HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wcarey

494 karma · joined August 26, 2010

submissionscomments
wcarey··on An Atonement of Nano
A wonderful use case for nano is introducing students who have never used a command line before to unix. You can teach a classroom of students to edit files in nano productively in a single 45 minute class period, which means that an introduction to programming class can move very quickly into actual programming. If your goal is to have student produce a working program on day one of class, nano is a godsend.

By then end of a semester, the students will be running into the ceiling of nano as an editor and you can tell them about other more featureful editors.

wcarey··on Kids might be digital natives – but a study shows they aren’t computer literate
In the high school computer programming class I teach we use headless Debian on a Raspberry Pi. The idea that you can rename files, move them, and organize them is mind blowing to about a third of the students. When I ask how they organize their school files, they either use Google Docs for everything (all in one folder) or, if they use Word, they have one folder with all their documents named, "New Document", "New Document (1)", "New Document (2)", &c. When I teach them Chemistry as juniors and insist that they use a spreadsheet (or general purpose programming language) for their complex problem sets, about 90% of them have never seen a spreadsheet before. We now have the "talk" with our juniors about backups, as more than one has lost their entire junior thesis because it was stored on their laptop and nowhere else.

It's frustrating that we spent decades developing fantastic tools to help ourselves with all sorts of intellectual work, and have more or less abandoned teaching people to use them well.

As the tower of abstraction has gotten taller, there's a temptation to teach near the shiny end; ML for high school! But that leaves students with huge gaps in their understanding of how things work under the hood, which impairs their ability to connect what they learn and build on it.

wcarey··on 1938 vs. 1940 (2018)
It's a daft idea that we would have been forced to sue for peace had we lost Hawaii.

Japan certainly did not have the logistical capability to take and hold Hawaii (Morison and Toll agree on this point) at any point in the war, so I'm suspicious of the argument that Midway was decisive. It represented one instance in a chain of many of Japan's fixation on the decisive battle. Guadalcanal, on the other hand, represents the American strategic fixation on continuous pressure and attrition. When the United States fought the battles Japan wanted to fight, we won (repeatedly; Midway, Philippine Sea, and Leyte). When Japan fought the battles the United States wanted to fight, they lost repeatedly. That suggests that none of the battles themselves were decisive, rather the strategic concepts of the respective nations.

Anthony Tully does a nice job demonstrating how absolutely screwed the Japanese were whatever the outcome of Midway: http://www.combinedfleet.com/economic.htm

wcarey··on Nearly half of adult Canadians struggle with literacy
How would price discovery operate on externalities? Who decides what's an externality? It seems like you're suggesting centralized planning under a different name.
wcarey··on The Parity of Zero
Right - I was aiming for something analogous to your rule, which has the condition of even inputs. I do prefer your simpler example. Either way, I'm not sure your rhetorical strategy would be persuasive to someone who was unsure of the parity of zero (because, as you say, zero is an exceptional number).
wcarey··on The Parity of Zero
I think the phenomenon you're describing is definitely real, and definitely worth thinking about. There is signal in your poll about parity, but there's a lot of noise there too. Figuring our what the signal is is very hard.

You're writing isn't elitist here, but I think it moves very quickly up the ladder of stasis in an unjustified way (https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/the_writing_proce...).

At my school we've been trying to sort out this phenomenon for about five years, and we're still wrangling at the stasis of definition, with understanding the nature of what we see in our students. An example:

After I teach imaginary numbers, I give my students an (ungraded) assessment with these questions:

1. Please circle the imaginary numbers in this list. (about half imaginary)

2. Please perform the following multiplications. (mixed; about half imaginary x imaginary)

3. What is the definition of an imaginary number?

4. In your answers to question two, please circle all the products that are themselves imaginary numbers.

5. Is the product of two imaginary numbers imaginary? Why or why not?

We've never explicitly discussed #5, but its answers flows necessarily from the previous answers. What I'm really interested in is whether the answer to #5 is coherent with the answers to the previous four questions. I'd say for about a third of students it is not. For example, a student correctly wrote that i * i = -1, and correctly identified -1 as not imaginary, but then said for #5, "Yes. Because when you multiply two imaginary numbers it doesn't become unimaginary."

We see that play out in essentially every subject, and it's gotten much more prevalent in the last, say, ten years. It's especially noticeable in our 8th grade formal logic class, where a meaningful fraction of students appear unable to reason propositionally or syllogistically at all.

We have some ideas about what's driving the change, but are still trying to figure out which of them are correct and what we can do about it. My personal theory is it's something to do with syntax and semantics, with some students not associating meaning with words in the way that one would expect. It's so hard to extract signal from the noise about that though.

wcarey··on The Parity of Zero
A counter argument to you approach: If I multiply two positive integers by one another is the result always greater than either integer? Turns out there is one exception to that rule. Does it serve a purpose? How do you know?
wcarey··on The Parity of Zero
Indeed. And Euclid’s definition of evenness (Def VII.6) applies only to numbers, which for Euclid excludes both 0 and 1. So there’s at least one vaguely axiomatic formulation of number theory where the correct answer is probably “neither because it’s not the sort of object to which you can predicate evenness or oddness”.
wcarey··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
1. Well, I just told you about them. It's old fashioned, but talking to people works wonders. You're not the first person I've encouraged to go directly to legal documents.

2. Probably the median person uses several -- google, facebook, and the like.

wcarey··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
How, even in principle, would google prevent a person from seeing legal documents? Most (all?) jurisdictions publish them on the web themselves? https://www.courtlistener.com/ is great.
wcarey··on Hemingway Editor
Incorrectly. It mistakes non-passive constructions for passive. For example, "The sailors are spent." is marked as passive despite not containing an action verb. It looks like it's just regexing on forms of "to be" followed by words ending in "ed" (perhaps also using a dictionary of some irregulars)?
wcarey··on Hemingway Editor
The difficulty, of course, is that clarity is primarily a function of ideas and meaning, and ideas and meaning are totally opaque to tools like this. For example, no complaints about this sentence:

> The poets breach the digestives by moatbutt every Thur.

And if I change the sentence to:

> The poets breach the digestives by moatbutt every Thurs.

it tells me my reading level has changed from 7th to 8th grade despite Thurs being a much more common shortening of "Thursday" than "Thur", which is nonsense. God forbid such tools ever be used with young students.

wcarey··on Hemingway Editor
Quite so. I suppose I lament the idea that you can become a good writer whilst shortcutting reading a large corpus of good literature. There are many ancillary benefits to reading good literature, and losing them makes education as formation that much harder.

It's a much more important example of the phenomenon that children who are glued to phones or movies on long car trips instead of playing the license plate game are missing out on some implicit geographical education.

wcarey··on Hemingway Editor
My particular objections to people being made machine like are rooted in a Christian conception of the inherent worth of humans as being made in the image of God (who is not a machine). Being machine-like impedes our progress towards our telos.
wcarey··on Hemingway Editor
I suppose I haven't given up on the idea that all of us can aim at being more fully human. You might be able to put together a sentence of that caliber! Particularly if you read a large corpus of great writing.

The worry is that young writers will become more machine-like in their thoughts, as part of a broader project to make people more machine like. For example, Google Docs complained to me that the sentence, "We will analyze the ballistics of the South Dakota, focusing on parameterizing the equations of motion" was incorrect because you don't put "the" in front of the name of a state. But I was talking about BB-57, the USS South Dakota, a battleship. Google Docs, naturally, doesn't have a sense of historical context.

I'm no great writer, to be sure, but the computer just doesn't understand what I mean, so it flags my thoughts as being wrong in some way. That smoothing out our thoughts is a long-term problem if our goal is to lead human lives, particularly as it makes it into education.

wcarey··on Hemingway Editor
The trend towards using syntactic machines to teach people to write perplexes me because writing is foremost about meaning. For example, the Gettysburg address begins:

> Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated, can long endure.

Hemingway flags that as passive voice, but it's actually a present progressive construction. Rather than computers making us more fully human, they strive to make us more machine like, and that's a worry.

wcarey··on Photos from inside a Typhoon class submarine
Even the much smaller submarines in the second world war where space was at extreme premium carried a fairly complete machine shop.
wcarey··on Ask HN: Good C++ code bases to read?
GDAL - https://www.osgeo.org/projects/gdal/ - is a nice codebase that features lots of hooks for extensibility, is relatively performant, and handles the sorts of complex data and algorithms you might encounter in SDR.
wcarey··on Free Software Is More Reliable (2011)
Battle for Wesnoth might be a counterexample to your argument about games: http://wesnoth.org It's an open source video game that's of high quality with good user experience, developed by lots of folks over a long period of time and available on many platforms.
wcarey··on Trump’s Taxes Show Chronic Losses and Years of Income Tax Avoidance
In particular, because the President is the source of classification authority, the oversight functions that would normally be fulfilled by financial disclosures on forms like the SF-86 have traditionally been fulfilled by the electorate. The financial disclosures are part of the process of ensuring that people entrusted with national security information are "reliable, trustworthy, of good conduct and character, and loyal to the U.S." Candidates releasing their tax returns is a (less rigorous) process aimed at the same thing.
wcarey··on What Is Math?
Those rules too exhibit cross-language conceptual shear. For example, English doesn't really have an equivalent of Latin's subjunctive mood, and our clause boundary system is way weaker. We use punctuation marks in a way that the Romans didn't (they used punctuation words in a much more systematic way than we do). Greek has a separate grammatical number for pairs of things as opposed to our singular and plural. Those rules, in addition to the individual words (perhaps) bespeak a different way of conceptualizing the world.
wcarey··on What Is Math?
Interestingly, much of what you describe is present in old mathematical texts. For example, Fibonacci's Liber Abaci is essentially a long succession of story problems. Diophantus's Arithmetic is a succession of concrete problems -- no story -- but it's concrete prior to abstract as you suggest.

Euclid II also develops most of Algebra geometrically, so there's much conversion between shape and symbol baked it. His method of computing the product of binomials is far superior to what's commonly taught.

So there's a good tradition of the thing you're looking for!

wcarey··on What Is Math?
It's less clear in informal languages that concepts exist apart from the language to describe them. This is one of the great difficulties in translation; different languages conceptualize the world in different (and sometimes incompatible) ways. For example, Latin has a variety of words for relationships of power that don't convey cleanly into English. The Greek word λόγος also doesn't cleanly render in English. Similarly for much of the Tao Te Ching. To what extent our language shapes our conceptualization of the world is currently an open question, but it seems like it's at least some.
wcarey··on Apple Terminates Epic Games' Developer Account
What would that look like? How could Apple ensure that subscriptions made through a third party payment processor are cancelable without dark patterns?
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
It seems like you've moved from a position of "way more harm is done by protecting people than allowing freedoms" to "more harm is done by allowing Apple to do as they wish; we need protection from that", despite Apple being a subset of "people".

And the "more of us than them" suggests that rather than any principled approach, you advocate something like the mob rule that the Athenians described to the Melians: the strong do what they will and the weak suffer what they must. Fair enough. That position has been common enough throughout history. Right now lots of people appear to like the way Apple is running their company. Does that make it right? You seem to think no, but are articulating reasons why you should think yes. That's perplexing to me.

I'm trying to make sense of what I think about the disagreement between Apple and Epic. I'm not sure. The arguments people are making against Apple so far seem unsuccessful and problematic to me. I think the collective bargaining argument I've cautiously advanced might make some sense.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
Perhaps an opportunity to cultivate some empathy and listen carefully to people whose relationship with computational devices is very different from yours. Telling people that their concerns are imaginary isn't a good way to persuade them.

I know people who break from what you call the practical options in both directions -- some who reject smartphones altogether and live their lives without them, doing all their digital work on computers that they have full control over -- and some who use only the stock apps on their phone and wish that app stores were not a thing. They want an entirely managed experience.

Neal Stephenson's essay In the Beginning was the Command Line gets at some of this nicely. Some people are, as he says, Eloi and some Morlocks. That's OK.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
You've made a compelling argument that Apple should be allowed to, in their freedom, do whatever they feel appropriate with regard to their own App store. The we each can make the right choice about whether or not we as individuals should do business with them. We should allow them that freedom. I'm convinced!
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
I'm not convinced the problems are larger (or, at least, not that they're larger for most people; some people are seriously inconvenience by Apple's policies. I once hit a hard roadblock trying to develop something for the iPhone and had to switch to Android exclusive development; so it goes). And I think having different organizations exploring different tradeoffs in this space is a valuable thing. There are platforms that are more open that Apples and platforms less open. That variety is healthy.
wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
That's good - we've moved from no harm to a balancing competing harms, which I think reflects the reality of the situation.

There's a spectrum of what you're allowed to do software-wise with various computing devices you purchase.

One the one extreme, you have something like a washing machine. It's a computing device running a particular suite of software that is essentially impossible for the end user to modify or replace. Many (most?) embedded systems are like this.

On the other extreme, you've got open hardware platforms like the Arduino where you can do whatever you want with the software for a very large value of "whatever you want".

The Raspberry Pi is in the middle, but very close to the Arduino. A Nintendo is somewhere in the middle but close do the dishwasher. Android devices are somewhere in the middle, but closer to the Arduino than the dishwasher (though this varies between devices and manufacturers). iOS devices are, again, somewhere in the middle. Much is allowed. Some things are not. OS X devices are closer to the Arduino than iOS devices are. That's also an intentional choice by Apple.

The placement of iOS along that spectrum is an intentional choice by Apple that customers have proven to support by buying iOS devices in prodigious quantity.

It's not obvious to me that taking a market leading choice in that spectrum and removing it produces less harm in the balance. It might, but it also might not. I'd be inclined to let people vote with their wallet as long as viable alternatives abound, which they do.

wcarey··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
That's a real possibility, and part of the greater tradeoff that happens with most technolgies: as they grow more powerful society applies more controls to them to prevent their ill use. Drunken horse riding is less regulated than drunken driving is less regulated than drunken nuclear submarine driving.

Happily, there's already a thriving ecosystem of alternate linux-based platforms that allow the sort of freedom that we both want and enjoy.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →