HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mtalantikite

3,839 karma · joined February 11, 2009

submissionscomments
mtalantikite··on Writing down unfiltered thoughts enhances self-knowledge
> Very similar to meditation. The best meditation advice I got was to just sit down, focus on doing nothing and be OK with being bored.

Similarly, no matter how much instruction I've gotten in meditation over the years, I still go back to Tilopa's advice all the time [1]. Just rest.

[1] https://unfetteredmind.org/tilopas-advice/

mtalantikite··on Writing down unfiltered thoughts enhances self-knowledge
Not OP, but I went through the Artist's Way a while back and kept morning pages up for two or so years after it. I'd still probably do morning pages every day if I didn't move on to sitting at my piano in place of them (and would do both if I had time in the morning). So in that regard I think it was a success -- it got me back to having a healthy relationship with music making and artistic practice.

The content of the workbook at places doesn't totally resonate with me, but I'd say there's enough in there that it's worth trying out. It definitely asks you to confront and reflect on a lot of things that have happened in your life, so it can be uncomfortable and bring up a lot. But that's of course an important part of art making.

I'd say just try it out, it's only 12 weeks and you can always bail if it doesn't work for you!

mtalantikite··on Airbnb CEO: NYC hotels will get more expensive after short-term rental crackdown
I think you're both sort of right? NYC is dense for a US city, but not really so for a global city. We're sort of space constrained on an island like Manhattan -- since it's an island -- but much of the outer boroughs are 3 story buildings (with of course exceptions in places like downtown brooklyn, williamsburg, LIC, etc.) There are places in Manhattan we could build more high rise condos, but it's probably easier to focus on the outer boroughs. No one is going to bulldoze brownstone brooklyn, but if we even built more like Paris, which has a population density of almost 2x NYC without skyscraper condos, there certainly would be a huge amount of extra capacity.

I'm not a big fan of what happened to my neighborhood (Williamsburg) with all the giant condo buildings that have gone up over the past decade or so, but people do need places to live and we probably should be growing denser across the entire city. There's definitely a lot of space left, just not a lot of will to change things.

mtalantikite··on Nobel Prize in Medicine awarded to Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman
Absolutely, and this is more along what I was asking. What about their discovery was deemed the most important part out of this long chain of work that led up to mRNA vaccination and this Nobel? Nature's news section had a history of discoveries a while back [1], and it seems like there is a lot of disagreement about who deserves what credit.

Personally, it seems like everyone's contribution is important, but we as humans irrationally want to point to a single thing/event/team and say "this was the cause" rather than stand back and notice how interdependent the whole thing is. In the end I think things like Nobels are pretty silly.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02483-w

mtalantikite··on Nobel Prize in Medicine awarded to Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman
No disrespect meant. However, I don't think it's a simple question.
mtalantikite··on Nobel Prize in Medicine awarded to Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman
Well yes, clearly -- 2005 is before 2008. But it's interesting to see who gets selected when so many other researchers end up being involved with these major technologies before and after a single paper.
mtalantikite··on Nobel Prize in Medicine awarded to Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman
For those that know more than I do, out of curiosity, why would this Nobel go to these two and not also Özlem Türeci and Uğur Şahin? The four of them shared earlier awards, and it was Özlem Türeci and Uğur Şahin's BioNTech that got the vaccine to market (after their decades of research).

The couple are billionaires, so I'm sure they're doing just fine, but that's gotta hurt to be overlooked for such a major prize when they did so much for that discovery and technology.

mtalantikite··on The Philips Hue ecosystem is collapsing
The Duane Reade near me always had them. Bodegas. Smaller grocery stores. I don't know, they never were hard to find here in NYC until a few months ago.
mtalantikite··on The Philips Hue ecosystem is collapsing
Somewhat off topic, but I bought a Philips Hue system for my house in August since the incandescent ban has made it difficult to find light bulbs. I spent some time getting the colors close to matching my incandescents with a light meter, set up some automations, etc. I could definitely tell they were LEDs (I think their R9 values are low), but they seemed... ok? I don't know, I still wasn't really loving it, but they were better than some other LEDs I had tried in the past. And some of the automations seemed legitimately useful.

Well, I got 4 ocular migraines in less than 3 days. Packed them all up and sent them back. If anyone has recommendations for LEDs that don't trigger migraines let me know. Or else I guess I'm buying a lifetime supply of incandescents and a storage unit for lightbulbs /s.

Honestly, the whole thing sort of seems like focusing on the wrong things. I've never owned a car, am vegetarian, have never lived in more than 1000 sq ft as an adult, and walk/take public transit in NYC daily. Not sure the 2 incandescent lightbulbs I use in my living room are really causing climate change.

mtalantikite··on “Stop Making Sense” is having a theatrical rerelease
Yeah, that's fair. I personally am not a fan of The Band and the only guest of theirs I listen to is Muddy Waters (and maybe Joni Mitchell), so I guess the historicity of it is lost to me. I do know people love the whole thing though -- a friend of mine MD'd a complete tribute show in SF years ago with a bunch of great musicians -- so maybe the whole thing hits different for fans of that sort of music.
mtalantikite··on “Stop Making Sense” is having a theatrical rerelease
> Not mentioning The Last Waltz is pretty unpardonable. But this IS a great movie, and so is that.

It's probably been 20 years since I've seen it, but isn't The Last Waltz a pretty straightforward recording of a concert? Stop Making Sense might seem like just a concert film, but I think the author's point is that it's quite unlike pretty much everything else in the category.

I saw David Byrne present Stop Making Sense at Metrograph here in NYC in 2017 and he gave a lot of insights on the making of it. One major one is that they filmed from a different camera angle on each of the three nights and put the concert together in post. So one night was from stage left, another night stage right, another straight on -- he didn't want you to see camera's in the background at all unless it was intentional (the article mentions it was filmed over three nights, but not this intentional framing).

He mentioned something about wanting the audience to see how the Talking Heads put together the band and a show over time, which is why he chose to build it up from that solo guitar moment up through Bernie Worrell (!) and the rest of the musicians walking on stage. He said he always had anxiety performing and would collapse back stage once it was over at first, but finally got comfortable with that front man role as time went on.

He also felt that Talking Heads were at the height of their powers (his words) and wanted to capture it, but couldn't get funding for a film and had to personally put up the money for it.

As for the "big suit", he said no one in the band knew it was happening and everyone sort of lost it when he walked on stage in it the first night.

Edit: One thing I forgot, Jonathan Demme gets mentioned all the time when talking about the film, but people forget that Jordan Cronenweth did the cinematography and had recently come off of doing Blade Runner.

mtalantikite··on Lead poisoning causes more death, IQ loss than thought: study
I swear that living in NYC for nearly two decades has made me incapable of making a grocery list and shopping like pretty much everyone else in the country (only slightly kidding). I just walk down the street and grab what I need.

I did just miss the 6 train by 15 seconds and am standing on the platform as I write this, which I guess is annoying? I’ll take it over driving in traffic though.

mtalantikite··on France prepares to ban vegetarian products from using meaty language
I personally agree with you -- as a vegetarian I'd rather eat a great black bean burger than some highly processed industrial fake meat product -- but I don't think plant based meats are going anywhere. Most people have no problem eating highly processed foods, and a lot even want that texture and flavor. People are out here drinking oat-flavored canola oil, and paying extra for it, after all.
mtalantikite··on New plant-based pork ribs to feature edible vegan bones
I’ve had the same problem with most veggie burgers, but found a recipe years ago that really holds up. It’s a Jamaican Ital recipe: https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2005/05/26/bean-burgers-jamaica...

Coincidentally I just got back from Jamaica a few days ago, and as a vegetarian I always try to find the Rasta spot as soon as I can as they’re usually the ones with the best veg food. I was thinking of these burgers and now here we are — I guess I should make a batch this weekend!

mtalantikite··on Launch HN: Stellar Sleep (YC S23) – An app that helps people with insomnia
Do you have any links to the research behind these CBT-I interventions? I'm curious what treatment looks like. I had never considered that I may have insomnia until just now, as I fall asleep fast and usually only wake up once during the night. However, I often wake up groggy and not feeling refreshed. I started tracking my sleep a couple months ago with a series 8 Apple Watch and consistently see only 20-45 minutes in a "deep sleep" phase.

I'd totally pay for this if it's something that might work, but honestly am skeptical about it working for my particular sort of sleep pattern. Congrats on the launch!

mtalantikite··on Oregon decriminalized hard drugs – early results aren’t encouraging
> People don't even bother getting it on the black market anymore where it is legal.

The unlicensed weed bodegas popping up on every other block in NYC beg to differ. People might not text a delivery service anymore, but they're definitely not going to legal recreational dispensaries here in NYC.

mtalantikite··on If we want a shift to walking we need to prioritize dignity
> I will never forget the sight of him carrying something heavy up those stairs...

Oh man, absolutely. I still have a vivid memory of moving out of a 5 floor walk-up with a narrow stairwell and as I was walking back into the building out comes the guy bear hugging my Fender Rhodes electric piano. It's gotta be around 150 pounds and very bulky. He was walking like it was nothing.

mtalantikite··on If we want a shift to walking we need to prioritize dignity
> And what if it was 100F, or 32F, or raining, or I didn't want to go for a walk, or I needed to get some large items like sugar or rice or a gallon of milk or a lot of beer for a party?

As a New Yorker, you just described daily life here? It’s really not a big deal — things are so close you can take multiple trips if you need to. Get some canvas bags. Plus since everything is so close you end up just doing smaller trips every day or so. If the shop is longer than 10-15 minutes and I’ve got more than, say, 40 pounds of groceries I might get a car back home, but that’s a rare trip. And honestly I’ll probably just walk it back anyway.

Maybe we just have a higher tolerance for pain here — I’ve certainly had people visit who think of themselves as fit and they get gassed out by regular New York walking life.

mtalantikite··on Environmental Discs of Tron Roadside Pickup
Absolutely. When I was in college (early 2000s) I found someone selling a Hammond A-100 in great condition for $400. It was her grandmother's who had recently passed, so they were trying to clear out the house. She had a really nice Wurlitzer baby grand piano for a similar price, but my college apartment definitely couldn't fit that thing.
mtalantikite··on Unesco calls for global ban on smartphones in schools
Very much unclear why I got down-voted for a pretty uncontroversial comment? I guess people didn't like that I took the train as a kid in the 90s before smartphones?
mtalantikite··on Unesco calls for global ban on smartphones in schools
Of course, all the time. I didn't grow up in NYC, but all my friends that went to school here took the subway or bus to middle or high school on their own. I've been in the city for a decent amount of time now (16-ish years) and I've always seen lots of young kids on public transit after school lets out.

I grew up just outside of Boston and my parents let me take the commuter rail to north station and the T over to Cambridge with friends as an early teenager. It never felt like a big deal, you just learned to read a subway map and a train time table. If you got lost you asked for directions.

mtalantikite··on Bruce Lee and Me
For sure, they definitely feed into each other. The yoga practice got me to put that meditation practice into my body in a different way, as did the Muay Thai. Plus the physical practice opened and strengthened my body so I could sit comfortably in lotus for long periods of time. Before that my hips were tight and the first few years of daily seated practice were uncomfortable. I rarely if ever exercised previously.

Anyway, getting the meditation practice off of the cushion was what the physical practices taught me. It's like the story of the arrow making dakini [1], you've got to have the practice in all actions you take.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saraha#The_Arrow_Making_Dakini

mtalantikite··on Bruce Lee and Me
I watched it at home, so I didn't walk out technically, but I also turned off "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood". The only movies I've physically walked out of have been "The Departed" and "Tree of Life". I don't think it's a big deal to bail on something you're not enjoying, but have given a best effort to get into.
mtalantikite··on Bruce Lee and Me
When I started training Muay Thai a little over a year ago the first thing that struck me was how kind everyone was in the gym. There's something about training that hard that really starts to remove the ego. I've had a long standing, daily seated meditation practice, and it wasn't until I started training my body hard (first ashtanga style yoga, now muay thai) that the meditation practice really started to deepen.
mtalantikite··on Tuition costs have risen 710% since 1983
They didn't want an educated, unemployed proletariat (their words, not mine): https://theintercept.com/2022/08/25/student-loans-debt-reaga...
mtalantikite··on Escaping High School
Oh, absolutely. I'm not saying that a professional musician at a major symphony doesn't know about theory -- this guy I took out was clearly very accomplished in his field and went to conservatory for it. Even the classical education I had up through high school included harmony and chords. But there is a difference between knowing the theory from a technical perspective to be tested on, and completely embodying it and using it to make music. Here's a recent video of my friend's group playing [1] -- everyone involved has a world-class level of understanding of theory, but uses it to improvise, not just to read sheets.

And let's not forget that a lot of 'classical' musicians back in the day were expected to be able to improvise as well. There's just a different priority for a 'classical' performer these days and a 'jazz' performer.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_BE_gi4YkA

mtalantikite··on Escaping High School
> I got to a pretty good technical competence with my trumpet but at the end of the day I could only play what was on the sheets.

This is pretty much how music is taught to all students learning 'classical' and was my experience as well. Most never really learn anything about music at a fundamental level, and can even have an entire career in the classical world not really knowing anything about what's going on in the music. Random story, but one night here in NYC I got asked by someone to bring out a visiting musician from Spain to hear some music, who had been playing in a major symphony there since the 80s (can't remember if it was Barcelona Symphony or Spanish National Orchestra). Brought him to Smalls in the West Village to catch whoever was playing that night. He was really impressed, kept on leaning over asking "how is that piano player doing that with no sheet music???". It's just not part of a regular classical musician's training, unless they're working to be a composer as well.

But back to your point, I felt the same way with music in my schools growing up. No one ever taught you how to actually play music, they just gave you sheet music and said "play this". It wasn't until much later that I started working with a jazz teacher privately that I got introduced to all the chords, scales/modes, and theories that'd you need to improvise or play music with others. Honestly, I probably would have been better off in high school if someone had told me to drop music classes altogether, handed me a bass or guitar or synth, and said go have fun with a few friends in a garage.

mtalantikite··on Get a personal teacher
I think one of the issues is that there can be a significant gap in the level of teachers that you encounter. There are tons of teachers out there that are probably not much better, and maybe even worse, than going through people on YouTube, personal websites, online courses, etc. But then there are the truly masterful teachers in which the experience is on a whole different level, where the learning is beyond what you could do on your own. It's more on the level of a traditional guru, in the original sense of the word [1].

I've had both experiences, and I agree, in most cases a private teacher might not be worth it, but if you find the right person, it'll bring you way further than you ever could have gone on your own.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guru

mtalantikite··on Fanon versus Canon
Haha, no, I read a lot of his work as a teenager as well as in college. I'm Algerian (Kabyle) and Fanon lived in my father's home city for a while. His work was very important in the decolonization movements and you'll encounter his writing all over classes in political economy, afro-am, marxism, etc.
mtalantikite··on Fanon versus Canon
And here I was thinking it was going to be about Fanon [1] versus the canonical political/social theories of his time.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frantz_Fanon

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →