HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

theincredulousk

446 karma · joined July 22, 2016

submissionscomments
theincredulousk··on Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest
Well you can but now carry a baseline hypocrisy that undermines anything you’d hope to accomplish.

I have a hard time respecting these people for that reason. Hard not to view someone as entitled, or having some form of delusional idealism, when they trash their company on Twitter. Every tweet was made either shortly before or after one their exceptionally large Google paychecks was direct deposited into their account.

Further highlighting this obscure world view, they thought they wouldn’t be fired for these things? Maybe they did know they’d be fired - that would at least be a credible signal of rational thought and motivation.

theincredulousk··on The only build system that might someday replace make (2010)
Ohhh the tragedy of build systems... Maybe the best example of meta technical debt on the planet, for so many canonical reasons that technical debt emerges in general. Top reasons no software engineering team fixes this:

The build system will not directly improve the end product. So no company wants to pay for it / use the time.

Due to the previous reason, a build system is not a compelling value proposition as a product (except for speed, see next)

Hardware/cloud technology has progressed fast enough that raw horsepower can be thrown at a slow build system with reasonably good results.

The ubiquity of legacy build systems makes integrating anything new extremely painful. Almost no software project these days is free from non-trivial dependencies that will certainly be using a legacy build system. Again, for any project team, this pain and extra effort cannot be justified as it doesn't make a difference to the end customer.

Engineers hate arbitrary syntax changes with respect to some scripting language when there is equivalent common practice. This goes for new general purpose languages too (entirely separate rant, but what is the point of arbitrarily changing the most widely known, generic C-style syntax of a function call? What value does it provide not to just re-use the return_type name(arguments) pattern that 99%+ of all programmers must already know? What is the return on the cognitive load???)

Most engineers simply don't care. They aren't interested. They click a green arrow or type "make" as a ritual and then wait for what they care about, which is the end-result. The only time anyone cares is when it has to be setup for the first time, or when it breaks. Everyone at this time will moan and say "this could be better, this build system sucks, we should make a better one", but once it is setup/fixed, everyone rapidly forgets about it never to return.

It is not a sexy problem. Telling anyone outside of software engineers that you made this awesome build system is pointless - they won't even understand the premise of the problem. In fact, interviewing recent CS grads, even they don't really know what a build system is.

  - If you think about it for a moment, these sort of reasons are the harbingers of technical debt.  
The primary one is not having a direct contribution to the end-goal. Obviously old-salt engineers know a good build system will save thousands upon thousands of hours in the long run. Just ask anyone that had to deal with a make system where dependencies were defined properly and -j couldn't be used. Or had to work with a system where incremental re-builds didn't work. Or spend half a day debugging in the bowels of a legacy build system.

Another key attribute of this kind of problem is that it is deceptively complex. Similar to how everyone tries to re-invent logging frameworks and message queue frameworks only to discover that the perfect solution is a unicorn - a white whale. The deficits in the other implementations were actually trade-offs, not architectural flaws that some inferior engineers overlooked.

My own recent experience with this topic was learning YOCTO+bitbake, and maybe similarly build root. Working with embedded systems, I was so optimistic that finally a build system came along that would wrangle the workflow of source code -> image -> flash. Could something finally provide full bi-directional dependency mapping between and image and source code? Could I look at a binary in build output and instantly discover what source went into that file, what scripts/rules created, what decided to put it in that filesystem location in the output? No. It improved many things significantly, especially when it comes to configuration management for custom Linux, but in the end you have to learn an entirely new (arbitrarily different) scripting syntax just to end up with something that is essentially as complex and daunting as a custom make-based system. Never-mind trying to set something up from scratch - it would be an entire project in itself if you didn't have the base provided by poke or the hardware manufacturer.

Anyways, build systems are a fascinating meta-topic in software engineering. My guess is that in 50 years, most software will still be built by make. And petabytes of bandwidth and megawatts of electricity per day will still be used to send "HTTP/1.1 200 OK\r\n" in ASCII plaintext as if the computer on the other end is reading the response aloud to a human being. Another tale of technical debt born of legacy compatibility and brute force compensation.

theincredulousk··on Apple pulls all customer reviews from online Apple Store
Unsurprising, given the (now very old) issue of selection/hidden-information bias in voluntary reviews. The people that are happy with the product are exponentially less likely to leave a "review" than the people that are unhappy, including outright trolls. The whole vibe that creates is not very "Apple".

In fact I'm not sure the problem has ever been "solved" - raw sample size of reviews is helpful, but nowhere near eliminates these biases.

How could it even be improved further in theory? I think you'd at least have to incorporate the number of total products sold into the review rating. If there were 10 terrible reviews on a product with 1,000,000 sold, that means something very different than one with 20 sold.

Baseline though, dealing with people, it will probably never be perfect unless the reviewers have "skin in the game". People with positive experiences need some incentive to leave reviews that is as compelling as the negative experience. Lots of Amazon sellers offer some kind of free product or coupon in their follow-up emails - maybe that works?

theincredulousk··on Apple bans vaping apps from the iOS App Store
Signaling and politics. Called it in a previous post - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20942910. If a person or entity has no skin in the game WRT a prevailing topic, but there is moral high-ground to stand on, they will get involved or form an opinion solely for the opportunity, essentially a photo-op, of them standing on that high-ground. "Protect the children" is probably the most popular high-ground used in this way.

Apple doesn't make a vaporizer, nor do vaporizing apps amount to more than a rounding error in revenue for them. Right on cue, they take the opportunity to make this token action, so that this article can be published.

It is a selfie of them standing on the high-ground; in the same way people stage a carefully framed IG post of them out "exploring" when they are actually in their backyard.

theincredulousk··on Vaping Illnesses Are Linked to Vitamin E Acetate, CDC Says
Agree with you, except the qualifier that “I certainly get all the hate against Juul”.

I certainly don’t get it. Saw the news on a TV in a bar last night, talking about the Vitamin E oil. The video clip to go along was someone using a Juul! Juul is getting conflated to be synonymous with vaping, and that is patently wrong. I guess they should be sorry for creating the best product, that so happens to be discreet enough for teenagers to hide.

theincredulousk··on Bank of America's CEO says it's saved $2B per year by building its own cloud
Boeing has made literally tens of thousands of airplanes "without trouble". One debacle doesn't mean they "can't even make an airplane".

"Space Shuttle" was rhetorical, but yeah, they could churn out a space shuttle. They could buy SpaceX and use their engineers to do it. BofA has $2.3 TRILLION in assets.

The point is you can buy expertise. It's not like a bunch of bank tellers coded up a cloud platform. Nor would you have a regional branch manager running an aerospace program. You'd hire people that know how to do those things the same as any other expert at any other company.

theincredulousk··on Bank of America's CEO says it's saved $2B per year by building its own cloud
This must be a jab, but obviously yes.

Last year they had $28 billion in net income. With that kind of money you can hire the best in the world to build literally whatever you want. They could go build a space shuttle if they felt like it - probably without much trouble.

In the unlikely situation that it didn't work, they'd pay someone else to fix it or re-do it. The least likely (albeit not unprecedented) end situation is that 'none of the things actually work'.

theincredulousk··on LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System
Supports Infiniband out of the box - neat!
theincredulousk··on Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store
That is unfortunately the essence of the issue surfacing with South Park, Blizzard, NBA, & now Apple. The Chinese market is the "wallet" and China is "voting" with it.

They have the ability to almost instantly evaporate a multi-billion dollar market. That is the kind of "wallet power" (somewhat idealistic) democratic-capitalist consumers like to think they have, but never really execute on with the same impact. This isn't defeatism on my part - things could be different - but they aren't for now.

theincredulousk··on Belgian startup Magnax has found a way to mass-produce the axial-flux motor
While an expensive option, if the advantages of an in-wheel motor were sufficient for a given application, active/magnetorheological suspension could largely compensate for it.

http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.678...

https://www.clearmotion.com/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MagneRide

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiaMpG4Y640

Further, on newer vehicles with the trend of 20inch+ rims, that is already 60-90+lbs (27-40+kg) of unsprung weight per wheel with tire. There is certainly room there for improvement to offset at least some of the motor weight.

Would have to know how much their in-wheel models would actually weigh though to determine beyond speculation if it could be reasonably compensated for in a highway vehicle.

theincredulousk··on Trump Administration Weighs Ban on Flavored E-Cigarettes
This is 100%-grass-fed, free-range, organic bullshit. How on earth could anyone, with a straight face, propose an outright ban on e-cigarettes while real cigarettes are still legal...

In public opinion, this is shaping up to be another tour-de-force showcasing the defective actors of our democracy. Starring, in order of appearance:

1 Moms that want the government to do their parenting, as the technology doesn't yet exist to Black Mirror them. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arkangel_(Black_Mirror))

2 Obnoxiously smug people that are willing to outlaw anything that doesn't affect them if there is morale high-ground to stand on

3 Corrupt politicians dressing up a power-move or money-grab in the name of protecting the children/public health

4 A recent but powerful entrant, Facebook users that have conjured degrees in both Medicine and Statistics, rapidly propagating the most poorly reasoned, common denominated, premature-birth-of-a-coherent-argument to all of their friends and family

Good times!

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
In the grand scheme of things it just isn't. 14 million rides a day, giving them a generous 1MB of data per ride, is "only" 14TB, 420TB/month. The data relevant to a ride for the clients like GPS location and ETA can fit into a few bytes...

A single video doorbell can use 200GB / month. With only 10,000 users that is 2 Petabytes of data traffic per month. Not to mention recordings that have to be stored and hosted for streaming later on.

Everything is relative (-;

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
A side-project isn't by definition irrelevant, and of course by sheer probability the engineers at those companies are, on average, going to create things that are within their area of expertise which is usually related to what the company they work at does :).

The motivations for making software OSS are varied and often strategic. For example software is often open sourced to:

* deliberately commoditize it - to eliminate competition and differentiation in that area / stack layer * leverage additional (free) testing and development. * Drive ecosystem / platform adoption * Literally free up customer budgets to be spent with them, rather than on licensing 3rd party software * Intangible benefits like community image, employee satisfaction, etc. * Some combination of above when the software is useful internally, but simply not in a market that the company wants to compete in, or a market worth their time

In any case, the point was that they are "side-projects" from a business perspective in that they cost money but don't generate revenue - the benefits are hard to quantify. Successful, stable companies have much more breathing room for strategic and the "hard to quantify" ROIs than does a company on a trajectory towards bankruptcy. It is kind of like an individual out-of-work engineer with a month's expenses left in the bank choosing to contribute to OSS instead of seeking out paid work. It is not that contributing to OSS is wrong, it is that the priorities in that situation are backwards.

RE: "Nobody is forcing Uber to employ people in California." That is entirely true, but I'm not sure what your point is. My comment is a post-mortem on what led to the layoffs. It is a priori that nobody has forced Uber to do anything that it did...

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
There was the fixed cost of developing it, and then the potential lost revenue of not selling it, similar to an opportunity cost.

If the presumption is that the software would be useful ("developed for a reason") economics suggests there is some price people would be willing to pay for it, and you forfeit that when you make it OSS. That absolutely costs something.

Sure you may not want to be in the business of commercial software (support, maintenance, ultimately just responsibility) which is a completely sane thing to avoid. However when you are bleeding money at the rate of a small country's GDP per year, avoiding opportunities to generate profit based on intangibles like community engagement can come off as ill-advised. In fact, if your company is declared bloated, it stands to reason that you should have the capacity to take on the additional overhead of selling the software. It is not that contributing to OSS is wrong, or that your points are wrong, just that there is a time and situation for this kind of strategy.

Contrast with Amazon, whose entire development of AWS was for the reasons you point out. Instead of open-sourcing it, to the extent that would be possible, they made it into a product and almost in a single move turned consistent overall loss into a massively profitable company.

So this is not at all to argue against the merits of having healthy OSS contribution at a company, but more to say that a company can't contribute to OSS if they are bankrupt - so avoiding the latter should be prioritized over the former.

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
Can't speak for OP, but I'd imagine most of the data in the system is metadata - i.e. very tiny. Sure they're moving a lot of packets, but an entire ride's data could probably fit in 100KB. If they have a million drivers active, what data do they actually need on them? Profile, GPS location, type? Few KB. Keeping the log of all rides probably takes up the most, but still, relatively small. In any case they essentially deal with small, highly compressible metadata.

Think of that vs. a company like Instragram where people are uploading probably terabytes of media content every day, and they have to maintain/host all that content to be served on-demand basically forever. This is probably a low-key reason for pushing "stories" - they get a reprieve by only having to store that for 24 hours. In any case, you're looking at orders of magnitude larger data usage in all aspects.

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
Good point - didn't think about that at all. Did you mean think before I speak, or Uber?

In any case, yeah, in that respect it is a massively shitty and unnecessary thing to do to employees. They could have easily left it as "re-structuring" without a risk of tainting the reputation of former employees.

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
Good point. I didn't have that perspective in mind so the wording was off.

My sentiment was that if a company is losing money consistently and egregiously, they are on borrowed time and a borrowed dime in very real terms as the trajectory is towards 0 - but the context is largely psychological. To your point, waste is waste. I agree wasting cash generated from profits is equivalent to wasting it from earnings.

I'd insist there is some practically relevant difference in there though.

Wasting money during a trajectory to bankruptcy creates a narrative of negligence that accelerates failure, while wasting it during a consistently profitable trajectory seems like sub-optimal management. The kind of thing that is theoretically identical, but in the real world of behavioral economics, the former seems more certain due to how easily the trajectory to failure can be estimated. The latter creates a weak narrative because of hidden information - nobody will ever know what "could have been" and so can never quantify how sub-optimal the management was.

E.g. nobody is dragging GE executives out of retirement/the grave to answer for long-term effects of sub-optimal management, and further nobody could prove at the time it was sub-optimal, only hypothesize. On the other hand, everything Elon Musk does at Tesla is torn apart and front page news, because they have a trajectory towards failure a high school student could easily calculate.

So "management's responsibility" to optimally allocate capital is sound in theory, but in the real world of imperfect and outright unknowable information, nobody ever really knows what optimal is. Sub-optimal comes to be expected as normal, but accelerating a trend towards failure is a powerful defining narrative. Somehow this matters.

theincredulousk··on Uber lays off 435 people
Probably some reality shaking out. Uber's engineering team puts out some impressive stuff, often as OSS. Their engineering blogs are regularly on HN. I've been genuinely surprised that they churn out some of these things and release them for free given their relatively extreme financial situation.

In contrast to companies like Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon etc. that have mountains of their own money to burn (rather than investors') on research and OSS side-projects, it always seemed to me that Uber was trying to play the same game, but far too early. Paying lavish SF engineer salaries to generate cool, but not revenue generating, software is probably excellent for morale, culture and recruiting, but a dubious use of resources when you are losing money seemingly faster than it would be logistically possible to literally burn it.

Saying they're ~ "culling the low performers" can be entirely true, but it is also a Silicon Valley, meritocracy-culture-friendly way of saying "we're losing far too much money to pay bloated growth-stage poaching-game salaries to engineers, so if you're not working on something that generates revenue, glhf"

theincredulousk··on Japan approves first human-animal embryo experiments
Yeah for example the super-profound and constructive top comment that just quotes the article and adds "WOW :O".

That's quality content, unlike a the South Park reference drawing a simile between serious research and the (humorously) exaggerated potential disasters of combining human DNA with other species.

Obviously the second was made by some common peasant lacking the intelligence to engage with the audience here. The first, clearly being the work of an intellectual powerhouse the likes of which we stand in awe of, has rightly collected the praise and votes they deserve.

theincredulousk··on Japan approves first human-animal embryo experiments
man-bear-pig origin story confirmed
theincredulousk··on A simulation of the insurance industry: The problem of risk model homogeneity
This entire paper and no reference to Nassim Taleb? They even use his language.

Any fans of Fooled by Randomness, Black Swan, etc.?

One of his main ideas, that he has followed up with Mathematics, is fragility to model error in the presence of fat-tails.

If you’re interested in this kind of stuff I’d highly recommend his books.

Anyone with math chops beyond mine checked out his papers? I don’t understand enough of them to endorse or critique.

theincredulousk··on Ask HN: Why are ISO standards so expensive?
TBH I think IEEE is worse than ISO. After a fairly hefty yearly membership fee, they want you to pay for individual specs that other IEEE members created???

I needed to look at a 15+ year old IEEE spec, and thought "hey I'm a member, certainly I have access to it!". Nope. They wanted like $50 from a member. For a 15+ year old spec.

I let my membership lapse after that. Just couldn't figure out a way that it was worth $250+ year.

theincredulousk··on Ask HN: Why are ISO standards so expensive?
I don't think $100 can really be considered a major roadblock to any technology professional capable of doing a standardized implementation...
theincredulousk··on Let's make them pay for using our personal data
In theory I agree, but the somewhat depressing realization is that your data is not especially valuable in and of itself. The marginal value of your data with respect to 10,000,000 other people's data is almost (but not quite) nothing. The value is in the whole.

It might work well if significantly large groups of people got together and collectively sold their data - say 100,000 or more. That would be kind of cool - "hey we are 100,000 people with X demographics and are willing to share Y data for Z dollars.

Doing it on an individual basis may be a symbolic victory, but that would likely be it. "Personal" data has a huge asymmetry in value. There is some Danny Kahneman in here somewhere - I bet people would value their own data 10x what they value a random person's at.

In my opinion people would on average refuse to sell their data individually because what it is actually worth would almost certainly be lower (probably much lower) than they'd imagine, and that sounds like it would make people sad not happy.

theincredulousk··on I/O Is Faster Than CPU – Let’s Partition Resources and Eliminate OS Abstractions [pdf]
Yes! Was surprised the paper didn't specifically mention RDMA, or to a lesser degreee SRIOV, with all their focus on NICs.

Also, there may be ongoing research, but it isn't theory at all. HPCs, HFTs, and the could providers have been leveraging RDMA for a long time - e.g. Infiniband. Doing it over Ethernet (RRoCE) is relatively new, and it isn't necessarily any big leap that is happens over 100G instead of 40 or 1.

However, an interesting point as network links go to 100G+ (esp. for RDMA) is again on the storage/processing side. E.g. a wireshark capture on a 100G connection? ~12.5 GB/second, near max bandwidth for DDR3, and can fill 64GB of RAM in about 5 seconds at full fire-hose. So again the hot-potato of bottleneck will be passed, at least for maximum sustained performance situations.

Side note, AFAIK RoCE exists mostly due to non-technical arguments, particularly the inertia created by existing familiarity and deployment of Ethernet in data centers. I think Microsoft was the one flexing on a standards-body to push it through. It is somewhat of a kludge as Ethernet wasn't designed with RDMA in mind - no guaranteed predictable latency, frames can and will disappear if switch buffers overflow, etc. So IMO "research" into the topic isn't super profound - akin to studying how your sedan might be heavily modified to go off-roading almost (but not quite) as well as a pick-up truck.

Even now many that have the luxury are just going Infiniband from the get-go if RDMA/latency are the key priorities rather than tacked on later.

theincredulousk··on Converting Merchant Ships to Missile Ships
Oh I see, so the whole weapon system including the computer systems etc.

The way the quote literally reads is that software virtualization and HPC somehow solved a physical geometry problem.

theincredulousk··on Converting Merchant Ships to Missile Ships
"Advances in high-performance computing, software virtualization [...] enable [...] cruise missiles to fit into [...] shipping containers."

Wut

theincredulousk··on Type-safe Bitmasks in C++
Defining bit values (and other externally defined magic numbers) explicitly in e.g. a defined-to-be-canonical header file (which might be just those 8 #defines) is much safer and easier to debug/maintain

I'm all for modern C++, but this is correct, at least IME with embedded systems. You're overall better off sticking with C-style if working at an abstraction level where the interface itself uses bitmasks. At this point you're manipulating memory manually which is (a) C's wheelhouse and (b) where type safety becomes largely irrelevant.

There is a lot to be said for using custom enum class implementations (e.g. http://www.drdobbs.com/when-enum-just-isnt-enough-enumeratio...) but it isn't clear to me how this kind of thing benefits bitmasks when the goal is presumably absolute maximum efficiency.

theincredulousk··on Reducing DRAM Footprint with NVM in Facebook
Thanks. I guess that still doesn't clear up why the whole article considers "Flash" and "NVM" as two distinct technologies/concepts/whatever.

Edit: even on that wikipedia page:

"The acronym NVM stands for non-volatile memory, which is often NAND flash memory"

I feel like I'm taking crazy pills here

theincredulousk··on Reducing DRAM Footprint with NVM in Facebook
Maybe this is obvious to those working with this, but did something change about what "NVM" means aside from "non-volatile memory", i.e. what "Flash" memory is? Is the assumption that "NVM" == "NVMe" or?
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →