HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lakecresva

299 karma · joined September 20, 2020

submissionscomments
lakecresva··on SF Conservancy now accepting copyright assignment for any GPL software
I meant each author who accepts their offer and assigns their copyrights, not each contributor to an individual project.
lakecresva··on SF Conservancy now accepting copyright assignment for any GPL software
What you seem to want is pro bono representation, which is just not what they're offering. It's apples to oranges. Achieving something that approaches your idea of fairness would require negotiation and the maintenance of an ongoing legally significant relationship. I don't know much about the politics of the SF Conservancy, but the language in the contract they're offering does not jump out as especially unfair or extreme. Accounting for details like successors in interest is how lawyers write tight contracts.
lakecresva··on SF Conservancy now accepting copyright assignment for any GPL software
I can't speak for them, but I can tell you that would add an enormous amount of overhead and risk for the lawyers involved. If you assign them your copyrights, their job is just to find GPL violations from the pool of projects they have the rights to and then initiate an action in court, which they do for a living. Without assignment, they can no longer proactively investigate with any reasonable chance of success, and they have to find a violation that's in a goldilocks zone; they need a GPL author whose rights have been violated and is willing to make a long term commitment to actively participating in litigation, that they know will communicate with them as needed, and who won't suddenly move to Nepal or be convinced by people online that they need to drop the suit or something.
lakecresva··on SF Conservancy now accepting copyright assignment for any GPL software
The relicensing language is not entirely unreasonable in my opinion. There are huge portions of open source copyright thinking that have never actually been analyzed by an appellate court, and none of it has ever been seriously examined by the Supreme Court. In the event that some core component(s) of your favorite flavor of the GPL are found to be unsound or some other legal catastrophe happens, they need the ability to switch to something else if they don't want to just close up shop. The idea of trying to contact every copyright holder and having to bargain with them over relicensing sounds like a nightmare, and contractual language like "relicensing of the Works under a substantially similar license" is a non-starter.

You're taking a risk. Do you think they're going to try and hijack your copyright for some nefarious purpose, or do you think they might need flexibility in relicensing your work in the future?

lakecresva··on SF Conservancy now accepting copyright assignment for any GPL software
Because 99.9% of developers aren't willing to suffer the time and expense of investigating violations and enforcing their copyrights in federal court.
lakecresva··on User beware: Modified AGPLv3 removes freedoms, adds legal headaches
> There's the theoretical possibility of a copyright claim for the text of the AGPL, where the AGPL's copyright holders disallow derivative works

There's also a pretty clear case for promissory estoppel since their FAQ (which is "maintained by the Free Software Foundation's Licensing and Compliance Lab") says "we will not raise legal objections to your making a modified license": https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#ModifyGPL

lakecresva··on FTC sues Intuit for its deceptive TurboTax “free” filing campaign
You don't need a CLA. Github's ToS are set up such that contributions you get from other github users are licensed in the same manner as your repo unless the contributor gets you to agree to accept them under some other license : https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/github-terms/github-t.... People should not be worried about you "going private"; if you've accepted non de minimis contributions from other users, any future conveyance or network interaction stuff would require you to include the source materials to stay in compliance.
lakecresva··on A statically typed scripting language that transpiles to Posix sh
The functional stuff in Nickel is really pretty vanilla, and the syntax seems much more inspired by ML than Nix. There's some info in the repo's `RATIONALE.md` that specifically answers "how is this different/better than Dhall/JSonnet/Cue/Starlark".
lakecresva··on The hardest program I've ever written (2015)
I also wrote a version of Bernardy's pretty printer, but I never did come up with a satisfactory way of formatting text together with code. The best looking solution of splitting on whitespace and making each word a group, either tacking it onto the current line or splitting onto a new line ends up being exponential even with pretty aggressive optimization. Everything else I tried looked bad.
lakecresva··on Why U.S. Infrastructure Costs So Much
An investigation, and the legal system. Corporations exist because they make a deal with the state. In exchange for limited liability, they're required to respect the corporate form which entails things like meeting minutes, preservation of certain business records and communications, conducting audits, imposing oversight, etc. If they don't abide by these rules, plaintiffs can sue the company and bypass the limitation of liability to recover from individuals in their personal capacity.

This system of incentives and disincentives does work, and the US had a better handle on it in the past.

lakecresva··on Why U.S. Infrastructure Costs So Much
Those things have legal remedies, the US legal system has just decided that the investor class should be absolved of any risk or liability. If you intentionally underbid to win a contract, you've committed fraud and are supposed to go to prison to disincentivize the next guy. If you are a contractor and are incapable of giving a good faith estimate of your costs, you're supposed to go out of business. If you cut a bunch of corners to stay under budget and do not render satisfactory performance, you're liable for breach of contract (and are supposed to go out of business).

The first two options have been removed from the toolbox of American government almost entirely.

lakecresva··on An engineer fighting Texas’s ban on Israel boycotts
Apparently this is the statute: https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/GV/htm/GV.2271.htm
lakecresva··on Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground
I didn't realize you assumed a loss through the entire thing. Sure, if you ignore the realities of the US property market and begin with the assumption that your home is going to lose six figures in value every few years then yeah I guess renting is better than buying.
lakecresva··on Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground
> Paying property taxes and mortgage interest and insurance and maintenance and real estate commissions are also throwing away money.

I don't understand, do you think landlords don't pay tax, insurance premiums, or maintenance costs for their property? Those are all passed on to tenants with room left over to make the landlord a profit.

lakecresva··on Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground
> Factoring in the % costs from before, that's a cost of $140.4k.

For a married person with a million dollar home, they'll make ~$150k back from the section 121 nonrecognition provision alone if they ever sell, not to mention the salt and mortgage interest tax deductions. The tax code heavily incentivizes home ownership.

lakecresva··on Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground
> So why stress yourself out over piece of paper.

You sound like a propaganda billboard from "They Live"; it's pretty incredible to call a property deed a "piece of paper". Setting aside the financial and psychological benefits that come with home ownership, the United States is a society that has made a lot of sacrifices in the name of preserving choice. You made yours, you chose to rent; the choice to own a home should remain a realistic alternative for those who want it. If your argument is that houses in absolutely prime real estate areas are always going to be out of reach of most buyers fair enough, but treating the idea of home ownership like a diamond ring is absurd.

lakecresva··on Effekt – A research language with effect handlers and lightweight polymorphism
Their section on development tasks mentions fleshing out std and improving array/mutable reference programming, so I think it just hasn't been redone yet. It seems like they spent a lot of development time recently (with great success) working on foundational stuff like perceus/fbip and doing a major version bump, so std is pretty bare.
lakecresva··on Backblaze IPO
> all shares of Class B common stock will automatically convert into shares of Class A common stock on the earlier of (i) the seven-year anniversary of the closing date of this offering...

This is an interesting olive branch to class A shareholders, but is there a reasonable way for them to prevent class B holders from just extending the deadline by amending the articles?

lakecresva··on Anatomy of a Terminal Emulator
Could not agree more with this. Thanks for the interesting article and your work on zellij.
lakecresva··on Let’s Put an End to Prosecutorial Immunity (2018)
You have absolutely no clue what you're talking about. Even if we're playing by the book, the Supreme Court can choose not to grant cert because they believe a compelling circuit split hasn't yet emerged, stare decisis, they don't believe the controversy is ripe, they think it's a matter for someone else like the legislature, they don't have space on the docket, etc. Not granting cert is absolutely not an endorsement of legal interpretation by a lower court.

Beyond that, idea that justices wouldn't, even subconsciously, use the power to choose their own docket to favor their own policy preferences is just naive.

lakecresva··on Let’s Put an End to Prosecutorial Immunity (2018)
Any decision in a civil case that has the weight of a final judgment can be appealed by the affected party. The cause of action in all of these cases alleging a violation of civil rights (like the right to silence during a terry stop) is 42 U.S.C. § 1983: "Civil action for deprivation of rights". The plaintiff would be the one filing the appeal, because lower courts have largely dismissed their claims; dismissal with prejudice is considered a final judgment.

The point about the status quo is that when there's uncertainty about what the actual law is, law enforcement picks a side and goes with it, and everyone else has to live in that reality. When there's genuine ambiguity as to how the law is actually supposed to apply, the Supreme Court shouldn't be able to just deny cert because they like what the government picked and are therefore beneficiaries of the legal uncertainty.

The situation in which lower courts would ideally try and kick something like this up to the supreme court is exactly when they start saying things like this in their opinions: "We hold that Alexander’s claim on this point cannot overcome the officers’ qualified immunity, because “it was not clearly established that an individual has a First Amendment right to refuse to answer an officer’s questions during a Terry stop.” Surprisingly few courts have ruled on this precise issue; the parties point to no cases from this circuit directly on point. The sparse case law that does exist, however, indicates no consensus that a defendant has a First Amendment right not to answer an officer’s questions during a stop like the one at issue here."

lakecresva··on Let’s Put an End to Prosecutorial Immunity (2018)
The Supreme Court should just not be allowed to select the cases they review. If lower courts and legal experts think there's a genuine circuit split or pressing legal issue that needs to be resolved, they should be able to force the Supreme Court to issue an opinion.
lakecresva··on Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not harm it
This information is required to be in the articles of incorporation which are filed with the secretary of state. For public companies you can usually just google e.g. "Apple articles of incorporation" and the sec's copy will show up.
lakecresva··on Millions Still Months Behind on Rent After Eviction Moratorium Ends
> The mortgagee in that case applied to the court for relief, and had to make ongoing payments during the period that relief was granted. The relief did not put the creditor at a substantial risk of bankruptcy.

I'm not sure how these are related to due process and the fifth amendment so I don't see how they would distinguish the two cases. Under the CDC moratorium eviction, tenants still needed to show the appropriate degree of financial hardship.

> But SCOTUS tends to avoid ruling on the constitutionality of a law in cases where the simpler explanation is that the law was not appropriately applied.

They're not arguing about that, because to do so would require something resembling a consensus on what the actual law is. They're arguing about statutory interpretation. The main thread of the dissent in Alabama Assn. of Realtors was that "[T]o make and enforce such regulations as in [its] judgment are necessary to prevent the introduction, trans-mission, or spread of communicable diseases [inter-state]." means exactly what it says.

lakecresva··on Millions Still Months Behind on Rent After Eviction Moratorium Ends
> So, if there are some limits, why not understand those in terms of what that very section explicitly lists?

Because the list ends with "and other measures, as in his judgment may be necessary.", and the text forces you believe that either a) the federal government intended to express a belief (in the same bill that officially gives the federal government quarantine authority) that disease could be contained via sanitation and pest control, or that b) they intended to give the Surgeon General a lot of latitude.

lakecresva··on Millions Still Months Behind on Rent After Eviction Moratorium Ends
Asked and answered by the Supreme Court a hundred years ago in Home Building & Loan Ass'n v. Blaisdell. In times of emergency (in that case it was the depression), the federal government can delay the repayment of debts without running afoul of the contracts clause or the fifth amendment.
lakecresva··on Millions Still Months Behind on Rent After Eviction Moratorium Ends
This comment is somewhat disingenuous. The full text of the statutory provision (42 U.S.C. § 264) is :

"The Surgeon General, with the approval of the Secretary, is authorized to make and enforce such regulations as in his judgment are necessary to prevent the introduction, transmission, or spread of communicable diseases from foreign countries into the States or possessions, or from one State or possession into any other State or possession. For purposes of carrying out and enforcing such regulations, the Surgeon General may provide for such inspection, fumigation, disinfection, sanitation, pest extermination, destruction of animals or articles found to be so infected or contaminated as to be sources of dangerous infection to human beings, and other measures, as in his judgment may be necessary."

While it's true that the majority wasn't willing to separate the first and second sentences, the decision was along party lines, and it just does not seem reasonable to me that a federal law intended to give the HHS "responsibility for preventing the introduction, transmission and spread of communicable diseases from foreign countries into the United States" would limit the authority granted in the section "Regulations to control communicable diseases" to nothing more than fumigation and pest control.

lakecresva··on Apple banned a pay equity Slack channel
> Why is it appropriate for a union to determine who has the right to accomplish specific tasks

It's just an exclusivity clause. The employees and management willingly entered into a contractual agreement containing a provision that management ostensibly understood and then completely failed to account for.

If I sign an employment contract that explicitly says "I will be your exclusive provider of X service, I am not available on weekends", the employer shouldn't be surprised when I refuse to come in on Saturday and Sunday or sue them for breach when they hire a second service provider.

lakecresva··on Apple banned a pay equity Slack channel
This sounds more like someone who just wants to blame a series of poor management decisions on those damn unions.

It's management's responsibility to make sure they have the right people on hand when they roll out an update to a major system. It's also their responsibility to come out of union negotiations with the right contracts, which would have at the very least included some sort of force majeure clause to account for technical disasters.

lakecresva··on Bringing the Unix philosophy to the 21st century (2019)
Nushell has a 'to json' command. The tables are just nice to look at, it's not a data format they're expecting people to parse.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →