HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

streety

430 karma · joined May 8, 2008

My blog: http://jonathanstreet.com/

Email jonathan at the domain above

submissionscomments
streety··on Linode adds datacenter in Europe
A similar experience here. Submitted the ticket and received email notification of a reply 3 minutes later. Migrating 12GB looks like it's going to take about 90 minutes.

Can't fault them so far.

streety··on Vine seeds become gliders with 12% descent angle
On first reading your comment my reaction was, "No way." With a little research though it appears the angle for a 747 is only 5.9 degrees.

Thanks for the perspective.

streety··on Device spells doom for superbugs
A shower does more than just kill micro-organisms. It might be useful as an extra step after a shower but there is nothing to suggest it would be effective at cleaning off the dirt accumulated during a day.
streety··on Researcher's labour of love leads to MS breakthrough
I've had a look on the MS Society website and the only commentary on this research I can find is this: http://www.nationalmssociety.org/news/news-detail/index.aspx...

At the time that article was posted the only peer reviewed article showed a correlation between MS and reduced blood flow but no details on treatment. To my reading it seems fairly balanced in that context.

To some extent I'm playing devils advocate but here goes . . .

Why shouldn't people be tested? Tested by who? Are there sufficient qualified people? How would it be paid for? Would it take resources away from other treatments which we know, even if not very well, do work? What would be the value? How long would people be waiting before they could be treated? Would people be a little more lax in taking other treatments during this time? If the treatment proved not to work as advertised what would be the effect on those who had hoped it would?

Donating data is a good thing? What would be the selection criteria? Those rich enough to pay for the scan themselves? Are they representative? What would be the administrative overhead? Just as adding a new developer to a project behind schedule can slow things down further would an avalanche of volunteered data slow down the overall process? To what standards would this data be collected?

streety··on Researcher's labour of love leads to MS breakthrough
I appreciate that the effect is medically significant but the intervention was conducted at just one centre. Can it be repeated or is it particular to this centre? There are many, highly statistically significant, results published which faded into obscurity because nobody was able to repeat the results. I hope this isn't the case here but until it is repeated we can't know for sure.

The other point to note is that this article has been written for mass consumption and as such highlights the good but perhaps also misses the problems. I've had a quick look for a peer-reviewed article. I've found this (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2647682/?tool=pu...) which I think talks about the initial part of this study but it doesn't include the 2 year follow up.

I really do hope this is as positive as it initially sounds but there is still some way to go yet.

streety··on Researcher's labour of love leads to MS breakthrough
It seems a stretch that he would refuse the treatment from his wife whilst treating 64 other sufferers. The study would have gone through the local ethics committees, probably with second opinions etc. I would be curious as to whether the ethics committee knew his wife would be amongst the trial group but I would find it difficult to condemn him if they didn't.
streety··on Researcher's labour of love leads to MS breakthrough
"The initial studies done in Italy were small but the outcomes were dramatic. In a group of 65 patients with relapsing-remitting MS (the most common form) who underwent surgery, the number of active lesions in the brain fell sharply, to 12 per cent from 50 per cent; in the two years after surgery, 73 per cent of patients had no symptoms."

Although these are big falls 65 patients is not a large group. I'm not surprised the MS Society is cautious at this stage.

streety··on The Last of the Bluefin Tuna?
Tilapia may well be fine as they are largely fed a plant based diet.

Salmon are fed a fish based diet. The fishmeal is obtained from less desirable fish but they're still taken from the oceans. Their stocks won't be as dangerously low but eventually they will be consumed.

streety··on Lessons from Rackspace's downtime
Although I think your overall point is valid I wonder whether there is a middle ground on the hardware. For many purposes offering a degraded service would be better than nothing and could perhaps be handled with 1.5x your needed resources rather than 2x. It may also be possible to make use of this fabled cloud to take the 0.75x resources you have left after an outage back up to 1x.

All this does add development time though and, as you say, for most sites it isn't going to be worth it.

streety··on Five million people see a classic case of calling random()without reseeding
Although factually correct I don't see the relevance given that this game is Flash based and written in actionscript. Am I missing something?

Also, why not link directly to the php site? http://php.net/mt_srand

streety··on Plan To Build Giant Floating Airport Off California Coast
"By any measure, $20 billion is a lot of money, but Englund claims his group isn’t seeking any government funding all they need from the Washington are airport rights to this swath of ocean."

Although it seems a little unlikely a request for government funding won't materialise in future it would seem that it wouldn't be for the entire amount.

streety··on Announcing CEO Office Hours
I could imagine that getting very intense. I would be interested to know roughly how many calls you receive. Do you use your personal mobile or do you have a dedicated number?

Although I like the idea of the personal touch and always being there for your customers I'm not sure I could, or would want, to be available 24/7. If I ever get the prototype out the door I had considered using twilio to set up a call system. The idea being it could go straight to voicemail when I really want to sleep. Do you just turn your mobiles off during the night?

streety··on Send Mail using SMTP and PHP.
There are a multitude of very well established projects making the sending of email trivial in PHP. This feels like re-inventing the wheel for the sake of a blog post.

Also, for me personally, I think you're going too far over towards self-promotion. There is nothing wrong with self-promotion but save it for your best articles rather than submitting every article you put together.

streety··on What's the Secret Success of Mint.com? The Real Numbers...
I guess it depends on the friends and family. If they can afford to lose $100k and they understand the risks, which for me would mean they've been there before and not just that they're telling you they understand the risks, then no I wouldn't have a problem.
streety··on The 'Silent' Aircraft Initiative
Would this really be an issue? In my experience the biggest hold up is people in the aisles putting their bags in the overhead lockers and edging into their seats while you're trying to get past to your seat. In the image you linked to the although there are more aisles each is shorter so there would be fewer people in front of you blocking your aisle.
streety··on "Sustainable Energy - Without the Hot Air" by David JC MacKay
You can convert the electrical energy to other forms of energy though and store it that way. In following the link that nkurz gave the Andasol solar power station was mentioned which apparently will store excess thermal energy in liquid salt allowing electricity generation into the night. Pumped storage hydroelectricity is another, more established, method of storage.

I don't envisage huge vats of molten salt meeting our energy needs throughout the night but I suspect that energy storage will continue to have a part to play in meeting our energy needs in the future. It seems to be relatively expensive but then so is long distance transfer.

streety··on Russian Billionaire Installs Anti-Photo Shield on Giant Yacht
I think you mean this: http://ahprojects.com/exhibitions/anti-paparazzi
streety··on Energy saving light bulbs offer dim future
I don't agree that people still using incandescent bulbs is evidence that electricity is ridiculously cheap. Electricity bills aren't itemised so only when the total becomes painful will people consider the cost of their individual appliances. Bulbs are priced individually and so people are hesitant to switch to an option, CFLs, which they may perceive to be the more expensive.
streety··on US Navy underwater laser development "changes everything"
I don't believe this is relevant to ground-to-space communications. The way I read the article the laser pulse has a short range, ionising the water in the vicinity of the buoy, which creates sound waves which emanate out to wherever the sub is. The laser isn't bouncing back and forth from sub to buoy.

As the communication is via sound and not laser it also means that anyone else in the vicinity could intercept the message. Strong encryption and authentication would still be required.

streety··on Google Plans New Mirror For Cheaper Solar Power
I wasn't aware that Google was working on a car but I doubt it will benefit directly from this project. Thermal solar is generally only used on very large scale projects as you need a surface area sufficient to heat a working fluid well over 100 degC. A car roof just isn't going to work.
streety··on Using The DMCA To Stop Patients From Rating Their Doctors
"Even though you can get in trouble for filing a false DMCA notification (and even for failing to take fair use into account), most online services will quickly pull down content when receiving a DMCA takedown to preserve their safe harbor protections. So in almost all cases, the content will get pulled down, even if the content isn't really infringing."

Although this will be true for content randomly scattered about the internet there aren't that many services reviewing doctors, RateMyMD.com was mentioned, and so I would expect them to have the clout and the incentive to stand against this.

streety··on Post your HN tricks.
If you want more than just the link in your RSS feed there was http://nirmalpatel.com/fcgi/hn_feed.fcgi

It looks like it is now just a redirect to http://andrewtrusty.appspot.com/readability/feed?url=http%3A... which if you de-construct the url leads to a more generic solution.

The content from there can also be fed into Yahoo Pipes for any filtering you want to do. Given the plethora of HN related pipes it seems like everybody just creates their own. Having said that if you want somewhere to start I use http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.info?_id=c0d729843a9b9e8de...

streety··on Rate my web app: 360 Voltage is in Alpha (see comments)
Why are you doing a temporary redirect rather than a permanent (301) redirect?
streety··on Big Pharma Abusing Patent Laws To Seize And Destroy Legal Indian Generic Drugs
At the risk of beginning a meta-discussion I can only suggest because a person disagrees with you.

Personally I found your contribution useful. It answered, at least roughly, a question I didn't have time to investigate myself: What ratio of marketing:R&D is considered acceptable?

streety··on Big Pharma Abusing Patent Laws To Seize And Destroy Legal Indian Generic Drugs
Okay, google is failing to work its magic for me today. Would you be able to point me to a more inclusive estimate of the marketing to R&D spend?
streety··on Big Pharma Abusing Patent Laws To Seize And Destroy Legal Indian Generic Drugs
I'm not saying the current system in US/Europe is efficient or even acceptable but it is a model that has produced novel therapeutics in the past. I think we can agree that the price is too high but hopefully we can also agree that benefits have been gained from those novel therapeutics.

I got the impression that the article was generally anti-patents and I framed my response in that context. A ban on patents has been beneficial for the generics industry but if it has a higher cost in terms of stifling novel therapeutics, which also have a benefit, then it may be an overall loss for the population as a whole. In this way there is little difference between a ban on patents being good for the generics industry and strong copyright laws being good for the record industry. Both may be true but the interests of the population may not be aligned perfectly with these industries.

On the other hand if research into novel therapeutics is able to thrive with a ban on patents then you get the benefits of new therapies and the affordable prices. This is what I would like to see before dismissing the patent system entirely when what may be best is a little tweaking.

Finally on marketing versus R&D I'm not sure that the multiple could genuinely said to be 'very large.' This article suggests marketing:R&D is 2:1. http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal...

streety··on In UK, Two Convicted of Refusing To Decrypt Data
Are you really suggesting the police investigate 200000 - 1.1M people a year who are using encryption to protect their secrets?
streety··on Big Pharma Abusing Patent Laws To Seize And Destroy Legal Indian Generic Drugs
"India has a legal and thriving generic drug market that was built up initially via a ban on pharma patents in India (which, as an aside, shows again that a ban on patents can actually help create a thriving industry)."

Personally I would be looking for evidence of a thriving industry in novel therapeutics, rather than generics, before considering everything hunky dory after a ban.

streety··on King Size Linodes Now Available
Taking another look at the linode site I can definitely see where the confusion might come in as it's difficult to find any indication that costs are calculated daily. However I did find the following, again from the FAQ:

Can I upgrade my Linode?

[...]

Removing resources pro-rates the balance of the month back to your account so you only pay for the time you've used them.

Edit: I've just gone into my linode account and the removal link does give you a figure for how much you'll get back. You pay for a month in advance but if you don't need the full month you can remove the linode and get your money back for the time remaining.

streety··on King Size Linodes Now Available
My understanding was that if you only needed a vps for five days then you're only charged for five days. Their prices are given as monthly but they measure your usage daily.
← PreviousPage 4 of 13Next →