HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wav-part

54 karma · joined October 12, 2016

submissionscomments
wav-part··on Symantec Backs Its CA
> it's a tree-structured PKI, just like the CA system, except that the top of the tree is run de jure by world governments.

Which can be solved by having bit.ly key validated by .ly key + Firefox key + LetsEncrypt key.

DNSSEC may have other architectural/mplementational faults but this property is not one of them. I believe this way of certification is the way forword for internet scale web of trust.

wav-part··on Symantec Backs Its CA
Just migrate to DNSSEC/DANE already. CAs have no incentive to mis-issue certs. CAs whole business model is selling trust. Its obvious TLDs (.com/etc) are the one who should validate/issue certs.

Regarding TLDs coming under control of Govts, Its solved by independent mirror nameservers run by app devs (Firefox/Chrome/etc) and NGOs (EFF/etc).

wav-part··on How Braintree destroyed a successful taxi startup from Serbia
I was more thinking about non-profit's own payment network over cc & others.

Fraud can be solved by making each irreversible txn ratable. Each seller can choose to make sum of all ratings and txn over some period public to appear more trustworthy. The algo can be more tweaked but txn rating is the gist.

wav-part··on How Braintree destroyed a successful taxi startup from Serbia
True. My point was that profit motivation of banks should not be an issue.
wav-part··on How Braintree destroyed a successful taxi startup from Serbia
It would have been true if there were not so many networks (SWIFT, VISA, MasterCard, Paypal, Braintree, Google Wallet, Apple Pay, ...). Judging by the increasing number of networks It can only be concluded that its not so hard. Only non profit can put stop to this mess.
wav-part··on How Braintree destroyed a successful taxi startup from Serbia
Payment Processing/Network is the most innovation-less thing IMO. But still there is not a non-profit leader. Why ?
wav-part··on How Uber Used Secret “Greyball” Tool to Deceive Authorities Worldwide
Manipulation != Coercion.

Yes both are problems but libertarianism claims to solve only one of those. For the other one, if you are unable, follow/place-your-trust-on someone else. There is no need to solve one problem by creating bigger problem.

wav-part··on How Uber Used Secret “Greyball” Tool to Deceive Authorities Worldwide
No. Notice the word "voluntary". From libertarian point of view, Socialism is ok if you voluntary opt-in. Voluntary/Consent is central point in libertarianism.
wav-part··on FCC weakens net neutrality rule in a prelude to larger rollbacks
Is not net-neutrality better handled by IANA ? If you are going to call your router "internet", you must treat all IP packets equally. Seems like reasonable terms to me. Afterall this is the property that made Internet what it is today.
wav-part··on India rupee ban: Snapdeal to deliver cash
A very detailed survey regarding the demonetisation though slightly judgemental.

https://decipherdemon.blogspot.in/2016/12/a-monumental-disat...

wav-part··on India rupee ban: Snapdeal to deliver cash
What troubles me more is, How did they come to ban-notes as conclusion considering the economy is mostly underground/decentrealized (ie they dont/cant have the data).

(Observation) India is highly decentralized/resilient. In India, Govt is just a thing. People dont pay much mind to it. They minimize interaction with Govt and bear it when they have to. But this time I think Govt overdid it.

wav-part··on India rupee ban: Snapdeal to deliver cash
http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/who-knew-pm-narendra-modis-bl...

> Prime Minister Narendra Modi handpicked a trusted bureaucrat, little known outside India's financial circles, to spearhead a radical move to abolish 86 percent of the country's cash overnight and take aim at the huge shadow economy.

> Hasmukh Adhia, the bureaucrat, and five others privy to the plan were sworn to utmost secrecy, say sources with knowledge of the matter. They were supported by a young team of researchers working in two rooms at Prime Minister Modi's residence, as he plotted his boldest reform since coming to power in 2014.

> It was made up of young experts in data and financial analysis; some ran Prime Minister Modi's social media accounts and a smartphone app that he used to solicit public feedback.

wav-part··on Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires can't fix local poverty
> In general libertarian thought, the government enforces contracts between private parties.

> Okay... So tomorrow, USG offers you an explicit contract by which remaining on its property (eg inside its borders), you agree to follow its detailed code incorporated by reference (currently called "laws"), as interpreted by its courts. You have a year to decide. At the end of the year, do you agree to this contract or do you leave?

If USG is the government then this is not libertarianism. If USG is corporation (ie private party) who is the LG then ? The world ?

Lets say LG=World then is it USG the land owner ? I think not, so I dont have to leave if I own a land.

> In Libertarian thought, following contracts is a moral requirement.

Even in LG, you may have contacts of any scope but the contract with the LG would be very minimal. USC is not a libertarian constitution.

> My entire point here is to help US-thinking libertarians avoid falling into the trap where their philosophy is bastardized to justify replacing government with all-powerful corporations.

This does not follow from the fact that LG enforces private contracts. Its still upto you whether or not to sign away your freedoms.

Nonetheless, Libertarianism would be big improvement from current state, and only slightly less from AnCap.

wav-part··on Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires can't fix local poverty
> There can also be a perfect LG that simply enforces the contract you signed with USG,

Thats not possible. LG would only enforce its own very minimal, objective & limited constitution. As a corporation within LG, USG would have to make USC enforcable without help from LG.

> or you can just imagine dutifully holding yourself to the contract.

Only if its in my interest to do so.

> If you sign the contract and stay, how would your basic situation differ from what it currently is

Its not. I am probably missing something, mind writing the whole question in one form again ?

wav-part··on Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires can't fix local poverty
> I assume you really mean non-aggressive

Yes.

> Except we've moved the boundaries such that USG is non-aggressive (domestically, at least) - you've merely assented to a contract that says you will not use drugs, or USG will have the right to imprison you

No, In Libretarian Land no one has right to imprison anyone for any reason whatsoever. This is a simple objective contract and I expect unanimous consent.

But you can also have have two Lands one support giving up of this particular freedom as part of contract and one simply outlaws it. More choices the better (which also means few govts being true socialist states, is ok). Let the market decide.

> For example, you're actually implying these approaches are inapplicable because USG is not a corporation!

You would not need this with Libertarian Government (LG) because LG would be very minimal and limited. Even if LG does a bait-and-switch (possible) other LGs/Govts can trade war. I should point out I dont support there be one global LG but numerous smaller LGs. Depending on one single entity is risky irregardless of its intentions.

> At the end of the year, do you agree to this contract or do you leave?

Lets say I sign it. After 5 years relocate to another country B. Then USG claims I owe them citing the signed USC. But for USC to be enforcable, B also have to consent to it. That is, I dont pay just because I signed the contract but because the consequences would be worse if I dont.

wav-part··on Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires can't fix local poverty
> Would you feel better by just viewing USG as a corporation with a contract that you continue to consent to by not having left?

Yes I agree.

So lets assume we have someone who has monopoly on land (like USG) and who is non-violent (unlike USG). How do solve this: Trade Sanctions/Non Cooperation. Bitcoin is a similar development.

> The straightforward response is that a contract to use a road should be scope-constrained to the topic of road usage, and not say also preclude you from using drugs on your own property.

Agreed.

> But that's no longer as simple and universal as a belief in unlimited contracts.

Existence of unlimited contracts does not imply one have to agreed to one unreasonably. That is, think before agreeing to a contract (and arbitrator).

Also note the contract to remove unlimited contracts would (probably) be unlimited itself.

wav-part··on Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires can't fix local poverty
No. It means small compititors band together to compete against the market leader.
wav-part··on Silicon Valley's prosperity paradox: 76000 millionaires can't fix local poverty
> (as there is no difference between a totalitarian government from an all-owning all-contracting corporation), even though they're easily tricked into condoning them.

Law works because everyone concent and choose to follow it. If you have such single non-violent corporation then there is nothing stops from people to just walk away.

wav-part··on Apple’s rotten appeal
> Yeah, sorry, Libertarianism is more like a religion than a system of governance.

Though I support Libertarianism, my post was not about it. I am saying, 10 small socialist nations > 1 big socialist nation. 10 small Apple > 1 big Apple. My point is big state or corporation is risky and can abuse their powers. We have anti-competition organisations for corporations. We should have for states too. If people of a region wants to secede out of a socialist/capitialist/etc regime we should all support.

> Leaving everything to the "free market" just frees those who already have wealth and power

No not just weathly but _everyone_.

> to do whatever they want and shackles the rest of us

Like, maybe, all Libertarians, I support non violence. I dont see how that would happen.

> who's only power at the moment is our vote

Vote is not power. The elected may have powers. But not voters. A widespread misunderstanding.

Vote in exchange for personal freedom only favours elected & friends. People are now realizing this.

> (and even that has been eroded over the last 40 years.)

Yes the world is correcting itself. Vote is not a power. Its productiveness or how useful/neccessery you are to others. To gain productivity you need freedom, thats what I advocate for.

> You do get told what your tax money will be used for.

Thats not really same as Apple wooing me for iPhone.

> Constantly. If you choose not to pay attention and choose not to vote, that's on you.

I am from India and I voted for Modi. I have never felt more cheated than now. Look at what a circus India is now. If thats not a case for Libertarianism/Microstates I dont know what is.

wav-part··on Apple’s rotten appeal
And like other comments have suggested. You cant sue for following the laws. If EC/EU does not like laws then change the laws. If EU does not like Ireland laws then kick Ireland out. But holding 13B euros hostage cannot be tolerated.
wav-part··on Apple’s rotten appeal
If you want my money you have to tell me what I am getting otherwise its just extortion. You could argue that state sell market access (which is perfectly ok) then yes its ok for states to compete.

> they pay taxes because we all have to pay taxes to do the things we want to do

What others do with their money is not my business.

> (provide education for our kids, have a police force to deal with crime, build and maintain bridges and roads, etc.)

I would argue that it does not cost that much and the services/goods being discuessed are _extremely_ overpriced. And the price does not just include money but personal freedoms.

But ofcourse how would we know that its overpriced. Hence why I suggest compitition between states is good thing and should be encouraged or It might be you who become the next target for majority's whim and then nowhere to go.

I am not judging people who want to live under socialism/capitalism/any-ism. I am just saying more choices/compitition is better for everyone.

Also read Private Cities [1].

[1] https://fee.org/articles/private-cities-a-path-to-liberty/

wav-part··on Apple’s rotten appeal
Replace

    Tax Heavens --> Compitition
    states --> corporations
    corporations --> customers
Do you see any problem ?
wav-part··on Apple’s rotten appeal
This sounds like dispute between Ireland and EU. Please remind me why is Apple dragged into this ? Specifically laws.

There is also the concern of how 13B Euros of Apple will-be/have-been seized/escrowed for the duration of the case which may takes years. In case EC loses, will EC/EU pay to Apple for temporary loss of their property ?

wav-part··on The Story of Apple's $14B Tax Bill
IMHO, Taxes (or market access/safety-of-life etc) are absurdely overpriced. We are seeing market-competition. And I for one welcome it, like any other competition.

I dont know whats "fair" and I dont care. I want things as cheap as possible.

wav-part··on The Story of Apple's $14B Tax Bill
> Though Apple will have to pay its tax bill within weeks, the money will be held in escrow, and the issue will probably take years to be resolved.

Am I the only one outraged by this ? There is no guarntee your money is safe. You hire tax advisors. You go as far as to get confirmation from Finance Minister. Its apparently not enough. This level of legal uncertainity is just insane.

wav-part··on Getting Rid of Comments on Vice.com
This has much simpler solution: user tagging. I think Reddit Enhancement Suite has it. I am working on a C Reddit/HN client (basically RES on steroids) that would implement these user remebering features such as usertags, usersets, bad/good users, total_upvote/downvotes_given_to_a_user etc.
wav-part··on Saudi Arabia adopts the Gregorian calendar
I would guess: Every non-appointed visit is successful.
wav-part··on Saudi Arabia adopts the Gregorian calendar
I get what you are saying.

1. Time should decrease to indicate the importance of it.

2. One should sync with attention span rather than something arbitrary like hour.

The idea is that, the number should not be so large (like min) that it becomes a spam. It should not be so low either that you lose track of time. Sync-ing is expensive.

I like this clock: (D, W, M, Y) measures 3hr chunck left in the (Day, Week, Month, Year).

> In my ideal world things like dentist visits would be completely asynchronous.

For stuff like this there is no need to keep track of time at all. Just set a reminder.

wav-part··on Native people are left poor as tech world takes lithium from under their feet
Hence Private Arbitration/Investor-state dispute settlement.
wav-part··on Native people are left poor as tech world takes lithium from under their feet
> particularly in criminal law there a wide variety of punishments to "make an example" to deter others from similar conduct, with little effort to make the punishments uniform.

Its uncertainity intended by law itself. All abided parties are most likely comfortable with it. No one would rely on this certainity.

Put it simply, You cant expect more certainity than the contract/law itself defines.

> If you have to go back and discuss the terms then there's already been a loss of trust; the courts are just there to pick up the pieces.

The loss of trust is exactly the scenarios where contracts are most useful. The contract would most likely have cancellation clause, which means it should terminate expectedly without any suprises assuming contract itself is objective (That is, It should not grant uncertainity like criminal laws).

So "Natives getting fixed amount in return for Li mining" is an example of objective contract.

← PreviousPage 5 of 8Next →