsApp make money?
> have you tried using WhatsApp without the Contacts permission?

Yes. It works. Reaching out to new people is a PITA, as you have to append their phone number to a an api.whatsapp.com/send?phone= URL and open that on your phone, but it works.

mftrhu··on Behavioral nudges reduce failure to appear for court
Ah, yes. An accelerated It Stands To Reason 101 course from the School Of Hard Knocks.
mftrhu··on Cellmate: Male chastity gadget hack could lock users in
Far enough that while people with an active sex life can use all sort of weird tools to engage in their fetishes, other [people] can try to justify their knee-jerk reactions by wanking about their evolutionary fitness.
mftrhu··on Elevated rates of autism in transgender and gender-diverse individuals
Indeed. There is a whole subreddit dedicated to documenting instances of people being arrested because of the travesty of justice that is Bill C16: check out https://reddit.com/r/ArrestedCanadaBillC16
mftrhu··on 11M households could be evicted over the next four months
> If you look at Italy, early on they realised there was a conflation going on, and so they did proper studies of some sample of COVID deaths to see why they really died. They concluded only 4% of the patients had no other medical conditions, and I recall reading (but don't have a link right now) that they concluded about 12% had really died of COVID. The rest all just happened to be infected when they died of something else, which would make sense given the first stat. So you can cut a digit off most of the reported death rates.

If you look at Italy, the recent ISTAT-ISS report (2020-07-16) showed the opposite: COVID-19 has been deemed directly responsible for the death of 89% of those who died testing positive for coronavirus ("morti per"), with the remaining 11% of deaths being caused by some other disease or pre-existing condition ("morti con").

Even excluding comorbidities such as diabetes and hypertension, which are very common, 18% to 28% of the deaths they analyzed were still directly caused by COVID. I'm not sure this can be brought down to 12% without being exceedingly selective (e.g., people aged 0-30 without hypertension, diabetes, respiratory problems... - I know I'm 27 and I wouldn't qualify).

> - Sono state analizzate le informazioni riportate dai medici in 4.942 schede di morte, di soggetti diagnosticati microbiologicamente con test positivo al SARS-CoV-2 (il 15,6% del totale dei decessi notificati al Sistema di Sorveglianza Integrata ISS fino al 25 maggio). Nelle schede di morte sono certificate, oltre a COVID-19, quelle condizioni e malattie che hanno avuto un ruolo nel determinare il decesso.

> - COVID-19 è la causa direttamente responsabile della morte nell’89% dei decessi di persone positive al test SARS-CoV-2, mentre per il restante 11% le cause di decesso sono le malattie cardiovascolari (4,6%), i tumori (2,4%), le malattie del sistema respiratorio (1%), il diabete (0,6%), le demenze e le malattie dell’apparato digerente (rispettivamente 0,6% e 0,5%).

> - La quota di deceduti in cui COVID-19 è la causa direttamente responsabile della morte varia in base all’età, raggiungendo il valore massimo del 92% nella classe 60-69 anni e il minimo (82%) nelle persone di età inferiore ai 50 anni.

> - COVID-19 è una malattia che può rivelarsi fatale anche in assenza di concause. Non ci sono infatti concause di morte preesistenti a COVID-19 nel 28,2% dei decessi analizzati, percentuale simile nei due sessi e nelle diverse classi di età. Solo nella classe di età 0-49 anni la percentuale di decessi senza concause è più bassa, pari al 18%.

Televideo source: http://www.televideo.rai.it/televideo/pub/view.jsp?id=888&p=...

ANSA source: https://www.ansa.it/canale_saluteebenessere/notizie/sanita/2...

The ISS-ISTAT report itself: https://www.istat.it/it/files/2020/07/Report_ISS_Istat_Cause...

mftrhu··on How and why I attempt to use Links as main browser
w3m supported tables and frames, but I'm pretty sure it never supported JS out of the box. There was an experimental w3m-js extension, but I don't think it ever saw much development: the most recent snapshot of that page [1] is from ~2010, and it links to patches from 2003.

Elinks supposedly had it, but you have to compile it in yourself and I'm not sure how it fares these days. Edbrowse has decent support for it, but its rendering is not meant for sighted people and rudimentary (e.g., no color, it doesn't bother with aligning table cells).

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20100504081232/http://abe.nwr.jp...

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →