HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on If You’ve Met Aliens While on DMT, These Scientists Would Like to Hear from You
If I had to hypothesize, I'd say that most hallucinogens generally stimulate lower-levels of the neocortex's sensory perception hierarchy, resulting in a distorted and more vivid experience of basic things like colors, textures, etc. But DMT is somehow particularly able to stimulate a higher-level representation that corresponds with the perception of a fellow intelligent creature. This is combined semi-randomly with one or more high-level representation of animals and objects to create the perception of intelligent "aliens" with a bizarre form.
stupidcar··on Organizational Skills Beat Algorithmic Wizardry (2015)
I was thinking along similar lines the other day. I was thinking about whether I've actually improved as a software developer over my career. It occurred to me that most of the languages and frameworks I use are either less than a few years old, or have been changed or reinvented in substantial ways. As such, not much of the declarative knowledge from my early career is of much use. But have my skills improved?

I came to conclusion that my ability to code on the micro scale, e.g. at the level of an individual method or algorithm, probably stopped improving after 2-3 years of professional experience. I think you could take the 24-year-old me, ask him to work on a narrow problem, and he'd do about as well as I would now.

But where the 24-year-old me struggled a lot was at the macro scale. He didn't know how to compose those individual pieces into a cohesive hole, and instead fell back on a handful of patterns like singletons. I remember horrible days trying to unravel my own code and figure out how component X was going to communicate with component Y, and the result was often a mess.

I think this macro-scale ability really does improve continuously over time, as you are exposed to more and better patterns for integrating components and managing dependencies.

stupidcar··on Illinois pension benefits have grown six times faster than state revenues
This ties into the larger problem of Western democracies generally degenerating into gerontocracies. Older voters can form a bloc protecting pensions and pensioner-directed state-benefits that no politician dare take on.

The results of this is a political trap without an easy exit: Impose punitive taxes on the working population and you'll strangle the economy and incite capital flight and outright rebellion. Form a consensus with other mainstream politicians to slash pensions and benefits, and you'll push the pensioner voting bloc into the arms of whatever extremists promise to protect their interests. And you can't allow large-scale immigration to correct the demographic imbalance and raise tax revenues, because the same pensioner voting bloc is also rabidly anti-immigration.

Brexit was a first taste of this: The 1997 Labour government saw the demographic and revenue crisis coming and thought EU migration was a solution. But the long-term result was to inspire an anti-immigration and anti-EU movement amongst older voters that has forced the country out of the EU. In Germany you see the same forces at work with the rise of AFD, and in France with the FN. This is going to get a lot worse before it gets any better.

stupidcar··on Medieval peasants got more vacation time than modern workers (2013)
By "all modern people", you apparently mean the relatively small group of middle-class professionals who can earn a decent salary on a shorter working week, and are in a position to negotiate it.

There is a far larger group of people working in low-skilled jobs whose entire salary is not enough to cover their outgoings, and must also rely on consumer debt and government assistance to support themselves and their families (think Walmart workers on foodstamps). What's more, the balance of power with their employer is such that they have absolutely no leverage to negotiate shorter working hours, even if they wanted to. A low-skilled worker is expected to be at the beck and call of their employer up to, and often beyond, the legal limit of work. When you can be fired from a job you've held for years for being 30 seconds late, you're not going to get far asking to work two less days a week.

It's nice that you were able to arrange an easier lifestyle for yourself, but don't mistake your privileged situation for the norm.

stupidcar··on D3.js 5.0 is out
Sorry, but this is a rewriting of history and the present facts, and I can't let it go unchallenged.

React was first released in 2013, whereas Angular (2) was first released in 2016. React was already a very popular and rapidly growing framework by that point, so the idea that people adopted it simply because of Angular 2 is clearly false.

And while the migration process from Angular 1 to 2 was painful, it's simply untrue to say that nobody bothered, or that every AngularJS developer moved away. If you look at a source like https://hotframeworks.com/, which sources framework popularity data from GitHub and Stack Overflow, you can see that Angular has achieved a significant amount of adoption, and there are plenty of examples of people migrating successfully from 1 to 2+.

stupidcar··on At the Mars conference, Jeff Bezos Hosted Roboticists, Astronauts and more
Are you pissed off because it's insufficiently editorialised? It's undoubtedly news — these are some very rich, influential and/or talented people, and all of them attending an event like this is notable. What it "means" is up to you, and different people will have different takes on it. I'd prefer that they just tell me it happened and let me make up my own mind.

My take is that society has different tribes of elites: You have old-school aristocracy and royalty, ultra-rich businesspeople, celebrity entertainers, politicians, artists, and top scientists. Each tribe is fascinated by, and envious of the different cachet and influence of the others. But the nature of the capitalist system means that it is the ultra-rich who pull the strings, and so they organise events like this in order to rub up against these other types.

In the past, the rich were most interested in rubbing up against the aristocracy, in the hope of acquiring by association the social capital associated with inherited nobility, and eventually becoming aristocrats themselves. Then, as the status of the aristocracy diminished during the 20th century, the rich became more interested associating with celebrities, as their associated glamour was something exotic and interesting.

In the 21st century, celebrity and fame has been demystified and become somewhat vulgar. So, now you have a subset of the very rich who are instead interested in associating with scientists, futurologists and researchers, as their air of intellectual achievement and specialised knowledge offers a new type of cachet that they wish to associate themselves with.

stupidcar··on Why I Don't Sign Non-Competes
Holy shit. That is way, WAY crazier than a non-compete. That is saying you can't work at all for a year after your employment terminates, because anything you produce during that time is presumed to have actually been created during your previous employment, and so belongs to your ex-employer. Even if you go and work for a non-competing company in a completely different field, and invent something totally unrelated to your ex-employer's business, then it supposedly belongs to your ex-employer. Since no new employer could accept that situation, it essentially prevents you from working.

I'm sure that can't be enforceable at all, but it's still completely sickening that a company would put something like that in its terms.

stupidcar··on Will GDPR Make Machine Learning Illegal?
Catching fake / spamming / abusive users on social media.

People are (rightfully) upset by the amount of spam and harassment happening on platforms like Twitter. Machine learning is a good way to tackle this problem at scale, in an automated way, by training models to spot and auto-moderate bad posts.

Under GDPR, anyone can demand an explanation for why they were marked as spam / abusive. This will allow trolls and spammers to improve their workarounds, by demanding an explanation for why their posts were blocked, then tailoring their later posts to avoid these signifiers. It will also let them impose a tax on platforms that try to block them by flooding them with demands for explanations under GDPR.

stupidcar··on The Nightmare Letter: A Subject Access Request Under GDPR
It also requires you explain the logic of any algorithmic decision you make.

I.e. If you use any sort of machine learning model, such as a neural network, you have to be able explain every decision it makes. Given that there's currently no know method to fully explain the outcome of a neural network decision, GDPR would apparently make it illegal for any EU business to use a neural network in any user facing capacity.

GDPR advocates answer to this seems to be that, while the regulations might read as such, it hasn't actually been tested in court yet and, who knows, maybe whatever judge it eventually comes up with will decide to keep neural networks legal!

So, if you're a company using machine learning in Europe, you just have to wait a few months and keep an eye on court news to determine if you entire strategy is permitted or not. Thank God for the stability and confidence provided to businesses by the single market!

stupidcar··on Inheritance Often Doesn't Make Sense
The deeper problem is that many domains cannot be modelled as hierarchical taxonomies, but only as ambiguous categories. This is a theory expounded by, amongst others, George Lakoff in his book "Women, Fire and Dangerous Things"[1] and elsewhere. Such cognitive categories are fuzzily defined, often overlap, and represent a collection of traits and properties that members of a category share some or all of. But different members can belong to the category to a greater or less extent, or be better or worse examples of it. E.g. both ostriches and sparrows are birds, but sparrows are usually considered a better example of the category birds.

Like the process of developing scientific taxonomies, efforts to model these kind of domains using OO techniques frequently run into edge cases that defy concrete classification. E.g. can all birds fly? Clearly, flight is an extremely important trait of the class "bird", but we also recognise flightless birds as birds, which means objects can lack an important trait of a category, but still belong to it, albeit as a worse example.

This is not just a theoretical problem. Imagine trying to invent a set of classes to model computing devices for an IT asset management system. What exactly constitutes a smartphone, vs. a tablet, vs. a laptop, etc.? It's easy to imagine the attributes and behaviors you might attach to these classes, but properly mapping every real world device onto them is extremely difficult. You are always going to get edge-case devices that straddle multiple classifications, or exclude some behavior that is assumed to be critical to devices of its type.

The result is that systems trying to model such domains end up with a variety of problems: Some impose a rigid, but essentially arbitrary, taxonomy, with the result that users struggle to use it properly. Edge-cases require special, out-of-band handling, e.g. users understanding that the system cannot properly represent items of a particular type, and that you have to accept a misclassification, or misuse the system slightly in order to make it work.

Some systems flatten and generalise the taxonomy into a single superclass, perhaps called "Device" in our example, that holds all the attributes and behaviors of all the former subclasses. This requires users to then interrogate objects of this generic type and essentially determine their "actual" type on an ad-hoc basis, with the result that they may be treated differently, or incorrectly, by different processes, depending on the heuristics that were applied in that case.

And finally many systems just abandon the idea of internally representing the taxonomy in concrete terms at all. As edge-cases proliferate, and that idea that "every X is just a specialised case of Y", is taken to its conclusion, the concrete taxonomy dissolves and is replaced with a general taxonomical abstraction. A new, more flexible object system is implemented on top of the native object system, such that users of the system can define their own classes, at runtime. These systems will support tagging and multiple membership, and other devices for representing complex taxonomies. This solves the problem of representation, but only by abrogating responsibility for defining it entirely to users of the system. These users are then faced with the task of developing the taxonomy from scratch in userland. In an organisation where different departments need to agree on a common taxonomy, this process is often centralised, and a single simplified set of classes is presented to sub-users. But then edge-cases to this taxonomy start to emerge, and the process repeats itself. This is how layers of abstraction proliferate.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women,_Fire,_and_Dangerous_Thi...

stupidcar··on Inheritance Often Doesn't Make Sense
> But taking a position where you say it's never the right tool or, conversely, always the right tool makes you sound ignorant and inexperienced.

Neither of those positions is advocated by the article, so who exactly are you talking about?

In fact, you seem to have assumed that "make sense" in the title referred to the issue of whether or not to use inheritance, whereas in fact the article is concerned with the customary conceptual understanding of inheritance within software engineering, and whether this understanding "makes sense".

This is an easy enough mistake to make simply from reading the title, but one that should have been cleared up in a matter of seconds once you started reading the article body, which I presume you did, rather than immediately rushing to the comment section?

stupidcar··on What America looked like before the EPA, in photos
As I understand it, the conservative attitude is that environmental concerns are either overplayed, or simply a Trojan horse invented to push anti-business/anti-capitalist policies, and a leftist agenda in general. They believe that many of the most fervent environmental campaigners are not really interested in evolutionary improvements to the current system, but instead want revolutionary change, including the complete replacement of the existing system with something more akin to communism.

As someone who is broadly centre left in outlook, I do actually agree that there is some truth to this. From what I've seen, many environmental campaigners do talk in terms of complete economic and political transformation. And they are often conflate environmental issues with other issues of social and economic justice, even when the actual links between them is questionable. For example, do we have to solve issues of gender, racial, and income inequality in order to stop climate change?

Personally, I think that these issues are not inextricably linked. I'd like to see improvements in all of them. But I also think that climate change is a more pressing issue, because while human-scale problems can always be fixed with more time, runaway climate change is likely a one way process, and one with a very narrow window of opportunity to address. I think many environmental campaigns would find a more receptive audience amongst conservatives if they focused more narrowly on the specific issues of pollution and climate change.

Of course, campaigners do have a answer for this. They argue that these issues are inextricably linked. That the capitalist system is incorrigibly rapacious, and all these different problems are really just products of the underlying dysfunction, and cannot be tackled in isolation. That "evolutionary" improvement is simply an emollient that cannot address the fundamentally catastrophic impact of the free market and the global supply chain on the biosphere, and as such, revolutionary change, even though very difficult, is the only solution that can work, and therefore the only thing worth campaigning for.

My take is that, while some of the fundamentals of modern capitalism are basically broken, with respect to environmental impact, they are still delivering results, in terms of general reduction of overall poverty and improvements to quality of life for the very poorest, and security for the richest. As such, it's not realistic to expect to achieve major changes through campaigns focused on policy. Instead, campaigns to influence policy should focus on specific issues that mitigate the worst of climate change and pollution. Their purpose should be to buy us enough time as a species to solve the other problems using technology. Technological change can deliver genuinely transformative changes to the economy, as we're seeing with the adoption of renewable energy and electric vehicles, but not always fast enough.

stupidcar··on Is vitamin D really a cure-all, and how should we get our fix?
There are many places and times of year where you just never cannot get enough sunlight through this method. Right now in the UK is midday, and it is completely cloud covered, and this will be the case most days for a large proportion of the year.
stupidcar··on Britain’s White-Collar Cops Are Getting Too Good at Their Job
What do any of those things have to do with the EU? Brexit supporters are in favour of more global trade with countries like China, and lower environmental and labor standards. They hated the EU because it was precisely the opposite: A self-sustaining trading bloc made up of mostly successful, developed democracies, with (relatively) strong regulatory protection for workers and the rule of law.

Corporate interests know that, in a struggle, size is what matters. Multi-national corporations can effectively bully the governments of individual countries far more easily than they can a supranational collection of governments who resist being played off against each other. Faced with a lack of success forcing the EU to deregulate, these interests have instead switched to trying to undermine the institution itself, by funding populist campaigns that blame economic problems on the EU, even though it was under-regulation of finance (championed by the UK) that lead to the 2008 crisis.

A break-up of the EU will lead to outcomes a thousand times worse for poor and working class people throughout its member nations, and consequently around the world. There will be a race to the bottom in terms of regulatory protection and labor rights. There will be massive declines in average standards of living. There will be a rollback of democracy, as strongmen and autocratic governments re-emerge in Europe. There will be a return to war between European states, and pogroms and ethnic cleansing as nationalist governments cast around for scapegoats for their own failure.

If you think the pre-Brexit economic model had "serious faults" then believe me, you ain't seen nothing yet.

stupidcar··on Found trapped in a diamond: a type of ice not known on Earth
Let's just be grateful it wasn't ice-IX they found.
stupidcar··on China Seeks to Repeal Presidential Term Limit
Something I think most Westerners who in liberal democracies don't understand is that the notion of "corruption" doesn't really exist in the rest of the world. At least not in the sense of being an immoral deviation from the norm.

What we think of as "corruption" would be better be termed "patronage", and it is the natural and default mode of political behaviour for human beings. It is impersonal, merit and market based systems that are the aberration, historically speaking. And, in the absence of strong institutions preventing it, societies inevitably revert to being patronage-based.

For example, imagine you are interviewing two people for a job. One is an extremely well-qualified and capable stranger. The other is a mediocre candidate, but is the son of a friend of your uncle. Who do you give the job to? For many people in the world, the idea that you would even consider not giving the job to the son of your uncle's friend is heresy. And they would not consider that attitude in any sense immoral or improper. Indeed, being in a position to help yourself and your acquaintances, and instead choosing to assist a stranger would instead be the perverse choice.

In a wider sense, within patrimonial societies there is never any question of ending patronage altogether. Instead, elite patronage networks compete with each other, and "anti-corruption" drives are about the dominant patronage-network cementing power and punishing another. We often see this in countries where every change in the government is accompanied by the prosecution of the old leaders for corruption by the new, only for the new themselves to be prosecuted a few years later upon leaving office.

Xi's efforts might be presented as being "anti-corruption" in nature, but they are very much about securing the position of himself and his patronage network. If he was serious about stopping corruption altogether, he would be concentrating on reforming China's institutions to make them more transparent, more merit-based and less susceptible to centralised political control. Instead, he's removing obstacles to himself and his patrons remaining in power indefinitely.

stupidcar··on China Seeks to Repeal Presidential Term Limit
I think term limits are a weak defence against autocratic leaders, because in such situations the separation of powers necessary to maintain the constitutional check usually doesn't exist. I.e. there's no independent judiciary or opposition bloc in the legislature. In a system like China, these institutions are politically inert facades, designed to outwardly resemble their democratic counterparts, but with actual power remaining wholly invested in the executive, which is wholly controlled by the ruling party.

The real checks on an autocratic leader are rivalries within the ruling party's elite, and once a leader like Xi has achieved dominance there, then amending the constitution to remove the term limit clause is trivial.

stupidcar··on How Many Tesla Model 3 Cars Have Been Made?
Despite the delays, the shape of the estimated production curve is pretty encouraging.
stupidcar··on A Chinese Casino company has set out to take over the U.S. island of Saipan
> Am I supposed to be enraged that there exists a job-site that is cutting every corner, a casino is being used for money laundering by the Chinese elite and politicians are probably making money in unethical ways as a result?

Um... yes? Do you think killing workers, money laundering and corruption are OK?

stupidcar··on How UK Spies Hacked a European Ally and Got Away with It
Europol as an organisation has no power to act on its own, it relies on the co-operation of the EU member states, and needs permission from the relevant national authorities to conduct investigations and arrest suspects. Regardless of the nationality of its leader, it can't realistically investigate British suspects if the British won't co-operate, and there's no prospect of them doing that here.

Furthermore, all large countries, like Britain, France and Germany, engage in this kind of espionage against "friendly" countries, and none of them want an agency like Europol getting involved, because then they would reduce their co-operation with it, and that would harm the fight against organised crime and terrorism.

Basically, when it comes to a supranational organisation like Europol, real separation of powers is impossible, because there's always a political calculus involved in a collaboration between sovereign countries with occasionally competing interests.

stupidcar··on Pro-gun Russian bots flood Twitter after parkland shooting
Note that while the headline says the bots are "pro-gun", the article says the bots flood Twitter with messages on both sides of an issue like this. The idea supposedly being to encourage political discord in general.
stupidcar··on CSS Grid for UI Layouts
The strangest phenomenon I have encountered when using Flexbox and Grid in CSS is a nagging sense of guilt. Through two decades of web development, my brain has so absorbed the idea that easy CSS layout is only possible through non-standard, browser-specific CSS or "wrong" things like table-based layout that it just won't accept that it's no longer the case. It's like when you leave school, but for years you still have dreams you're late for class.
stupidcar··on 1960s Kodachrome photos of London’s East End
These are lovely. The photographer who found and digitised these also has some great shots in a similar vein: https://chris3.500px.com/
stupidcar··on Australia’s new real-time banking payments platform
I find I need to do it quite often. Usually because, for speed or convenience, one person in a group has paid for something, like movie tickets, a round of drinks, or the bill a restaurant. Being able to do it easily and immediately makes it much less likely that you'll forget and require your friend either to take a loss, or deal with the awkwardness of chasing people for money.

Right now we use Revolut for this, where possible. But that only works when the person receiving the cash also uses it, which isn't always the case. Having a more universal system that works for everyone would be very handy.

One amusing thing about doing this approach is that, if you tend to split who does the principal payment evenly between your group of friends, then you realise you are rarely adding or removing funds from your Revolut account, you are just shuffling the same small sums back and forth between yourselves in order to keep things fair.

stupidcar··on Roam has constructed an international housing network for digital nomads
Well, obviously there has to be some kind of booking system, but it could work on a more ad-hoc basis. You can stay in your current location for as long as you like, or you can login and see which other locations have capacity, then let them know you'll be coming in day or so.

Would this be less convenient in certain situations, where you had definite travel plans in advance? Sure. But it'd also encourage and enable the kind "nomadic" approach they claim to be delivering, and you could always use a regular hotel if you absolutely had to be in a particular city one a particular date.

As it stands, "business hotel with guaranteed decent wifi" might be a useful market niche, but it's a far cry from the kind paradigm-shift this seems to be being spun as. And I think there would be something quite interesting in doing it for real.

stupidcar··on Roam has constructed an international housing network for digital nomads
The Roam site seems to require you to book at at particular location, with check-in and check-out dates, and a per-day pricing structure. How is that really any different from a traditional hotel/hostel?

It'd be more interesting if they were offering, say, the possibility to get a 6-month tenancy agreement with the option to freely move between locations during that time. But that doesn't seem to be the case?

stupidcar··on SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy successfully launches
They know how the press works though. There's a huge amount of attention being paid to this launch, and journalists will be racing to report it ASAP. If they announce immediately that the centre core has been destroyed, the headlines around the world are going to be "SPACEX LAUNCHES CAR BUT LOSES SPACECRAFT", and the failure, however partial, will be a central plank of the story.

If they delay the core announcement by a couple of hours or so, the headlines are all "SPACEX SENDS CAR TO MARS", with a minor note appended later to say, "A SpaceX spokesperson later confirmed the landing of the spacecraft's central core did not succeed and it has been lost." Like it or not, issues of timing like this makes a big difference to how the exact same events are reported and perceived.

stupidcar··on Perspective: Streaming pivot visualization via WebAssembly
Did you experiment with doing it JS-only prior to the C++ version? If so, what kind of performance increase did you see with WebAssembly?
stupidcar··on A pessimistic vision of India’s looming environmental and economic collapse
Original Mathusianism should be distinguished from neo-Malthusianism, in that the latter does at least have some evidential basis in that it is based on measurement of resource levels and their rate of use, not just some political philosopher's wooly notion of overpopulation.

The problem, as I see it, is that even if you are optimistic about the theoretical capacity of the planet to sustain human life, its practical capacity is limited by how efficiently we use the resources to hand, and the current system does not properly incentivise efficient use. More often, it's the complete opposite, because the price of resources like water and soil does not reflect their true scarcity.

It's like having a large store of firewood. Enough, in theory, to heat your home through several years of harsh winters. Then you burn the whole stockpile in a great bonfire on the first cold Autumn night. That night, by every metric, you'll be warmer and cosier than you ever have been before, but you'll still have doomed yourself.

stupidcar··on The State of Atom's Performance
If they're so bad, why are so they popular?

https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2017#technology-mo...

← PreviousPage 13 of 26Next →