HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

shinratdr

1,430 karma · joined September 24, 2009

submissionscomments
shinratdr··on Apple’s Struggle to Get the iPhone X to Market on Time
How about this objection:

With attention enabled, how is it any easier for police to force you to look at your phone to unlock it than it would be to grab your finger and force you to unlock your device with your fingerprint? Or beat you until you give up your passcode?

They all require restraining you and applying force, or threatening you until you comply. This is honestly the most ridiculous point.

All biometrics trade a little security for convenience. This is a known fact, it's not new, and it's no different with FaceID than it is with any other biometrics solution ever made.

shinratdr··on Apple’s Struggle to Get the iPhone X to Market on Time
Regardless of what you call them, Geniuses are just CSRs, and I think we've all gotten ill-informed information about products and services from CSRs regardless of the company. I would stick to official press releases and copy about the device for accurate information.

There is absolutely no way FaceID is required, I would bet my life on it. It flies directly in the face of the whole "Apple cares about your privacy" thing they've been pushing as of late.

shinratdr··on Apple’s Struggle to Get the iPhone X to Market on Time
> TouchID, for better or worse, has run the gauntlet.

Yet if you had a 5S you knew how awesome it was from day one.

I think the point is if you're preordering something with a new feature, you'd better have a lot of trust in the company you're preordering from to deliver on what they promise.

Many people have that trust with Apple, so they're fine with committing in advance. I don't see a big problem with that when they have a very solid track record.

> (holding it wrong and such)

I never met a single person who actually had this issue, and there were literally millions and millions of iPhone 4 devices in the wild. I owned one personally, never experienced it. Few things were as overblown as this.

Apple offered everyone the option of simply returning the device for a full refund, and nobody took them up on it. Why? Because the phone was great and the issue was pretty much non-existent.

shinratdr··on Apple’s Struggle to Get the iPhone X to Market on Time
> But it will be the false negatives that will by far be the most annoying and noticeable.

How do you know that's what it means? You have literally no idea if this report is even true, or what the implications of it would be if it were true.

People are drawing a lot of conclusions from an unsubstantiated report on a brand new unreleased feature for a phone that nobody has yet and has never used in the wild.

shinratdr··on Apple’s Struggle to Get the iPhone X to Market on Time
> Both will likely confuse and annoy long time customers and should've been solved with an ergonomic button on the back.

One more reason why the iPhone X isn't "the iPhone" this year. Apple knows this, it's the most fundamental shift in how you use the device since the original iPhone.

Those that feel confused and annoyed can always return the phone and buy the iPhone 8 for less money. Many already have opted to just buy the iPhone 8 rather than wait.

I don't think it's a mistake at all, it's a carefully calculated move to ensure that the vast majority of their customer base isn't alienated by pricing this phone out of reach and making it very clear that this is a glimpse into the future of the iPhone, not the iPhone you know and love.

shinratdr··on Apple’s Struggle to Get the iPhone X to Market on Time
> I've asked a few people and haven't gotten a solid answer if its a requirement on setup of a new iPhone X.

I don't know why you would assume this. I think it's very obvious that it isn't. TouchID is also not a requirement for any previous iPhone.

There is nothing about the iPhone X that would require FaceID. If you're happy just using a passcode, then that's your choice. They've given no indicators otherwise.

shinratdr··on Problems with MacBook butterfly switch keyboards
Because this isn't the typical experience for most?

I've had nothing but good things to say about Apple's repair policies. If it's in warranty, wander into an Apple Store, explain the issue, come back an hour or two later for your free fix or replacement.

Done and done. I've also heard horror stories, but they're a pretty big company. I'm not surprised it's a mixed bag. I can say that there are almost no companies that have a store a couple blocks from me that I can walk into and get free same day repair service for some devices.

The vast majority require me to mail my device into some unknown depot and be without it for a much longer period of time.

shinratdr··on Designing Websites for iPhone X
The rich minority are also the people who pay money for stuff, which is typically the goal of most websites.
shinratdr··on iPhone 8
I don't agree. I found EarPods very painful, and the AirPods were rough for about a day and then my ears got used to them.

They look very similar, but something about how their weighted changes the fit.

shinratdr··on iPhone 8
> $999 for the base model is just ridiculous.

Why? It's not the "base model" it's the lowest capacity of the absolute highest end phone in the lineup, which now comprises five different phones at much more reasonable price points.

So your argument is basically that no phone should be that expensive? I can't speak for anyone else but I hate that. What is wrong with a super-premium phone? If anything phones are frustratingly constrained by their price point.

People use them in the way they used laptops 10 years ago, they're your central communication hub and for many people their secondary or even primary computer. What's wrong with having a high end option for those that use their phone more than everything else.

I'm buying the iPhone X day one. Why wouldn't I? I haven't upgraded my desktop, laptop, gaming PC, tablet, or smartwatch in 2-4 years, but that's because I don't use any of those things even close to as much as I use my phone.

If I'm spending multiple hours a day every day using something, you'd better believe it should be the best one available. If you don't feel that way, there are four other iPhone options and countless Android options at your disposal.

shinratdr··on iPhone 8
I don't see your point. This is true, but it's true for everything. Passwords, biometrics. Even a physical key.

If your point is no lock is safe from someone saying "I will kill you if you don't unlock this" then yeah, that's true.

shinratdr··on Disney acquires own streaming facilities, will pull Netflix content
I've never had it replace local files. I would say you should back up your music collection like anything else in case something happens, but as long as the files are there locally I see no reason why it would replace them.
shinratdr··on Disney acquires own streaming facilities, will pull Netflix content
I was on Google Play Music from the beginning, and only left when they cancelled my early access plan without asking me and refused to reinstate it. Apple Music has leapfrogged them in every way, and Google Music has only regressed since launch, especially in terms of UX.

I did really like Google Play Music, and allowing the local library sync as a free draw was a really smart move. But the sour taste they left in my mouth by killing my discount plan and ruining the UX meant I looked at other options. Signed up for Apple Music day one and it has improved leaps and bounds since then.

It's very clearly a huge priority for Apple, and they aren't resting on it.

shinratdr··on Disney acquires own streaming facilities, will pull Netflix content
> using own music on phone (admittedly a bit of a hassle, you have to put it on a playlist on pc then sync download that playlist on mobile)

This really isn't the same thing at all. With Apple Music or Google Play Music, your own library and cloud tracks are seamlessly integrated and can be streamed and accessed from anywhere and any device.

A kludgy solution where you can use Spotify like a 90s MP3 player really doesn't cut it. If Apple, Google and Deezer can offer local library support, Spotify has no excuse. It's a huge gap, and makes Spotify unusable for many people or only supplementary.

I don't expect a streaming service to have everything in history all the time, just have as much as possible, and let me fill in the gaps.

shinratdr··on Disney acquires own streaming facilities, will pull Netflix content
Apple Music is rapidly evolving. They're putting a lot of effort into it.

OS integration is a big one for me, Apple Music is just so seamless. Personally I hate the Spotify UI, search is among the worst, and just like Google Music I find it has way too much Karaoke bullshit cluttering up results when it doesn't have the song you want.

That plus Spotify having no way to upload your own local files makes it a complete non-starter for me. Apple Music is getting way better on the radio & playlist front. The New Music Mix knows me surprisingly well.

I'd give it another shot if you haven't tried in the last 6 months to a year.

shinratdr··on Disney acquires own streaming facilities, will pull Netflix content
> I love Google Play Music for exactly this reason: I have 20k songs uploaded and counting. No other service is offering anything close.

Actually Apple Music offers exactly this. There might be other reasons you'd prefer not to use it, which is fine, but in terms of offering they're actually quite similar.

Except Apple will actually allow you to upload more songs than Google Music, up to 100,000.

shinratdr··on Snap falls to IPO price
They don't. Snapchat is a feature, not a product. They should have sold to Facebook when they had the chance.

Now everything novel they had (expiring message, stories, filters) has been successfully aped by Facebook and incorporated into Instagram, and because Instagram offers a UX that isn't intentionally shitty, they've already shot past the Snap userbase.

Sell your stock now, and don't be surprised if they're irrelevant/bankrupt by 2019.

shinratdr··on Why traditional password managers are flawed
Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Have you seen how people manage their passwords? Even a deeply flawed password manager is better than the current method of using the same password for everything or resetting their password every time they need to log in.

Average people probably have 20-50 accounts they have to remember the passwords for regularly, and for people who do a lot of online shopping or internet browsing, it's probably closer to 50-100.

Even when we had to remember phone numbers, people retained what, like maybe 10, max? Expecting them to remember unique combinations of 50 different username/email/password combos isn't just bad security, its arguably near impossible for most people.

It's all well and good to warn about the flaws in trusting a browser (although this basically amounts to "too much is going on so don't trust it" which is a poor argument) or the inherent insecurity of a master password.

But if you're already in the state that most users are in, those "massive issues" are orders of magnitude better than the current state. The convenience compromises those solutions make is so that people will adopt them.

Is this more secure? Definitely. Will any significant number use it? No.

shinratdr··on Apple Teases Upcoming Space Gray iMac Pro, "the most powerful Mac ever"
What makes you think that? A large part of the cost of the iMac is the screen & design. I would expect an entry level new Mac Pro to cost exactly the same or less than every other Mac Pro, so around 3K.
shinratdr··on Xperia Touch makes any surface interactive
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Rolly
shinratdr··on Abusing Gmail to get previously unlisted e-mail addresses
Oh absolutely, it's a good system and many sites already utilize it.

I only mentioned the Gmail example because that's what the article was about, it sounded like you were suggesting a solution for that scenario.

shinratdr··on Abusing Gmail to get previously unlisted e-mail addresses
Which is great for most accounts, but what about a primary?

How do you sign up for Gmail without an email account in this case?

shinratdr··on Google fixes a problem with AMP, lets you view and share publisher’s own links
> Amp is currently a mobile only thing, and most users on mobile are not blocking ads.

Most users anywhere are not blocking ads, adblocking by its nature as a non-default option and something you have to know how to do will most likely never be the thing that "most users do".

However, the idea that people on mobile do not block ads is just false: https://pagefair.com/blog/2017/adblockreport/

Worldwide, there are almost 150m more mobile adblock users than desktop adblock users. The trend of only blocking ads on your desktop is largely a North American phenomenon.

I can't speak to whether or not AMP is designed to try and stem this tide or not, but I can say without a doubt that mobile adblock is exploding, especially when considering the worldwide market, and that publishers are probably very nervous about this.

shinratdr··on Leap Motion Goes Mobile
> It would have been great to see it included in laptops, for instance.

It was included in laptops. It was terrible and useless.

A classic example of potentially great technology with very poor implementation and application.

shinratdr··on iPhones send call history to Apple, security firm says
Yeah and some people still want a typewriter. They can have one. That doesn't make it any more useful than the one trick device it is.
shinratdr··on iPhones send call history to Apple, security firm says
It's amazing how long a battery can last when it's connected to a device that doesn't do anything.

Have you ever measured the battery life of a battery still in the package? It's amazing, standby time is like years.

shinratdr··on Vine will be discontinuing the mobile app
So... Vine is shutting down? Why mince words? The app is the only part of the service that you can use to generate content, unless I'm missing something.
shinratdr··on Poll on macOS 10.12 is broken
> It seems like 10.6 is the agreed-upon high point for macOS

I don't know who is agreeing here, but I find people who say this to be looking with some seriously rose-tinted glasses. Mac OS X 10.6 is really not that great. It's hardly as "rock-solid" as people make it out to be.

It's the iOS 6 of OS X. It's the refinement of the most familiar interface before things started changing. That doesn't make it better, just more comfortable for some.

Here's the kicker: it's ugly. It looked good at the time, but looking back on it, it looks clunky. The remaining Aqua elements look out of place and weird, buttons lack consistency, design is all over the map.

10.12 isn't perfect but it's a pretty damn good OS. Mac OS X/OS X/macOS has always been kinda buggy; it's the nature of an OS with a significantly smaller userbase. IMO it's no worse now than it was in 10.6, except it has a ton more features.

shinratdr··on iPhone 7
That's because it didn't have a 2.5mm audio jack. How can it usher in the era of something it isn't a part of?
shinratdr··on A Design Defect Is Breaking iPhone 6 Pluses
The iPhone 5 black paint chipping problem, the iPhone 5 sleep/wake button failure, the iPhone 5 battery problem. The bending issue extends to the regular 6 as well, I've encountered multiple devices in the wild that have it. That's about it though.

I would also argue that all of these issues are more isolated than reports make it seem. No doubt, they are all grounds for a good extended warranty program at the very least but they aren't dangerous, recall-worthy or a case where all devices are affected. Just a significant enough number that if it occurs, it should be a free repair or replacement.

For a quick glance at all the recent acknowledged design flaws Apple has copped to, this page is a useful resource: https://www.apple.com/ca/support/exchange_repair/

← PreviousPage 2 of 26Next →