HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rewq4321

774 karma · joined May 24, 2019

submissionscomments
rewq4321··on The case for mutual educational disarmament
Underwhelming conclusion to the article IMO:

> What if the gaokao (and similar tests) were held earlier in a pupil’s career? If these exams truly test the knowledge required for university, they must be held just before university starts. But if such tests mostly serve as filters, sifting better students from worse, they need not be held so late. An aptitude test at 16 years of age, say, will probably generate a similar ranking as one held two years later. The tests would remain stressful. But an earlier gaokao would save families a year or two of costly cramming, shortening “the obstacle course”, as Hirsch put it, without much changing the results. Such tests will always have high stakes. But they need not require such high effort.

I was somewhat "late" in terms of some aspects of my development, and so there's a chance I'd have been put on a particular track simply because my peers were more biologically mature. I won't pretend to know the solution here (though I'm interested in the research around "mastery-based" learning), but I do know that sometimes a system is in a deeper local optima than you expect, and making small changes like the one suggested here isn't enough to get it out.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastery_learning#:~:text=Maste....

rewq4321··on Google’s ‘Project Hug’ paid out huge sums to keep game devs in the Play Store
The evidence of collusion between Apple and Google coming out of the Epic case is amazing to me. I'd always thought it was a sort of unspoken "game theoretic" type of collusion (which I'm sure it is in part), but it looks like they've had very explicit communication about it:

https://mobile.twitter.com/jowens510/status/1428417681351348...

> After another meeting between Apple and Google senior executives, notes showed that the execs agreed: "Our vision is that we work as if we are one company."

Just incredible.

rewq4321··on $600M taken in largest DeFi hack to date
To be clear for other skimmers like me, the "helper" who got 45k is donating to various addresses, not the 600m hacker. (Posting this because I misinterpreted, not because parent was wrong)
rewq4321··on An Animal’s Place (2002)
This documentary is worth watching: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQRAfJyEsko (Dominion, released in 2018, unfortunately requires signing into youtube due to age retrictions)
rewq4321··on Systemic Discrimination Among Large U.S. Employers [pdf]
I'm curious whether it's the same type of discrimination that this study presents. I.e. is it "group A is undesirable" or is it "most applications are from group A, and so when we positively discriminate for diversity/equity reasons, group A is most affected in terms of absolute counts" your excerpt seems to suggest the former, but my previous assumption was that it was the latter.
rewq4321··on Systemic Discrimination Among Large U.S. Employers [pdf]
It's 2.1 percentage points which they say is about a 9% difference.
rewq4321··on Mixed Reality with Passthrough
Can someone explain how they can keep the passthrough video private? Sounds like they're saying the data is processed on a separate worker that can't access the network, but that worker obviously needs to pass data back to the main thread so that UI/content can be rendered in response to the video.

Perhaps they don't allow "custom" processing by the dev? E.g. can only use FB's face/pose/etc detector? That would be quite limiting though.

Maybe they only allow passing back a small amount of information per frame? That'd still make it possible to leak information over several frames (if GAN latents are anything to go by, there aren't that many bits of information in a human face, for example).

rewq4321··on Valve Steam Deck
A duopoly can be a distinction without a difference if there's territory-dividing collusion, or even just game-theoretically "optimal" moves by the players towards a sub-optimal state for the customers.
rewq4321··on Valve Steam Deck
> "Steam Deck starts shipping December 2021 to the United States, Canada, the European Union, and the United Kingdom. More regions coming in 2022—stay tuned for more info."

Does anyone know why hardware product launches tend to be region-constrained initially? Is is for shipping/logistics reasons, or legal/tax/etc stuff?

Software/SaaS launches never have these constraints, so I figure it must be shipping related, but that would amaze me. Is there still no company that makes international shipping painless/simple? What would be the difficult part for Value here?

rewq4321··on Valve Steam Deck
Honest question (I may have misunderstood): Do you mean to imply that those are good prices? For reference, I'm paying about $40 for 1000 mbps (I'm not in the US). Can go to 10gbps for about double that price (IIRC), but I think the bottleneck becomes server bandwidth so it wouldn't speed me up for most services.
rewq4321··on Why is standing more tiring than walking? [audio]
I'm hoping that the next generation of VR headsets will be good enough (mainly in terms of resolution) that I'll be able to use one for coding. Seems the majority of the $5k is just for the fancy hanging screen.
rewq4321··on Neurons unexpectedly encode information in the timing of their firing
> there's evidence that at least some neurons "record" information about their activity in the form of RNA

Source? I'm not a neuroscientist, but I'd have thought that I'd have heard of this if there were legit evidence. Are you saying that neurons might use RNA as a sort of "long-term" memory of activation patterns? This seems really unlikely! But again, I'm not a neuroscientist.

rewq4321··on LaMDA: Google's New Conversation Technology
> You can't win at the moment....

What?? "You can't win" because this language model tries to avoid saying bigoted things? You say that like it's some sort of catch-22. It's a very desirable property and is a hard problem that needs to be solved to safely deploy these sorts of models to billions of users.

rewq4321··on Project Starline: Feel like you're there, together
"Hard tech" often only matures after several hype cycles. Sometimes cool tech demos can be produced a century or more beforehand. If you were in the 1980s and people were talking about video calls being the next big thing, you might point out that people have been working on video calls since the 1930s[0], and it hasn't caught on in every one of the hype cycles that have followed, so that's an indication that it won't catch on in the future. Video calls have caught on now though - especially as they've reached mobile devices instead of requiring a literal booth in your house, as with AT&T's initial "Picturephone" tech in the 70s.

I will say though that people tend to assume that each new technology will replace the preceding technology (text->audio->video->VR/light-field->...), but in fact it tends to end up just supplementing the existing tech.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_videotelephony

rewq4321··on Project Starline: Feel like you're there, together
The difficulty completely depends on the level of quality you're after. They're certainly working on cutting-edge-level quality, so it is likely no easy task. Someone else pointed out that they released a paper on related tech last year:

https://augmentedperception.github.io/deepviewvideo/

rewq4321··on Project Starline: Feel like you're there, together
No, this sends a different image to each eye. It's not actually a transparent piece of glass with an image on it[0] - I think they just try to make it seem as if it is a transparent pane you're looking through.

The marketing for it is pretty terrible though, because I initially came away with the same impression as you.

[0] See image here: https://www.engadget.com/google-project-starline-191228699.h...

rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
> It is an obstacle (at least a massive annoyance) for library authors

Yeah that's a completely fair point. Ruffle dev makes a similar argument up-thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27199260

rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
Oh, good to know!
rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
That's a fair point. I hope you're involved in the spec discussions around these topics! There's definitely room for improvement in terms of ease of use.

I noticed this update on the https://web.dev/coop-coep/ article recently:

> We've been exploring ways to deploy Cross-Origin-Resource-Policy at scale, as cross-origin isolation requires all subresources to explicitly opt-in. And we have come up with the idea of going in the opposite direction: a new COEP "credentialless" mode that allows loading resources without the CORP header by stripping all their credentials. We are figuring out the details of how it should work, but we hope this will lighten your burden of making sure the subresources are sending the Cross-Origin-Resource-Policy header.

rewq4321··on Project Starline: Feel like you're there, together
Do you know if it supports multiple people on "screen" at once? Or does it rely on eye tracking of a single person (plus projection of some sort?) to be able to achieve the 3D effect?
rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
> I don't think there's any plan to deprecate the previous standard (WebGL) that came out around 10 years ago

There's basically zero uncertainty around this. It would break the internet. As you probably know it's extremely difficult to make even tiny backwards-incompatible changes to features that have become web standards and have been implemented on all major browsers.

rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
> how does this work on Github Pages

Spectre called for some drastic measures, and it'll be up to Github/Netlify to decide how they react. Developers who want simple hosting solutions for their little projects will host elsewhere (e.g. replit.com, glitch.com) if they need to. This isn't exactly a massive obstacle if you've set out to build a complex game in the browser. It's just a couple of headers...

>How long until this shows up in Firefox

WebRTC data channels work fine in the mean time. Have you seen games like krunker.io and dotbigbang.com et al? It's perfectly possible to create real-time games in the browser using WebRTC.

rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
I don't think you's want to use WebGL2 as an analogue here. Radically different depth and breadth of buy-in across the browser ecosystem. I'm no expert, but I'm genuinely curious where you got the 10+ year figure from (is there an up-to-date estimate/roadmap from any of the people working on this?). I was under the impression that we'd see an MVP stabilise relatively soon (i.e. within a couple of years at most). Of course, there will still be features being added in 10 years time, since graphics APIs and GPUs are always evolving.
rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
> Timer precision has been reduced to around 1ms

> threading is also disabled or behind HTTP response headers post-Spectre

It seems like you've written a long-winded complaint that you have to add a http header (like this[0]) to your server's response? Though it's true that the Spectre stuff broke everything for a little while there (and there are still ergonomics-related teething problems with headers that are being worked on).

> Games need UDP style non-guaranteed networking, but we only get this as a tiny part of WebRTC (DataChannels).

WebRTC DataChannels work fine though? Does it matter that it's a small part of the whole WebRTC spec or that server-client use is a bit of a hack? Either way, WebTransport hits origin trial in Chrome in about a week, and it's specifically designed for UDP-like client-server communication, so the WebRTC approach can be swapped out once that is stable.

[0]: https://web.dev/coop-coep/

rewq4321··on First Public Working Drafts: WebGPU and WebGPU Shading Language
> people are saying it will take 10+ years

Who is saying that? Genuinely curious. It has strong buy-in from Apple, Google and Mozilla, and all 3 are implementing the spec right now (and updating implementations as the spec changes). Seems very doubtful that it'd take anywhere near 10 years to be supported by major browsers. I guess it depends on what subset of graphics/compute features you need for it to be viable for your specific use case.

rewq4321··on Hosting SQLite databases on GitHub Pages or any static file hoster
I've got no experience with Datasette, but if it's all in pure python, then you can use Pyodide[0] to run it within a wasm module. I was surprised how easy it was - took about 15 minutes and I had a Python package working perfectly in the browser. The Python package is about 3x faster than the JS/wasm version, but I'm guessing that performance gap will narrow when we get wasm-gc.

[0] https://github.com/pyodide/pyodide

rewq4321··on Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger life cycle assessment (2018)
I don't think people tend to eat plain ground beef though? Flavouring/salt is generally added
rewq4321··on Ask HN: How would you store 10PB of data for your startup today?
You can definitely serve way more than a few GB per month through Cloudflare on the free plan. I serve tens of terabytes a month for free. If OP needs to serve hundreds of terabytes per month they may get an email asking to upgrade, but the backblaze/Cloudflare setup would probably still be the cheapest. BunnyCDN is great too.
rewq4321··on Brave disables Chromium FLoC features
> Lets not pretend that ads help people with less money.

Who's pretending? Ads naturally and quite effectively price-discriminate, and so they do make internet content cheaper for people with less money.

You may have problems with excessive consumption, but many people in developing countries do not. They desperately need the free content (educational, informative, and otherwise) that the current internet model provides them.

rewq4321··on Can a Vegan Diet Be Healthy? A Literature Review
> Maybe but if most vegans are not healthy

It's well documented that vegans, on average, live longer than omnivores (even controlling for exercise level, smoking, etc), and I don't think there's any evidence that vegans are more nutritionally deficient than omnivores - in fact, I think there's evidence for the opposite.[0] Though I agree that we preface diets with "healthy if..." I think the standard western diet is more in need of that prefix.

[0] "Mean intakes of fiber, vitamins A, C, and E, thiamin, riboflavin, folate, calcium, magnesium, and iron were higher for all vegetarians than for all nonvegetarians. Although vegetarian intakes of vitamin E, vitamin A, and magnesium exceeded that of nonvegetarians (8.3 ± 0.3 vs 7.0 ± 0.1 mg; 718 ± 28 vs 603 ± 10 μg; 322 ± 5 vs 281 ± 2 mg), both groups had intakes that were less than desired. The Healthy Eating Index score did not differ for all vegetarians compared to all nonvegetarians (50.5 ± 0.88 vs 50.1 ± 0.33, P = 0.6)." https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21616194/

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →