HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CharlesColeman

2,502 karma · joined February 4, 2019

submissionscomments
CharlesColeman··on Boeing to Suspend 737 Max Production in January
> Ban the aircraft. Criminally charge everyone involved in suppressing it's serious issues and forcing it through approval.

That's going a bit too far. Banning MCAS and requiring pilots to undergo MAX-specific training and certification seems more reasonable (and less wasteful) response to the issues.

I would support criminal charges against the chief decision-makers that led Boeing into this mess, going all the way up to the top. Examples need to be made to reset the priorities of corporate decision-makers.

CharlesColeman··on ICANN Delays .ORG Sale Approval
> That's not an argument. Any regressive policy could and has been justified in those terms.

Yes, it is. The US government has an institutional history of overseeing ICAAN, so it's the most practical organization to take on that role on short notice.

I think you're letting the perfect be the enemy of the good. Your preferred multi-national solution would likely take years to negotiate, which means it's not really even a solution at all, as far as .org is concerned.

CharlesColeman··on Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair
> Good luck for average Joe Farmer troubleshooting why the hydraulic valve doesn't work? Can be everything from a faulty valve or cabin switch over broken shielding somewhere along the CAN (or other) high speed bus leading to garbled transmissions to a software bug somewhere in the control unit. The farmer can easily fix a broken component - but good luck finding the issue in the latter two failure modes, I doubt it's even possible for a small freelance shop as it requires HF communications or IT knowledge combined with specialized tooling (signal analyzer, some kind of debugging tool for the CU).

If the machine was built for reparability, it could have built-in diagnostics that could greatly help troubleshoot those kind of problems.

For instance, couldn't broken shielding leading to garbled transmissions be partially diagnosed if error rates over the cable are tracked and a warning displayed that identifies the part in question?

CharlesColeman··on Tell HN: CNN Lite no longer functional
> FYI, another name for lite.cnn.com is m.cnn.com

That makes the "Please update to the latest version of the CNN app" message make more sense: they've probably saw lite.cnn.com as a service for phones, and decided to discontinue it in favor of their app.

CharlesColeman··on Tell HN: CNN Lite no longer functional
> For a long time CNN was the "School Shooting Channel" and the "MH370 Channel"; call it bias or not, but it was definitely focused on things that seemed to get a certain kind of person watching while biting their nails.

And before that it was the Scott Peterson channel.

Personally, I think the invention of the 24-hour cable news network was a mistake. There just isn't enough breaking domestically-relevant newsworthy material to fill the airtime. IMHO, the only good solution to that problem is to increase the proportion of relatively mundane international news coverage or in-depth investigative documentaries. Unfortunately a lot of people aren't interested in the former and the latter is expensive. Instead the networks either fill the airtime with wall-to-wall coverage of stuff like the murder of Laci Peterson presented like it's 9/11 or Pearl Harbor or with wretched opinionating.

If I were king, I'd limit breaking news programming to two hours a day per channel, and opinion to two hours a week.

CharlesColeman··on Airbus Beluga XL
Really? By what measure? The OP wiki page says this:

> With 30% more capacity than the existing Beluga, it will be able to carry two A350 XWB wings instead of one.[5] Its new fuselage is 6.9 m longer and 1.7 metre wider than the Beluga, and it will be able to lift a payload 6 tonnes heavier.

CharlesColeman··on ICANN Delays .ORG Sale Approval
> Why should the U.S. government hold such control?

Because they did until very recently.

> If anything, some sort of multi-national, strictly non-profit charity should be setup for this, or if not, the U.N. as a last resort.

That would take literally years, and would be too-little, too-late to deal with these shenanigans around the .org TLD.

CharlesColeman··on Shopping Sucks Now
> On the first page, there are two different gloves listed, one for $17 and one for $60, that look exactly identical and come in the exact same colors. Both have the same exact star rating (4.5/5) and hundreds of positive reviews.

> I’d love to only spend $17 except there is no way 17-dollar leather gloves won’t be fake and off color and smell of gasoline when they arrive, and after only a few wears the lining will pill or develop holes. I’d love to just buy the $60 gloves except that seems like a pretty large amount of money to spend on non-weatherproof gloves, and how can I, when there are identical $17 gloves right there.

It could also be that the $60 gloves came from the same factory and are exactly identical to the $17 gloves, and if you buy them you're going to get ripped off by at least $43.

I wouldn't say that the problem of shopping is now "perfect information," it's rather a deluge of information liberally peppered with dishonesty and arbitrariness.

CharlesColeman··on Google Culture War Escalates as Era of Transparency Wanes
I agree completely.

Going to work without a union is like going to court without a lawyer. Are there incompetent lawyers? Does it cost money to hire a lawyer? Of course, but that doesn't mean it isn't a stupid idea to try to represent yourself pro se.

Unfortunately, workers in the US have been the subject to the equivalent of a fifty year propaganda campaign bankrolled by prosecutors (business owners) to convince people they're really better off if they represent themselves pro se (without a union).

CharlesColeman··on Google Culture War Escalates as Era of Transparency Wanes
> I think the mindset of changing of something from within is actually a good one. “Moving on” is probably easier and pragmatic but as a society it’s better to change things instead of just tossing them aside and going to the next thing. I hope the same people will also be active in politics and try to change things.

I agree. "Moving on" is a market/capitalist attitude, while "trying to change the company from within" is a democratic/civic attitude. The US has has way too much of the former and way too little of the latter than what I'd consider healthy for a democratic nation. Civic participation is often a thankless slog where it seems like your efforts are having no effect, but it's extremely necessary.

Also I think "moving on" often isn't so much "tossing aside" but simply ignoring/avoiding the problem.

CharlesColeman··on Learning from OpenBSD can make computers marginally less horrible
That's true: those things do negatively affect customer experience. However they don't affect customer experience as negatively as the experience of having their software break.

To put this in another context: newer building codes may result in better and safer homes, but it'd be extremely user hostile to force homeowners proactively upgrade their homes to compliance each time a new version is released (at the threat of having their home condemned if they do not). The sensible compromise, in buildings and software, is to allow things to be upgraded over time, as they're modified.

CharlesColeman··on Learning from OpenBSD can make computers marginally less horrible
> Typically customers choose MacOS over Windows (when price is no object).

But when they do so, I think they do it in spite of the lax attitude towards compatibility, due to other factors. Chief among them is the higher prestige Apple products have, the fact that many basic users only use very few programs that are all under heavy development (e.g. browsers) that lessens the sting, and many regular users have become resigned to being abused by their technology providers.

If you narrow the question down to one factor, we're going to break your stuff vs. we're going to do everything we can to keep your stuff working, I think most people would choose the latter

CharlesColeman··on Learning from OpenBSD can make computers marginally less horrible
> OS Application Binary Interface (ABI) release inter-compatibility is the cancer killing the modern operating system.

I think that's only true perspective of an OS developer:

ABI inter-compatibility (e.g. the Windows and Linux model) prioritizes customer experience. Customers hate it when their applications stop working, and application developers don't want to spend lots of effort to track platform API changes just to avoid breakage.

Abandoning ABI inter-compatibility (OpenBSD, Apple) prioritizes platform developer experience. They want to be able to freely make API changes and don't want to spend time maintaining old APIs that they could use to work on new APIs.

I think the problem with the latter is, while there may be a few hundred developers working on a particular OS, there's are orders of magnitude more customers and application developers. Totally abandoning ABI inter-compatibility seems like putting the interests of the very few over the interests of the very many.

CharlesColeman··on Getting Drivers for Old Hardware Is Harder Than Ever
It seems a lot of the examples are about BIOS and other types of firmware, though. I'm not sure if Linux would be much help with that.
CharlesColeman··on Retired USAF General Makes Eyebrow Raising Claims About Advanced Space Tech
> A "stealth" ICBM would not really get you much, would it?

Stealth may help avoid interception during the midcourse phase, though:

https://media.nti.org/pdfs/10_5.pdf:

> Midcourse Phase – “Largest Intercept Window”

> The midcourse phase allows the largest opportunity to intercept an incoming missile. At this point the missile is no longer under power, so it follows a more predictable path. Depending on the interceptor launch location, multiple interceptors could be launched, with a delay between them to see if the first ones were successful. Since the interceptor has a longer time to engage, fewer interceptor sites are needed to defend larger areas.

> Unfortunately, a longer period in space provides an attacking missile the opportunity to deploy countermeasures against a defensive system. However the defensive system also has more time to observe and discriminate countermeasures from the warhead.

But I think you're right that it a stealth ICBM wouldn't achieve as much as one would naively assume, and boost-phase detection would still invite retaliation.

CharlesColeman··on S&P 500 Buybacks Now Outpace All R&D Spending in the US
> But why?

I already explained my reasoning for forbidding them.

CharlesColeman··on S&P 500 Buybacks Now Outpace All R&D Spending in the US
I trust "finance professionals" on stuff like that about as much as I trust Mark Zuckerberg on internet privacy.

Insiders may have expertise, but their insider-ness means one should be skeptical of their perspective for all kinds of reasons (including, but not limited to: self-interest, indoctrination, selection effects, acclimation to industry practice, etc.).

CharlesColeman··on S&P 500 Buybacks Now Outpace All R&D Spending in the US
> The point is that purchasing their own stock is not for the purpose of manipulating its price. The price increase is a natural consequence of there being less outstanding shares. Less outstanding share = one share is worth more.

You're literally describing manipulating price by manipulating supply. If companies aren't buying back their stock to make its price go up, why are they buying it? You're contradicting yourself.

> Buybacks has many advantages though. The biggest one is that if you want to reinvest dividends into stock you would have to pay taxes which creates a situation where you are liable for taxes even if you didn't make any money (if the price fluctuates). Buyback is like automatically reinvested dividend. I don't think it should be taxable for the reasons outlined above.

I understand that stock buybacks have advantages in certain situations for some people. I'm suggesting those advantages be eliminated.

CharlesColeman··on S&P 500 Buybacks Now Outpace All R&D Spending in the US
> It makes sense to do it this way as well as otherwise you would be losing money to taxes just because the price fluctuates

I'm unsure how you're reaching this conclusion. I said nothing about eliminating capital gains and moving to some kind of system where investors are taxed on yearly stock price fluctuations. All I proposed was to forbid companies from purchasing their own stock for the purpose of manipulating its price upward.

Dividends exist and have a long history as being the the way of returning cash to shareholders. Forcing their use for that purpose would make it easier to make and enforce policies on that activity.

CharlesColeman··on Small-town America fights for its life
> But you left out some important bits from your response, including that several academic groups have used the site for building fake news classifiers

No I didn't. My quote from Wikipedia included this: "The Poynter Institute notes, "Media Bias/Fact Check is a widely cited source for news stories and even studies about misinformation, despite the fact that its method is in no way scientific [emphasis mine].""

The fact that some AI group used it to train a classifier is not a very strong endorsement in my opinion. AI researchers aren't journalism subject matter experts, and Media Bias/Fact Check is obviously a very convenient data source, but covenience is not good indicator of quality.

> Despite publications in academia using the site, you may also note the following:

> ...I'm not sure what to think of the above pedigree for CJR's editor, but IMO I suspect he either fell to one end of the political spectrum or the other.

You seem to be trying to synthesize two disparate observations to imply the idea that Kyle Pope is some kind of conservative and therefore too untrustworthy to evaluate Media Bias/Fact Check, but that betrays a poor understanding of how newspapers operate. In a well-run paper, there's a separation between the newsroom and the opinion/editorial pages. For instance, the WSJ has a famously conservative editorial page. You might think its reporters have the same ideology, but (IIRC) its newsroom staff is even more liberal than that from the NYT, a fact that seldom shows because they're so professional. The newsroom exists to report the facts, and the editorial pages to voice the opinions of the owner/publisher. That Jerod Kushner had his paper endorse Donald Trump in no way reflects on Kyle Pope's judgement as a journalist.

Furthermore, Kyle Pope's own Wiki page has him saying:

> In an interview with Brian Stelter of CNN, Pope stated that after the election of President Donald Trump, the news media needs to rethink how it covers the news in order to "retake the agenda from this man who so hungers for attention, and how do we tell stories in a way that reflects the scale and sweep of the moment we're in?" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyle_Pope)

The tone of that kinda confirms to me that your quotes are two puzzle pieces that don't actually fit together.

I'm inclined to trust the CJR's editor's judgement on journalism topics (topics which include the Media Bias/Fact Check website), because the CJR is the professional journal of the most prestigious American school of journalism.

CharlesColeman··on S&P 500 Buybacks Now Outpace All R&D Spending in the US
> Read an idea in American Affairs in support of taxing buybacks.

Honestly, at their most supportable, share buybacks seem to be just dividends in all but name with different tax consequences (i.e. they're a tax dodge). I'd support a law that declared the only legal way to intentionally return cash to shareholders is via dividends, to close the loophole and increase tax revenues.

In other cases, they just seem like financial engineering employed by CEOs and other interested parties to game their personal job performance metrics.

CharlesColeman··on S&P 500 Buybacks Now Outpace All R&D Spending in the US
> What I don't understand about this is... Why can't I partake?

Honestly: because you're not rich and connected enough to have the rules written for to your benefit your naked self-interest. If it was legal and economical for ordinary people to evade taxes, too many people would do it and the country would collapse.

CharlesColeman··on Nearly half of American workers have low-wage jobs
> From the union discussion the other day, one thing that always struck me was how weird it was that more conservatives don't encourage labor unions in the private sector.

At least in the US, I attribute this to "big business" interests being a major faction in the Republican coalition, more due to contributions of money than votes. Their ideology is ultimately self-interest, they benefit from weak unions/worker disorganization, and have the resources to promote their self-interested view as that of the party/ideology. They've been successful, because most people have more of a political tribal identity which dictates their positions than a well-thought-out ideology.

CharlesColeman··on Small-town America fights for its life
> Neutral source: https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/washington-examiner/

Neutral, perhaps, but also poorly qualified:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_Bias/Fact_Check:

> The Columbia Journalism Review describes Media Bias/Fact Check as an amateur attempt at categorizing media bias and Van Zandt as an "armchair media analyst."[2] Van Zandt describes himself as someone with "more than 20 years as an arm chair researcher on media bias and its role in political influence."[3] The Poynter Institute notes, "Media Bias/Fact Check is a widely cited source for news stories and even studies about misinformation, despite the fact that its method is in no way scientific."[4]

CharlesColeman··on Google under investigation for ‘Thanksgiving Four’ firings, discouraging unions
> I would oppose a cartel of companies acting in a way that extracts too much money from consumers. We have a whole area of law for dealing with this. Unions are a cartel of employees who use the threat of financial harm to limit the freedom of employers and individual workers from freely entering into mutually beneficial work arrangements.

How so? An employer has a monopoly of jobs at a particular workplace, so why not let a union have a monopoly of workers to fill the jobs at that workplace. IIRC, union representation is at the workplace level, and different unions can compete to represent the workers at that workplace.

CharlesColeman··on Google under investigation for ‘Thanksgiving Four’ firings, discouraging unions
> That's a bad analogy. Defendants cannot avoid a hearing. Employees can just get another job.

I don't share your quibbles, but all right. How about this:

A worker without a union is like going to court without a lawyer.

A lot of court cases are optional. You can always just not demand what you're owed or pay whatever your asked. If you lose, just hope the next person you do business with will be more trustworthy.

> Starting businesses is hard. It entails a lot of risk. Risk that was never taken by employees. And employees are not bound to the fortunes of the company the way owners are. If the company loses money or goes belly-up, the employees get new jobs. But the owners must simply bear the loss.

So what? None of that is a convincing argument that non-business-owners should not benefit form organization. It's not like owners are the only ones taking a risk [1], workers do too. Do you think they somehow fantastically shift into equivalent new jobs whenever their laid off? Workers invest in company-specific knowledge and put down roots near their employer that are harder relocate than capital, for instance.

You also oddly fail to differentiate between groups like the struggling small business owner and the private equity firm billionaire who lays off 10,000 workers just because he'd prefer that he and his shareholders be richer. Whatever sympathy the former deserve is not due to the latter.

[1] they're the only ones risking capital, not the only ones taking a risk.

CharlesColeman··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
> This would mean China is always a step behind. China wants to become the leading country. To achieve that in the shortest time span possible, they copy whatever they can, learn from it and build upon on it. In short, China copies, then innovates.

They don't necessarily have to innovate to become a leading country. They could do that by achieving mere technological parity, but producing it at a larger scale.

For instance, if China slavishly copied all US weapons designs and went to war with the US, China would win. It has more population and a larger industrial base, which means more soldiers in uniform and more equipment on the battlefield. The slavish copying would neutralize the US "quality" advantage, turning the conflict into one about "quantity."

CharlesColeman··on Google under investigation for ‘Thanksgiving Four’ firings, discouraging unions
> The moral justification for unions is that they prevent mistreatment of employees, not that they can transfer as much of the company's profit as possible to employees.

In your opinion. In my view, one of the many moral justifications of unions is that they create a more even playing field between workers and already organized management/capital, and that includes the workers receiving a greater share of the profits the they had an essential role in creating.

A worker without a union is like a defendant without a lawyer.

CharlesColeman··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
> Then why doesn't someone hold them accountable for this type of garbage.

IIRC, IP theft issues are one of the grievances cited for the current US trade war with China.

CharlesColeman··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
> One of those restrictions involved country of origin, but I can't remember the details.

Maybe security clearance restrictions? IIRC to get clearance you're not allowed to have dual citizenship (b/c divided loyalties) nor relationships with foreign citizens that could open you up to influence/coercion (e.g. a foreign citizen spouse or relatives residing in a foreign country that could be threatened for leverage).

← PreviousPage 3 of 26Next →