HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neartheplain

2,334 karma · joined December 17, 2020

submissionscomments
neartheplain··on The Most Dangerous Censorship
The Senate's comprehensive report on the Capitol attack [0], released earlier this month, appears to exonerate Trump in deployment of the National Guard. In fact, his acting Secretary of Defense (to whom deployment authorization was delegated) suggested locking down DC ahead of time, but city officials demurred.

>Mainly since White Americans are still the majority and by and large supporters of the right, I don't see movements like BLM gaining much power.

You'd be surprised. Most violent actors who call themselves antifa are white, especially in the Pacific Northwest [1]. During last summer's Portland courthouse siege, a white BLM/antifa rioter stabbed a black Trump supporter in the stomach [2]. This stabbing wasn't reported in outlets like NPR or the Washington Post, even as they praised rioters and criticized the police response.

[0] https://www.rules.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Jan%206%20HSGAC%2...

[1] https://twitter.com/AntifaWatch2/status/1302964750817652739

[2] https://heavy.com/news/2020/07/blake-hampe/

neartheplain··on The Most Dangerous Censorship
I encourage you to read the Senate's comprehensive report on the Capitol attack, released earlier this month:

https://www.rules.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Jan%206%20HSGAC%2...

There was incompetence and miscommunication at every level of the multi-agency, multi-layer bureaucracy in charge of protecting the Capitol. For example: "In at least once instance, USCP protective shields were locked in a bus during the riot so that a CDU platoon was unable to access them, and as a result, the platoon was required to respond to the crowd without the protection of their riot shields." Worse: "USCP officers, for example, were given defective riot shields that had been improperly stored and, as a result, shatter[ed] upon impact."

Planners thought the Jan. 6 rally would "be similar to the previous Million MAGA March rallies" in which participants stayed in the designated areas, and violence was only provoked by counter-protestors. Given attendees' vocal support for police and years of prior peaceful rally behavior, I understand their assumption. In hindsight they were clearly mistaken, and their lack of preparation for every contingency was inexcusable.

The report describes general incompetence, complacency, and failures of communication. It does not describe favoritism or cooperation with the far-right. It does not show that Trump or his subordinates obstructed the National Guard deployment. In fact, on Jan. 4 call with DC officials, acting Secretary of Defense Miller "suggested locking down D.C. to avoid potential violence; however, the idea was not pursued." The Guard was only requested to provide aid at the Capitol at the last minute.

neartheplain··on Google turned me into a serial killer
Can users tell when info box answers have been auto-generated vs. curated? How often is KG content updated or re-verified, as in the case of businesses changing their operating hours? Are KG verifiers subject matter experts, e.g. medical professionals, or unskilled workers?
neartheplain··on Google turned me into a serial killer
Even if 90% of businesses play along (doing Google's data entry work for them), the 10% chance of my wasting half an hour makes it worth ignoring the info box and double-checking each time.
neartheplain··on A backlash against gender ideology is starting in universities
If higher-quality statistics are available, I'd certainly be curious to see them.
neartheplain··on Canada: Hundreds of unmarked graves found at residential school
I had no idea these schools still existed in the US. Based on your comment, I looked up this article:

https://www.wyomingpublicmedia.org/open-spaces/2016-02-26/to...

This particular school isn't operated by a church, but by the Bureau of Indian Education (which I also didn't know still existed) and the US Department of the Interior. Sounds like the school has evolved significantly from when it was first established in 1892:

>Things have changed a lot at Sherman in Doepner’s lifetime. He says a Navajo woman who went there in the 1960s and was forbidden from speaking her language now teaches that language at Sherman. “I believe that those efforts over the past 35 or 40 years have helped transform the nature of what [Bureau of Indian Education] schools have tried to do which is to celebrate the culture of the students, of their families, of their ancestors,” Doepner says.

>Some Wyoming students who’ve attended Sherman agree. “They have a beading class,” says Scottie Nez, a junior at Fort Washakie High School who spent his first two years at Sherman. “And pottery—ceramics class. They have a basket-weaving class. And they have a Navajo language class.”

Of interest in relation to the original link, this school also has a dedicated cemetery:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Indian_High_School#She...

>Because of Bureau of Indian Affairs policies, students did not return home for several years. Those who died were often buried in the school cemetery. May 3 marks an old tradition amongst the local tribes where many local reservations decorate their cemeteries with flowers and replace old crosses. Sherman Indian High School designates this as Indian Flower Day.

neartheplain··on The Most Dangerous Censorship
(Considered not replying, but then looked again at the link title...)

The view of law enforcement as going easy on the far-right may have been true in 1970s America, but it does not appear so 2021. Far-right militia movements have been subject to intense scrutiny and violence (and some allege, entrapment) since their growth in the 1990s [0][1]. In the case of the Capitol riot, 525 people have now been federally charged [2]. Arrested rioters have been "savagely beaten" in jail by prison guards, to the point of skull fractures and permanent blindness [3].

It's true that fringe Congressional Republicans such as Josh Hawley or Marjorie Taylor Greene have tried to blame antifa for the Capitol insurrection. They hold no powerful Senate or House positions, and appear "prominent" mainly due to the attention the the press gives them. The actual Republican Congressional leadership swiftly denounced the insurrection, and placed blame for the attack on President Trump [4][5].

In contrast, President Biden and prominent Senators such as Jerry Nadler have repeatedly denied the existence of organized far-left violence at all [6][7], describing events such as the month-long nightly siege of the federal courthouse in Portland "a myth" and "imaginary." Speaker Nancy Pelosi has acknowledged antifa gangs' existence in the past, after they vandalized her house and sprayed it with pig blood.

As rioters threw Molotov cocktails and firebombs at the federal courthouse in Portland, attacked federal agents with hammers, lasers, and bricks, beat and stabbed journalists, set fire to the Mayor's condo building, and were arrested carrying illegal firearms, the Washington Post gave them a glowing photo shoot [8]. They were praised as morally virtuous freedom-fighters. In Seattle, anarchists occupied several city blocks for weeks with assault rifles, and shot dead an unarmed black child [9] before destroying the evidence and concealing the killer's identity. These stories disappeared from the Washington Post, NPR, and even Fox News within days, yet we still get frequent updates on the Capitol insurrection.

Finally, it makes no difference whether cops arrest more left-wing rioters if the local DA and US Attorney decide to release them and dismiss all charges [10][11]. There's been little such leniency applied to violent actors in the Capitol insurrection. This has not gone unnoticed by either the far-right or far-left.

The exasperation I feel watching this unfold as someone on the center-left is a shadow of what I sense from the actual right wing. I think anger at the leniency given to far-left violence last summer is what propelled a lot of people to attack the Capitol, in a "if they can get away with it, why can't we?" sort of tantrum. This emotional potential still remains. The risk of an eventual organized right-wing backlash, which so far has not reached the level of burning down buildings, executing people in the street, or occupying city blocks with armed militants, is what worries me most about the chance of more far-left violence. The extreme right is watching the extreme left get away with it, and they are taking notes.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25839889

[1] https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2021/06/07/w...

[2] https://www.insider.com/all-the-us-capitol-pro-trump-riot-ar...

[3] https://www.politico.com/news/2021/04/06/capitol-riot-defend...

[4] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/mitch-mcconnell-blam...

[5] https://www.newsweek.com/kevin-mccarthy-tells-gop-stop-claim...

[6] https://townhall.com/tipsheet/leahbarkoukis/2020/07/27/nadle...

[7] https://news.yahoo.com/biden-says-antifa-idea-not-025049929....

[8] https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/08/08/trump-sent-...

[9] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25671284

[10] https://www.wweek.com/news/courts/2020/08/11/district-attorn...

[11] https://www.kgw.com/article/news/investigations/portland-pro...

neartheplain··on A backlash against gender ideology is starting in universities
They cited a wide body of studies, including studies which included only trans kids. All studies produced consistent results. For those who didn't read the full article, here's the preamble to the 80% figure quoted above:

>There have, however, been almost a dozen studies of looking at the rate of "desistance," among trans-identified kids—which, in this context, refers to cases in which trans kids eventually identify as their sex at birth. Canadian sex researcher James Cantor summarized those studies' findings in a blog post: "Despite the differences in country, culture, decade, and follow-up length and method, all the studies have come to a remarkably similar conclusion: Only very few trans-kids still want to transition by the time they are adults. Instead, they generally turn out to be regular gay or lesbian folks." The exact rate of desistance varied by study, but overall, they concluded that about 80 percent trans kids eventually identified as their sex at birth.

neartheplain··on A backlash against gender ideology is starting in universities
Here are the numbers:

In 2019, the most recent year for which the FBI has data, the total US homicide rate was 4.3 deaths per 100,000 people [0] (possible underestimate; incident reporting is voluntary, and 25% of police departments don't submit expanded homicide data). Human Rights Campaign recorded the deaths of 25 transgender and gender non-conforming people in 2019 [1]. There are an estimated 1 million people who identify as transgender in the US [2], and an estimated 1.2 million people who identify as nonbinary or gender non-conforming [3]. That produces a US trans and nonbinary homicide rate for 2019 of 1.1 per 100,000.

Of all homicides reported by HRC with transgender or gender non-confirming victims in 2019, just one was determined to involve a clear anti-LGBT motive. HRC's data may be an underestimate. However, it is consistent with their estimated homicide rates and rate of hate crimes reported in other years.

Any murder is a tragedy, hate crimes all the moreso. However, a single-digit number of annual anti-trans and nonbinary murders is thankfully not an epidemic. The overall homicide rate for trans people seems much lower than the national average.

Notably this data excludes assaults, harassment, stalking, or any other attacks which don't result in fatalities.

[0] https://crime-data-explorer.app.cloud.gov/pages/explorer/cri...

[1] https://www.hrc.org/resources/a-national-epidemic-fatal-anti...

[2] https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/group/gender/transgender/index.html

[3] https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/nonbinar...

neartheplain··on A backlash against gender ideology is starting in universities
Studies have consistently shown that most trans children revert to their original gender identity post-puberty [0]:

>The exact rate of desistance varied by study, but overall, they concluded that about 80 percent trans kids eventually identified as their sex at birth. Some trans activists and academics, however, argue that these studies are flawed, the patients surveyed weren't really transgender, and that mass desistance doesn't exist.

>Indeed, some of the studies cited by Cantor had sample sizes as low as 16 people and were more than 40 years old, and one was an unpublished doctoral dissertation. But the most recent study, published in 2013 in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, followed up with 127 adolescent patients at a gender identity clinic in Amsterdam and found that two-thirds ultimately identified as the gender they were assigned at birth.

This does not imply any percentage of patients who underwent surgery to "restore" their original sex. Orchiectomies, mastectomies, and histerectomies are irreversible in any case, not to mention bottom surgery.

[0] https://www.thestranger.com/features/2017/06/28/25252342/the...

neartheplain··on “Older unlisted videos will be made private unless you opt out”
YouTube link (not unlisted):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAHzP4umE4M

neartheplain··on A backlash against gender ideology is starting in universities
>Note, some number of people identifying as gay later chose to identify as straight. Is this a counter argument to gay people being a reality? Does that illustrate the problem with your point?

You have misunderstood my point. It was directed specifically at this statement:

>And whatever it's point of origin, this reality for these isn't going to change.

For some, but not all, trans people this reality does change. They exist, and they also deserve empathy and support.

neartheplain··on Is education no longer the ‘great equalizer’?
Interesting to see this on the front page right next to "Software Developer Shortage Is Coming":

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27606393

Can't speak to other forms of higher education, but my degree in computer science has more than paid for itself and acted as my ladder to the upper-middle class.

neartheplain··on The Most Dangerous Censorship
Personally, I fear mob violence commited with the sanction and cooperation of the state and news media. That's the sort of violence which starts, keeps going, and doesn't stop until it literally burns itself out.

In general, organized violence ends when 1) law enforcement takes decisive action to detain the perpetrators, and 2) organizers think the violence no longer serves their political goals. Both 1) and 2) were true of the Capitol insurrection, which was universally condemned and whose perpetrators were swiftly rounded up. Neither were especially true of the far-left anarchist uprisings, particularly in cities like Portland where permissive DAs let the same rioters out literally within hours of their arrest, while NPR and the Washington Post praised those who threw firebombs at courthouses and police stations. So, I expect less of the former and more of the latter.

neartheplain··on Say Goodbye to the American Dream
Blog post without new ideas or analysis. The closest thing it has to actual data is a (unlinked, plain-text) list of pop history books, dumped on the reader without summary or context. Overuses dramatic spacing every third paragraph. Lumps all higher education into a single category. Fails to interrogate the problems presented or to suggest solutions, beside "vote, educate ourselves and others, and stop spreading lies." Overall, disappointing and a waste of time.
neartheplain··on A History of The Rochester, NY Camera and Lens Companies (1974)
UW Madison has a 1MW research reactor: https://reactor.engr.wisc.edu/
neartheplain··on Turn your old, cracked Android phone into a backup server
Yes, for actual backups I have M-DISC BluRays [0] which I keep in a fireproof box. They're limited in capacity compared to the full NAS, but big enough for really important stuff like photos and scanned documents (which conveniently are intrinsically write-once).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-DISC

neartheplain··on Turn your old, cracked Android phone into a backup server
To me, a real NAS box means:

- ECC RAM, to avoid corruption on write

- Software RAID, to avoid data loss due to drive failure

- Some kind of checksumming and error-correcting filesystem, e.g. ZFS, to prevent data loss due to bad sectors

- Enough CPU to transcode media in real-time

- Vanilla distro with SSH, SMB filesharing, Plex, and networked printing

- A spare PSU in the closet

I explicitly avoid:

- Hardware RAID (unnecessary, expensive, harder to fix)

- Any OEM prebuilt NAS products (more expensive, less capable, less user control)

- Any specialty NAS-oriented distros or OSes (more feature bloat, bigger attack surfaces)

I use plain old Debian for my home NAS. I'd switch to OpenBSD in a heartbeat if it supported a checksumming and error-correcting filesystem.

neartheplain··on Unitree’s Go1 Robot Dog Looks Pretty Great, Costs Just $2700
Knightscope has tried to deliver this (security guard mobile robot) for years, with decidedly mixed results:

>In December 2017, the San Francisco SPCA rented a Knightscope K5 robot to patrol the area next to their animal shelter, including the public sidewalk, to deter vandalism. The SPCA received complaints about using a robot on a public sidewalk where homeless people were encamped, and the robot was covered with a tarpaulin and smeared with barbecue sauce; the SPCA discontinued the contract.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knightscope

neartheplain··on Life as a public school teacher in the San Francisco Bay Area in 2021
That's part of what makes "Asian schools" interesting. Many Asian American students at high-performing US public schools come from solidly middle and working-class backgrounds. Their parents simply chose to invest every cent in their child's education, sometimes at great personal financial risk. Anecdotally, I know one Korean American couple of extremely modest means who took out a second mortage just to get their oldest through undergrad.

To a significant extent, Asian American parents and students have shown that merit-based admissions _do_ work as a socioeconomic equalizer (see above Atlantic article). The problem as I see it is how to replicate this success among other demographics, including white Americans of middle and working-class backgrounds. Another part of the solution in my view is just making more magnet schools.

neartheplain··on Life as a public school teacher in the San Francisco Bay Area in 2021
There are many good reasons to de-racialize the discussion around US public education. One is that the "white school" trope is increasingly out of date. Instead, we've begun to see "Asian schools" wherever high-performing public high school schools admit students based on standardized testing. The top-ranked high school in the entire US, Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology, is 65% Asian and 23% white in a county that is 17% Asian and 62% white [0][1]. Stuyvesant High School in New York City, another high-performing public magnet school, is 74% Asian while Asian residents make up just 14% of the city's population [2][3].

In my view, there's a degree to which such lopsided admissions represent a greater Asian American cultural emphasis on education (good) coupled with a marginal standardized test score advantage produced by many hours of after-school test prep (bad). As repeated studies have shown, the advantage of e.g. SAT test prep courses is consistently relatively small, but enough of an edge to matter when you're looking at a ~10% admissions rate [2][4]. Not all applicants have parents who can afford or are aware of the value of such test prep, so it represents an uneven advantage. Crucially, this advantage is not inherently racial, but rather an artifact of culture, parental choice, and socioeconomic background. To mitigate this uneven advantage without completely eliminating merit-based admissions, a blurring filter e.g. random lottery might be applied to the top X% of test scorers.

And there is absolutely value in merit-based admissions. It makes these magnet schools what they are [5]. Despite their distorted demographics, it's what enables schools like Stuyvesant to still function as effective ladders out of poverty for many students:

>What makes these schools so good? The general consensus is the academic rigor. But what’s come out clearly in our interviews with Stuyvesant graduates is something arguably more important: a peer-driven expectation of achievement. What Stuyvesant does is take 3,000 pretty bright kids and put them in a building together. Then magical things happen. They push each other, they strive to be like each other, they learn from each other.

>Nearly all of these kids went to college, often selective ones, and most went on to do well professionally. The poorer students became middle or upper-middle class, and the middle-class students often did better than their parents. And they were happy—most (though not all) felt that Stuyvesant had had a big effect on their lives. For instance, Elizabeth Reid Yee, a white 1985 graduate who grew up poor in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, fully credits Stuyvesant with keeping her from a life of poverty.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Jefferson_High_School_f...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairfax_County,_Virginia

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuyvesant_High_School

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_New_York_City

[4] https://www.thoughtco.com/are-sat-prep-courses-worth-the-cos...

[5] https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2018/06/new-yo...

neartheplain··on A Hole in the Head: A History of Trepanation
Fascinating Wikipedia rabbit-hole, although I laughed out loud at the oddity of this sentence [0]:

>Feilding learned about the ancient practice of trepanation from Bart Huges, whom she met in 1966, and who published a scroll on the topic.

Curious as to the details of scrolls as a modern publishing medium. The source link is broken, so I guess I'll never know.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amanda_Feilding#Trepanation

neartheplain··on Kids need freedom, too
I also grew up in a midsized Midwestern city, and had the same (wonderful) childhood experience. Biked to school, parks and playgrounds, the YMCA, local diner, you name it. This was in the 1990s and early 2000s, so I doubt much has changed.
neartheplain··on Facebook will start putting ads in Oculus Quest apps
100% anecdotal, but: my elderly mother can't watch kids play console games on TV without rapidly experiencing motion sickness. She does just fine in VR (mini-golf is her favorite game on the Quest).

I'd love to see actual data on the issue. Until then, I'm optimistic that VR's floor of non-acclimatable users is similar to or smaller than the same for regular video game consoles.

neartheplain··on Facebook will start putting ads in Oculus Quest apps
>I think people underestimate how fragile this technology space is; we're talking a system that only a percentage of the population can use without experiencing motion sickness

FWIW the Quest and Index have largely solved this problem. There are still certain experiences in VR which require more motion-sickness acclimation, such as roller coasters or fast-moving shooters. However, 1:1 motion experiences no longer cause problems for even the most sensitive players, in my experience.

I've demoed current VR hardware to highly sensitive friends and family members without issue. The same friends and family couldn't tolerate earlier generations of VR for more than a few minutes.

neartheplain··on Facebook will start putting ads in Oculus Quest apps
It's currently impossible to tell how Facebook has damaged the Oculus brand, simply due to the lack of a credible mobile (aka "untethered") VR competitor. Once someone like Valve, HTC, Sony, or Apple finally release untethered hardware at a competitive price point, we'll see whether customers are really willing to tolerate forced Facebok account integration and ads in VR.

Personally, I absolutely love the Quest's price point, form factor, and overall software quality. At the same time, I despise Oculus as a brand and Facebook as a company for all of the above. I'm prepared to jump ship the split second an alternative is available.

neartheplain··on Britain’s destruction and concealment of colonial records (2017)
Some papers were sent back to Britain for safekeeping, per the article. Speculatively, perhaps someone who was there could also tell us what was burnt in more detail.
neartheplain··on Britain’s destruction and concealment of colonial records (2017)
Any newer studies with examples of some of the concealed records? This one is frustratingly vague on the details.
neartheplain··on If you sell a house these days, the buyer might be a pension fund
States with this amount of obstructive ossification, such as the Byzantine Empire or Austria-Hungary, don't generally stand the test of time. Just before Austria-Hungary's collapse following WWI, the collection of taxes in Dalmatia (now Croatia) cost twice as much as it raised [0]. We still use the word Byzantine today to describe systems that are "complicated, secret and difficult to change" [1].

I don't know what this could mean at the city or county level. Keep an eye out for wayward Sultans and Allied powers?

[0] https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-and-late-austrian-empire

[1] https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/englis...

neartheplain··on The History of Nuclear Secrecy in the U.S.
If we're talking about devices with megaton or hundred-kiloton yields, accuracy isn't super important. And simpler, unminiaturized weapons are probably going to be bomber-dropped anyway.
← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →