HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nunuvit

457 karma · joined April 14, 2023

submissionscomments
nunuvit··on Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear
Why is the current time and redundancy requirement insufficient? They had plenty of time and opportunities to look at it, and they succeeded with time to spare. What is the scenario where they would run out of time, and why couldn't they land assuming that the landing gear wasn't deployed?

You'd need potentially an unrealistic number of cameras. Even if you decide on a case by case basis, you still have to weigh the risk that every component adds, and with a finite amount of money to spend on risk reduction you want to get the most bang for your buck.

nunuvit··on Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from taking customers in Titan
Sure, I can "prove" that my sheet of sandpaper works by using it all day. Does that mean it should work all day tomorrow? It's a useful bit of information ... about how it's approaching the end of its service life. If you don't evaluate how much sand is left before using it again, what is there to debate? Either you don't care if it works tomorrow, or you're about to learn an important lesson on how sand paper works.
nunuvit··on Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from taking customers in Titan
It would not follow a bathtub curve. As the Wikipedia article explains, you have to at least check the in-service products to get a bathtub curve. As this article [1] explains, they did not do that. Therefore, no bathtub curve guarantee.

For argument's sake, let's say it would follow the bathtub curve. You could summarize all the warnings they were given as basically saying that the wear out curve crosses the other two curves all the way on the left. You could also say that they took the bathtub curve for granted, not realizing that it's the result of deliberate work. So again, still no bathtub curve, no matter which way you look at it.

[1] https://abc7chicago.com/missing-titanic-sub-oceangate-lawsui...

nunuvit··on Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear
The people in the airplane ask the people on the ground to look at it for them. "They" refers collectively to pilots, flight attendants, and air traffic controllers.
nunuvit··on Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear
You'd gain nothing, they can already see it with their eyeballs, and they don't require anything else like faster response or a different viewpoint. You'd lose in terms of putting another hole in the aircraft and maintaining another system, and you'd still need the manual procedure in case the camera didn't work.
nunuvit··on Sears offered complete houses in large DIY kits
I had it backwards. I thought you meant the new wood is bad because it breaks fasteners.

In any case, is unnecessary to use wood like that.

nunuvit··on The Power of 10: Rules for Developing Safety-Critical Code [pdf]
It's doable sometimes when there's a tailoring framework. Here's a publicly available example [1]. Though I admit that it's usually easier to do in the US than in the European Union, so your experience may vary.

[1] https://www.nasa.gov/seh/3-11_tailoring_and_customization

nunuvit··on Sears offered complete houses in large DIY kits
> This wood breaks screws and bends nails

While driving the fastener, or over time while the structure settles?

Either way, I can't see how this is a problem with the wood itself. The structural design and material properties have to be specified in a compatible way. The only three options are the spec is wrong, the materials are out of spec, or the engineer considers it a non-issue.

nunuvit··on The Power of 10: Rules for Developing Safety-Critical Code [pdf]
> Agree that many safety-critical coding standards are a grab-bag of sometimes dubiously-valuable rules.

What frustrates me is that most standards are self-aware of this and explicitly allow you to tailor them, but hardly anyone does that to a meaningful extent.

nunuvit··on A proto-pizza emerges from a fresco on a Pompeii wall
Did you scroll down and see the painting of the animal skull next to it? It looks 3D.
nunuvit··on Estimated U.S. deer population, 1450 to 2016
Ah, gotcha. I think you're just not accustomed to this use of the word. It's in the dictionary and people use it that way. In this case, probably used for effect in the story, but it's legitimate.

Curious why you hope it's not used for farm animals?

nunuvit··on Profits are driving inflation. When will politicians and the BoE admit it?
Are you saying that there's insufficient supply for some reason other than consolidation? I can think of many reasons, but they all share consolidation as a common factor when tracing back to the root causes.
nunuvit··on 'I can't say my own name': The pain of language loss in families
It's not a mystery. If you narrow the scope of the problem to pronunciation, then it's a solution. Good job.
nunuvit··on Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
Can you explain why they think an opinion on happiness would have a shelf life?
nunuvit··on Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
It's a Socratic question ...
nunuvit··on Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
Why will any reply to your question matter tomorrow?
nunuvit··on Physicists discover a new switch for superconductivity
How could that possibly harm anyone?
nunuvit··on 'I can't say my own name': The pain of language loss in families
And when she wants to say a different Bengali word? She acknowledged that she can learn, but the point of the article is that her upbringing was disconnected from the language and culture.
nunuvit··on The world’s empty office buildings have become a debt time bomb
Ok, so it seems like they're hard (or impossible) to find in your area, but that's not true everywhere.
nunuvit··on Estimated U.S. deer population, 1450 to 2016
Harvesting implies he killed and ate it. Whether you see that as a euphemism or more graphic probably depends on your dietary philosophy.
nunuvit··on Towards a “PCB Drone” – Making a PCB Motor which reaches 30k RPM [video]
He spends an order of magnitude more than necessary for convenience.
nunuvit··on The world’s empty office buildings have become a debt time bomb
Yeah, but they make shorter buildings out of steel and masonry, too. Next time you're apartment hunting, you can call ahead and ask whether the building is lumber construction, if you're not sure.
nunuvit··on 'I can't say my own name': The pain of language loss in families
She said her Bengali relatives tell her she says it with an accent. Becoming fluent wouldn't necessarily fix that. Teaching diction is a specialized area, and most language instruction doesn't go too deep into it.
nunuvit··on Docs Show FBI Pressures Cops to Keep Phone Surveillance Secrets
This already happens quite a bit with the referendums required to amend state constitutions in the US. Maybe not quite as nefarious, but they sneak in unpopular stuff, and the ballot summaries don't mention those parts.
nunuvit··on New rule would give electric utilities incentives for investing in cybersecurity
Never heard of a hardware vendor accepting payment in the form of company culture.
nunuvit··on How I landed a model rocket [video]
The regulation says "active controls", which is pretty broad.

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-22/chapter-I/subchapter-M...

nunuvit··on Limits of Programmer Productivity: A lesson from Fred Brooks
Having coworkers who are too curmudgeony to overuse chat apps and wikis.
nunuvit··on Our Plan for Python 3.13
Completely agree with you about it not being technically complex.

I responded to your other comment, so let's move it over there.

nunuvit··on Our Plan for Python 3.13
> the lack of clarity on the criteria for inclusion, as well as the constant goal post moving

This is where I think Sam is being unfair. He's asking for a breaking change. For 25 years, CPython has consistently and clearly said that they fully support no-gil in other implementations, and have a minimum criteria of no performance regressions for CPython. He made his performance demonstration before getting real buy-in. I understand he made that choice because of how his funding works, and now he's desperate to get a result. They acknowledged his demo and said they're considering it. Lashing out and accusing them of unclear criteria and moving goalposts misrepresents the situation.

It's not his decision to risk burning the community on a breaking change. He knows they haven't decided on it. It's reasonable to expect someone to do that work. He hasn't done it, so they will have to do it.

The steering committee also has to consider how this change will impact pursuing other goals. It doesn't exist in a vacuum all by itself.

They reiterated that they do in fact want to remove the gil, even after noting how much work it will be to do due diligence. They've also said they want to take in big projects like creating a JIT. Seems to me like effort itself isn't an issue. By calling it a fork, coming from the steering committee, they're saying either the transition plan is non-existent, or it's the wrong design for their goals, or it's coming at a bad time. Maybe all of them.

His task was to convince the committee to remove the gil. He interpreted that as simply doing a technical demonstration. Not sure why, especially given the history.

nunuvit··on Our Plan for Python 3.13
The usual way to dispute a decision is to start by refuting the justification. I think that's a reasonable ask.
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →