HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

griffzhowl

1,116 karma · joined April 22, 2020

submissionscomments
griffzhowl··on A new bridge links the math of infinity to computer science
Numbers are definitely essential concepts for some kinds of reasoning. If that's what you're saying then fine.

The thing is assuming that 5 exists to conclude that 5 exists is obviously circular.

griffzhowl··on 'Once in 300 years' rain hits Thai city as floods ravage South East Asia
The article says it's the heaviest rainfall recorded in Hat Yai over the last 300 years. So that's the actual meaning, and interpreting it in the probabilistic sense seems to have been the initiative of the headline writer.
griffzhowl··on A new bridge links the math of infinity to computer science
You've already assumed 5 exists in order to assert that it's prime.

In any case existence of mathematical objects is a different meaning of existence to physical objects. We can say a mathematical object exists just by defining it, as long as it doesn't lead to contradiction.

griffzhowl··on Human brains are preconfigured with instructions for understanding the world
A professor once told me that if someone asks when a concept was first discussed in philosophy, it's always best to reply "Isn't it in Plato?"

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/innateness-history/#PlaAr...

griffzhowl··on Moss survived outside of the International Space Station for 9 months
True. I got visions of patches of moss growing on the outside of the ISS
griffzhowl··on 'The French people want to save us': help pours in for glassmaker Duralex
> anything that truly benefits workers will be at odds with things that benefit the business.

Generally yes, unless the workers own the business.

griffzhowl··on 'The French people want to save us': help pours in for glassmaker Duralex
Look for successful models I guess

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=tech-startup+cooperatives&ia=web

griffzhowl··on 'The French people want to save us': help pours in for glassmaker Duralex
Yes, we had them in school in the UK too. Just had a flashback to the number at the bottom of the glass
griffzhowl··on 'The French people want to save us': help pours in for glassmaker Duralex
They did survive. There are thousands in Spain and Italy especially.

One of the most well-known is the Mondragon Corporation from the Basque country, one of Spain's largest comanies:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation

griffzhowl··on Android/Linux Dual Boot
extramuraloading?
griffzhowl··on Geothermal's Time Has Come
> Are you suggesting to basically harvest the thermal energy in the rock in a non-renewable fashion?

As I understand it, that's how many geothermal plants work, effectively mining the heat underneath them, but at a rate of extraction that means they would become uneconomical over a span of decades rather than months.

griffzhowl··on Hilbert space: Treating functions as vectors
Thanks for the clarification
griffzhowl··on Hilbert space: Treating functions as vectors
> In most function vector spaces you encounter in mathematics, you can not say what the value of a function at a point is.

Could you spell out what you mean by that? Functions are all defined on their domains (by definition)

Are you referring to the L^p spaces being really equivalence classes of functions agreeing almost everywhere?

griffzhowl··on Android/Linux Dual Boot
I agree with the ethos but "banning installing" wouldn't have been correct here.

There should be terminology for installing from the source of your choice which doesn't carry the marginal or sinister connotations of "sideloading" though.

"Freeloading" would have been a good one but... yeah

griffzhowl··on Geothermal's Time Has Come
> the energy flow across the crust is ~0.1W/m^2

It's a misleading comparison. This is only the average amount of heat that diffuses through an ordinary patch of surface, and has more or less nothing to do with how a geothermal plant works, since they don't harvest heat by covering a large area of surface with conducting material.

The surface heat flow is low because rock acts as an insulator. If you drill down to where it's hot and draw the heat up you obviously get orders of magnitude larger flows of energy to the surface.

griffzhowl··on Mysterious holes in the Andes may have been an ancient marketplace
It does seem an unlikely place for a market:

13°42′59.9″S 75°52′28.46″W

If there really were baskets of corn there, it seems more likely it was used for storage, and situated along the ridge not too far from the valley floor to protect the crops from floods and perhaps raids. Picture (a) in the article has a defensive settlement marked nearby.

Still, a very enigmatic site

griffzhowl··on UK's first small nuclear power station to be built in north Wales
That part of the sea as well as Doggerland itself are named afer Dogger Bank, a large sandbank that must have been some promontory on Doggerland.

Dogger Bank in turn seems to be named after a kind of Dutch fishing boat called a dogger

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogger_Bank

griffzhowl··on James Watson has died
I don't think it's a chicken or egg problem. We still have the non-functional form of the gene for synthesizing vitamin C in our genomes. It's been identified, and the mutation which knocked out it's functionality is known. This was a single event. If the primate who had this variant didn't already have a diet high in vitamin C, it wouldn't have survived. And since their diet was high in vitamin C, they obviously had the sensory apparatus necessary for detecting the food sources
griffzhowl··on OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court rules
Maybe, but it's also possible to get an AI to produce a song with the exact same lyrics. And a human copying lyrics would also be a copyright issue in any case.

But anyway it seems I misinterpreted the issue and record companies have always been against reproduction of lyrics whether an AI or human is doing it

griffzhowl··on OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court rules
Hmm, alright. I actually do play guitar and used to find chords/tabs with lyrics easily. I haven't been doing that for maybe 10-15 years. Anyway, maybe those sites were paying for a license and I just never considered it
griffzhowl··on OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court rules
Thanks. Maybe that misconception was the problem. Taking a hammering in downvotes, lol
griffzhowl··on OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court rules
Had a couple of drive-by downvotes... Is it that stupid an opinion? Granted I know nothing about the case except for what's in TFA
griffzhowl··on OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court rules
I think having the lyrics reproducible in text form isn't the problem. Many sites have been doing that for decades and as far as I know record companies haven't gone after them. But these days with generative AI, they can take lyrics and just make a new song with them, and you can probably see why artists and record companies would want to stop that.

Plus, from TFA,

"GEMA hoped discussions could now take place with OpenAI on how copyright holders can be remunerated."

Getting something back is better than nothing

griffzhowl··on BBC director general and News CEO resign in bias controversy
> Trans men are men, socially and legally.

Legally in what sense? I don't think they're being sent to men's prisons. I hope not anyway...

griffzhowl··on The Manuscripts of Edsger W. Dijkstra
Indeed
griffzhowl··on The Manuscripts of Edsger W. Dijkstra
Usually the chapter 0 is preliminary or prerequisite material. It makes sense in an obvious and intuitive way if you want an ordinal "before the first", even if that sense isn't a rigorous mathematical one (although I think there's no problem with it).

I guess the practice was influenced by computer science - I don't know of an example that precedes it, but one fairly early one I've found is Bishop and Goldberg's Tensor Analysis on Manifolds from 1968, with a chapter 0 on set theory and topology. Back then the authors felt the need to justify their numbering in the preface:

"The initial chapter has been numbered 0 because it logically precedes the main topics"

Quite straightforward.

There's also the "zeroth law of thermodynamics", which was explicitly identified long after the first, second, and third laws, but was felt more primary or basic, hence the need for an "ordinal before the first"

griffzhowl··on Syntax and Semantics of Programming Languages (1995)
I think you misread what GP thinks syntax is. GP's definition

"whether the construct is allowed/part of the language (syntax)"

is the same as yours

""Syntax" just means what strings are valid programs"

griffzhowl··on James Watson has died
> primates ... lost the ability to synthesize vitamin C eons ago, and as a result evolved excellent color vision for finding fruits

I have a feeling this must be the other way around. The ancient primates had a diet high in fruits, which is why they could survive without harm when the gene for synthesizing vitamin C mutated into a non-functional form. They must have had the colour vision for detecting ripe fruits before that.

griffzhowl··on Analysis indicates that the universe’s expansion is not accelerating
You're probably thinking of the DESI BAO results from March, which also cast doubt on the standard cosmological model. These new results point further in the same direction as the DESI ones

https://newscenter.lbl.gov/2025/03/19/new-desi-results-stren...

griffzhowl··on Analysis indicates that the universe’s expansion is not accelerating
It's not just a question of instrumental error though. There are also assumptions being used in interpreting the data from the instruments, and it's not generally possible to assign them reliable probabilities.

e.g. the first line of the article's abstract quoted above:

"Supernova (SN) cosmology is based on the key assumption that the luminosity standardization process of Type Ia SNe remains invariant with progenitor age."

If the results reported in the article are right, the confidence we should have in this assumption, and therefore any results relying on it, have just radically changed.

← PreviousPage 4 of 17Next →