HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nickolai

1,833 karma · joined November 23, 2010

submissionscomments
nickolai··on Introducing the HUD. Say hello to the future of the menu
I may have missed it, but have they actuelly had real users(i.e. not ui designers) do some usability testing (i.e. actual real work) on this? Coming up with it an pushing it into a public release in 4 months looks risky to me. Given how frustrated some users were with Unity, I really hope they learned the lesson.

This as presented this has a very high risk of turning into a "guess what the designers were thinking" game. While very flattering to the designer, it is frustrating as hell to the user. Arguably the current interfaces offer pretty much the same issue : a "guess in which menu I put the option" game - however there is one crucial difference : we got used to the current one, and actually have a really good idea how the designers were thinking - and where they put that option.

EDIT : Right. I did miss that. Thanks.

nickolai··on The New French Hacker-Artist Underground
Not that kind of UX. In this article UX stands for 'Urban eXperiment', not user experience. Have a look at it it is an interesting read.
nickolai··on Transparent Aluminum
> So in reality this is a modest improvement (2x) over existing laminated glass armour

More than 2x actually - the guy behind the glass would be dead, unlike the one behind their improved glass. I'd say this is a significant difference - they deserve some extra credit for keeping the guy behind their armor alive.

I do find the title a little misleading though, since this has nothing to do with metallic aluminum as one would expect from reading the title.

nickolai··on Duck Programming
One of the ways ive seen these systems born is when the user requirements are ill-defined.

"Okay so you are not sure - you may need either foo or bar, so we will put this little foo-to-bar knob here so you can tune it just as you like, however you like, whenever you like". Neither of the parties involved in the project definition can be bothered to figure out what actually has to be done, and next thing you know you end up with an overpriced-overengineered specialized turing complete language interpreter that has the customer do all the actual work implementing the business logic.

My theory is that this often stems from a communication issue. And some laziness.

nickolai··on The "C is Efficient" Language Fallacy (2006)
Umm, yes C/C++ will not parallelize your code for you, whereas Language XYZ will. Im not sure how this is an argument against C/C++ being effective. C/C++ will not parallelize your code by design. It's was never meant to. I'd never blame my stick-shift car for not changing gears by itself - thats the first reason I didnt buy an automatic in the first place!

If your matrix manupuilation code performance becomes an issue, you, the C/C++ coder will have to parallelize it and take responsibility for whatever assumptions have to be made.

Im sure that the limit of what one considers as acceptable code alteration by the compiler/interpreter depends on the person. Personally I'd be very wary of a system trying to guess-parallelize my code - especially if I can do it myself whenever I see fit by adding a dozen boilerplate code lines. I'm sure most academics needing a numerical calculus system would be glad to have the system abstract away every possible optimization, so that they can stay as much as possible in the 'abstract math space'.

I am also kind of wary of the "look, I wrote the program in several languages and here is the perf comparison". Our skills with each language vary. What I liked was (i cant seem to find the link) a teacher who asked his class to write a program doing some text manipulation/indexing (iirc) in whatever language they wanted. The fastest code was in C, yet the worst C implementation was significantly slower than an average java code. To sum all this up - the speed depends on the skill of the person in the particular language, much more than on the language itself.

nickolai··on Web Giants Consider 'Nuclear Option' Blackout to Fight SOPA
I dont like the term "nuclear option". The fact that there is no "mutually assured destruction" if they follow-up with this makes this so called "nuclear option" much less scary. Besides it is never been done before, so no one even knows what would be the result.

Saying "Please stand by for a demonstration of relevancy" and doing it would be way more effective

Speaking of "nuclear options", one of the reasons the bombs were dropped on japan in WW2 instead of just sending an "or else!" telegram was that threats would not have been taken seriously until the effect was confirmed - an there were even some doubts on whether it will work at all as designed. Unfortunately it did.

nickolai··on Pepsi explain why you'll never find a mouse in Mountain Dew
>Plain orange juice has a higher pH than Mountain Dew. I think that comparison would be enough to quell any shock over citrus soft drinks.

Having a higher pH actually means being LESS acidic. And no one would ever expect a mouse to 'turn into jelly' in a bottle of orange juice.

nickolai··on Why 37signals Doesn't Hire Programmers Based on Brainteasers
I'd feel uneasy if asked to show some of my code.

Obviously i cannot show something i'm currently working on, and everytime I look back at some code I wrote six moths ago I find myself wondering "did I really write this piece of crap?!". And it's always been this way - at least since i've been six months into programming. I hope it is a good sign.

nickolai··on Reddit Users to Target Supporters of SOPA in Congress After GoDaddy
I frankly wouldnt mind if the abortion opponents, or the climate change deniers, creationsists, flat earthers or any other such group decided to blow up a few politicians' careers by emptying their closets on Main Street.

As long as they actually do this instead of using the skeletons to blackmail the guy into submission i'm perfectly fine with it. We may not agree with their goals, but the side-effects of their activity would be positive. That's one crook out of the game - which can't be a bad thing.

Since the opposing groups would likely be employing a similar cleanup strategy, we might just end up with honest politicians with empty closets as a neat side-effect.

nickolai··on Why C Is Obsolete
I don't understand his matrix example.

in C++, you'd have a Matrix class with a getter. To get an element of the matrix you'd do

  int v = pMatrix->get(i,j);
whereas in C you'd typedef a Matrix structure type and have an accessor function

  int v = matrix_get(pMatrix,i,j);
Looking inside the functions, they'do pretty much the same thing. In both of these functions you'd be basically accessing either element i+imax * j of your data array if you are implementing the matrix as a single array, or the j-th element of the i-th row if you were using a pointer to pointer structure. the C version would work on the provided matrix structire whereas the C++ would use the implicitly provided this structure. C++ would allow your matrix class to override some operator to make this look cooler - but operator overloading being a good thing is not really a consensus AFAIK.

I dont see anything more than a syntactic difference here. The abstract reasoning behind the structures/classes is exactly the same.

C may be obsolete, but this is hardly a justification.

nickolai··on How can Skyrim be so unoptimized? Modders do better job than Bethesda
>disable optimisations in parts of the code because they were found to cause bugs elsewhere.

Well that is exactly what I meant. Compiler optimizations by themselves do not cause bugs - they reveal bugs. They are specfically designed to be sematically equivalent[1]. Without the compiler optimizations the bugs may not manifest themselves, or only manifest themselves in particular conditions that may not be spotted by QA - but the bugged/unsafe code is still present. Any functional discrepancy between compiler-optimized and non-optimized code should be cause for concern.

>Creating a rich interactive world the size of Skyrim is a considerable technical achievement,

I wouldnt say that the size is a technical acheivement - the credit would mostly go to the artists there - and they did an amazing job. Although it would cerainly not be possible without a decent quality engine.

Don't get me wrong. I really like skyrim, and have spent a lot of time with it. But I simply get the feeling that performance receives less and less attention in the modern products.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compiler_optimization

nickolai··on How can Skyrim be so unoptimized? Modders do better job than Bethesda
> Rewriting some x87 FPU code and inlining a whole ton of useless getter functions along the critical paths because the developers at Bethesda, for some reason, compiled the game without using any of the optimization flags for release build.

That sounds appalling. This is not some tricky algorthm-level optimization - they seem to have simply disabled compiler optimizations. Or forgot to reenable them for the final release. Inlining a function should have zero impact on the QA process (some try to explain the lack of optimization by the need to 'fix' bugs). If it does, then there is some sort of memory corruption bug somewhere, and the code should fail QA anyway.

Ensuring compiler optimizations are active would be the first low-hanging-fruit thing to come to anyone's mind when considering performace. The fact that it was 'forgotten' means that no one even considered performance during the whole development process. Not even in the "let's leave it to the compiler" form.

nickolai··on Paul Graham: SOPA Supporting Companies No Longer Allowed At YC Demo Day
>judiciary.house.gov/issues/Rouge%20Websites/SOPA%20Supporters.pdf

'Rouge websites'... Really ? How about figuring out that spelling thing before trying to pass legislation...

Or did we miss something and all this SOPA fuss is actually about misspelled counterfeit cosmetics exclusively?

nickolai··on People of the Internet: we can fix the English language
>If you spend a lot of time writing copy for the web or answering support emails, you know what I’m talking about. When you start a sentence, you can feel the nausea coming on from a mile away: there’s no gender neutral third person singular pronoun.

Technically, there is such a thing. "it" is a gender neutral third person singular pronoun[1] and even more amusingly it is not part of the proposed "replacement" list. It does sound very weird in most cases - and would definitely look dehumanizing in a support reply, but technically speaking the language is not broken.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It_%28pronoun%29 . Example given: "Is it a boy or a girl?"

nickolai··on Bug Prediction at Google
So in summary, their system highlights the files that had 'a lot of bugs lately'. While useful, this is more of a trend analysis and extrapolation rather than actual prediction. The title made me hope of something that would highlight some potential bug nests from static code analysis or the like. Interseting, but a little disappointing.
nickolai··on An Ode to a 'Poor Black Kid' I Never Knew: How Forbes Gets Poverty Wrong
That's a very intersting quote article you quote there. Just one thing : the article seems to claim that not caring to solve one's problems stems from the impossibility to solve them all in a forseeable future. Hence the problems create a "why bother ?" attitude, which in turn creates more problems. This pretty much nails the issue to me. But then the author goes on "The core of the problem has not been self-discipline or a lack of opportunity, my argument is that the cause of poverty has been poverty."

This is where I'm lost - isnt a "why bother?" attitute a textbook definition of lack of self-discipline?

I do agree with everything else in the article, especially with the idea of removing problems and roadblocks instead of simply throwing money at the issue.

So In my opinion there is a self discipline issue. Trouble is, the more you assist people in solving their problems, the more incline they will be to let their problems rot until you come and solve them again. The ultimate goal theere is to find a way to reliably restart the problem-solving circuit, once the people have been pulled back up to the surface.

AFAIK, no one has found a reliable way yet and unfortunately there is not much of a proposal in the article either.

nickolai··on Startup Ducks Immigration Law With 'Googleplex of the Sea'
As you point out, the challenges to overcome for such a project to succeed seem really huge compared to the expected benefit.

I think the one of the ideas about this kind of "overkill workaround" project is to get as much airtime as possible while kicking and screaming about how the current system is broken.

I wholeheartedly agree with the end goal, but to me this kind of article is really a form of disguised criticism - "Our system is SO broken that SOME PEOPLE are considering building an ARTIFICAL ISLAND (amazing, huh?, huh? HUH!? - wink wink sigh - yes it's really THAT bad!) to work around it.

nickolai··on Busted: BitTorrent Pirates at Sony, Universal and Fox
An insightful nugget at the very end, for anyone missing it:

>In a response [another copyright advocate caught 'stealing'] issued a press release stating that their IP-addresses were spoofed. A very unlikely scenario, but one that will be welcomed by BitTorrent pirates worldwide. In fact, we encourage Sony, Universal and Fox to say something similar. After all, if it’s so easy to spoof an IP-address, then accused file-sharers can use this same defense against copyright holders.

Could such a defense be expected to work ? Has it ever ?

nickolai··on Real life “Constructicon” quadcopter robots being developed
I think I recall something like this posted some time ago. It is an interesting idea, with a few caveats :

* At least in the video at the bottom of the article, it is not actually a swarm - there is never more than one robot doing each task (pickup, place), and one can see them waiting to get a 'workzone' cleared before moving in. In a swarm I'd imagine each flier working independently, with interaction limited to collision avoidance and occasional cooperation when needed(lift heavier block, etc).

* I hardly see such bots battling even moderate windspeeds in a real-life construction project, while carying any kind of real-life construction material block - assuming they can even lift one.

* Intuitively, I'd say this way of building is very energy-inefficient (in terms of power used by the drones) - but I'd love to see some actual figures.

nickolai··on How does biology explain the low numbers of women in computer science
Um... That was remarkably content-free. Almost everyone i've met in CS so far knows that 'men are better than women at math and/or CS' is an mountain-sized stereotype with possibly a sand-grain sized nugget of truth to it.

Yes we men do have our share of die-hard macho morons, but symmetric attitudes are not that hard to find in the feminist ranks either. In fact I think that in proportion to the number of men, we have less of these problematic types in CS than in some other fields.

nickolai··on If you want to get rich, stop being a fucking joker
The caps/profanity to content ratio is way to high for my taste. Weird: usually there is interesting stuff on that blog, and the writing is Okay too.

not to self : never drink and post.

nickolai··on How to forcibly eject a CD/DVD from a MacBook Air USB SuperDrive
> Of course, if for some reason none of your Macs will even POST or you happen to be Mac-less, and you're nowhere within driving distance of someone with a working Mac or an Apple Store the, yes, disassembling the drive is probably a reasonable option.

You forget the part about the damaged cable like what can be seen on a few pictures. If the link between the MacBook and the drive is severed, there is no way a firmware on the laptop could cause the disk to eject. And with no forcible eject trigger you're left with the 'cracking the case open' solution.

Shouldn't happen more than once per drive though, so I guess this is why Apple couldn't be bothered with an actual forcible reject button.

EDIT : he seems to claim that the reboot trick does work, so apparently the cable is still at least partially functional in his case.

nickolai··on Ask HN: What is wrong with this? (How the Greek economy bailout works)
I'm no economist, but it seems to me that in the example, the debt owed by the whole vilage to the outside world is essentially zero. The problem described is a liquidity problem much more than a debt problem. We could in theory imagine the villagers to trust each other enough to trade the IOUs between each other and solve the problem without the rich german. For example if A owes 100 to B who owes 100 to C who owes 100 to A, then A could give C's IOU to B and have his debt cleared B would then give C's IOU to C in exchange of his own bieng returned. No more debt and no germans involved. However this assumes that B trusts C enough to accept his IOU as payement from A.

If we were to use the analogy In the case of Grece, the hotel owner would owe a few thousand euros to different pawnbrokers in nearby villages, rush to pay them, and the german is in for a nasty surprise after he's done inspecting the rooms. Not that he wasnt expecting it to happen when he put a note on the table or that losing the 100 euros is such a big deal to him.

As I said I'm no specialist so I may be wrong here.

nickolai··on Tablet and Notebook Redefined: Asus Transformer Prime In-depth Look
This reminds me. Haven't we seen a post about Asus doing nothing but shamelessly copying Apple on top of the first page some time earlier today?
nickolai··on [dead]
Interesting idea, but I'm with Napoleon on this one

"Never ascribe to malice that which can adequately be explained by incompetence"

nickolai··on [dead]
Very Cheesy, but i think, 'worst ever' is a bit of a stretch.
nickolai··on Solitude and Leadership
Great piece. was already discussed here : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1476425 .
nickolai··on Easter Island heads have bodies
>Eh. I guess I'll just stick to HN classic.

it's #2 there now (http://news.ycombinator.com/classic)

nickolai··on The implications of UEFI "Secure Boot" for Linux users
While that's an understandable concern, I think parent was wondering whether Microsoft should be more concerned with why their system allowed the rootkit to install itself in the first place.
nickolai··on [dead]
Was posted on TC and discussed here : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3155358
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →