HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wilburTheDog

233 karma · joined October 9, 2013

submissionscomments
wilburTheDog··on Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook
>Just stop letting them buy their competitors.

And how would you stop them from simply replacing their competitors? From the article "Budding companies that resist being acquired are pruned through flagrant copying." Would you pass a law that said Facebook can't expand their business to do anything a competitor is doing? I can't see how that would fly.

wilburTheDog··on Facebook banned me for life because I help people use it less
I don't use facebook. I never plan to use facebook. What's stopping me from publishing Unfollow Everything myself? What standing would Facebook have to sue me for publishing a chrome extension?
wilburTheDog··on Decomplication: How to Find Simple Solutions to “Hard” Problems (2016)
It sounds you're saying the article was oversimplifying complex problems because in the real world it's not so easy to just eat less/better and move more to loose weight. I think you may be missing the distinction he was making between simple and easy. I think fundamentally the problem of loosing weight is not particularly complex[1]. But for many people it is quite hard to do. We may have psychological issues with choosing the right foods, we may have other things we want or need to do instead of exercising, there could be many things that make it hard to do the things we need to to be healthy. And because it's hard for us we are vulnerable to someone selling us an 'easy' solution.

Of course, solving our psychological issues, or finding the time or willpower to exercise, or making the money to buy healthy food or the time to cook it are all different problems. And those problems can be quite complex.

1. This recent HN discussion goes into it in more detail. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28597975

wilburTheDog··on I Don't Understand This (Yet)
In the first case the request worked when executed in Postman but failed when executed from a browser, which said it was a CORS error. Using the logs we traced it up to the authorization step in APIG, which wasn't being executed (because auth header was required to execute it) and so wasn't generating logs. And that's where I was stumped, because it was not a part of my mental model that request headers could disappear between client and APIG. We eventually realized the browser uses the proxy and postman doesn't, so we asked the networking group and they admitted they were removing the auth header in the proxy.

Regardless of the details this is one of those situations I wasn't able to solve by just thinking about it. If I had a 'debugger' that could step through these API requests it would have been much easier to figure this one out. I don't know enough about OpenTelemetry to say if it would have helped or not.

wilburTheDog··on I Don't Understand This (Yet)
I think this is very true. The most vexing problems I've run into lately have all been because something is going wrong in a step I don't have much control over. Like in one case the proxy was stripping out the Authorization header for PUT requests (seriously). Or in another the corporate-signed certs used by all the on-prem systems weren't validating on AWS because they don't have a valid root cert. I really wish I had a "debugger" that could trace the interconnections between all the systems my app depends on.
wilburTheDog··on I Don't Understand This (Yet)
>Rob Pike of golang fame noted that while he reached for the debugger first thing, Ken Thompson would ignore what Rob was doing and just stand and think. Then after a while he'd say: "I know what's wrong" and very often be right.

I feel like this is not a helpful take on debugging for most of us. I'm certainly not as good at this as Ken Thompson, and very seldom is the problem space simple enough that I can hold a complete mental model of it in my head. Instead I reach for the debugger to collect more data on what's going on. And I can usually find the issue by looking a lot faster than I can correctly theorize about it.

In Debugging by Davig J. Agans, his third rule is "Quit thinking and look". And I tend to agree. In the majority of cases when I'm debugging a problem the solution only reveals itself when I see that missing piece of information.

EDIT: As others have rightly pointed out, if I wrote the code I've already thought about it and have a mental model of what I wrote. And yes, I do think about what could be causing the problem. I guess it's those cases where I think it should be working in a certain way, but it isn't, where I find it most valuable to stop thinking and look. And usually in those cases I either have an incorrect or incomplete model, or I wrote something that didn't match what I was thinking.

wilburTheDog··on Fairphone 4
I've had my pixel 2 for almost four years and I'm still perfectly content with it. Google, however, stopped supporting it after 3 years. The 5 year support guarantee fairphone provides looks really appealing to me. The fact that it's user-serviceable is also a nice bonus.

It's a pity it's not available in the US.

wilburTheDog··on Teletransportation Paradox
I read it like this. Alice gets in the machine and creates ten new copies of her. Each of them thinks they are Alice. Are they all right? If so what does the concept of 'me' or 'self' actually mean? Are you a unique individual? Do you have (or are you) a soul or something that exists independently of the arrangement of atoms that makes up your body? Or is your identity and sense of self completely the result of the way the neurons between your ears are connected?

I think this kind of question is particularly important to people brought up with strong religious beliefs.

wilburTheDog··on I ruin developers’ lives with my code reviews and I'm sorry
>Stop being an asshole, and find non-assholes to work with.

I think the process of realizing he needs to do that and doing it is what he's describing in his article. Generally people don't open up about how their behavior is toxic unless they recognize it as a problem. And, though my experience with Russian culture is limited, I understand that competitiveness and criticism is the rule, at least in the STEM fields there. So this guy has been behaving the same way (most) everyone else does, but now he's realizing it's bad and trying to fix himself. I don't think he deserves the criticism he's getting in the comments here. We all start somewhere, and trying to improve should always be encouraged.

wilburTheDog··on Humility is undersung leadership skill
I look for two things when I'm interviewing someone for a developer position. One, can they think logically enough to write a couple simple example problems in code (fizzbuzz level stuff). And two, do they clam up or try to bullshit me when they don't know the answer to a question, or do they just admit they don't know it. For me, just being able to comfortably say you don't know how to answer my question means you are humble enough to work on my team.
wilburTheDog··on A Compass for the Politics of Collapse

  I think, no matter how hard you try, you can't produce something like this without it being biased toward your own opinions on the topic.  And those of us with different opinions would phrase things differently.  I suppose I would fit in his Pessimist/Defeatist category, though I wouldn't call it that.  (And I guess deniers wouldn't call themselves deniers either.)  I would probably refer to my own take on collapse as depressive realism rooted in observations of climate change.  As one observation, take the latest IPCC report.

  U.N. Secretary-General, António Guterres described the latest IPCC report as "a code red for humanity." "The alarm bells are deafening, and the evidence is irrefutable: greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel burning and deforestation are choking our planet and putting billions of people at immediate risk," Guterres said. [1]

  The more you look the worse it gets.  We aren't going to be able to reduce atmospheric CO2 without some sort of drastic uncomfortable change.  The lockdowns during the pandemic reduced emissions by about 17% at one point.  But despite that, CO2 in the atmosphere continued to increase.  Whatever we do has to be more drastic than the pandemic lockdowns, and permanent, or it will keep getting worse.  I just don't see people being willing to go along with that, especially those of us in comfortable Western societies.  I don't know, is that pessimism, defeatism, or realism?


[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/09/ipcc-report-un-climate-repor...
wilburTheDog··on Myths about how the brain works
The question has been debated longer than the shrine has been around. See: Ship of Theseus.
wilburTheDog··on 'Rent-a-person who does nothing' in Tokyo receives endless requests, gratitude
I think there is another level to what this guy is doing that's hard to see if you just believe what he says about himself on its face. I feel like to be able to listen to and or be with someone while they do whatever and have no judgement, criticism, or suggestion requires you to have a very high level of Zen. I would probably want to correct or assist or do something in most situations. He's operating on the level of a therapist. But it's hard for people to admit sometimes that they need a therapist. There is a stigma and a feeling like there is something wrong with you that you have to get over just to ask for a therapist. This guy skips over all of that resistance by having, by all appearances, no ego at all. He's saying 'I don't have any skills so I can't possibly criticize you'. But having no skills doesn't stop most people from making suggestions or being critical. He is providing high value assistance to people and presenting himself in such a humble way that it's easy to ask for his help.
wilburTheDog··on A nameless hiker and the case the internet can’t crack
Last time I moved I gave USPS a change of address to a PO Box. Then, after updating all the important ones I forgot, I let it expire six months later. I'm still getting junk mail at my new address, but some of the more annoying ones have lost track of me.
wilburTheDog··on AI writing code will make software engineers more valuable
I think that's unavoidable. There is always a level at which your understanding of your tools gets fuzzy and incomplete. Do you understand everything about what your compiler is doing? Your OS? Your could provider? The hardware any of them are running on? The majority of us are standing on the shoulders of the few that do understand those things and provide them to us to use.

And if you mean that we would not understand what the software we write is doing to produce the result it does, aren't we already there with machine learning?

wilburTheDog··on On Behalf of Environmentalists, I Apologize for the Climate Scare
It appears the author wants to convince us of his credentials as a progressive and then use any good will that generates to try and persuade us that environmentally progressive ideas are wrong. He claims we have been 'badly misinformed' by people with 'unsavory or unhealthy motivations'. But this synopsis of his book makes it look like it could have been written by a coalition of lobbyists from the meat and nuclear industries. Who are we to trust?

Also I think it's interesting that the only positive review he includes is from Richard Rhodes. I have never read anything from Richard Rhodes, but the second amazon review of his book Energy: A Human History has this to say 'the author is highly skeptical about renewable sources like wind and solar, waxing instead about the lost promise of nuclear'.

wilburTheDog··on U.S. field hospitals stand down, most without treating any Covid-19 patients
I think that until we get everyone tested we aren't going to know the real fatality rate. Some portion of people, perhaps larger than we expect, experience this virus as a cold that passes normally. Some people never even realize they have it. Until we have tested everyone and know for sure how many people have it asymptomatically that fatality rate is likely an overestimate and we can't really know by how much.
wilburTheDog··on To get good, go after the metagame
Charles Ellis wrote a book(1) about that. He asserts that any professional sports competition is a winner's game - you win by successfully executing difficult plays and being better than your competition. But amateur sports is usually a loser's game - you win by not making as many mistakes as your competition. The book is about finance but the observation is universal.

1. https://www.amazon.com/Winning-Losers-Game-6th-Strategies/dp...

wilburTheDog··on Sir David Attenborough: Climate change 'our greatest threat'
A few things to consider on the topic.

It is estimated that there is, on average, a ten year lag between the time CO2 is emitted and the time its maximum effect is felt in the climate. Some estimate the lag can be even longer. So we haven't yet seen the worst of the ~36GtCO2/yr we've been releasing into the air for the last ten years or so.(1)

Methane is a much stronger greenhouse gas than CO2.(2) And it is at the heart of one of the positive feedback loops we have started by warming the earth. The arctic permafrost contains a difficult to estimate but staggeringly large amount (in the Gigatons) of methane, both in the form of methane hydrates (frozen methane) and stored carboniferous materials which, when no longer frozen, are quickly turned into methane by bacteria.(3) At this point existing warming of the planet has progressed to the point that there is no way to stop a massive arctic methane release.(4) And, in fact, if you look at the recent satellite data(5) you will see that the methane levels at most layers of the atmosphere are higher than the satellite instruments are capable of measuring.

And reducing our emissions may make things worse. The Aerosol Masking Effect (aka global dimming) is what scientists are calling the fact that sulfur and other pollutants in the air can reflect sunlight away from the earth and cool the planet.(6) If we stopped all CO2 emissions today the global temperature would rapidly rise as the aerosols fell from the atmosphere.

There's a lot more, but I'm feeling too much anxiety about this to go on.

1. http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/10/3/031...

2. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-bad-of-a-gree...

3. https://envisionation.co.uk/index.php/nick-breeze/203-subsea...

4. https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2785/unexpected-future-boost-o...

5. https://www.ospo.noaa.gov/Products/atmosphere/soundings/iasi...

6. https://arstechnica.com/science/2016/03/our-aerosol-emission...

wilburTheDog··on Sir David Attenborough: Climate change 'our greatest threat'
Well, one can lead to the other. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/heatwaves-may-dram...
wilburTheDog··on Where Oil Rigs Go to Die (2017)
What a strangely touching article. I'm not particularly interested in oil rigs, but that was a compelling read.
wilburTheDog··on 'Mindful people' feel less pain
I think the suffering is the result of your desire for things to be different than what they are. It's natural to feel like you want a headache to go away, but it seems to me that the more I accept that this is just the way it is right now, the more I embrace the pain and accept it as a part of me, the less power it has over me. And conversely the more I try to push it away like it's some kind of monster that's torturing me the more it becomes one. I have actually had that experience while meditating with a headache. Fully embracing and identifying with the pain makes it hurt less. It's a weird paradox because you can't start by thinking "I want this pain to go away so I'm going to embrace it". That doesn't work. You have to start with the attitude of "I'm going to be fully present for this moment, whatever it is". That is the path that leads out of suffering.
wilburTheDog··on Extreme temperatures 'especially likely for next four years'
I guess it's hazardous to your career to project any further out than that. Given the various positive feedbacks(1) at play, however, I can't think of a realistic argument for why anything would get better in four years.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_feedback

wilburTheDog··on Amazon device recorded private conversation, sent it out to random contact
I recently stayed at a house which had an alexa device. In a conversation where I said the words light switch several times Alexa beeped and responded to me each time. I think most of us just believe Amazon when they say "Alexa responds to its name" and don't stop to consider the possible failure modes. We want to believe it can understand our words, when it's really just guessing. Over long enough time it's inevitable that it will misunderstand you and do something you don't want.

Still, I wonder how it heard "record this conversation and send it to someone on my contact list".

wilburTheDog··on Uber vehicle reportedly saw but ignored woman it struck
Thanks for the explanation. I hadn't heard of frequency binning(1) before. It makes sense that stationary objects would be filtered out before they even reach the signal processing software.

But Uber did seem to be relying more heavily on radar than the other sensors. From an article I linked in another comment "the number of LIDAR sensors were reduced from five to just one – mounted on the roof – and in their place, the number of radar sensors was increased from seven to 10. Uber also reduced the number of cameras on the car from 20 to seven." And for LIDAR this "results in a blind spot low to the ground all around the car."

They had to know radar wouldn't detect stationary objects. So the signal processor should be prioritizing camera and LIDAR reports of anything stationary in the road. If it really was programmed to ignore such a signal it seems like gross malfeasance to me. If not, then the speculation in the linked article is incorrect and it's the same problem Tesla's system has.

1. https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1278779

wilburTheDog··on Uber vehicle reportedly saw but ignored woman it struck
Wow. That Chinese accident video confirms my worst possible understanding of this. There are no special conditions. If a truck is parked in your lane you're going to hit it. More people should know about this. Maybe people don't want to believe it. I don't know. But I do know that I'm not going to trust any system that doesn't have multiple LIDAR sensors. Though it may take a while for the price on those to drop enough to make it affordable.
wilburTheDog··on Uber vehicle reportedly saw but ignored woman it struck
The article linked mentioned "B was the problem", meaning it ignored the sensor input. Another article(1) about it mentions that Uber had reduced the number of LIDAR sensors from five to just one rooftop sensor. The president of the company that builds the sensors even said you would need side sensors to see pedestrians, especially at night. But LIDAR is expensive. So it seems that, like Tesla, they were trying to rely on radar for that kind of thing. But that does leave the blind spot(2) I mentioned.

Given that I don't see how this case is so different.

Though I still don't understand how, specifically, that blind spot problem works. They say when the car in front of you changes lanes and a stopped truck is now in your lane you'll hit it. What if no car changed lanes in front of you? Would you still hit a stopped truck in your lane? The guy whose Tesla hit the bridge column seems to tell me yes, but I'm not sure.

1. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/03/28/uber_selfdriving_de...

2. https://www.wired.com/story/tesla-autopilot-why-crash-radar/

wilburTheDog··on Uber vehicle reportedly saw but ignored woman it struck
If I understand it right, this is the biggest blind spot of all the automated driving systems. The software just ignores stationary objects because the sensors don't have the resolution to determine whether they are in front of the car or on the side of the road. And if it didn't ignore stationary objects the car would come to a halt at every garbage can, mailbox, and bush along the road. Until they can work lidar into the system this will not be preventable. And, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the vast majority of accidents that were the fault of the self-driving car happened because it hit something stationary in the road (or off to the side of the road, in one case I recall).

Since I've learned about this blind spot in these system I no longer trust them. I think everyone with a self-driving car should understand this. But maybe it's not in the interest of the manufacturer to explain it, or people would demand they fix the problem, which they cannot do just yet.

wilburTheDog··on Tesla Was Kicked Off Fatal Crash Probe by NTSB
After reading about this for a while, just now, I'm much less comfortable with the idea of trusting an automotive autopilot system. Just imagine if your taxi driver told you "I will drive perfectly safely, except if there is a truck parked in the road. Then I will run into it at speed." It seems like such a glaring omission. If I were an engineer I don't think I would be comfortable releasing an autopilot system with this kind of safety issue.
wilburTheDog··on Tesla Was Kicked Off Fatal Crash Probe by NTSB
If this is true then how can we have had Collision Avoidance systems[1] in cars for years that are able to automatically apply the brakes to prevent this sort of accident? And If the answer is 'autopilot doesn't work that way' then why not use both systems, with the collision avoidance system taking precedence as it deems necessary?

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collision_avoidance_system

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →