HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jkimmel

917 karma · joined June 1, 2012

Quantitative biologist.

Co-founder & Head of Research at NewLimit. Previously Principal Investigator at Calico, PhD at UCSF.

If you're in town, feel free to shoot me an email to chat about how cells work, aging research, the life sciences, startups, or the local coffee shop landscape. I'm always looking to learn from interesting people.

@jacobkimmel on Twitter et. al.

jacobkimmel@gmail.com

submissionscomments
jkimmel··on The Growing Impact of Old Scientific Papers
>For instance, a lot of citations in my field (theoretical CS) are "attribution citations" that point the reader to the original paper that introduced a concept or proved a result

This is also common in modern biology. As the recent "Top 100 Papers" article in Nature News noted [1], the most cited papers in the life sciences are highly biased toward methods development.

The most cited paper is a great case study, the majority of molecular biologists have probably used some variation of the Lowry method, but I'm fairly certain most of them haven't actually read the original paper. However, it remains as an "attribution citation," whenever a Lowry-like method is used to quantify protein.

[1] -- http://www.nature.com/news/the-top-100-papers-1.16224

jkimmel··on The Scientific Quest for Lasting Youth: Prospects for Curing Aging
This paper has a lot of misleading information that I don't have time to parse out at the moment. I'm relatively well versed in aging literature, and right off the bat, citing the SENS hypothesis before anything a bit more validated by data leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

For a thorough overview of why aging happens, and how we may target it with therapeutics, may I suggest this excellent paper highlighted in Cell Press' "Best of 2013."(Full Text is free!)

Hallmarks of Aging - http://www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(13)00645-4.pdf

If you're interested particularly in the forefront of rejuvinative biology, may I suggest a few more amazing papers.

Aging and reprogramming: a two way street Anne Brunet's group at Stanford. tl;dr - Pluripotent reprogramming (see Yamanaka 2006) reverses many molecular signals of aging http://web.stanford.edu/group/brunet/Mahmoudi%20et%20al%2020...

Several of the recent parabiosis papers, from the labs of Amy Wagers & Lee Rubin at Harvard, and Saul Villeda at UC - San Francisco

--Young blood reverses age-related impairments in cognitive function and synaptic plasticity in mice http://www.nature.com/nm/journal/v20/n6/full/nm.3569.html

--Restoring Systemic GDF11 Levels Reverses Age-Related Dysfunction in Mouse Skeletal Muscle http://www.sciencemag.org/content/344/6184/649.abstract

--Vascular and Neurogenic Rejuvenation of the Aging Mouse Brain by Young Systemic Factors http://www.sciencemag.org/content/344/6184/630.abstract

jkimmel··on Amazon.com redesign
http://imgur.com/cMshOJx

Screenshot for anyone who isn't seeing the new page.

jkimmel··on Hacker News API
just wanted to let you know that I love your application!
jkimmel··on Accidental release of 45L of polio virus solution into the environment – Belgium
Usually, the big biotech production plants look a lot like breweries. Giant bioreactors that look like fermentors are hooked up to complex control valves moving fluid from one to the other in the various steps of a complicated process.

My best guess is that a technician accidentally hit the "dump waste" button before the vessel was decontaminated/when it had the wrong solution in it/before the virus was deactivated, etc.

This incident is especially worrisome, but having seen the control boards for one of those giant reactors, I'm not surprised that mistakes are made on occasion.

jkimmel··on All About ATM Skimmers
At least in Orlando, the new Bank of America ATMs have a slot loading mechanism that takes your card in automatically (as in, you gently place the card in the slot and a motorized mechanism pulls it in).

I wasn't sure of the reasoning for this initially, but my assumption is that it makes it more difficult to skim. The actual 'swipe' in which the mag strip is read seems to occur inside the machine, so a skimmer would need to be mounted with the machine opened up.

jkimmel··on We Are Entering the Age of Alzheimer's
>If you don't have a statistically significant sample size and a control group, you are conducting bad science.

I would argue that a sample of 1 with no control is not worthy of being called science.

jkimmel··on New Requests for Startups
>I don't really understand how they can afford tuition + room + board but need the $140 (less taxes) a week, but as it turns out this is very common.

As a student, maybe I can shed a little light on this. There are a few reasons working part-time at minimum wage can make economic sense for a student.

At least at my institution, few kids whose parents foot the tuition bill work.

The students most likely to be working 20 hours/week are the same students likely to receive some form of financial aid/merit scholarship. As such, the tuition + room + board costs may be significantly less than the sticker price. Considering this reduced expense, the ~$200/week from part-time work may make a considerable contribution to a student's budget.

Even if these students aren't able to completely cover the remaining cost of school not covered by financial aid, there are many instances where that part-time job replaces a potentially high interest student loan, reducing the overall cost of education in the long run.

In some instances, even students whose parents assist them with educational expenses require a part-time job for discretionary expenditures. I have more than one friend whose parents pay tuition, but do not cover the cost of gasoline/car repairs necessary for the student to go to class.

jkimmel··on The U.S. government tried to rank colleges in 1911
The US News rankings have a lot of factors which can easily be gamed and/or probably aren't relevant to ranking an institution based on quality. One that comes to mind is including the "Easiness" factor from RateMyProfessor as a positive metric (easier schools are ranked more highly).

On a more philosophical level, having a private 3rd party control the decisions of our college-bound youth could become problematic. How likely is it that the US News rankings may have some sort of bias, anything from an analyst's alma mater being ranked higher to quid pro quo bribery? Hopefully, a public institution would be more robust in the face of these biases.

jkimmel··on Why I'll Never Tell My Son He's Smart
I found this to be very insightful, as I am not familiar with the cited research. It brings to mind my own memories of growing up, and how being told how "smart," I was could actually act as a hindrance.

As the article notes, I was only praised when I got a correct answer, or used a big word without stumbling. In one particular memory, I am afraid of taking a new mathematics placement test in school -- not because of the difficulty, but precisely because I had gotten a perfect score on the last one. There was no room to grow, if I didn't get them all right again, would that make me not "smart?"

Very simple changes in the language we use with young children could possibly avoid that kind of anxiety in bright youth.

jkimmel··on My startup failed, and this is what it feels like
>What's the benefit of being able to say you're a YC founder?

Being able to attach the YC brand to your resume is probably very helpful when seeking investment for a new venture or applying for a job at a BigCo.

Although I have no knowledge of the situation beyond this (very well written) post, I don't think it's farfetched that a couple developers would join an existing company just to experience YC and improve their Valley credentials.

jkimmel··on Cool Kids Lose, Though It May Take A Few Years
I entirely agree with you -- it is far too trivial to place adolescents into distinct subpopulations. However, I think this study did a pretty good job defining the traits of youth they tracked, see the abstract:

>Pseudomature behavior—ranging from minor delinquency to precocious romantic involvement—is widely viewed as a nearly normative feature of adolescence. When such behavior occurs early in adolescence, however, it was hypothesized to reflect a misguided overemphasis upon impressing peers and was considered likely to predict long-term adjustment problems.

The authors used these criteria to determine whether a specific set of early life behaviors are predictive of later life decisions. In this case, the statistics say that this is the case. While that may not be true in every sense (the "nerd" can get into drugs, the "cool" kid can also get a 1600 on the SAT), it is more common than not based on these data.

The "cool"/"nerd" labels themselves seem mainly to be injected by the media atop the findings of this particular study.

jkimmel··on City of Chicago Data Portal
>Basically, people fortunate enough to be born with the aptitude for higher education get a 50% premium for their efforts.

I think a minor edit makes this statement more accurate:

Basically, people who complete higher education get a 50% premium on their efforts in aggregate.

Though as others have noted before, this level of analysis is in and of itself problematic. If top performers for multiple generations have entered the higher education system, it is difficult to separate out the confounded variables of natural ability, drive, and the "higher education premium" (so to speak).

How do we necessarily know that college graduates are earning more due to their education, and not because the population of the most driven and/or most able individuals happens to go to college? It's a difficult problem.

The only real viable suggestion I've heard is to compare earnings of individuals with similar pre-college academic performance who attended college to those who didn't. Most likely, these individuals would have to be on the threshold of collegiate entrance (by SAT, GPA, etc.), so perhaps even this analysis would not properly assess the benefit of college to high performing students.

jkimmel··on Hello, Stranger
Tangentially related: the recent "Humans of New York," blog/book [1] and the various other spin offs [2][3] seem to thrive on this same experience. Something about breaking the ice and making human connections seems to strike an inherent chord within many people, despite the difficulty many of us have putting such techniques into practice.

[1] - http://www.humansofnewyork.com/ [2] - http://portraitsofboston.com/ [3] - http://facesoforlando.tumblr.com/

jkimmel··on Project Ara – Google's modular phone project
You're indeed correct that Moto attempted something similar with the Atrix.

As a onetime Moto Webdock owner though, I'll attest to the fact that the grandparents dream is far from realized. At the time, the phone was simply too underpowered to provide a usable experience running just a browser (outdated Firefox at that). I picked the accessory up on Craigslist and it quickly found a resting place in my closet -- it was neat, but only in the proof of concept sense.

I'd love to see a company attempt something similar with today's hardware. A phone like the Nexus 5 / HTC One could provide a pretty slick experience, given enough RAM.

jkimmel··on I Didn’t Want To Lean Out
I'm currently considering graduate school, and have unfortunately read too many stories quite like this.

Do you have an idea of how prevalent this kind of micromanagement is for peers in your cohort? Do you just have a particularly unreasonable PI?

jkimmel··on “This presentation can’t be opened because it’s too old”
>lab equipment that's air-gapped because it only works on some obsolete OS that's horribly insecure.

Just to emphasize how prevalent this is, I work in a 5 story life sciences research center with hundreds of personnel. All of our lab computers are airgapped, many of them stuck on OS versions >10 years old.

I used OS X 10.1 the other day. That was certainly an experience.

jkimmel··on When New Yorkers Lived Knee-Deep In Trash (2013)
HN discussion from some months ago.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6012254

jkimmel··on This is how much I want to intern at Google.
another typo, $33,000 should be $333,000. also, you may want to find a value for unique visitors to Times Square every day. The first thing I thought about while reading was how many of those 10^6 people are commuters who would walk past the ad every day for 3 months. Not trying to nitpick, but I think looking into that could really show attention to detail.

it looks nice otherwise, definitely above the normal effort put into an intern application. best of luck!

jkimmel··on Richard Lynch, an awesome PHP community guy and former colleague needs our help
You're barely older than me, and I can't begin to fathom how I would handle that situation. Your actions demonstrate incredible selflessness, and a startling degree of competence in the face of something no one your age should have to consider.

Your efforts are truly amazing. I hope one day in the face of such challenges I could be half the person you are now.

jkimmel··on California Cracks Down on Hacker Boot Camps
>If you already have prior programming knowledge and know at least one programming language, joining this camp is silly

As someone in this group, I'd have to disagree with you.

I work in a life sci research setting, and am usually the only person with any programming knowledge or experience whatsoever. In research, "it works," is generally the only quality control placed on bespoke software. I'm capable of writing working programs to perform simple tasks & do on a regular basis, but I could not begin to write a large web application using best industry practices. I've also never spoken at length with other programmers regarding the problems I'm facing, and as such, I would have a significant degree of difficulty discussing conceptual frameworks with a team.

Having spoken to a few people who attended these schools, it seems that they have a thing or two to teach someone like me.

Perhaps it's not worth $10k, but I think that's a separate argument.

jkimmel··on Christ, I hate Blackboard
Another student here with my two cents.

Your course website looks very clear, easy to use, etc. (also, I like the approach you seem to be taking with the material, I learned from the same book and always thought the convergence test guesswork was silly)

Part of my personal frustration with custom Professor sites, and that of other students I know, is simply that it's yet another site to keep track of. For all the failings of large LMS's, they are effective at centralizing coursework into a location a student can check daily. When a few professors have custom sites, it's easy to forget to check one Prof's site for updates, announcements, etc. Even just for syllabus info, I have more than once gone to my LMS and groaned when I realized that I had to look up the address for a custom site or dig through bookmarks. I once had a semester where every Prof used their own site, and I had to cycle through 5 bookmarks daily to keep track of everything.

TL,DR: it's simply one more thing to keep track of, increasing the friction of information acquisition from a student's perspective.

jkimmel··on Ask HN: What's your speciality, and what's your "FizzBuzz" equivalent?
I work in the life sciences. You would be amazed at what proportion of researchers have no conceptual understanding of what a p-value actually is.
jkimmel··on Schoolchildren ordered indoors as air pollution cloaks Shanghai
Is there a level of public outcry regarding the pollution?

I realize that criticism may be somewhat muted given the nature of the PRC government, but I can't imagine a city as large and cosmopolitan as Shanghai merely accepting this level of environmental mismanagement. Unfortunately, articles regarding Beijing/Shanghai pollution usually fail to mention public sentiment above the level of brief individual anecdote ("It's hard to breath on the way to the office" - Chinese citizen, etc.).

Perhaps someone local could provide some insight?

jkimmel··on The Problem with Higher Education - An Unfortunate Email
Just out of curiosity, did you apply to Georgia Tech's Online Masters when it opened a few months ago?

It will be interesting to see how they treat candidates with primarily industry credentials/experience, given that an online degree may attract a higher proportion of these prospective students (industry credentials suggest a full time job, which may lead to a preference for an online degree, but I'm obviously speculating).

jkimmel··on Does Our Industry Have a Drinking Problem?
Interesting, I wasn't aware that this was permitted in the UK.

Here in the US, under-18's often aren't allowed on the premises of a drinking establishment at all, so the OP does raise a point depending on the location of the conference.

jkimmel··on Why I moved to Miami
Did someone flip the street signs on me? I live in downtown Orlando and love the atmosphere. Plenty of meetups, cheap rent in and around the skyline, great nightlife, tons of big name concerts and great local shows every night of the week.

Gainesville on the other hand seemed to be mostly a bunch of drunken undergraduates. Cool if that's your scene, but outside of Grooveshark there didn't seem to be much of a tech community, and very little in the way of the fine arts.

jkimmel··on All Is Fair in Love and Twitter
> "Seven years after it was founded, the company with a catchy name had more than 2,000 employees"

This sticks out to me more than anything else in the article. I had no idea Twitter had such a massive headcount.

Does anyone have an idea as to the division of labor? 30% infrastructure, 10% design, etc.

My naivety must be showing, but I have a hard time imagining what all those engineers are up to.

EDIT: Sorry for the confusion. I realize that all 2000 employees aren't necessarily engineers, but I think it's safe to assume >1000 are probably in some sort of development role. To me, that still seems like a fairly large engineering base.

jkimmel··on The Arsenic DNA paper exposes flaws in peer review
Your point regarding anonymity is highly valid, and I appreciate that you bring it up. There is actually a concept I'm rather fond of that seeks to address this, usually referred to as peer-reviewed peer review [1].

Essentially, anonymous experts review publications in much the manner they do now, with no risk of their identities being revealed. A separate set of review-reviewers then rates the publication-reviewers themselves, scoring them on a standardized quantitative scale (1-10) based on the validity of their claims and the depth of their assessment. In this manner, experts collect an "aggregate reviewer rating" of sorts analogous to an h-index [2], call it an R-index.

This R-index can then serve to select accurate reviewers for future publications. A high R-index could also be included as a positive bullet point on a CV, providing some reward for reviewers to put a high degree of effort into their otherwise unrewarded reviewing work.

A few potential flaws are evident: what is one to do if early reviews are scored poorly, and you are no longer able to provide new reviews to increase your R-index? A grace period before scoring could potentially remedy this, ie) an R-index is not assigned until a reviewer has written >10 reviews.

[1] - http://www.frontiersin.org/Computational_Neuroscience/10.338... [2] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H-index‎

jkimmel··on Poll: Changing to Android after iOS7 Update?
Nitpick, but I think "went to work for Google, too." is supposed to say, "went to work for Yahoo!, too."

On a related note, JBQ leaving really left a sour taste in my mouth. I remember him being a constant and positive force on the message boards back in the Android 1.x days; though I don't really know him, he seems like the kind of developer that doesn't jump ship without good reason.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →